Which bluetooth headset for c.£100
Which bluetooth headset for c.£100
Author
Discussion

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
Looking for a Bluetooth headset to be used for sat nav directions (paired to a Zumo 340), listening to music and the occasional phone call. Currently considering the Sena SMH5 which can be purchased for about £105. Just wondered what else I should be considering at the price point?

Edited by wilbo83 on Thursday 2nd March 21:32

Bordtea

362 posts

177 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
I've got a Sena SMH10 and it's brilliant. Well worth the money, although I believe the 20s is supposed to be the one to get now, but it's a bit pricier!

I'd definitely go with the SMH10 over the 5 if your budget will stretch

Birky_41

4,668 posts

215 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
I'm crap with anything like this but was recommended a sena. Took me ages to remember the name of it so kept calling it tena lady

Anyways... Another vote for me. I think mines an SMR or similar. Battery easily lasts a day chatting to my mate when I was at iom and quality below 50 people think your in a car

I could hear on an upright bike upto about 110ish

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
Have been investigating this very same topic. As usual, everything comes with ifs and buts. i need a Dual set so.....

As I understand it, the main difference between the

5 -https://www.infinitymotorcycles.com/product/sena-smh5-bluetooth-headset-and-intercom-basic-kit-dual/6804
and the:

10 - https://www.infinitymotorcycles.com/product/sena-s...

was range. As I'm only looking to communicate with my pillion, the 5 works for me BUT

- waterproof capability appears a compromise, unless you get a kit that fits directly into a helmet such as a Shoei GT which then seems to take the kit price above the the cost of the 5 duo -https://www.infinitymotorcycles.com/product/sena-10u-bluetooth-headset-and-intercom-for-shoei-gt-air/6752

https://www.infinitymotorcycles.com/product/shoei-...

How they can otherwise produce external electronic kit and not make it waterproof is beyond me.

So, the equivalent Scala to the '5' looks like its the Freedom duo for £279.99 BUT, it is certified waterproof and rustproof and that counts for a lot. https://www.infinitymotorcycles.com/product/scalar...

Their Shoei Duo set also gets the VAT back: https://www.infinitymotorcycles.com/product/shoei-...

Feedback sought as well!!


supercommuter

2,169 posts

133 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
Raved about my Scala Q1 and Q3 before but mine just cannot handle the charge cycles. Q3 has now packed up and buttons stopped working.

Q1 battery only lasts 3 hours now.

This is from a daily charge cycle 5 days a week for about 2 years on the Q3 and 1 so far on the Q1.

amancalledrob

1,248 posts

165 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
A vote for Sena SMH5. Battery life seems good, audio quality good, easily audible above 80mph with earplugs in. As mentioned if I phone someone below about 60mph they think I'm in a car. Phone button means you can ask Google to read your text messages, voice-to-text, voice dialling, you can say 'navigate to...' and it'll launch Google Maps and start giving you directions, you can ask it what the time is etc - that stuff probs works with any headset that has a similar button/function though

Mine has been through some proper downpours and hasn't suffered, and range seems sufficient if it's you and another biker but maybe not enough for groups

wilbo83

Original Poster:

1,552 posts

196 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for all the responses so far, very useful. The Sena SMH5 sounds like it will be good at what I want it for. My only concern is how ‘future proof’ it is. I have seen different reports suggesting it can only be linked up to 1 other unit and then other sources suggesting it can be connected to up to 4 other units, like the SMH10.

Sena website suggests it is only one-to-one:
https://www.sena.com/product/smh5/

However this webbikeworld review suggests it can be up to 4:
http://www.webbikeworld.com/motorcycle-intercoms/s...



kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
supercommuter said:
Raved about my Scala Q1 and Q3 before but mine just cannot handle the charge cycles. Q3 has now packed up and buttons stopped working.

Q1 battery only lasts 3 hours now.

This is from a daily charge cycle 5 days a week for about 2 years on the Q3 and 1 so far on the Q1.
I suppose the question is do the new units have a different battery.

amancalledrob

1,248 posts

165 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
wilbo83 said:
Thanks for all the responses so far, very useful. The Sena SMH5 sounds like it will be good at what I want it for. My only concern is how ‘future proof’ it is. I have seen different reports suggesting it can only be linked up to 1 other unit and then other sources suggesting it can be connected to up to 4 other units, like the SMH10.

Sena website suggests it is only one-to-one:
https://www.sena.com/product/smh5/

However this webbikeworld review suggests it can be up to 4:
http://www.webbikeworld.com/motorcycle-intercoms/s...

I've linked mine to three others smile

supercommuter

2,169 posts

133 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
kurt535 said:
supercommuter said:
Raved about my Scala Q1 and Q3 before but mine just cannot handle the charge cycles. Q3 has now packed up and buttons stopped working.

Q1 battery only lasts 3 hours now.

This is from a daily charge cycle 5 days a week for about 2 years on the Q3 and 1 so far on the Q1.
I suppose the question is do the new units have a different battery.
This is true. I also found the contact pins corroded badly. £100 for a few years use everyday is not so bad i guess. Maybe I am expecting too much!

Birky_41

4,668 posts

215 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
amancalledrob said:
A vote for Sena SMH5. Battery life seems good, audio quality good, easily audible above 80mph with earplugs in. As mentioned if I phone someone below about 60mph they think I'm in a car. Phone button means you can ask Google to read your text messages, voice-to-text, voice dialling, you can say 'navigate to...' and it'll launch Google Maps and start giving you directions, you can ask it what the time is etc - that stuff probs works with any headset that has a similar button/function though

Mine has been through some proper downpours and hasn't suffered, and range seems sufficient if it's you and another biker but maybe not enough for groups
Thats the name I meant smh I knew it was something like that

Really is very good but I've got nothing to compare it to

Wedg1e

27,048 posts

296 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
I was going to buy the Sena SMH10U 'integrated' set for the Shoei Neotec but then I read more bad than good reviews, mostly based around how it refused to connect to phones and GPS (surely the whole point of it?) and how dire is/was the PC software to set it up.
Now I see they've issued several firmware revisions for the headset so all might be rosy but 200 sheets is a lot to lay out to be a guinea-pig. Also the price has come down about 50 quid which may reflect it being a poor seller.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
Any Scala users here?

welsh blackbird

692 posts

275 months

Friday 3rd March 2017
quotequote all
Wedg1e said:
I was going to buy the Sena SMH10U 'integrated' set for the Shoei Neotec but then I read more bad than good reviews, mostly based around how it refused to connect to phones and GPS (surely the whole point of it?) and how dire is/was the PC software to set it up.
Now I see they've issued several firmware revisions for the headset so all might be rosy but 200 sheets is a lot to lay out to be a guinea-pig. Also the price has come down about 50 quid which may reflect it being a poor seller.
I've just bought one of these for my Schuberth C3 Pro. I haven't fitted it yet, but I'll let you know how I get on with it! (Won't be 'til next month, though).

I paid £209 from Fast Bike Bits via Amazon. Everywhere else seemed to be £259 and over.

The reviews I read were pretty positive; I prevaricated for ages before I took the plunge, but the fact that it's integrated into the helmet rather than tacked onto the side swung it. Also, it gets much better reviews than Schuberth's own system.

As you say, the firmware can be updated, so any flaws should have been eliminated.

SteelerSE

2,028 posts

187 months

Saturday 4th March 2017
quotequote all
I used the Schuberth integrated one for a while and it was OK but not worth the money. It died after two years which is pretty unimpressive at that cost. Some issues connecting, the battery life wasn't brilliant either. All in all a great idea but not a good enough design/implementation.

I've gone with the Sena 20S as a replacement which has much better speakers. They're a bit wider but work well in my Arai. The controls are still taking a bit of getting used to but it pairs effortlessly with my phone and the boom mic seems to provide much clearer communication even though it's in a full face lid.

Talking on the phone is easy, the radio is pretty good and playing music etc via the phone is also really easy. Battery life seems to be about 10-12 hours of being connected via Bluetooth and playing something all the time but that's a guess rather than something that I've measured. You also have the option to plug in your own ear buds if that's a preference.

So far so good.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Saturday 4th March 2017
quotequote all
SteelerSE said:
I used the Schuberth integrated one for a while and it was OK but not worth the money. It died after two years which is pretty unimpressive at that cost. Some issues connecting, the battery life wasn't brilliant either. All in all a great idea but not a good enough design/implementation.

I've gone with the Sena 20S as a replacement which has much better speakers. They're a bit wider but work well in my Arai. The controls are still taking a bit of getting used to but it pairs effortlessly with my phone and the boom mic seems to provide much clearer communication even though it's in a full face lid.

Talking on the phone is easy, the radio is pretty good and playing music etc via the phone is also really easy. Battery life seems to be about 10-12 hours of being connected via Bluetooth and playing something all the time but that's a guess rather than something that I've measured. You also have the option to plug in your own ear buds if that's a preference.

So far so good.
Steeler, can i ask why you chose the 20s over the 10 or 5?

Ty

SteelerSE

2,028 posts

187 months

Saturday 4th March 2017
quotequote all
kurt535 said:
Steeler, can i ask why you chose the 20s over the 10 or 5?

Ty
Mainly because of the sound quality and the FM radio. It also has a much wider feature set. If you look here http://www.webbikeworld.com/motorcycle-intercoms/s... there's quite a good comparison of features.

Features exclusive to the Sena 20S:

Bluetooth 4.0
Built-in FM radio with seek/scan and station presets.
Dedicated headphone/earbud port on the front of the helmet mount (!).
Group intercom function.
Sena smartphone app (Android and iPhone).
Audio multitasking (music or GPS instructions play under the intercom conversation; volume can be adjusted).
Voice command system with adjustable "motion sensor"; tap twice on the intercom module to activate.
NFC (Near Field Communications) allows "tap and pair" with other NFC-enabled Bluetooth devices.
Ambient mode: press a button on the headset to hear sounds and conversation outside of the helmet (overrides internal connections).

Updated Features of the Sena 20S:

Low profile jog dial acts as a button and the phone button on the rear.
13 hours of talk time and 10 days standby time (claimed). SMH10 has 12 and 10.
8-way multi intercom. SMH has 4.
2 km distance for the 20S compared to 900 m for the SMH10.
Can be paired with up to 9 Bluetooth devices. SMH10 has 3.

OverSteery

3,794 posts

262 months

Saturday 4th March 2017
quotequote all
SteelerSE said:
Mainly because of the sound quality and the FM radio.
Does your FM radio work. I'm well pleased with my sena 20, but the radio is totally useless.

Birky_41

4,668 posts

215 months

Saturday 4th March 2017
quotequote all
SteelerSE said:
Updated Features of the Sena 20S:

Low profile jog dial acts as a button and the phone button on the rear.
13 hours of talk time and 10 days standby time (claimed). SMH10 has 12 and 10.
8-way multi intercom. SMH has 4.
2 km distance for the 20S compared to 900 m for the SMH10.
Can be paired with up to 9 Bluetooth devices. SMH10 has 3.
My smh is 4 way, I've never used more than 3 way but upto 6-7 of us go out at times so 8 was would be brilliant (this is sounding like an orgy)

And yep crystal clear in a straight line upto 900mtr or so but quickly cuts out like a dab radio anymore than that

Can't grumble on battery though. I've been out literally all day and it's not gone flat

SteelerSE

2,028 posts

187 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
OverSteery said:
Does your FM radio work. I'm well pleased with my sena 20, but the radio is totally useless.
Yes it does. You need to preset the right frequencies in the app but it works well. I haven't figured out the right control for seeking new channels on the move yet but it's fine for what I want. I have 5 preset channels to make it easier to cycle through them.