Pondering a move to BMW.
Pondering a move to BMW.
Author
Discussion

Wildcat45

Original Poster:

8,160 posts

219 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
Brand loyalty can make you blinkered. For the last decade We've been JLR customers.

A chance encounter with a salesman and his M2 Competition led to the offer of a long and comprehensive test drive and an introduction to a whole new world of interesting cars last week.

The fact that we are considering a move from a diesel Discovery Sport to a smallish 2 door petrol car has highlighted the fact we have no need for a 7 seat SUV. We did once but the need passed and we just got into the habit of buying Land Rovers.

I'm finding the whole BMW range a bit confusing, so I'm after experiences and advice.

There is me, my wife and two Bedlington Terriers. 6-8000 miles a year. We want petrol, preferably six cylinders and it doesn't have to be as fast as an M2 but I'm quite happy if it is. Something with AWD possibly but definitely not an SUV but i do like a fast estate.

I'm thinking around the £50k mark and new not used.

Any thoughts on what would suit?

What about servicing? In 10 years of several Land Rovers, I've only had to have two services. The cost is absorbed into the deal with 5 years "free" servicing. Am i in for a shock with BMW?

Finally, security. Is all the "its easy to nick with a laptop" and "your M2 will be lifted from your drive by tech savvy criminals" chat by the bloke at he end of the bar any more relevant than it is now with a 45k Discovery Sport sitting outside?

I've noticed most BMWs come well equipped but that stuff like electric seats and keyless entry is usually extra as part of a comfort pack. Are there any must have options that you'd reccomend?

The sales guy we met said he had M2 Competition cars in stock. With Land Rover, sometimes we've ordered a build, and waited for minths. Other times theres been a decent choice from stock. With BMW in general, is it a case of building to order and waiting months, or is there usually decent stock of new metal?




Wills2

29,754 posts

205 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
Just get a 540 xdrive touring or m340i xdrive touring.


ninepoint2

4,107 posts

190 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
RS6 thumbup


Wildcat45

Original Poster:

8,160 posts

219 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
Just get a 540 xdrive touring or m340i xdrive touring.
Which was more or less the conclusion i had come to.

How old are these models? I would prefer not to buy something that will soon be superceeded.

CrgT16

2,527 posts

138 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
The 3 series has just been launched, the 5 series is about 3 years in its life cycle. Get the 3 for driving, the 5 for space and comfort. We got a 530d and it’s great to be in. I also had a previous gen 340i and the engine is great, not a sportscar but very nice indeed.

RUSSELLM

6,003 posts

277 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
JLR wise, you don’t fancy an XF estate ? All wheel drive and 300 BHP.

matt21

4,401 posts

234 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
I definitely think the new M340i X Drive Touring. You can get a nice one for £50k

Check carwow and coast2coastcars.com for discount there is often 20%+ discount. With discount they are good value cars

Wills2

29,754 posts

205 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
ninepoint2 said:
RS6 thumbup
They are 100k, he wants a new car.



Wildcat45

Original Poster:

8,160 posts

219 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
RUSSELLM said:
JLR wise, you don’t fancy an XF estate ? All wheel drive and 300 BHP.
I've given it some thought. Its nit a badb car, but it feels like an old model waiting for a facelift.

E-bmw

13,524 posts

182 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
ninepoint2 said:
RS6 thumbup
Only if you like understeer. wink

pincher

10,581 posts

247 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
Similar situation - currently have a 2011 530d estate but don’t particularly have a need for such a big car any more (both kids now driving) Fancy an M2C. Went out in one the other evening. Brutal. You’ll love it. Your dogs won’t laugh

Wildcat45

Original Poster:

8,160 posts

219 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
pincher said:
Similar situation - currently have a 2011 530d estate but don’t particularly have a need for such a big car any more (both kids now driving) Fancy an M2C. Went out in one the other evening. Brutal. You’ll love it. Your dogs won’t laugh
It really was a great test drive. I'm thinking the dogs may be gapper. They don't like being in the boot of the Landy so most times they're out they are clipped onto harnesses on the back seat anyway.

Using man logic for the M2C is easy. We don't use or need all the Disco Sport's capabilities, 7 seats off road stuff etc so lets get a car without those features but with other non essential capabilities like 400BHP.


Pica-Pica

16,668 posts

114 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
Wills2 said:
Just get a 540 xdrive touring or m340i xdrive touring.
+1

pincher

10,581 posts

247 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
Wildcat45 said:
Using man logic for the M2C is easy. We don't use or need all the Disco Sport's capabilities, 7 seats off road stuff etc so lets get a car without those features but with other non essential capabilities like 400BHP.

Just thought I would correct that for you laugh

Wildcat45

Original Poster:

8,160 posts

219 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
pincher said:
Just thought I would correct that for you laugh
Thanks for keeping me straight. An important point there

pincher

10,581 posts

247 months

Thursday 13th February 2020
quotequote all
thumbup