BMW E90 Chassis feel and Runflats
BMW E90 Chassis feel and Runflats
Author
Discussion

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

265 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
Dredging up a favourite topic as I am thinking of getting an E90.

Conveniently my mum has a 330d auto which I have been using today to get a feel for it.

I quite like it but it doesn't have the chassis feel I would want. The steering is fairly good but it is a heavy car and I don't have the confidence to feel the limits of grip, seemingly it is a bit too stiff.

Would binning the run flat tyres help? I assume so but any advice/experience much appreciated. 

Digitalize

2,850 posts

166 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
Runflat tyres and standard M Sport suspension make it very skittish over bumpy roads, similarly though fitting non-rft's made the backend of mine feel a bit wallowy and slow to react.

People do as you'd expect really and fit parts from the M3 to improve handling.

Andy70

1,463 posts

190 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
my partner has an e90 330i and I have an e46, Ill be ditching the run flats too when they need changing but then I'll be into finding a jack and a can of tyre weld or something for the boot (that's all I had in my M3 anyway as standard). The ride is on the firmer side but not unbearable, certainly not as stiff as an m3 so not quite sure what top gear always rant on about regarding the harshness of run flats, but as my partner isn't necessary into the firmer thing we will probably put normal ones on, any way they are cheaper and have more choice too, I recon it should soften it up a bit. just an opinion and gives you something to thing about

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

265 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
Thanks both, I don't mind the ride, though it is a little harsh (this is an SE spec car) but more the lack of feel and hence confidence to push hard.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
I had E92 M sport 335i, 19s runflats to begin. Skittish as someone said, bad ride too. Swapped to Michelin Pilot Super Sports; massive difference on handling, no longer skittish, better grip but still not the best ride.

For winter I wanted some 17s tyres to save costs. so I got some style 158 wheels. Car immediately felt lighter, nimbler, more like my old E46. This was winter and the winter Hankooks whilst good didn't allow me to fully exploit the car but come Spring I decided to keep 17s wheels and put on some Michelin Pilot Sport 4s.

Car was changed for the better again, grip was now outstanding.

For another post on here, last week, I dug up an old brochure and it seems all E9Xs other than 335 have servotronic steering (this was a E91 brochure just in case that's key) so maybe if steering feel is an issue, for you, a 335's th one to go for. In my opinion, the E46 still had the edge on steering feel even when the E92 was feeling lighter/nimbler on 17s and gripping better on MPS4's but my E92 was massively more alive in terms of steering feel than any of the current crop of cars I've driven 1, 2, 3, 5 Series.


stevesingo

5,048 posts

253 months

Saturday 24th December 2016
quotequote all
It might be a good idea, when going from RFTs to Non RFTs, to go up a load rating on the tyres for a slightly more roust construction. In the case of 225/40 R18W 88, go to a 91 and the 255/35R18 90 got to a 94 load rating.

I recently swapped the tyres on our E90 330ifrom Bridgestone RFT to Goodyear F1 Asym 3 with increased load rating. The steering is not quite as direct, but the gains in ride quality, noise and ability to deploy the power outweigh the losses elsewhere.

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

265 months

Sunday 25th December 2016
quotequote all
Thanks all. Ours has hydraulic steering and I think the steering is pretty good.

May take the plunge and get an E91 325i touring and bin the RF tyres.

Digitalize

2,850 posts

166 months

Sunday 25th December 2016
quotequote all
Almost all of them have hydraulic steering, only some very late ones changed to electric.

cerb4.5lee

45,284 posts

211 months

Sunday 25th December 2016
quotequote all
I've currently got a E90 330i m sport and had a E90 330d m sport, and I've driven a E92 330d SE and I thought it handled like a boat in the corners and wasn't in the slightest stiff.

The M Sport with runflats is a very harsh ride but I like the extra stiffness in the corners.

Also got a 640d m sport and ditched the run flats on that, and it's improved the ride dramatically but because of the electric steering compared to the hydraulic its still not a great steer.

As an all round car I do rate the 330d very highly, but for me personally I prefer the M Sport suspension compared to the SE for pushing on.

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

265 months

Sunday 25th December 2016
quotequote all
I don't want a stiff car - this is the comfortable family wagon. So more than happy with some lean in the corners provided the ride is decent. All I want is more connection with the back axle...

I may go for an E60 or even late E46 but subframe issues scare me.

Smuler

2,288 posts

170 months

Sunday 25th December 2016
quotequote all
I'm running a 2002 E46, @ 72k previously took a 2005 to 136k.
No subframe issues and I thought this was predominantly a E46 M3 common problem ?

As I said before these will give you a better connected feel than the next generation.
But maybe try for 17s cos on 18s ride is still firm. Certainly more so than my E92 when I swapped to 17s.

Interesting retorts on my comment on servotronic steering on others but the 335. I'm just going with what brochure said and it was an early one , pre facelift so 2007?

Andy70

1,463 posts

190 months

Sunday 25th December 2016
quotequote all
[quote=Smuler]I'm running a 2002 E46, @ 72k previously took a 2005 to 136k.
No subframe issues and I thought this was predominantly a E46 M3 common problem ?

I agree, I'm far from a BMW expert, but I thought the subframe issue was only on the M3's too, an educated guess to me is that when the M division stiffened the suspension up, they didn't bother reinforcing the subframe which possibly couldn't cope with the extra rigidity? Redish, my local BM indi is working on an upgrade for the M3 subframe. Regarding ride comfort though, my partners 330i is more than acceptable and putting normal tyres on it in my opinion may make a little more softer perhaps. But would I be right in saying that BMW's in general seem to run a bit stiffer than most cars any way as they are drivers cars? 'The ultimate Driving Machine' as the keep telling us. like I said, nothing wrong with the ride on my partners car with runflats, I don't understand what the fuss is about. My bog standard 325 compact seems much firmer than your usual run of the mill ford/Vauxhall, but not harsh

Mike335i

6,090 posts

133 months

Monday 26th December 2016
quotequote all
Just on the steering type used, I believe at the facelift in 2009 all E9x models moved to an electric system, except for the 335i/d and M3 models which retained the hydraulic system.

SidewaysSi

Original Poster:

10,742 posts

265 months

Monday 26th December 2016
quotequote all
My mum had a 1999 318i from new which came apart on a roundabout in a big way.

Think maybe the early cars suffered but I don't want the risk again with my wife and kid.

stevesingo

5,048 posts

253 months

Monday 26th December 2016
quotequote all
SidewaysSi said:
I don't want a stiff car - this is the comfortable family wagon. So more than happy with some lean in the corners provided the ride is decent. All I want is more connection with the back axle...

I may go for an E60 or even late E46 but subframe issues scare me.
I wouldn't worry too much. Ours is used as the family car and it is perfectly OK as such.

There are other advantages of the M Sport spec such as the better seats, short shift gear lever and smaller steering wheel.