At LAST - a nice looking new BMW
At LAST - a nice looking new BMW
Author
Discussion

pistonbroke PHd

Original Poster:

2,058 posts

237 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Yes, at last a BM I like the look of. The outgoing 2004 E46 coupe was nice and I haven't liked much since - but now there's the 135 Coupe - 3 litre straight six ( cloud9 ) with 305bhp. I think they've got this one spot-on right. The 120d will be £21k, the 135 about £29k.










Apologies if a repost, haven't seen another.

deevlash

10,442 posts

266 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Are your eyes broken? hurl

Kinky

39,943 posts

298 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
I'm with Mr. D on this one yes

K

Stu R

21,638 posts

244 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Nice? God no. I wouldn't admit to being knocked over by one never mind liking them.

clonmult

10,529 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Kinky said:
I'm with Mr. D on this one yes

K
Another vote with you on this.

My housemate was commenting on how good it looked on Sunday evening - I just said nope, you're wrong mate (but then he thinks his bug eyed Impreza WRX looks good).

Its too short/awkward/frumpy. The E36 and E46 coupes are much better looking cars; okay, I've got some bias, but I think the E36 is still the peach of the last 10 years of small BMW "family" coupes.

Marki

15,763 posts

299 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
The more i see the 1 Coupe the more i like it, im about to order a company car and the 1 coupe is high on the list right now

Spokey

2,246 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
clonmult said:
I think the E36 is still the peach of the last 10 years of small BMW "family" coupes.
The words "pot", "kettle" and "black" come to mind.

RichBurley

2,432 posts

282 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Marki said:
The more i see the 1 Coupe the more i like it, im about to order a company car and the 1 coupe is high on the list right now
As a BMW fan, I say "Don't do it!!!". It looks HORRIBLE!

Marki

15,763 posts

299 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
RichBurley said:
Marki said:
The more i see the 1 Coupe the more i like it, im about to order a company car and the 1 coupe is high on the list right now
As a BMW fan, I say "Don't do it!!!". It looks HORRIBLE!
Hsve yet to see one in the flesh but from the pics i have seen i really like it

edx

1,852 posts

236 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
pistonbroke PHd said:
Yes, at last a BM I like the look of.

I think they've got this one spot-on right
Are you insane or visually challenged? wink

I think it looks like a cross between some kind of crap Rover and a Hyundai Accent.

The proportions are just all wrong, especially from the side & rear 3/4 view.

As to a nice looking recent BMW - look no further than the Z4C IMO - ( I am slightly biased though ).


chris7676

2,685 posts

249 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Nice? Lacks character visually, so not my type.

pistonbroke PHd

Original Poster:

2,058 posts

237 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
edx said:
Are you insane or visually challenged? wink

I think it looks like a cross between some kind of crap Rover and a Hyundai Accent.

The proportions are just all wrong, especially from the side & rear 3/4 view.

As to a nice looking recent BMW - look no further than the Z4C IMO - ( I am slightly biased though ).
Let's not forget one thing - beauty is in the eyes of the beholder! As it happens, the Z4M or non-M Coupe is probably the only car that BMW have launched over the past 5 or 6 years that would make me look over my shoulder at as I locked the door and walked towards my house. Not keen on the front end though. And while the new 1-series isn't exactly beautiful, it looks much closer to how the E46 looked (just a bit stubbier) and overall, I like it. It's as much a feeling of relief as anything else, because some of their other efforts are (imho) pig-ugly - notably the saloon version of the current 3-series. I'm still having to force myself to like the 5-series (while the E34 and E39 were absolutely right in their times) and the 7-series has had its styling criticised by pretty much one and all (nice inside though). X5 - instantly forgettable, like a face-lift of the original. X3 - I ordered one when it was announced but cancelled my order - and lost my deposit - because when I saw it in the flesh I didn't like anything about it. And mad though the M6 is, for £85,000 odd it's at the very least underwhelming compared to the likes of the Aston V8, Audi R8 or Maserati Coupe which you can buy for similar money.

I've always liked coupes as a concept, and rear-wheel drive, and my budget next time round would probably be under £30k. Can't think of anything I prefer the look of than the new 135. But it's just my opinion FFS, no need to accuse me of being insane just because I like the look of something. Hey - some people marry ugly women (in the opinion of others) smile

Edited by pistonbroke PHd on Tuesday 23 October 12:19

edx

1,852 posts

236 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
pistonbroke PHd said:
edx said:
Are you insane or visually challenged? wink

I think it looks like a cross between some kind of crap Rover and a Hyundai Accent.

The proportions are just all wrong, especially from the side & rear 3/4 view.

As to a nice looking recent BMW - look no further than the Z4C IMO - ( I am slightly biased though ).
Let's not forget one thing - beauty is in the eyes of the beholder! As it happens, the Z4M or non-M is probably the only car that BMW have launched over the past 5 or 6 years that would make me look over my shoulder at as I locked the door and walked towards my house. Not keen on the front end though. And while the new 1-series isn't exactly beautiful, it looks much closer to how the E46 looked (just a bit stubbier) and overall, I like it. It's as much a feeling of relief as anything else, because some of their other efforts are (imho) pig-ugly - notably the saloon version of the current 3-series. I'm still having to force myself to like the 5-series (while the E34 and E39 were absolutely right in their times) and the 7-series has had its styling criticised by pretty much one and all (nice inside though). X5 - instantly forgettable, like a face-lift of the original. X3 - I ordered one when it was announced but cancelled my order - and lost my deposit - because when I saw it in the flesh I didn't like anything about it. And mad though the M6 is, for £85,000 odd it's at the very least underwhelming compared to the likes of the Aston V8, Audi R8 or Maserati Coupe which you can buy for similar money.

I've always liked coupes as a concept, and rear-wheel drive, and my budget next time round would probably be under £30k. Can't think of anything I prefer the look of than the new 135. But it's just my opinion FFS, no need to accuse me of being insane just because I like the look of something. Hey - some people marry ugly women (in the opinion of others) smile
I know what you're saying about alot of the current model range, alot of it is pretty uninspiring.

Insane was meant in the nicest possible way, but perhaps a little harsh on reflection, I didn't mean to cause offence. thumbup

Each to their own at the end of the day I guess as you say beauty is in the eye of the beholder. smile

MitchT

17,117 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
1 Series coupe looks too square and tubby for my liking. My favourite new BMWs are the 6 Series and the new 3 Series coupe with a sports pack. Of course, an M1 CSL, if they ever did such a thing, would be totally exempt from any looks-based criticism hehe

Cliffv8

565 posts

234 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
It could be nice, getting shoot of the love handles on the bottom of the doors would be a good place to start, and the Z4 M coupe cloud9


Edited by Cliffv8 on Tuesday 23 October 17:53

kilarney

492 posts

252 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Marki said:
The more i see the 1 Coupe the more i like it, im about to order a company car and the 1 coupe is high on the list right now
Im with you here.First co. car that I can have that I would spend my own cash. Looks good in a functional ugly way. Its gonna sell.

flattotheboards

6,689 posts

235 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
the 1 series coupe looks crap imo. the z4 coupe is way nicer.

allnighter

6,663 posts

251 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
The 1 series is a bit like a horrible piece of furniture left behind when you move in a new house.You think about getting rid of it ,you postpone then after a while it starts to grow on you and you end up thinking yes it's not that bad after all.
1st impressions are the truest.Butt ugly definitely.yes

As for PistonBroke, judging by your TV Vs Plasma/LCD appreciation,my comment would go like this: Say no more! hehe (sorry I could not resist!) biggrin

dxg

10,726 posts

289 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I'll say thing for this model - if you look at the feedback on the American forums, they seem to be loving it. So, in that regard at least, BMW may have achieved what they set out to do.

clonmult

10,529 posts

238 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Spokey said:
clonmult said:
I think the E36 is still the peach of the last 10 years of small BMW "family" coupes.
The words "pot", "kettle" and "black" come to mind.
Its close between the E36 and E46 definitely, my opinion seems to vary with the phases of the moon ...

But just looked at the dimensions.

How the hell have they managed to make the 1 series Coupe LARGER than the old E36 Coupe, and yet still manage to bring something out that looks incredibly ungainly?