Car at the end of PCP - what options
Car at the end of PCP - what options
Author
Discussion

007singh

Original Poster:

268 posts

199 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
Lets say that you have a BMW on PCP, and it comes to the end of the term. The agreement states the car will be worth £10000 at the end, and this will need to be paid to own the car. If the car is valued at £12000, then you clearly have £2000 equity to use towards a new car.

However, if you come to the end of the term and are in negative equity, and the min future value which was meant to be £10k, but the car that is valued at only £8k, you would logically hand the car back. Assuming you want to keep it, would you be in a position to either offer 8k, or a lower figure and offer to buy the car? Anyone have experinece of this? Or are legally only left wtih 2 options: pay £10k or hand the car back?

Bit wooly, but just wondered what happens.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
007singh said:
However, if you come to the end of the term and are in negative equity, and the min future value which was meant to be £10k, but the car that is valued at only £8k, you would logically hand the car back. Assuming you want to keep it, would you be in a position to either offer 8k, or a lower figure and offer to buy the car? Anyone have experinece of this? Or are legally only left wtih 2 options: pay £10k or hand the car back?

Bit wooly, but just wondered what happens.
When the market collapsed at the end of 2008 / early 2009, there were reports of BMW Finance doing deals with people who wanted to buy their cars at a lower value.

But I gather that was very unusual, and the cars are normally taken back by BMW Finance and auctioned at closed auctions, where they generally sell for prices higher than you might imagine.

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Wednesday 6th April 2011
quotequote all
007singh said:
Lets say that you have a BMW on PCP, and it comes to the end of the term. The agreement states the car will be worth £10000 at the end, and this will need to be paid to own the car. If the car is valued at £12000, then you clearly have £2000 equity to use towards a new car.

However, if you come to the end of the term and are in negative equity, and the min future value which was meant to be £10k, but the car that is valued at only £8k, you would logically hand the car back. Assuming you want to keep it, would you be in a position to either offer 8k, or a lower figure and offer to buy the car? Anyone have experinece of this? Or are legally only left wtih 2 options: pay £10k or hand the car back?

Bit wooly, but just wondered what happens.
BMW will retail that same car at £11k though, so why would they sell it to you for £8k?


mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
The term "Guaranteed Future Value" is an oft-misunderstood one.

If your PCP has a GFV, Balloon, Final Payment or whatever that is the amount of money that you are contractually obliged to pay to own the vehicle regardless of prevailing market conditions. In my experience the word "Guaranteed" leads to much confusion. The only thing being guaranteed is that you must pay the final payment specified to keep the car.

This refers ONLY to PCP.




007singh

Original Poster:

268 posts

199 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for all the info. I agree with what all are saying. I just wondered how much scope for negotiaion there might be if you wanted to keep the car, but they were saying it is worth less than the final payment (hence you can give it back and pay nothing).

I would have thought that if the took a car back that was worht 8k, they would need to spend money on it to get it ready for sale, and then have to market it/etc, hence figured they might just accept a little less for it.

Closed auctions - did not realise they might sell for more than expected!

dooosuk

464 posts

256 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
007singh said:
but they were saying it is worth less than the final payment
Would BMW ever admit to that though or would they just say it's worth £10k. I can't see them ever saying it's worth less than the agreed price when you give it back.

tim2100

6,288 posts

288 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
End of the PCP, either pay the GFV, and sell the car on or keep it. OR Hand it back.

If the market value is £8k and the GFV is £10k You will not be able to haggle to get the car at the lower amount. Best chance is try to find out which auction they send it to and buy it from Auction.

Another option is to keep the car, but then that is another agreement you will need to take out.


andy665

4,217 posts

259 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
mattviatura said:
The term "Guaranteed Future Value" is an oft-misunderstood one.

If your PCP has a GFV, Balloon, Final Payment or whatever that is the amount of money that you are contractually obliged to pay to own the vehicle regardless of prevailing market conditions. In my experience the word "Guaranteed" leads to much confusion. The only thing being guaranteed is that you must pay the final payment specified to keep the car.

This refers ONLY to PCP.
With the greatest of respect - thats rubbish. If its a PCP the word "guaranteed" relates to the the value that is set at the beginning of the agreement - it means that as far as the purchaser is concerned that is the minimum that the car can be worth - it is also (and obviously) the amount that is o/s on the agreement should you wish to keep the vehicle and secure full legal title.

You can never be in negative equity with a PCP - you can be left with a penalty charge if the car is returned with a higher mileage than that agreed and / or the vehicle is not in reasonable condition. Most manufacturers use the BVRLA condition report which is entirely fair and reasonable in terms of its expectations.

If the car is worth less than the GMFV then you have been protected from a reduced market value - if you want to keep the vehicle you will not have to pay more than the GMFV - as to whether the finance provider would accept an offer lower than the GMFV - they are not legally obliged to even consider your offer but the worst that they can say is no. If they feel insulted with nyour offer they cannot refuse to let you purchase the car at the agreed GMFV. You cannot negotiate with the dealership as they have nothing to do with the agreement which is between you and the finance provider.

This is based on me having 17 years of experience of developing and launching PCP programmes for a number of manufacturers within the UK

Edited by andy665 on Thursday 7th April 11:21

mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
andy665 said:
it means that as far as the purchaser is concerned that is the minimum that the car can be worth -
With the greatest of respect, that's rubbish.

Much of what you say is correct but trust me there is a misconception about the term "Guaranteed Future Value".

A Ford dealer, for example is not obliged to honour the GFV of, say a Citroen PCP.

Purchasers often assume that they are guaranteed to receive at least the value of the GFV as a trade-in against a new car - they aren't.







Edited by mattviatura on Thursday 7th April 11:49


Edited by mattviatura on Thursday 7th April 11:54

andy665

4,217 posts

259 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
mattviatura said:
With the greatest of respect, that's rubbish.

Much of what you say is correct but trust me there is a misconception about the term "Guaranteed Future Value".

A Ford dealer, for example is not obliged to honour the GFV of, say a Citroen PCP.

Purchasers often assume that they are guaranteed to receive at least the value of the GFV as a trade-in against a new car - they aren't.
I would have assumed that anyone with any degree of common sense would realise that the Guaranteed Minimum Future Value only applies when looked at by the two parties involved in the original transaction - the customer and the finance house - surely people are not that naive that they think that the GMFV has to be honoured by everyone









Edited by andy665 on Thursday 7th April 12:10

007singh

Original Poster:

268 posts

199 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
andy665 said:
With the greatest of respect - thats rubbish. If its a PCP the word "guaranteed" relates to the the value that is set at the beginning of the agreement - it means that as far as the purchaser is concerned that is the minimum that the car can be worth - it is also (and obviously) the amount that is o/s on the agreement should you wish to keep the vehicle and secure full legal title.

You can never be in negative equity with a PCP - you can be left with a penalty charge if the car is returned with a higher mileage than that agreed and / or the vehicle is not in reasonable condition. Most manufacturers use the BVRLA condition report which is entirely fair and reasonable in terms of its expectations.

If the car is worth less than the GMFV then you have been protected from a reduced market value - if you want to keep the vehicle you will not have to pay more than the GMFV - as to whether the finance provider would accept an offer lower than the GMFV - they are not legally obliged to even consider your offer but the worst that they can say is no. If they feel insulted with nyour offer they cannot refuse to let you purchase the car at the agreed GMFV. You cannot negotiate with the dealership as they have nothing to do with the agreement which is between you and the finance provider.

This is based on me having 17 years of experience of developing and launching PCP programmes for a number of manufacturers within the UK

Edited by andy665 on Thursday 7th April 11:21
Thanks Andy, you pretty much summed up my thoughts exactly!

The worst they can say is "no". As for is they would ever say the car is worth less than 10k etc, I guess they might not, but I can judge what it is worth by looking at similar cars/spec/mileage on sale at dealerships and private sales to judge it.

mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Andy we may have got off on the wrong foot, I dislike being told I'm talking rubbish when I'm not.

I've been a licenced credit broker and have sold vehicle leasing and finance products since 1997, although admittedly I'm not currently offering PCP as I don't have a facility to do so.

I like the product, have sold it and used it myself but there is a massive problem as the way it is sometimes sold (often by car sales people who haven't got a clue what they are selling) and (mis)understood by the general public leaves an awful lot of room for misinterpretation.

You are understandably defensive of your product which I agree is fundamentally sound but PCP gets a terrible press. Read some of the other threads on here if you disagree - all it takes is for one purchaser (possibly not as sophisticated as yourself) to misunderstand what they have signed.


Edited to add the all-important word "sometimes".




Edited by mattviatura on Thursday 7th April 12:46

andy665

4,217 posts

259 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
I agree - PCP has not had the best press - the problem is not the product but two main other things:

1. People who can't explain it properly (incredible really as its a very simple product)

2. Customers who hear what they want to hear and think that reading the small print is not necessary (not that it should be if a professional explanation has been provided)

DeanR32

1,840 posts

214 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Great topic here guys.

I've been contemplating a PCP deal on a new BMW for a while now (although I bought an E60 with a personal loan in the end. Need the finance for tax ), and although it seems pretty straight forward, I'm sure there must be grey areas as to where you could get caught out.

On the face of it, it does seem like a good alternative to a HP agreement as there'd be lower payments and I'd have the finance I need to get rid of money for business reasons, but the only thing that puts me off is not owning the car after laying out all that money.

Thinking about it though, I'm going to lose money on the car I've bought as it depreciates so maybe it evens itself out over the 3 year period.

Anyone on this thread got a car through the PCP agreement? Any advice/info any of you can give would be appreciated

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
DeanR32 said:
Great topic here guys.

I've been contemplating a PCP deal on a new BMW for a while now (although I bought an E60 with a personal loan in the end. Need the finance for tax ), and although it seems pretty straight forward, I'm sure there must be grey areas as to where you could get caught out.

On the face of it, it does seem like a good alternative to a HP agreement as there'd be lower payments and I'd have the finance I need to get rid of money for business reasons, but the only thing that puts me off is not owning the car after laying out all that money.

Thinking about it though, I'm going to lose money on the car I've bought as it depreciates so maybe it evens itself out over the 3 year period.

Anyone on this thread got a car through the PCP agreement? Any advice/info any of you can give would be appreciated
PCP will work for many people, the ones it doesn't work for are those that like to keep their cars for 5-10 years.
If you are the sort of person who like to swap every 1-4 years then you can't really beat them, well you can pay cash.

you may actually get a better deal on a contract hire. Lots of people are put off hiring a car, but it is often far cheaper, or rather, the same each month but a much lower deposit.
My only worry with contract hire is you have to see the term out, so I would do a 24 month hire period.
If you need out for any reason after 12 months you still have to pay the full term.

DeanR32

1,840 posts

214 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Thanks Gizlaroc

When you think about it, if you can vary the terms, it shouldn't alter the payments too much as the future value of the car would be greater or less, dependent on the term length

Can you do PCP on AUC's too?

Probably should just ring them instead of pestering people with Q's on here!

mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
gizlaroc said:
My only worry with contract hire is you have to see the term out, so I would do a 24 month hire period.
If you need out for any reason after 12 months you still have to pay the full term.
Not strictly correct mate, it depends on the funder (finance company).

For example Lex always used to ask for fifty per cent of the outstanding rentals - each is different.

I think it would be handy if there was a vehicle leasing/funding FAQ or some such on here, while finance isn't for everyone there are many for whom it's an important consideration and most threads asking questions tend to degenerate into pro and anti factions shouting at each other.

Mods?




gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Yeah you can, and that is when it starts to get really attractive, think I was paid £448 a month for a 12 month old 535d sport touring back in 2006.
And I did a PCP on an M3 CSL as well, and with only £1500 deposit it was around £400 a month for a £35,000 car because the residuals were so good on them.

Best one was a 2 year old Audi S4 avant, it cost me £21000 priavtely and on a PCP through Lombard it was £227 a month over 48 months with a £1k deposit, because they gave a £12.5k balloon on it.
That was a 2005 car that I bought in Jan 2007, so the 48 months would have been up couple of months back and that car would have been worth £12.5k all day long still with 60k miles on it.

People can say "But you never own it!" but I don't care, I don't notice £230 a month going out, but I would notice £21,000 going out.

I believe if the cost of finance is outweighed by the savings made by using it, then go for it.
I know people that set themselves strict limits budget wise and won't use finance, however, a new car will loose a good 25-35% in year one, so take advantage of that, you can be in something for 2 years and it only loose 5-10% a year, then suddenly at 3 years they have no warranty, more expensive servicing etc. etc.
If you look out there, private cars at a year old are only a tiny bit more than the same cars at main dealers at 3 years old, so buy private and fiance the difference if you need to, pay the 7% interest on the extra £2k or so.

You have to sit down and work out which is really the cheapest option, buying cash isn't always.


DeanR32

1,840 posts

214 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
Good idea mate

For some people, financing a car is pretty much the only way I can afford to drive a decent car. A section on here, maybe even a sponsored section would be a great idea.

Me personally, I like to find out what options there are for me and if/how I can afford it before I start the hunt for a car. Having a section on here to visit firsthand would be an excellent idea!


robsti

12,241 posts

237 months

Thursday 7th April 2011
quotequote all
andy665 said:
With the greatest of respect - thats rubbish. If its a PCP the word "guaranteed" relates to the the value that is set at the beginning of the agreement - it means that as far as the purchaser is concerned that is the minimum that the car can be worth - it is also (and obviously) the amount that is o/s on the agreement should you wish to keep the vehicle and secure full legal title.

You can never be in negative equity with a PCP - you can be left with a penalty charge if the car is returned with a higher mileage than that agreed and / or the vehicle is not in reasonable condition. Most manufacturers use the BVRLA condition report which is entirely fair and reasonable in terms of its expectations.

If the car is worth less than the GMFV then you have been protected from a reduced market value - if you want to keep the vehicle you will not have to pay more than the GMFV - as to whether the finance provider would accept an offer lower than the GMFV - they are not legally obliged to even consider your offer but the worst that they can say is no. If they feel insulted with nyour offer they cannot refuse to let you purchase the car at the agreed GMFV. You cannot negotiate with

the dealership as they have nothing to do with the agreement which is between you and the finance provider.

This is based on me having 17 years of experience of developing and launching PCP programmes for a number of manufacturers within the UK

Edited by andy665 on Thursday 7th April 11:21
So you are to blame!!! wink