Which F31? 320d 330d 330xd 335xd
Which F31? 320d 330d 330xd 335xd
Author
Discussion

podpod

Original Poster:

135 posts

146 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
hi guys/gals im thinking about getting a estate next as the family is growing.. gonna have a newborn soon and already got a 2 year old..

its going to be a used car probably around a 14 plate, to be honest the 320d doesn't really interest me but the 3 litres do.I've never had awd so for me that would be an upgrade, I understand not as fun as rwd but their is the safety element to it... I had a f10 530d for a short while only a se great engine,hated the seats and over all the car was too big I have quite a tight driveway.

other cars I keep considering are the golf r, seat cupra as the used prices are better than I thought they would be.. bmws seem to hold their value pretty well compared!




helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
Any apart from the 320d.

msej449

177 posts

152 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
I had an F31 330d xDrive Touring for 3 years. I think it's a great car for your situation and I'd go with xD on the basis that not only is this a powerful engine but it's heavy on torque. xDrive makes the handling very 'neutral' i.e. neither under or over-steer biased. But this isn't to everyone's taste and some people describe it as boring. With winter tyres on, I've driven happily in conditions that saw an X5 in the ditch (too much momentum on snow - don't assume big 4x4s are the safest family transport). And when you're on your own, you have a 0-60 in 5s machine. But don't expect it to be nimble/exciting: even a M with adaptive suspension will betray it's weight and setup. At the time, my job involved a lot of driving 'round the country in all weathers and it fitted the bill perfectly as an effortless long-distance cruiser with a lot of capacity (over a saloon) and capable of handling winter wet weather, cold roads and snow.

I have a set of winter wheels and tyres, roofbars and snowchains for sale, if you do decide to go for an F31.

Oh and the replacement? An M235i Convertible RWD. Change in job meant I don't travel so much and kids now off our hands ....


Edited by msej449 on Sunday 20th November 18:08


Edited by msej449 on Sunday 20th November 18:10

JakeT

6,002 posts

151 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
I'd say 330d. Mainly because the xDrive models can't have the Sport suspension, so you lose out there. Not to mention a good set of winters should see you pretty well through the chilly months. 320d doesn't do a lot for me besides economy, and over recent years the 6-cyl models have proven to be more reliable.

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
Make sure you get M Sport seats as you say the SE seats are pants,for Power /MPG has to be the 30d derv with no Xdrive which just ruins the ride you and with Xdrive only get SE suspension even if it says M Sport unless you option Adaptive.

podpod

Original Poster:

135 posts

146 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
JakeT said:
I'd say 330d. Mainly because the xDrive models can't have the Sport suspension, so you lose out there. Not to mention a good set of winters should see you pretty well through the chilly months. 320d doesn't do a lot for me besides economy, and over recent years the 6-cyl models have proven to be more reliable.
330d are cheaper than the xdrives and the 335d too..

i know alot of people with the Xdrive change out there springs ta ACS (theirs a few threads about its) the question is how does a stock 330d compare to a 330d xdrive with changed out springs?

oh and i would only go for a msport!!



Edited by podpod on Sunday 20th November 18:55

keepoffthemarbles

58 posts

121 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
I'm a thousand miles into my 335d xDrive M Sport. It's an awesome car, but flawed in the suspension department as you will read all over the place. If I'm honest, the suspension isn't causing me too much pain, but I do not like the run flat tyres.

The engine and gearbox are mega and wafting along on the wave of torque is addictive. I've driven the 330d also and to be fair it's not that far behind day to day. I also had a 330d RWD loaner when my Mini was playing up and getting that thing out of damp junctions in a hurry was very hit and miss so for me AWD was a major purchasing factor. In fact, I ruled out an M140 partly because of this and it was a little too small.

Extras I'd look out for (assuming they are the same on a 14 plate). Media Pro, HUD, Comfort Access, Surround View and for me the extra to end all extras is Adaptive Headlights.

Marbles.

Wills2

29,910 posts

206 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
The 320d, the lightest car and most economical, will cruise at 90mph all day and return good mpg, which after all is the point of a diesel.


smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
The 320d, the lightest car and most economical, will cruise at 90mph all day and return good mpg, which after all is the point of a diesel.

is it though Wills apart from my 50mpg I can stick my 30d in sport ,lever to the left and ...vroom!! smile

podpod

Original Poster:

135 posts

146 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
The 320d, the lightest car and most economical, will cruise at 90mph all day and return good mpg, which after all is the point of a diesel.

320d is the sensible choice, but also competes with a lot of other 2 litre engines! I don't think the 320d is "enough" for me. i'd rather get a Skoda or Seat to be honest.

cerb4.5lee

45,290 posts

211 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
If it has to be diesel then I'd go 330d without xdrive.

A 335i touring would be my pick but rare as hens teeth.

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
podpod said:
320d is the sensible choice, but also competes with a lot of other 2 litre engines! I don't think the 320d is "enough" for me. i'd rather get a Skoda or Seat to be honest.
2.0d isn't really sensible. People think it is, perceived benefits are better mpg, lower running costs etc. Reality is: mpg no better than 3.0, less refined engine, less power, less reliability. And a little part of you will cry every time you start it up and wish you had a 6 cylinder.

Wills2

29,910 posts

206 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
podpod said:
Wills2 said:
The 320d, the lightest car and most economical, will cruise at 90mph all day and return good mpg, which after all is the point of a diesel.

320d is the sensible choice, but also competes with a lot of other 2 litre engines! I don't think the 320d is "enough" for me. i'd rather get a Skoda or Seat to be honest.
Of course it's only my opinion but a 320d M sport on 18" wheels is a really good steer and the best handling cooking 3 series and is leagues ahead of a FWD Skoda/Seat to drive, the 335d is a wallowy boat in comparison.

Same weight as my old 911 at 1500KG and 7 seconds to 60mph more than enough.

Yes the others are faster but don't be fooled into thinking that they are better drives as they aren't.

Here is Chris Harris's take on the 320d:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zKrXFTL_6pw




cerb4.5lee

45,290 posts

211 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
podpod said:
Wills2 said:
The 320d, the lightest car and most economical, will cruise at 90mph all day and return good mpg, which after all is the point of a diesel.

320d is the sensible choice, but also competes with a lot of other 2 litre engines! I don't think the 320d is "enough" for me. i'd rather get a Skoda or Seat to be honest.
Of course it's only my opinion but a 320d M sport on 18" wheels is a really good steer and the best handling cooking 3 series and is leagues ahead of a FWD Skoda/Seat to drive, the 335d is a wallowy boat in comparison.

Same weight as my old 911 at 1500KG and 7 seconds to 60mph more than enough.

Yes the others are faster but don't be fooled into thinking that they are better drives as they aren't.

Here is Chris Harris's take on the 320d:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zKrXFTL_6pw


Don't get me wrong the 3 litre diesels aren't anything to get excited about, but the 20d engine in my old 520d is easily the worst engine I've ever sat behind.

For me a 4 pot diesel engine from any manufacturer is just the pit's, they're crude feeling and sound terrible...granted they can be economical in certain applications but it's an engine that you can only hate.

numtumfutunch

5,184 posts

169 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
msej449 said:
I had an F31 330d xDrive Touring for 3 years. I think it's a great car for your situation and I'd go with xD on the basis that not only is this a powerful engine but it's heavy on torque. xDrive makes the handling very 'neutral' i.e. neither under or over-steer biased. But this isn't to everyone's taste and some people describe it as boring. With winter tyres on, I've driven happily in conditions that saw an X5 in the ditch (too much momentum on snow - don't assume big 4x4s are the safest family transport). And when you're on your own, you have a 0-60 in 5s machine. But don't expect it to be nimble/exciting: even a M with adaptive suspension will betray it's weight and setup. At the time, my job involved a lot of driving 'round the country in all weathers and it fitted the bill perfectly as an effortless long-distance cruiser with a lot of capacity (over a saloon) and capable of handling winter wet weather, cold roads and snow.

I have a set of winter wheels and tyres, roofbars and snowchains for sale, if you do decide to go for an F31.

Oh and the replacement? An M235i Convertible RWD. Change in job meant I don't travel so much and kids now off our hands ....


Edited by msej449 on Sunday 20th November 18:08


Edited by msej449 on Sunday 20th November 18:10
Vaguely interested in the wheels/tyres

Where in the UK are you roughly please?

Cheers

silent ninja

867 posts

131 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
smashy said:
Make sure you get M Sport seats as you say the SE seats are pants,for Power /MPG has to be the 30d derv with no Xdrive which just ruins the ride you and with Xdrive only get SE suspension even if it says M Sport unless you option Adaptive.
helix402 said:
2.0d isn't really sensible. People think it is, perceived benefits are better mpg, lower running costs etc. Reality is: mpg no better than 3.0, less refined engine, less power, less reliability. And a little part of you will cry every time you start it up and wish you had a 6 cylinder.
Agree with these guys. I had a similar choice with the 35d Xdrive and 30d basically at parity in terms of cost. The XDrive looks like it's on stilts and I couldn't see the point in buying a car then modifying it at my cost. 4wd isn't an absolute necessity; can't say RWD has been a major issue for me in Britain.
I've had my car for 7 months and can report the mpg is stellar and performance is there when you need it. the 30d is a terrific cruiser - 70mph and you're only doing 1500 revs with plenty of pull well into triple digits when you need to overtake. It's amazing how these cars can do 0-60mph in less than 5.5s or so yet return mpgs cars dreamt of 15-20 years ago.

Nothing beats a petrol though. I miss the revving but I appreciate the diesel when I've got the family and luggage in the car and we're cruising along for 100 odd miles. 3 litre diesels make a great GT car.

335d

758 posts

149 months

Sunday 20th November 2016
quotequote all
A vote for the 335d here, although it is a bit irritating to have to upgrade the springs. The end result is a fair bit better than standard M Sport suspension. The 330d is pretty good too, and probably 4mpg more efficient, so perhaps a test drive is needed to see whether the extra pace is worth it for you.

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Monday 21st November 2016
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
If it has to be diesel then I'd go 330d without xdrive.

A 335i touring would be my pick but rare as hens teeth.
Ditto.

smashy

3,108 posts

189 months

Monday 21st November 2016
quotequote all
335d said:
A vote for the 335d here, although it is a bit irritating to have to upgrade the springs. The end result is a fair bit better than standard M Sport suspension. The 330d is pretty good too, and probably 4mpg more efficient, so perhaps a test drive is needed to see whether the extra pace is worth it for you.
hello 335d in my F30 30d on a journey back to London one night on the M4 to keep me amused resetting the obc for 15 mile intervals at 80mph 70 mph and 55/60mph ( lorries in the way) the OBC showed 46mpg 56mpg and 72 mpg yes 72 mpg

the 80mph and 70mpph were in comfort the 55/60mph in eco pro

It would be really intersting to see what the 335d would do.I did this exact thing with my 120d a few years ago on the same stretch and the mpgs were exactly the same to the 1mpg

335d

758 posts

149 months

Monday 21st November 2016
quotequote all
smashy said:
hello 335d in my F30 30d on a journey back to London one night on the M4 to keep me amused resetting the obc for 15 mile intervals at 80mph 70 mph and 55/60mph ( lorries in the way) the OBC showed 46mpg 56mpg and 72 mpg yes 72 mpg

the 80mph and 70mpph were in comfort the 55/60mph in eco pro

It would be really intersting to see what the 335d would do.I did this exact thing with my 120d a few years ago on the same stretch and the mpgs were exactly the same to the 1mpg
Smashy - I can't remember if your car is sDrive or xDrive - I'm asuming sDrive as those are certainly above the figures I would get. My long term average is just below 40mpg. I believe the 330xd has very similar fuel economy to the 335(x)d.

I would estimate 45 / 52 / 60 mpg for those steady speeds. I'll have to see if I have the patience to try it out. I routinely get just above 50mpg on a longish cross country A road run, where overtaking is futile as there are just a procession of cars. On a 300 mile 90-95mph (autobahn of course) run with occasional roadworks it is always almost bang on 40mpg by the end which I find very impressive.