K&N Race air filter with standard map?
K&N Race air filter with standard map?
Author
Discussion

andy tims

Original Poster:

5,606 posts

277 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Do I need a remap to make the best use of, or as a minimum avoid damage, if I swap from an OE filter?

The bike is a GSXR 750 K8 with the standard pipe.

I was thinking that more air might lean out the air / fuel mix?

Thanks in advance.

Steve Bass

10,760 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Do you think OEM filters are restrictive???? Really???

The ONLY advantage of a K&N is being able to wash it. And even then I'd wager a regularly changed OEM item out performs it as the oil needed on the K&N gets contaminated and blocked much faster than the cotton type and actually hurts flow.

Seriously, save your $$$. Stick with standard on a performance bike....

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
andy tims said:
Do I need a remap to make the best use of, or as a minimum avoid damage, if I swap from an OE filter?

The bike is a GSXR 750 K8 with the standard pipe.

I was thinking that more air might lean out the air / fuel mix?

Thanks in advance.
Yes. The race versions flow a lot more air. K&N themselves say you need to remap with their race filters.

With their road ones, they flow more than OE, but you don't have to remap them.

http://www.knfilters.co.uk/kn/sport_bikes.aspx

Personally I wouldn't bother with a race air filter and a standard exhaust. I would add one as a supporting mod to a full system, or a decat with a race can.

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Steve Bass said:
Do you think OEM filters are restrictive???? Really???

The ONLY advantage of a K&N is being able to wash it. And even then I'd wager a regularly changed OEM item out performs it as the oil needed on the K&N gets contaminated and blocked much faster than the cotton type and actually hurts flow.

Seriously, save your $$$. Stick with standard on a performance bike....
Most OE filters are paper rather than cotton.

After market filters are usually an improvement IMO, but I'd only put them on as a supporting mod. The major restriction on modern sports bikes is the exhaust system.

Steve Bass

10,760 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
WaferThinHam said:
Most OE filters are paper rather than cotton.

After market filters are usually an improvement IMO, but I'd only put them on as a supporting mod. The major restriction on modern sports bikes is the exhaust system.
Problem isn't the question of whether the filter flows more, it's whether the engine requires more and if the OEM is an actual restriction......
An engine is a pump in simple terms. It draws air in one end and expels it the other. The efficiencies of that are simple to measure.
So if an engine requires (for example) 350 cfm to produce its maximum power, and the air filter supports 450cfm, there's no restriction. However, if the K&N supports 500 cfm, yes it flows more, but there's still no improvement in performance. The engine is pulling as much as it can use with the standard filter and therefore making all the power it can.. And if there were such a restriction, there'd be substantial negative pressure behind the filter. It'd either collapse into the engine or fail creating blow by. But they don't.... funny hey wink
Also, I'd wager the 750 suzi uses the same filter as the 1000? If so, that filter supports 180 bhp, so it stands to reason it'll happily supply the 750's needs.
Finally, if K&N's (et al) were such fantasical things, why are they not used by OEM? How come a paper filter is still able to support the needs of a 200+ bhp engine? With manufacturers seeking ever higher headline figures, surely this would be a magic bullet if the claims stacked up????
Truth is they don't.... Snake oil. Simple as. Even on a full race exhaust kitted bike, OEM filters are by far the best.


WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Steve Bass said:
Problem isn't the question of whether the filter flows more, it's whether the engine requires more and if the OEM is an actual restriction......
An engine is a pump in simple terms. It draws air in one end and expels it the other. The efficiencies of that are simple to measure.
So if an engine requires (for example) 350 cfm to produce its maximum power, and the air filter supports 450cfm, there's no restriction. However, if the K&N supports 500 cfm, yes it flows more, but there's still no improvement in performance. The engine is pulling as much as it can use with the standard filter and therefore making all the power it can.. And if there were such a restriction, there'd be substantial negative pressure behind the filter. It'd either collapse into the engine or fail creating blow by. But they don't.... funny hey wink
Also, I'd wager the 750 suzi uses the same filter as the 1000? If so, that filter supports 180 bhp, so it stands to reason it'll happily supply the 750's needs.
Finally, if K&N's (et al) were such fantasical things, why are they not used by OEM? How come a paper filter is still able to support the needs of a 200+ bhp engine? With manufacturers seeking ever higher headline figures, surely this would be a magic bullet if the claims stacked up????
Truth is they don't.... Snake oil. Simple as. Even on a full race exhaust kitted bike, OEM filters are by far the best.
The 750 actually uses the same filter as the 600, so make of that what you will. The 1000 has a different airbox and filter design.

There's a lot of companies that have made their business selling what you describe as snake oil. Truth is the OEM won't fit them for the same reason they don't fit nice multi adjustable levers/rearsets as standard. Cost! And that it's not a factor to all buyers.

Every decent level race bike I can think of uses afte rmarket filters.

In terms of does the extra flow actually do anything, yes it does. As I'm sure you know the ECU will compensate for the increased air flow within a given range and add a little more fuel too. Giving you a bigger bang = more power. That is of course assuming that your exhaust isn't the biggest inital restriction in the first place. Which IMO is exactly where I'd start. smile



Edited by WaferThinHam on Sunday 5th March 17:26

andy tims

Original Poster:

5,606 posts

277 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Having done further research, I'll stick another OE filter in for now.

If I get round to changing the pipe, I'll get a race filter & a re-map then.

I agree about manufacturers scrimping by fitting paper filters - they still generally fit rubber brake hoses too.

Steve Bass

10,760 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
WaferThinHam said:
The 750 actually uses the same filter as the 600, so make of that what you will. The 1000 has a different airbox design.

There's a lot of companies that have made their business selling what you describe as snake oil. Truth is the OEM won't fit them for the same reason they don't fit nice multi adjustable levers/rearsets as standard. Cost! And that it's not a factor to all buyers.

Every decent level race bike I can think of uses afte rmarket filters.

In terms of does the extra flow actually do anything, yes it does. As I'm sure you know the ECU will compensate for the increased air flow within a given range and add a little more fuel too. Giving you a bigger bang = more power. That is of course assuming that your exhaust isn't the biggest inital restriction in the first place. Which IMO is exactly where I'd start. smile
marketing & hype don't make a product actually work.... wink

So let's use a little science instead of hyperbole and 'race teams use them"
http://www.nicoclub.com/archives/kn-vs-oem-filter....
Testing to ISO standards, rather than internet hearsay biggrin
Bottom line is your assertion that the OEM filters are a restriction doesn't stack up. With the volumes of air being ingested by the motor at max rpm, any restriction would have a sizable impact on performance. yet we don't see that. Any restriction in the inlet system would cause a huge negative pressure on the engine side of the filter that the pumping action of the motor, regardless of combustion, would pull the filter into the engine. But we don't see that either. And if such a restriction were present, fitting a K&N would throw the AFR out across the whole range. bikes run narrow band lambdas and the ECU is set to manage the lambda over a small area of the rev range for emission purposes. Outside this range, the ecu makes no adjustments other than normal temp, baro etc trims tables. but if the filter flowed more, we'd see skewed AFR's across the entire throttle & rpm range EXCEPT where the lambda provides feedback. but once again, we don't....
As for cost, if it were the case, K&N would turn cartwheels to supply an OEM if for nothing more than just the marketing kudos. and if a manufacturer could gain the claimed improvements for a few quid and trump their rivals, they'd be all over it like white on rice. but once again, they're not. and considering the effort, cost and R&D that goes into such things, what's the betting the manufacturers already know this???
The real question however, is whether the k&N flows more air than necessary.....
they don't, and even K&N admit this..
and away form the boring science bit, I've spent countless hours on the dyno and have yet to see a meaningful improvement from a K&N type filter. Even back to back single modification there was never more than half a bhp either way which is normal for a non chassis inertia dyno considering heat soak, tyre temps etc.
I know people really, REALLY wan them to work bu the fact is, they do bugger all. in fact, once the oil is dirty, they actually flow far less than OEM..




Steve Bass

10,760 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
andy tims said:
I agree about manufacturers scrimping by fitting paper filters - they still generally fit rubber brake hoses too.
Andy, if manufacturers could score the gains touted by the likes of K&N just by fitting a filter, they'd have been doing it years ago. The vast amounts of $$$$ poured into engine development for a few improvements inn torque would be laughed at if all they needed was a K&N.
As for scrimping, the question is does the paper element do the job for the duration of the service interval??
Are the BMW S1000RR, 1299 or R1 hampered by their 'scrimped" filters??? On the contrary, they go rather well, and keep going that way for a long time.
Bottom line is if you want to use a filter that flows more air, first you need an engine that needs more air. Without modifications to cam timing or lift, valve duration, intake flow or compression ratios, the motor won't need any more air than its getting. and the oil on the K&N type actually gums up and gets coated in particles faster and actually hurts performance.


WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Steve Bass said:
marketing & hype don't make a product actually work.... wink

So let's use a little science instead of hyperbole and 'race teams use them"
http://www.nicoclub.com/archives/kn-vs-oem-filter....
Testing to ISO standards, rather than internet hearsay biggrin
Bottom line is your assertion that the OEM filters are a restriction doesn't stack up. With the volumes of air being ingested by the motor at max rpm, any restriction would have a sizable impact on performance. yet we don't see that. Any restriction in the inlet system would cause a huge negative pressure on the engine side of the filter that the pumping action of the motor, regardless of combustion, would pull the filter into the engine. But we don't see that either. And if such a restriction were present, fitting a K&N would throw the AFR out across the whole range. bikes run narrow band lambdas and the ECU is set to manage the lambda over a small area of the rev range for emission purposes. Outside this range, the ecu makes no adjustments other than normal temp, baro etc trims tables. but if the filter flowed more, we'd see skewed AFR's across the entire throttle & rpm range EXCEPT where the lambda provides feedback. but once again, we don't....
As for cost, if it were the case, K&N would turn cartwheels to supply an OEM if for nothing more than just the marketing kudos. and if a manufacturer could gain the claimed improvements for a few quid and trump their rivals, they'd be all over it like white on rice. but once again, they're not. and considering the effort, cost and R&D that goes into such things, what's the betting the manufacturers already know this???
The real question however, is whether the k&N flows more air than necessary.....
they don't, and even K&N admit this..
and away form the boring science bit, I've spent countless hours on the dyno and have yet to see a meaningful improvement from a K&N type filter. Even back to back single modification there was never more than half a bhp either way which is normal for a non chassis inertia dyno considering heat soak, tyre temps etc.
I know people really, REALLY wan them to work bu the fact is, they do bugger all. in fact, once the oil is dirty, they actually flow far less than OEM..
Interesting reading. Personally I still feel that aftermarket filters offer an improvement over OEM, but I'd still change an exhaust first as I've been saying since the beginning. They're only really useful as a supporting mod, or if you're doing mega miles and want a washable filter.

Also why would K&N want to supply OEMs? I would undermine their whole business. A load of bikes they couldn't supply after market filters for......

I'm sure you have seen this too, but what about a K&N or similar race filter when teamed up with a full system? I would expect to see more of a difference between OEM and Race aftermarket at that stage.



WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Steve Bass said:
Andy, if manufacturers could score the gains touted by the likes of K&N just by fitting a filter, they'd have been doing it years ago. The vast amounts of $$$$ poured into engine development for a few improvements inn torque would be laughed at if all they needed was a K&N.
As for scrimping, the question is does the paper element do the job for the duration of the service interval??
Are the BMW S1000RR, 1299 or R1 hampered by their 'scrimped" filters??? On the contrary, they go rather well, and keep going that way for a long time.
Bottom line is if you want to use a filter that flows more air, first you need an engine that needs more air. Without modifications to cam timing or lift, valve duration, intake flow or compression ratios, the motor won't need any more air than its getting. and the oil on the K&N type actually gums up and gets coated in particles faster and actually hurts performance.
Again more interesting reading. If you don't need to modify fuelling unless you're changing the cams, head or pistons, why do Akrapovic say that you need to remap when fitting some of their exhausts?

Steve Bass

10,760 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all


[/quote]

Again more interesting reading. If you don't need to modify fuelling unless you're changing the cams, head or pistons, why do Akrapovic say that you need to remap when fitting some of their exhausts?

[/quote]


Indemnity wink

Modern bikes run very lean in the Euro emissions zone but beyond that they often run on the rich side as it's far safer for the motor.
Removing the cat allows better gas transfer and prevents combustion fouling at high rpm as the gasses can get backed up behind the cat and pollute the incoming cylinder charge. So removing this restriction as well as changing the primaries pulse tuning on a full system does allow the motor to breathe better and make more power. But, and it's a big but. It'll still make that same power on the OEM filter.
Now if you substantially modify the head to achieve a higher cfm at a given rpm, yes, you need more air. and maybe the oem filter now becomes a restriction. so fine, you use a k&N type filter. however, to achieve better flow, the particulate mesh is now bigger, resulting in larger foreign objects getting into the cylinder. Fine for an engine that gets rebuilt at 1000kms. You can't have something for nothing after all......
and btw, not disagreeing with you on the value of opening the pipe. Just no need to mess it all up with an oily rag as a filter biggrin

WaferThinHam

1,680 posts

161 months

Sunday 5th March 2017
quotequote all
Steve Bass said:
and btw, not disagreeing with you on the value of opening the pipe. Just no need to mess it all up with an oily rag as a filter biggrin
Could be worse. Could be junking the airbox all together or drilling holes in the lid!

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Monday 6th March 2017
quotequote all
Spoke to Track Electronics just the other week about this.

Could be I misheard him but he said he has never seem power gains from fitting a K&N, only a cost saving because you can wash them.

trickywoo

14,288 posts

261 months

Monday 6th March 2017
quotequote all
A K&N can make the induction sound nicer but as everyone else has said I'd not fit one expecting more power.

bogie

17,109 posts

303 months

Monday 6th March 2017
quotequote all
Panel filters in the airbox? not worth the bother, OE filter is plenty good enough for reasons stated ....so if you really need to spend £30 on one, you dont need a remap.

RemaL

25,103 posts

265 months

Monday 6th March 2017
quotequote all
Getting on the band wagon. I will have a DNA air filter inn my H2. recommended by loads of well know tuners from the UK to US.

I'm not just adding the filter as some work is being done via flash ECU, PC5, Dyno time etc...

Do I feel the OE filter are better or worse than a aftermarket one. I could not give a toss really as I don't know enough about them and the engineering side of air filters.


Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Monday 6th March 2017
quotequote all
I used a K&N filter on my old Honda because it's re-usable and I'm tight, but I wouldn't put one in my nice new(ish) GSXR-750.

They clog up bloody quickly because they're so sticky and drag all that horrible red oil through the engine. Makes a right mess.



cmaguire

3,589 posts

140 months

Monday 6th March 2017
quotequote all
RemaL said:
Getting on the band wagon. I will have a DNA air filter inn my H2. recommended by loads of well know tuners from the UK to US.

I'm not just adding the filter as some work is being done via flash ECU, PC5, Dyno time etc...

Do I feel the OE filter are better or worse than a aftermarket one. I could not give a toss really as I don't know enough about them and the engineering side of air filters.
With genuine forced induction, not 'Ram Air' or whatever, you are more likely to see benefits.

I have a K&N on my GSXR750 (because the original was due replacement and I could re-use). It was mapped at BSD with a full system. I subsequently found the filter was what I considered filthy with dead flies etc. After cleaning and minimal oiling I took it back for a check, half out of curiosity as it made 139-something before and it would be nice to get the 140. It was apparently a little leaner than before so some fuel was added.

End result? Bugger all, still 139. I expect it would still be 139 on a new standard filter. The exhaust added nearly 10 horses.

Steve Bass

10,760 posts

264 months

Monday 6th March 2017
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
I used a K&N filter on my old Honda because it's re-usable.......
This is the ONLY worthwhile justification for the oiled type filter...

Prof Prolapse said:
They clog up bloody quickly because they're so sticky...... and drag all that horrible red oil through the engine. Makes a right mess.
But this is their main downfall.... The filtration effectiveness drops off very quickly. I'd bet the k&N needs almost monthly servicing to maintain its claimed flow rates.
It's no surprise dyno places & tuning places recommend them.... more sales and maintains the myth...
hard data just doesn't back up the claims though. The facts are often inconvenient like that sadly