Garage Hourly rates
Discussion
Googled to find that BMW main agents were charging £215 hour for car repair, that was during 2014 and the highest charging garage in England (Brentford). Took my newly acquired e46 into my local indie BMW garage and their charge was £60 hour labour. Not to bad at all but of course would prefer a lower hourly rate. (Bury st Edmunds, Suffolk)
How do you fare on the hourly rate charges, unless you have the time, ability and kit to DIY of course.
How do you fare on the hourly rate charges, unless you have the time, ability and kit to DIY of course.
I've had a few jobs done by my local Sytner garage in the past to maintain main agent history, and looking at them now I can't really see what their hourly rate is!
Probably why they do their invoices as they do. 
But my local BMW indie (who is ex-Sytner anyway) charges £60 + VAT per hour, which seems pretty reasonable in this part of the world. (Just hope he doesn't read this)!
Probably why they do their invoices as they do. 
But my local BMW indie (who is ex-Sytner anyway) charges £60 + VAT per hour, which seems pretty reasonable in this part of the world. (Just hope he doesn't read this)!
Ive landed on my feet really, where I'm from the local BMW specialist is ex main dealer and all warranties are still valid and he is about £60ish plus vat, I used to take my M3 there when he was only £50 an hour, however he realises I don't want to really be spending that on my crappy old 325 ti and he put me in touch with a guy he knows who is ex BMW main dealer and now has his own little garage and charges £35 quid an hour, no VAT lol and he is very local to me so I'm a happy chappy
Andy70 said:
Ive landed on my feet really, where I'm from the local BMW specialist is ex main dealer and all warranties are still valid and he is about £60ish plus vat, I used to take my M3 there when he was only £50 an hour, however he realises I don't want to really be spending that on my crappy old 325 ti and he put me in touch with a guy he knows who is ex BMW main dealer and now has his own little garage and charges £35 quid an hour, no VAT lol and he is very local to me so I'm a happy chappy
Result! My BMW Indie charges the same rate for my Z4 Coupe as my "crappy old 325ti"!Just curious, but where are you?
Bristol, my old regular garage who's rates have gone up is Redish, (last time I used him was on my M3 and he was 55 quid an hour then, bargain),some have mentioned him on here, he is great but cant justify nearly 80 quid an hour on my car, no disrespect to him still loads less than the dealers and his work is still BMW warrantied I think, he recommended a friend of his, they still work together on projects I believe now and again and this guy operates not too far from me, so I go there now
Mave said:
Would you mind sharing his name / details? I'm up for a service in the new year, so starting looking around the Bristol area :-)
Do you mind if I check with him first just to make sure he is ok with it? feel free to message me privately if you wish, you never know he might appreciate the free recommendations, but best make sure. He is on the A38 near the kings head pub (Bedminster Down) if that is local enough for youMave said:
Would you mind sharing his name / details? I'm up for a service in the new year, so starting looking around the Bristol area :-)
Just for the record though, the receipt wouldn't show him as a BMW specialist as he works on most vehicles so he operates as just a 'general mechanic', but for me its the piece of mind that he can diagnose faults probably more efficiently and know his way around BM's a bit better than someone who works on fords/Vauxhalls most days and his prices are more than reasonable but like I said has a history with BM main dealers and a local BM indi, plus works closely with Redish from time to time Although somewhat off topic, sorry, it is worth throwing this out there as it was mentioned above, It is my understanding that no work done by an indy or any other type of mechanic outside of BMW, is warranted by BMW in any way, other than for parts BMW agents may supply to them that carry a parts warranty. As far as servicing and brake type parts go, this will be be very little as most indies probably use aftermarket parts, especially under the OE description when customers then believe the garage means original BMW. It really means OE quality according to the supplier of aftermarket stuff, so that is usually just the word of the aftermarket advisor. Some may argue that they know for certain an aftermarket supplier supplies parts to BMW so therefore is actually an OE part, but that aftermarket manufacturer may have submitted several parts to a vehicle manufacturer only to have one specific part approved, yet this entitles the aftermarket manufacturer to claim their parts are OE quality, and here we fall into the trap.
The only thing the indies can claim, rightfully, is that the BMW manufacturers warranty is not invalidated by having your car serviced or repaired there, assuming they carry out work according to BMW specification using genuine BMW parts, that is not the same as warranting the work they do, no matter how recently an indie tech left the authorised workshop.
All parts an indie fits, have to be processed by BMW warranty via the approved workshop if suspected to be defective, which means either you or the indy have to authorise investigation for such defect claims prior to acceptance. Nothing is warranted unless validated, harsh maybe but correct, yet claims can be straightforward once the authority to proceed is granted. Also worth a note, is that this should never have to be given by any customer, but your chosen repairer, who should arrange all of this. A good one will, giving peace of mind.
Just worth a mention, as I suspect many people have little idea of how things work in that regard from things I've read on here and elsewhere.
Another thing to consider for some, is that indies, although great for straightforward nut and bolt work, and familiarity work, by that I mean solutions they remember form their time in the dealership, they don't always have access to service information that could mean for you, a different type of repair. It is possible if they don't have the licensed BMW tech, or Autologic for example with support, or similar, that the only way they find out some technical improvements, or known possible fixes, is via help from elsewhere or lengthy diagnosis, or worse in previous experiences, trial and error, leaving a customer paying for the parts fitted during the investigation. A main dealer is less likely to do this in my experience, although still possible if the tech tries to cover up poor diagnosis. It's hard to gauge who to trust, but my point ultimately, is that a labour rate half of the dealers isn't always, for certain types of work in particular, good value or necessarily going to lead to the best repair for me/you.
It's really hard to know how good people are at all sorts of work, even simple stuff can be done by ham fisted people wherever they work, including main dealers, so rates are not all there is to it, reputation counts for a lot. Some always do more than the basic job, but few I suspect, in that they clean around areas worked on when not necessary, or carry out little jobs foc. If the dealers did this and offered rates depending on the type of work everyone's options would be greater.
I'm just being devils advocate here, only prompted to reply like this as someone believes indie work is warranted by BMW, that's how I interpreted it haha.
On the subject, here's a test for some. Ask any independent claiming they're using 'OE' parts, to produce the receipt from the dealer. As OE really means original dealer supply, where OE quality means the better end of the aftermarket. Even if you tell them you accept they make money here most won't show you I suspect. After all it is cheeky haha. Another aspect is that I bet that a constructive conversation with your BMW dealer will get you your service and brake parts for example, at a discount, at least 10% but up to 20% if you are honest about taking it to an indy to repair. Actually they may offer you a labour deal if switched on, but more significantly, they may know the indy if you tell them where you're going, and also know that they never sell this type of part to them, meaning you can get the parts you really want, and that are truly better for your car, at better prices than the indy would supply them to you even if they had bought them from the dealer, it's a win.
I have done this several times over past years, although with people I have got to know a bit, but I just don't discuss the conversations I have had at the dealers, with the indy, I just say I bought the parts intending to do it myself but haven't the time etc.
Just my 2p, should be a new thread but the prompt was in this one..........please carry on :-)
The only thing the indies can claim, rightfully, is that the BMW manufacturers warranty is not invalidated by having your car serviced or repaired there, assuming they carry out work according to BMW specification using genuine BMW parts, that is not the same as warranting the work they do, no matter how recently an indie tech left the authorised workshop.
All parts an indie fits, have to be processed by BMW warranty via the approved workshop if suspected to be defective, which means either you or the indy have to authorise investigation for such defect claims prior to acceptance. Nothing is warranted unless validated, harsh maybe but correct, yet claims can be straightforward once the authority to proceed is granted. Also worth a note, is that this should never have to be given by any customer, but your chosen repairer, who should arrange all of this. A good one will, giving peace of mind.
Just worth a mention, as I suspect many people have little idea of how things work in that regard from things I've read on here and elsewhere.
Another thing to consider for some, is that indies, although great for straightforward nut and bolt work, and familiarity work, by that I mean solutions they remember form their time in the dealership, they don't always have access to service information that could mean for you, a different type of repair. It is possible if they don't have the licensed BMW tech, or Autologic for example with support, or similar, that the only way they find out some technical improvements, or known possible fixes, is via help from elsewhere or lengthy diagnosis, or worse in previous experiences, trial and error, leaving a customer paying for the parts fitted during the investigation. A main dealer is less likely to do this in my experience, although still possible if the tech tries to cover up poor diagnosis. It's hard to gauge who to trust, but my point ultimately, is that a labour rate half of the dealers isn't always, for certain types of work in particular, good value or necessarily going to lead to the best repair for me/you.
It's really hard to know how good people are at all sorts of work, even simple stuff can be done by ham fisted people wherever they work, including main dealers, so rates are not all there is to it, reputation counts for a lot. Some always do more than the basic job, but few I suspect, in that they clean around areas worked on when not necessary, or carry out little jobs foc. If the dealers did this and offered rates depending on the type of work everyone's options would be greater.
I'm just being devils advocate here, only prompted to reply like this as someone believes indie work is warranted by BMW, that's how I interpreted it haha.
On the subject, here's a test for some. Ask any independent claiming they're using 'OE' parts, to produce the receipt from the dealer. As OE really means original dealer supply, where OE quality means the better end of the aftermarket. Even if you tell them you accept they make money here most won't show you I suspect. After all it is cheeky haha. Another aspect is that I bet that a constructive conversation with your BMW dealer will get you your service and brake parts for example, at a discount, at least 10% but up to 20% if you are honest about taking it to an indy to repair. Actually they may offer you a labour deal if switched on, but more significantly, they may know the indy if you tell them where you're going, and also know that they never sell this type of part to them, meaning you can get the parts you really want, and that are truly better for your car, at better prices than the indy would supply them to you even if they had bought them from the dealer, it's a win.
I have done this several times over past years, although with people I have got to know a bit, but I just don't discuss the conversations I have had at the dealers, with the indy, I just say I bought the parts intending to do it myself but haven't the time etc.
Just my 2p, should be a new thread but the prompt was in this one..........please carry on :-)
Andy70 said:
Mave said:
Would you mind sharing his name / details? I'm up for a service in the new year, so starting looking around the Bristol area :-)
Do you mind if I check with him first just to make sure he is ok with it? feel free to message me privately if you wish, you never know he might appreciate the free recommendations, but best make sure. He is on the A38 near the kings head pub (Bedminster Down) if that is local enough for youCarsOrBikes said:
snip
That's why mine only uses 'genuine' parts, and has a trade account at his local BMW dealer for parts, and I get a copy of the parts invoice for my records. The only non-genuine parts mine has fitted are the aftermarket stuff (intake, exhaust, pads) and the clutch/flywheel (£1400 fitted using LUK parts at an indy vs £3400 for BMW parts plus fitting at the same indy).Sometimes I supply the parts when I know I can get them cheaper from a different dealer.
BTW, I once asked 4 of the same franchise of BMW dealers to quote for an Inspection 2 on my car. Despite them all claiming the same hourly rate, the price varied by £400 between them and none could explain why. Went to the cheapest in the end obviously. Was even happier when I checked and found out the UV-marked service parts had been replaced as per the service schedule (only UV-marked as I'd had suspicions of work not being carried out previously - as I'd got it back from an earlier inspection with no valve clearance report, no shims needed and no record of cam chest gasket being replaced).
mmm-five said:
....... Was even happier when I checked and found out the UV-marked service parts had been replaced as per the service schedule (only UV-marked as I'd had suspicions of work not being carried out previously - as I'd got it back from an earlier inspection with no valve clearance report, no shims needed and no record of cam chest gasket being replaced).
Were the parts really replaced? - Or did they simply use a black light, find all of the UV markings and simply wiped them off! 

Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



