Changing my M3 EVO for e39 530 diseasal
Changing my M3 EVO for e39 530 diseasal
Author
Discussion

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,364 posts

243 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Yep, can't believe those words have fallen from my lips, however I drove a 530d last night and while its no ball of fire, its not exactly a slovenly barge either.

Loved the auto box and poke at 2k rpm. Loved the comfort, space, relaxed quiet ride. Loved the fact that speed bumps were suddenly no longer things to be feared and avoided (although I still have the 355 for that). Loved being able to hear the radio and watch TV at the lights.

Apparently things to be aware of are suspension needing a refresh, auto box, cooling system and turbo failure.

I can feel some wafting coming on...




Emeye

9,781 posts

253 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
This reply is pretty common on these BMW diesel threads, but unless you do high mileage, get a 530i instead - great engine, less issue to worry about and not that thirsty if cruising on the motorway - my 530i Sport was manual, and BMW autoboxes crucify the mpg, but they do that to the diesel too.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

230 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
I have a 530i auto and do 20,000+ miles a year. I wouldn't swap it for a 530d.

Emeye

9,781 posts

253 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
To add, I did 11k miles in 7 months and averaged 29mpg in my 530i Sport, and I have a heavyish right foot and like to get places quickly. wink I could see 36mpg if sat in 60-70mphish moving traffic.

Edited by Emeye on Thursday 23 September 12:21

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,364 posts

243 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
OK, also considering a regular 530 petrol...

Great Pretender

26,140 posts

244 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Don't.

The Torque of the Diesel suits the car; the 3.0 petrol can feel a little strained by comparison.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

230 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Great Pretender said:
Don't.

The Torque of the Diesel suits the car; the 3.0 petrol can feel a little strained by comparison.
Not much of a chore to work the rev range of such a lovely engine.

Great Pretender

26,140 posts

244 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Matt UK said:
Great Pretender said:
Don't.

The Torque of the Diesel suits the car; the 3.0 petrol can feel a little strained by comparison.
Not much of a chore to work the rev range of such a lovely engine.
Indeed, but it's still a very heavy car with a relatively torqueless engine.

IMO of course.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

230 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Great Pretender said:
Matt UK said:
Great Pretender said:
Don't.

The Torque of the Diesel suits the car; the 3.0 petrol can feel a little strained by comparison.
Not much of a chore to work the rev range of such a lovely engine.
Indeed, but it's still a very heavy car with a relatively torqueless engine.

IMO of course.
Torque-wise, it's not bad for a n/a petrol. Mines an auto as well, which I guess helps in that when I put my foot down, the right gear is selected.

Edited by Matt UK on Thursday 23 September 16:11

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

243 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
My 528 never feels strained, in sports mode it holds onto the revs anyway.

Emeye

9,781 posts

253 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Drive one - you decide OP! Also you could consider a 525d - the manuals do not have the swirl flap issue!!!

DennisCooper

1,340 posts

201 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Hi there,

the E39 is a great choice still, and the 530d is still very much sought after !

The usual Petrol Vs Diesel debate will always be there - so really it comes down to what you want.

Mine is a Diesel auto, and I love it. Averages 32.1 round town sometimes a little lower and on long runs easily sees 38-42 mpg depending on how much of a grandad speed I want to do!

I've had it re-mapped, EGR valve bypass, K&N induction kit and stainless steel exhaust back box fitted. The increase in power and torque is fantastic, the smooth power delivery is addictive and at motorway speeds the effortless way the speed builds up under that wave of torque is fantastic!

I've yet to do a side by side motorway test with a 530i petrol, but I'm fairly confident I'd be able to pull ahead and with less screaming of the engine - although the 530i petrol is perfectly suited to high revs if needed !

Cheers, Dennis!

sleep envy

62,260 posts

279 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Cactussed said:
I can feel some wafting coming on...
hehe

you're bored aren't you?

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,364 posts

243 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
Cactussed said:
I can feel some wafting coming on...
hehe

you're bored aren't you?
No... whistle

abarber

1,712 posts

271 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Try the 530i, it's a superb engine. Creamy smooth and a pleasure to work.

Sure the diesel has more torque, but then it has to pull gearing that is 1/3 longer.

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,364 posts

243 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Like I said, I need to have a drive of both back to back and then make my mind up.
In the mean time, anyone fancy a nice M3 EVO? wink

sleep envy

62,260 posts

279 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Swap? wink

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,364 posts

243 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
For the Porker?

sleep envy

62,260 posts

279 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Plus cash (to me, you cheeky fker)?

sleep envy

62,260 posts

279 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Plus cash (to me, you cheeky fker)?