seems pref.of 330i over 335i how come?
seems pref.of 330i over 335i how come?
Author
Discussion

carlovers

Original Poster:

424 posts

224 months

Sunday 10th August 2008
quotequote all
As above ,what makes a lot of members prefer the non turbo, really curious cheers!!

[TW]Fox

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 10th August 2008
quotequote all
Almost as much power, much more economical, based on the newer N52 not the previous M54..

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
As an engineering achievment the 335i is amazing, but ultimately it is a bit boring, press the throttle and your pushed down the road, in comparison the 330i is just more satisfying.
It will also return 25% better mpg and in this day and age is something to think about.

a contrario

62 posts

219 months

Monday 11th August 2008
quotequote all
All good points. I reckon that the N/A car sounds nicer too...

orangutan

37 posts

241 months

Saturday 16th August 2008
quotequote all
probably because those that prefer the 330 can't afford the 335

having driven both they are both wonderful cars BUT the 335 is a class above in terms of easy to use speed - it is actually more in the M3/RS4 class!

i would also say that even with the turbos it manages to be just as smooth and also has a lovely subdued whoosh under that straight 6 howl....incredible car for the money and, for my money (and i have had both plus a 130i), the much better car....




[TW]Fox

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 16th August 2008
quotequote all
orangutan said:
probably because those that prefer the 330 can't afford the 335
Or not, given there is little between them on the used market.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Sunday 17th August 2008
quotequote all
orangutan said:
.......the 335 is ........ easy to use speed - it is actually more in the M3/RS4 class
And this is exactly why it can be a bit soulless too.

I had a 270bhp 330i as a loan car for 2 days while my 335i was in at BMW. A week later I sold the 335i.

Depends what you want, but it a bit like M3 vs B3, the B3 is just as quick but in a more executive way, my dad would never own an M car but loves Alpinas, where as I would prefer the M as I adore the brutality of them and they hold my interest more.



abarber

1,713 posts

272 months

Sunday 17th August 2008
quotequote all
[TW]Fox said:
orangutan said:
probably because those that prefer the 330 can't afford the 335
Or not, given there is little between them on the used market.
Hardly, was not a factor for me, at all. The 330i felt a lot lighter and sounded sweeter. Just a much more rewarding drive.

orangutan

37 posts

241 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
well the affordability remark was a bit of mischief....

but i guess is does come down to opinion. having spent time in both i cannot think of any area in which the 330 excels over the 335. however i can feel the 335 excelling in both outright and accessible performance, both of which are critical in driving enjoyment of a "performance" car.

personally i found the 330 quite gutless in comparison at lower revs and, for those purists who will scream that you should be in the right gear, you shouldn't always have to! unless you are racing.....


VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
Hmm, personally i prefer the urgency of the N/A unit over the turbo'd unit, as well as the noise.

But then i said the same thing when i sold my 450bhp 993 turbo and bought another n/a 993 C2, on public roads the C2 was simply much more fun to drive and the response from the engine was more urgent, more instantaneous, more alert. I find the N52 to be the most eager production engine i think i've ever driven, be it in 130, 330, or 630 form (not driven the 530i with this engine).

abarber

1,713 posts

272 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
VS, I'm also coming from a 993 C2. Perhaps there's a pattern there!

smile

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
I'm on a 1 series board, babybmw.net, and there are FOUR of us on there who are 964/993 + 130i Msport.

Seems there is a certain common appeal...

Webber3

1,228 posts

250 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
orangutan said:
.......the 335 is ........ easy to use speed - it is actually more in the M3/RS4 class
And this is exactly why it can be a bit soulless too.
This is why I prefer spirited driving in my 330i over my 650i. It's not all about the power and speed. The 650 with its auto gearbox and V8 engine just wafts along reaching stupid speeds with no drama. In my manual 330i you have to push the car hard and work for it.

I looked at replacing my 330i with a 335i a while back, but I couldn't see any compelling reason to change. I'm now looking at changing the 330i for another four door family car but I'm a bit stumped on what to get. I can't stand the new A4 or the A6, don't like the 5 series and the M3 is more of a toy than a family car (an I'm going to get myself a proper toy next spring). Might just have to get another 330i.

[TW]Fox

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
Webber3 said:
Might just have to get another 330i.
Why? Yours is barely 2 years old. Just keep it?

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
orangutan said:
well the affordability remark was a bit of mischief....

but i guess is does come down to opinion. having spent time in both i cannot think of any area in which the 330 excels over the 335. however i can feel the 335 excelling in both outright and accessible performance, both of which are critical in driving enjoyment of a "performance" car.

personally i found the 330 quite gutless in comparison at lower revs and, for those purists who will scream that you should be in the right gear, you shouldn't always have to! unless you are racing.....
I hope you are comparing the new 272bhp 330i vs the 335i and not the older engine that has been around for a good 8 years??

Now my dad loves the Alpinas where as I love the M cars, but we all look for different things in a car.



dxb335d

2,905 posts

226 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
I like turbo shove. So wouldnt even entertain a 330i over a 335i.

The performance difference is much larger than you think. If you like high reving N/A motors the 330i is a cracking car to drive.

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
dxb335d said:
The performance difference is much larger than you think.
Out on the road, i beg to differ...

orangutan

37 posts

241 months

Monday 18th August 2008
quotequote all
"out on the road" is exactly where the difference is so marked actually - on the track with 2 matched drivers there may not be too much in it but in real driving "out on the road" the 335 is vastly quicker, and i mean vastly ;-)

you would have to be trying VERY hard and be a good driver capable of wringing the best out of the car to keep up with a reasonably driven 335 on real-road driving.

don't get me wrong, i love the 3.0 NA engine - had 2 of them (130, 330) but there is a lazy side to me that means i don't always want to wringing the cars neck to go quickly. also, not being able to run several exotic playthings it is good to have something that is a bit of a "swiss army knife" that will stay with exotica but also do the daily grind in comfort.

i used to believe in different cars for different situations and then i found that i just kept wishing i had them all at various points on longer road trips. there is only one way to do that without a major sponsor and support team following you with a fleet ;-)

closest i have had to "one car does all" has been a DMS X3 sd (335d engine with 340hp, 500ish torques) - that was some beast and i regret selling it often...but the 335 coupe is much better handling of course although only slightly worse offroad....


VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Tuesday 19th August 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Agree with caboosemoose on this one.
A friend has an AMV8 and when we play on the road there's nothing to seperate the 130 and the AM - whoever is in front stays in front.

bazking69

8,620 posts

221 months

Tuesday 19th August 2008
quotequote all
One issue for me (as the sort of guy who can't afford a BMW that is still under warranty) is the long term reliability of the 335i, and its turbos/related parts. The diesel has had its well documented turbo problems, even on the latest generations. I personally wait to see what happens as 335i's get out of warranty and on a bit.
I'd love a 335i in a few years time, fanstastic engine, but suspect that the NA 330i may be the thinking mans option as it is a tried and tested unit reliable unit.