430d or 435d.....xdrive or not
430d or 435d.....xdrive or not
Author
Discussion

diehardbenzfan

Original Poster:

2,948 posts

188 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
After 8 months of toying with all sorts of ideas to get a car, I think I have finally decided and it's going to be a used 4 series bmw, they hold their value very well and they are very nice looking cars.

Now I want to buy this car and keep it for the next 3-4 years, maybe longer which means most of the time, it's going to be out of warranty apart from the 1 year bmw give in approved used.

The natural choice would be the 435d as it's quicker and 4 wheel drive but long term wise, will the xdrive be more prone to problems? As they've only started engineering it in RHD a few years ago.

Some of you will say get the 430d as it handles better but Ive read up on the 335ds and I hear you can get AC schnitser (can't spell lol) springs for around 500 pounds that improves handling.

Anybody here had any problems? Heard any stories??


GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
IMHO save yourself some money and get the 430d RWD.

Unless you live somewhere really remote, RWD will be just fine, and the 430d is plenty quick enough for UK roads.

Kawasicki

14,418 posts

266 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
I've driven both rwd and awd 4 series in the snow in Sweden. Get the rwd.

cerb4.5lee

45,284 posts

211 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
GTEYE said:
IMHO save yourself some money and get the 430d RWD.

Unless you live somewhere really remote, RWD will be just fine, and the 430d is plenty quick enough for UK roads.
Agree with this.

diehardbenzfan

Original Poster:

2,948 posts

188 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
Thanks guys

Here's something funny, there's 2 cars I want, a 435d coupe, 2014 for 26,500 that has no optional extras apart from the 19inch alloys and a 430d gran coupe 2015 with them sport plus pack, adaptive dampers and a few other bits for 30,000, the insurance for the 435d is 1100 a year (im 23) and I can't find a quote cheaper than 2 grand for the 430!!! What the hell is all that about??

Kawasicki

14,418 posts

266 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
diehardbenzfan said:
Thanks guys

Here's something funny, there's 2 cars I want, a 435d coupe, 2014 for 26,500 that has no optional extras apart from the 19inch alloys and a 430d gran coupe 2015 with them sport plus pack, adaptive dampers and a few other bits for 30,000, the insurance for the 435d is 1100 a year (im 23) and I can't find a quote cheaper than 2 grand for the 430!!! What the hell is all that about??
statistics, maybe.

have a good look for better prices, and if nothing turns up buy the 35d

diehardbenzfan

Original Poster:

2,948 posts

188 months

Thursday 22nd December 2016
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
statistics, maybe.

have a good look for better prices, and if nothing turns up buy the 35d
I've made an offer to the dealer for 28,000 for the gran coupe, it's a fantastic looking car, especially in carbon black, granted it costs more but I can imagine it will hold its value well with all the options. There are far cheaper cheaper gran coupes but I'd prefer to buy it from a main dealer.

Kawasicki

14,418 posts

266 months

Friday 23rd December 2016
quotequote all
diehardbenzfan said:
Kawasicki said:
statistics, maybe.

have a good look for better prices, and if nothing turns up buy the 35d
I've made an offer to the dealer for 28,000 for the gran coupe, it's a fantastic looking car, especially in carbon black, granted it costs more but I can imagine it will hold its value well with all the options. There are far cheaper cheaper gran coupes but I'd prefer to buy it from a main dealer.
Good for you, hope you enjoy it!

AB

20,656 posts

226 months

Friday 23rd December 2016
quotequote all
Having driven them both, the 435d has the edge in most situations and actually (probably due to the type of driving I do in it) is much more comfortable due to lack of M Sport suspension.


CarsOrBikes

1,158 posts

215 months

Friday 23rd December 2016
quotequote all
The only advantage of the 3.0 is that it can have M Sport suspension, and more economical than a 3.5, but it is noticeably slower. The M sport plus is ace I think, bigger brakes, better looking car, with the window tint too, plus HK, great. X drive I think will be fine, although it would be nice to be able to try the 3.5 if rwd only. The GC is a bigger car, almost between the coupe and a GT style, but it sounds like it has the right options. Personally, the coupe suits me better at 6'3", and there is no pillar in the way looking right at junctions, and considering the size of the GC the doors don't allow much better access for me than the 1 series 5dr. The GC still looks nice, but the Coupe gets my ultimate vote on looks overall. I'd like the MP brake kit still, even bigger than the M sport plus, and then an M performance body kit :-) Hope you like either, both nice cars.

kingofdbrits

630 posts

224 months

Friday 23rd December 2016
quotequote all
Go for the xdrive, so much easier to get the power down in wet/greasy conditions so you can actually use the power all year round that you've paid good money for. It does rain 180 days a year in the UK.

I find it amusing, today while pootling down a 50mph duel carridgeway i came upto a roundabout, some douche came flying up the outside lane, trying to overtake on the roundabout, we start to exit side-by-side and there's a slow moving lorry 50m up the road so just a gentle squirt that would have a RWD car floundering in such conditions and i leave the Merc standing, make my pass easily and pull in before the crappy RWD cars traction control light has stopped flashing and i leave it go on its merry way, well in excess of the limit.

keepoffthemarbles

58 posts

121 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
I had a 330d loaner for a Christmas tour of the relatives in North Wales. RWD M-Sport saloon and I came away thinking it was all the car you would ever need except for one thing. The slightest hint of moisture on the road would have the traction light blinking like a fairy light.

Eight weeks ago I took delivery of my own 335d Touring. The 4 wheel drive makes a huge difference in everyday use in poor conditions, for example 'sprinting' out of a T-junction, but I suspect as many say on here it will not excel in snow with standard tyres. The 330d managed close to 50mpg over the 1k miles I had it and I suspect the 335d will come in 10% or so down on that on the same tour this christmas. As I've mentioned before on here, the car looks a little uncomfortable on the higher springs, but I'm not overly concerned by the handling especially in sport mode with adaptive dampers.

I thought the 330d offered all the performance you could ever want but 335d is is another level. I don't think you really need the extra performance and in fact the 20d is probably adequate but the 6 cylinder engines are much nicer and what the heck, knowing you have the extra is nice. It's good fun out dragging cars that think you're a 2.0d but make sure you have them beat before the twisty bits ;-)

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
I have never noticed this gulf of performance between x30d and x35d. Perhaps it was the expectation that the 35d was some sort of next level monster alongside a 30d but when I test drove a 535d with a view to purchase I was underwhelmed - it simply felt like a slightly quicker 530d. Since picking up a 15 530d I've driven a friends 14 535d and again - it felt like a slightly quicker version of my own car.

That said there is zero fuel economy penalty (Bar the XDrive effect on the 4 Series) so there isn't really a compelling reason NOT to buy the 35 other than the XDrive.

So, for me, this would be XDrive or no XDrive. My XDrive experience is limited to 20d's where I was thoroughly unimpressed, it just made the car handle more poorly and sapped power and economy. I can't imagine it's much use in wintry conditions as XDrive cars are invariably fitted with 30 profile RFT's anyway.

Edited by Fox- on Saturday 24th December 09:42

keepoffthemarbles

58 posts

121 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
Fair point Fox. Maybe it's down to me only driving the 30d on manky winter roads and not really being able to use the performance. If i close my eyes I can still see that traction light blinking.


diehardbenzfan

Original Poster:

2,948 posts

188 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
my question is though does anybody know of any reliability issues with the x drive? To my knowledge, whenever a manufacturer does something new, it never ends up being reliable until a few generations later, granted they have been doing it in lhd for years but I'm just abit skeptical about paying 30k on something that's relatively new.

Never the less, it's going to be the 430d, going to go in on Tuesday and make it official. I would have liked that 435d but the one in question didn't have any options and all I can think of is the resale value.

Anyways I'll post pictures on Tuesday if I get it! Going to carry on looking for cheaper alternatives but I doubt any new ones will turn up for sale over the following 4 days.

Merry Christmas everyone!


nickfrog

25,463 posts

248 months

Sunday 25th December 2016
quotequote all
Good move. If you're concerned about winter traction then find the smallest oe wheels for that car on ebay and fit some winter tyres. You probably won't have any depreciation on the wheelset when you sell the car.

Big GT

2,114 posts

123 months

Monday 26th December 2016
quotequote all
My 430d has gone back after 24months on lease. The 430d has all the poke needed for uk roads in gear acceleration will leave mosts things. Never driven the 435xd but imagine with extra grunt and 4wd is a a-b world beater.

Tires will last longer on the 430d. Fronts on mine lasted 40k and rears 30k. I averaged 42.7mpg so running costs good for something that quick.

Great engine, gearbox and chassis.

what spoilt the car was the steering that had no feel, the i drive drove me nuts, and the pointless selectable driving modes.

silent ninja

867 posts

131 months

Monday 26th December 2016
quotequote all
I have the 430d GC. I actually think it looks better than the 2 door coupe. The hatch powered boot is big and practical.

I could've had the 435d Xdrive for marginally more, but firstly I didn't want the jacked up height which totally ruins the sporty aesthetic of the car in my opinion (you'll need to modify it with aftermarket springs). Secondly, the RWD feels more fun and has sports suspension (not the floaty SE suspension of the XD).
I've also averaged about 43mpg, similar to above poster. It has so much torque and is genuinely fast in all situations when needed. The cabin is well dampened except for tyre roar (run flats). Gearbox is flawless, steering is quite accurate despite lacking in feel.

Having said that, I had a Jaguar XF for a couple of days and the suspension and handling on that is better than the current crop of 3/4 series - in fact any German car in the same class. You could really point the nose. Shame the cabin didn't feel as premium. I imagine the XE will be even sharper.

Anyway, the 4 series is a good choice. I love the fact my car is so wide and low. It has a better balance of feminine and masculine features in my opinion than the 3 series - the nicest cars (e.g. an F Type) have the best balance - but it still looks aggressive. BMW did well with the design.


Edited by silent ninja on Monday 26th December 12:15

335d

758 posts

149 months

Tuesday 27th December 2016
quotequote all
I haven't heard of any reliability issues with xDrive, and there are lots of 335d and 435d owners on the Bimmerpost forum. Mine is approaching 40k miles now and has been faultless. Some over there are on 70-80k I think.

The 30d and 35d are both good engines. There is a fair difference between them in performance, but they're both pretty refined. xDrive is quite rear-biased, so feels similar to a RWD, but without the yellow flashing traction light.

Andy70

1,463 posts

190 months

Tuesday 27th December 2016
quotequote all
Im going to risk opening a can of worms now, but is it worth getting a diesel full stop? countries are starting to ban them in major cities including ours and for a while now they have been considering taxing them heavily as they are huge polluters, petrol all the way for me :-), plus if you do the maths aren't diesels dearer to run in the long term so you don't see the value in the extra fuel economy saved?