Commuting by bike
Author
Discussion

Chicken Chaser

Original Poster:

9,136 posts

255 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
I'm looking at some numbers on commuting and i'm trying to establish whether I can commute by bike for a considerably cheaper amount than by car.

Car will do somewhere in the region of 42-46mpg, and the commute is 90 miles round trip. With my shift pattern, it's approximately 15000 miles a year. Less say 1000 miles for really bad weather days where the car needs to be used and I've got potentially 14000 miles of riding a year.

On the face of it, 40+mpg against say 60+mpg for a bike (i'm talking of a middleweight parallel twin kind of figure), sounds ok but then tyres and servicing comes around much more often. In the very least i'd be going through 2 sets of tyres a year at £200+ a go and servicing on top of that.

Anyone who is a high mileage commuter on the bike give any pointers? I'm just about to sell my KTM 1050 Adv and i'm considering whether to buy something simply for the work commute.

308mate

13,758 posts

253 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
Chicken Chaser said:
I'm looking at some numbers on commuting and i'm trying to establish whether I can commute by bike for a considerably cheaper amount than by car.

Car will do somewhere in the region of 42-46mpg, and the commute is 90 miles round trip. With my shift pattern, it's approximately 15000 miles a year. Less say 1000 miles for really bad weather days where the car needs to be used and I've got potentially 14000 miles of riding a year.

On the face of it, 40+mpg against say 60+mpg for a bike (i'm talking of a middleweight parallel twin kind of figure), sounds ok but then tyres and servicing comes around much more often. In the very least i'd be going through 2 sets of tyres a year at £200+ a go and servicing on top of that.

Anyone who is a high mileage commuter on the bike give any pointers? I'm just about to sell my KTM 1050 Adv and i'm considering whether to buy something simply for the work commute.
I would say beware. If you're already doing it in a car, the cost saving would need to be significant to make it worth while and unless you're running Range Rover as your commuter, I doubt it will be. I did 12,000 miles a year for the last 2 years or so and to be honest the overall value proposition is reduced to nothing more than a) its more fun and b) its not the fking piece of st train service. Monthly, accounting for monthly finance, insurance, fuel and reg, the bike is cheaper. But add in riding gear for all seasons, maintenance, extra maintenance for high miles and adverse conditions, fuel consumption closer to 45mpg than 60, stopping for fuel, wear and tear on existing riding kit, discomfort, lower luggage capacity, extra stress and not to be underestimated is the time spent kitting up and de-kitting again at each end; and really it starts to become pretty marginal.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
Could the Honda NC750x make a big difference ? it has a high official MPG


boyse7en

8,249 posts

196 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
Look at the Honda NC750, and also the BMW F800 variants - average of 65-70mpg on longer runs with mine. More is achievable if you stick to the speed limit.

Avon Storm XM tyres on mine last 8000 miles on the rear, the front still had probably 2-3000 miles left but I changed both anyway.


abarber

1,713 posts

272 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
I think you're on the right lines there with a parallel twin. I'd go for a used ER6-F to negate some depreciation and add a top box. They do 60-70mpg and are quite light on tyres / brakes, yet still reasonably pokey.

You can save a good 1/3rd on tyres by buying the previous models online, even with fitting. Fit a scott oiler and you should easily get 30k out of a chain.

I'd change the oil myself and do basic servicing. Once a year would do it. Add cost for bike gear, tax insurance, locks, punctures etc though. Maybe offset the cost against more depreciation on the car.

crofty1984

17,064 posts

235 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
SystemParanoia said:
Could the Honda NC750x make a big difference ? it has a high official MPG

Don't know what the official mpg is but on my nc700 (meant to be thirstier than the later 750) I struggled to get less than 80mpg unless I ragged the fk out of it everywhere. Once I managed to get it down to a shade under 70.
Not the most fun bike in the world, but perfect for what you want it to do and the "boot" is ridiculously useful. It'll crack 100mph easily enough so it's not exactly a moped. But nor is it a fireblade! Factory heated grips are very good.

gavgavgav

1,569 posts

260 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
I have a similar commute, basically you will be looking at 2 x servicing a year, 2 sets of tyres, chain every other year (I find it's the winters that kill them, tend to last 2 winters). it's surprising how much chain oil you need. Don't forget the gear you will be wearing as it wears out too, I must spend on average £500-700 a year on refreshing boots, gloves, jackets etc. (need a couple of pars as when wet they take ages to dry) helmet tends to be every few years. All the gear gets tired after 30K odd.

The biggest challenge is when you need to put it is to have stuff done like servicing, replacing tyres. You tend to need to rely on it when commuting.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
gavgavgav said:
(need a couple of pars as when wet they take ages to dry)
Or fork out on a DryGuy




E36GUY

5,907 posts

249 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
Biggest advantage to commuting by bike is the time saving. It's 30 mins home to office for me no matter what the traffic's doing. Anywhere from 45-90 minutes in the car.

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
Yeah bike is purely a time saving thing for me now....halves the commute!

The old one did 105mpg, that saved me a considerable amount of cash seeing as I was coming in from Zone 6, just worked out the MPG on the CBR600f - 32mpg :/ so £3.50 a day in fuel and the same again for insurance/repairs/tax vs. the £8 a day it'd cost on the train

Dakkon

7,833 posts

284 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
To echo some others comments, I commute by bike to save time more than money, going into work in the morning by car is not too bad, the occasional terrible traffic day but on the whole not too bad. Going home in the evenings is a whole different ball game and I am frequently held up in some serious jams.

So I switched to a bike, its 50 miles each way and overall I am not that much quicker by bike, but I am much more consistent in the time it takes.

Just saying, don't look at commuting by bike as a purely cost based decision.

Chicken Chaser

Original Poster:

9,136 posts

255 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. In a way I've lost a bit of the passion for riding around on bikes for no real reason, I couldn't get with it last year and save for a couple of occasions I went out and thought to myself about 30 mins in, where am I going and why? It wasn't the bike it was me. The bike is incredible but it was expensive toy/ornament sitting in the garage. £5k I could possibly justify to myself, at £8k it was money I could spend elsewhere.
I can see myself missing not having the option of one in the next few months but will have to think long about what I want from it. Commuting would be one way to reason for one but I couldn't see it being much, if any cheaper.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
I expect that if you add all the extra costs up, the bike will likely be as expensive as the car, and possibly even more expensive if the bike is purchased solely for the commute.

When doing your costings, don't just look at fuel. Tyres, servicing and chains all have a big impact on the 'per mile' running costs. Mileage related depreciation is another big cost on a bike, as is (as previously mentioned) decent gear.

If the bike is used only for commuting (and the car is used for "other duties") then the whole cost of tax and insurance also needs to be considered, as does the cost of the capital or any loan interest costs on the money used to pay for the bike.

As a financial proposition, you need to either be looking at something of 125cc or less and/or commuting somewhere with a car congestion charge that bikes don't pay.

EagleMoto4-2

669 posts

135 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
There are bikes out there that get considerably more mpg than most cars. I have a CBR500R and can easily get over 90mpg (I am a light rider though). I only commute 20 miles per day, but because of gearing up it can take as long as being in the car, unless there is a big traffic jam.
Learning to work on the bike myself saves a lot of servicing costs, for instance I can change the chain and sprockets myself. So far tyres seem to hold up well, so I guess it depends how hard you ride and how heavy you are, but at least there are only 2 of them to change on a bike.
If starting from scratch it will take quite a few years to recoup the initial outlay in gear and the bike itself, but as you are commuting a fair distance it might not take too long before you are saving money.
Saving money on the commuter run was the initial reason I got into bikes, however it then led on to me getting a second "fun" bike!

Biker 1

8,615 posts

150 months

Wednesday 15th March 2017
quotequote all
SystemParanoia said:
The rider is way better looking than the bike.... getmecoat

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
Chicken Chaser said:
I'm looking at some numbers on commuting and i'm trying to establish whether I can commute by bike for a considerably cheaper amount than by car.

Car will do somewhere in the region of 42-46mpg, and the commute is 90 miles round trip. With my shift pattern, it's approximately 15000 miles a year. Less say 1000 miles for really bad weather days where the car needs to be used and I've got potentially 14000 miles of riding a year.

On the face of it, 40+mpg against say 60+mpg for a bike (i'm talking of a middleweight parallel twin kind of figure), sounds ok but then tyres and servicing comes around much more often. In the very least i'd be going through 2 sets of tyres a year at £200+ a go and servicing on top of that.

Anyone who is a high mileage commuter on the bike give any pointers? I'm just about to sell my KTM 1050 Adv and i'm considering whether to buy something simply for the work commute.
What is your budget? I recently bought a CB13 07 plate with 6k on the clock for 4k. In my search i saw numerous really sorted Fazer Thous - Gen 1 - for £3k. Their only downside is the lack of ABS which is why I backed off buying one (although i loved riding them for years). I suppose the point I'm trying to make is for a commuting bike, guiltily ragging someone's ex pride and joy for commuting makes better £ sense even if the mpg is hanging around the 40 mark. Also, depreciation wouldn't be such a major issue too.

Riknos

4,701 posts

235 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
Swap the bike for something a lot cheaper, £2k max maybe? to release some funds, might make it more cost saving.

A daily commuter is going to get rusty, scratched, stone chips flung up, oil from the chain everywhere, so get something a bit cheaper and snottier.

Don't have to go the same way I did with a 99 Hornet, but something closer to that than an £8k bike...

Andy XRV

3,930 posts

211 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
Biker 1 said:
SystemParanoia said:
The rider is way better looking than the bike.... getmecoat
It had to be said yes

rapide

180 posts

280 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
Riknos said:
Swap the bike for something a lot cheaper, £2k max maybe? to release some funds, might make it more cost saving.

A daily commuter is going to get rusty, scratched, stone chips flung up, oil from the chain everywhere, so get something a bit cheaper and snottier.

Don't have to go the same way I did with a 99 Hornet, but something closer to that than an £8k bike...
Or you could just look after your stuff. Preparation, regular maintenance, bit of care and effort and there is no reason why a bike can't stay immaculate whilst being used everyday. No different to cars or any other possession.

Renn Sport

2,761 posts

240 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
Life is too short... just use the KTM and be done with it.