E92 325i auto box problem
E92 325i auto box problem
Author
Discussion

Glade

Original Poster:

4,518 posts

254 months

Sunday 18th December 2016
quotequote all
I have an E92 325i with GA6HP19Z ZF box.

Have had an intermittent problem that is getting more frequent.

When it happens, my code reader stores
4F85
4F83



It doesn't happen on short journeys, only after an hour or so.

At which point at a steady speed (say 70) you would expect the box to be in 6th, if you accelerate the revs will rise before there is any noticeable acceleration but it doesn't seem to be changing gear. Then sometimes it seems to be hunting between 5th and 6th.

Then it throws an orange warning light and goes to neutral. Mostly it then locks in 4th until you restart the car. Sometines it just stays in neutral.

If you use manual mode to lock in 6th it confirms that the clutch is 'slipping' and locking in 5th or 6th makes no difference eventually it drops into fault mode.

Any ideas?


Glade

Original Poster:

4,518 posts

254 months

Sunday 18th December 2016
quotequote all
http://www.bmwlogicseven.com/?p=3738

This is the best resource I have found. When mentioning those codes he suggests valve body rebuild, and that loss of pressure will put serious strain on the clutches...

Are we looking at rebuild time??

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Monday 19th December 2016
quotequote all
Glade said:
Are we looking at rebuild time??
Maybe. How many miles has it done ?

Suggest take it to your local auto gearbox specialist.
ZF boxes are used in lots of cars, so there should be
no problem finding someone to look at it.

FYI, new ZF box about £1100 without VAT and you'll want to have
a new torque converter while you're in there, about £250 again
sans VAT. New fluid not cheap either.

About six hours fitting time too. About £2K all told.

So it will be well worth finding out what the specialist
says. Feel free to get a second or third opinion before
committing yourself.


iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 19th December 2016
quotequote all
dcb said:
FYI, new ZF box about £1100 without VAT and you'll want to have
a new torque converter while you're in there, about £250 again
sans VAT. New fluid not cheap either.
Really? Is that direct from ZF?

Elliot2000

786 posts

207 months

Monday 19th December 2016
quotequote all
They suffer with oil leaks and if the oil gets low enough then I can start getting those issues. But also quite likely u may be looking at a rebuild.

Not hard to check the level if u can get it on a ramp

Glade

Original Poster:

4,518 posts

254 months

Monday 19th December 2016
quotequote all
75,000 miles.

The first "specialist" I rang seemed to think it was better to wait for total failure before replacing the whole thing. Not mush of a specialist.

I better ring a few more places.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 20th December 2016
quotequote all
Glade said:
75,000 miles.

The first "specialist" I rang seemed to think it was better to wait for total failure before replacing the whole thing. Not mush of a specialist.

I better ring a few more places.
This site might help:

http://www.fedauto.co.uk/

You can locate an approved repairer who has knowledge / experience working with ZF gearboxes. FATE will afford you some protection if anything does go wrong compared with another so called 'specialist.'

My experience with an approved FATE workshop with my ZF 6HP was that they knew what I was talking about when we exchanged a few e-mails. When I went there they were clear about costing throughout and within hours they knew what it was... they gave me a lead time... and the car was ready in that time. It turned out to be my mechatronic sleeve... it leaked and caused low oil so the gearbox was going a bit loopy shall we say.

wax lyrical

1,074 posts

272 months

Tuesday 20th December 2016
quotequote all
My 2008 E93 335i has over 125k miles on the clock with no transmission issues at all. I think it uses the same ZF unit?


Glade said:
75,000 miles.

The first "specialist" I rang seemed to think it was better to wait for total failure before replacing the whole thing. Not mush of a specialist.

I better ring a few more places.

Glade

Original Poster:

4,518 posts

254 months

Tuesday 20th December 2016
quotequote all
Great tip on that fedauto site. Found a place nearby who look like they talk the talk. Just waiting to hear back.

Alarm bells are ringing though... on their website they have a section that says

website said:
Coolant Poisoning.

This is by far one of the most common failures of gearboxes we see. A mysterious loss of coolant, with no apparent signs of engine issues, often indicates a problem. Unfortunately, this is often ignored until it is too late. The combined radiator/transmission coolers have a limited life, with the barriers between the two circuits being compromised. The coolant then leaks into the gearbox system, with the anti-freeze and water breaking down, effectively steaming off all the linings in your gearbox and attacking the bearing surfaces. At this point, a full refurbishment is the only option. In these cases, we fit a separate cooler and blank off the failed radiator cooler after the repair. We also either refurbish or replace your torque convertor, to ensure there is no debris or coolant left in the system.
A while ago my coolant mysteriously disappeared overnight!!!!! I topped it up and coolant level has been fine since... yikes

I wonder if my transmission oil cooler uses the radiator coolant and that has failed...


Edited by Glade on Tuesday 20th December 19:35

Glade

Original Poster:

4,518 posts

254 months

Tuesday 20th December 2016
quotequote all
banghead

Of course it does!

Sardonicus

19,464 posts

252 months

Tuesday 20th December 2016
quotequote all
Easy to check just remove the filler plug on the side of the box whilst car level and the engine running and check for coolant ingress it will be obvious as the fluid will now be over filled and will gush out, its ruined the box already by now you cant successfully flush the contaminated fluid so a rebuild will be inevitable IMO hopefully this wont be your problem in which case I would suggest a trans service new oil and filter 1st good luck

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Wednesday 21st December 2016
quotequote all
website said:
Coolant Poisoning.

This is by far one of the most common failures of gearboxes we see. A mysterious loss of coolant, with no apparent signs of engine issues, often indicates a problem. Unfortunately, this is often ignored until it is too late. The combined radiator/transmission coolers have a limited life, with the barriers between the two circuits being compromised. The coolant then leaks into the gearbox system, with the anti-freeze and water breaking down, effectively steaming off all the linings in your gearbox and attacking the bearing surfaces. At this point, a full refurbishment is the only option. In these cases, we fit a separate cooler and blank off the failed radiator cooler after the repair. We also either refurbish or replace your torque convertor, to ensure there is no debris or coolant left in the system.
Fascinating.

I wonder if anyone has fed back this info to ZF ?

If I own any more cars with ZF boxes, I'll be checking
for this common fault.


Sardonicus

19,464 posts

252 months

Wednesday 21st December 2016
quotequote all
dcb said:
Fascinating.

I wonder if anyone has fed back this info to ZF ?

If I own any more cars with ZF boxes, I'll be checking
for this common fault.
Nothing to do with ZF but the vehicle manufacturer (i.e BMW) on how they choose to control fluid temps scratchchin