To buy or not to buy (salvage question)
Discussion
Help me out here gents ( & ladies), not sure what to do.
My R1200RT has been written off (subject of previous posts) and I am to be paid out. Ignoring all the liability/excess/PCP points, because they are what they are, what I can’t decide is whether to buy the bike back or not.
The figures are:
Pre-accident value (the amount they are offering): £8500. I'm happy with that, it's come up from an initial £7300. I paid £8995 last August.
Cost to buy the salvage: £3500 (42%). This apparently might be negotiable by a very small amount but not significantly.
After the accident I rode the bike 40 miles and it rode perfectly. So I don’t think there will be any question of structural damage, replacement disks, etc. The one thing it does need before being used again is a repair to a dented header. This might pull/push out (scruffy but free option), or I might have to buy a replacement set (currently £150 secondhand on eBay). Then I’d have a fully-working but scratched-up bike.
It’s a Cat D. If I did repair the cosmetic stuff, I guess it would be worth 65-70% of the list? So, £5500-6000 at today’s price? I don’t know what it will cost to repair the cosmetics, I’m happy to wait around until the right colours come up on eBay.
But as I type this I think I’m talking myself out of it. The balance I get from the insurance payout would be a deposit on something new.
Such a shame, it was/is a bloody good bike. I think I’d buy it at £2500 but not £3500.
What say m’learned friends?
My R1200RT has been written off (subject of previous posts) and I am to be paid out. Ignoring all the liability/excess/PCP points, because they are what they are, what I can’t decide is whether to buy the bike back or not.
The figures are:
Pre-accident value (the amount they are offering): £8500. I'm happy with that, it's come up from an initial £7300. I paid £8995 last August.
Cost to buy the salvage: £3500 (42%). This apparently might be negotiable by a very small amount but not significantly.
After the accident I rode the bike 40 miles and it rode perfectly. So I don’t think there will be any question of structural damage, replacement disks, etc. The one thing it does need before being used again is a repair to a dented header. This might pull/push out (scruffy but free option), or I might have to buy a replacement set (currently £150 secondhand on eBay). Then I’d have a fully-working but scratched-up bike.
It’s a Cat D. If I did repair the cosmetic stuff, I guess it would be worth 65-70% of the list? So, £5500-6000 at today’s price? I don’t know what it will cost to repair the cosmetics, I’m happy to wait around until the right colours come up on eBay.
But as I type this I think I’m talking myself out of it. The balance I get from the insurance payout would be a deposit on something new.
Such a shame, it was/is a bloody good bike. I think I’d buy it at £2500 but not £3500.
What say m’learned friends?
CAPP0 said:
After the accident I rode the bike 40 miles and it rode perfectly. So I don’t think there will be any question of structural damage, replacement disks, etc.
Depends how much you want a new bike I guess.
Keep yours and pocket £5k less any repair costs (as you say if you do it with second hand parts it will be cheap)
Or take the £8.5k and buy a new bike.
I'd be tempted with the £5k if it wasn't my only bike and used for commuting until it dies.
If its your only bike, dunno, up to you
Keep yours and pocket £5k less any repair costs (as you say if you do it with second hand parts it will be cheap)
Or take the £8.5k and buy a new bike.
I'd be tempted with the £5k if it wasn't my only bike and used for commuting until it dies.
If its your only bike, dunno, up to you

OverSteery said:
CAPP0 said:
After the accident I rode the bike 40 miles and it rode perfectly. So I don’t think there will be any question of structural damage, replacement disks, etc.
My brother low sided his rsv Mille and scuffed fairings with a scratch on swing arm where the bobbin goes
Insured for £3000 and was written off. Other than scuffs there was absolutely no damage. Frame checked by moto liners in Kent. Bike was a cat d from this
He got paid out and bike was something like £600 to buy after
Insured for £3000 and was written off. Other than scuffs there was absolutely no damage. Frame checked by moto liners in Kent. Bike was a cat d from this
He got paid out and bike was something like £600 to buy after
Krikkit said:
OverSteery said:
CAPP0 said:
After the accident I rode the bike 40 miles and it rode perfectly. So I don’t think there will be any question of structural damage, replacement disks, etc.
- fork leg. It's metal, not painted, and the very bottom of it was scuffed in the impact. 99.9% not bent in any way. However, one new fork leg is £600.
- front brakes. They say it needs two new disks. I've ridden a bike with a warped disk before (hello Mr Disk lock) and I know how that feels. These are not warped. But a new pair is £400
- Exhaust manifold. New from BMW - that'll be £1000 please, sir.
So there's £2k, before you even start on anything else, including the things they have added into the quote which weren't in any way affected/damaged (for example, they say it needs a new oil cooler surround. Just the plastic surround. The one which sits at the front of the bike, under the headlight. On the bike which was hit on one side and fell on the other. Quite how that has damaged the area at the front under the headlight I have no idea (clue: it wasn't damaged at all) but they have added another £250 on for that).
And so it goes on.
There must be some racket going on, I'm not quite sure what but can only think it's along the lines of, most people don't want to buy the salvage back, someone makes sure the bike goes to the "right" person. that person repairs it for far less than the estimate, sells it on and splits the profits.
Different Values, but similar here. My scooter was written off due to panel Damage, So qote was for
New handle bar cowl and all the panels on the left hand side. Insurance valued the bike at £1400, Buy back price £96. I now have a scooter with a few scratched panels then I'm less precious about and stands me in less than the quoted price for a service.
So if you can ride as is, then you have a cheap bike with an insurance payout to buy something else
New handle bar cowl and all the panels on the left hand side. Insurance valued the bike at £1400, Buy back price £96. I now have a scooter with a few scratched panels then I'm less precious about and stands me in less than the quoted price for a service.
So if you can ride as is, then you have a cheap bike with an insurance payout to buy something else

djt100 said:
Different Values, but similar here. My scooter was written off due to panel Damage, So qote was for
New handle bar cowl and all the panels on the left hand side. Insurance valued the bike at £1400, Buy back price £96. I now have a scooter with a few scratched panels then I'm less precious about and stands me in less than the quoted price for a service.
So if you can ride as is, then you have a cheap bike with an insurance payout to buy something else
Yep on a different scale but my brother did the same. Bike went to a track dayer in the end New handle bar cowl and all the panels on the left hand side. Insurance valued the bike at £1400, Buy back price £96. I now have a scooter with a few scratched panels then I'm less precious about and stands me in less than the quoted price for a service.
So if you can ride as is, then you have a cheap bike with an insurance payout to buy something else

Are you mad?! Buy it. Commute on it knowing that if it corrodes like mine did or gets the odd scuff it's no big deal, have the benefits of an awesome bike and either bank any left over after the finance is paid off or have a new one in the garage for play times.
Oh hang on, are you saying there is no payout because of settling with BMW and the 3.5 needed to buy the old one could be used for a new one? In which case buy a new one that's needs nothing spending on it. At around 200 per month, that 3.5k could be a deposit on a new one and then a contribution to an upgrade each year for 2 further years with neglible servicing as theyre newer bikes.
Oh hang on, are you saying there is no payout because of settling with BMW and the 3.5 needed to buy the old one could be used for a new one? In which case buy a new one that's needs nothing spending on it. At around 200 per month, that 3.5k could be a deposit on a new one and then a contribution to an upgrade each year for 2 further years with neglible servicing as theyre newer bikes.
308mate said:
Are you mad?! Buy it. Commute on it knowing that if it corrodes like mine did or gets the odd scuff it's no big deal, have the benefits of an awesome bike and either bank any left over after the finance is paid off or have a new one in the garage for play times.
Oh hang on, are you saying there is no payout because of settling with BMW and the 3.5 needed to buy the old one could be used for a new one? In which case buy a new one that's needs nothing spending on it. At around 200 per month, that 3.5k could be a deposit on a new one and then a contribution to an upgrade each year for 2 further years with neglible servicing as theyre newer bikes.
Ha ha, we are so on the same page!Oh hang on, are you saying there is no payout because of settling with BMW and the 3.5 needed to buy the old one could be used for a new one? In which case buy a new one that's needs nothing spending on it. At around 200 per month, that 3.5k could be a deposit on a new one and then a contribution to an upgrade each year for 2 further years with neglible servicing as theyre newer bikes.
Yes, initial thoughts were to buy the salvage and run it, a bit scuffed, with impunity. But the price of the salvage has gone from £2250 to £3500 (the AMC said £2250, it went back to the insurance co direct and they upped it). I think £3500 is too steep for a Cat D scuffer; I'd happily pay the £2250 and have put that to them in writing. £3500 is 42%, surely nobody ever pays that for salvage?
In terms of the finance, 6 months in to the PCP, with this settlement I'd essentially get my deposit back, which isn't a terrible situation to be in, and I'd have all the joy of choosing a replacement

So to clarify:
Do you have cash for the scuffer plus the balance of a payout, or is the 3.5k going to be the balance of the payout?
If you have both, I still say buy the old bike and a newer one.
If the cash for the old bike and the balance of the payout are one and the same, new bike time. And if lightly damaged cat D RTs are going for 2250, I'll make enquiries myself! Even at 3500, that's many miles of very comfy riding for very little cash.
Do you have cash for the scuffer plus the balance of a payout, or is the 3.5k going to be the balance of the payout?
If you have both, I still say buy the old bike and a newer one.
If the cash for the old bike and the balance of the payout are one and the same, new bike time. And if lightly damaged cat D RTs are going for 2250, I'll make enquiries myself! Even at 3500, that's many miles of very comfy riding for very little cash.
308mate said:
So to clarify:
Do you have cash for the scuffer plus the balance of a payout, or is the 3.5k going to be the balance of the payout?
If you have both, I still say buy the old bike and a newer one.
If the cash for the old bike and the balance of the payout are one and the same, new bike time. And if lightly damaged cat D RTs are going for 2250, I'll make enquiries myself! Even at 3500, that's many miles of very comfy riding for very little cash.
Out of the insurance payout, no, that wouldn't pay the PCP balance and buy the salvage, although I do have the cash at hand for that if I go that way. If I settle and walk away from the bike then I'd have something around a 10% deposit for something new. So I'm slightly between your two scenarios.Do you have cash for the scuffer plus the balance of a payout, or is the 3.5k going to be the balance of the payout?
If you have both, I still say buy the old bike and a newer one.
If the cash for the old bike and the balance of the payout are one and the same, new bike time. And if lightly damaged cat D RTs are going for 2250, I'll make enquiries myself! Even at 3500, that's many miles of very comfy riding for very little cash.
I've gone back to the insurance co and offered them 30% for the salvage - see what they com back with.
Ask and you shall receive....
Just got off the phone with the insurance company. They have dropped their price on the salvage, and the way it all works out, I will have to put my hand in my pocket for the princely sum of £1975 to retain the bike
I then own the bike, no PCP or anything. I think a 2012 RT for under £2k is a leeetle bit of a bargain. I could break it for parts for more than that.
Sums are all worked out based on the agreed value, the PCP balance, their lower % on the salvage but £1975 is the bottom line. Back to the world of comfort, adjustability, toys - oh, and audio
And there's still plenty of cash in the bank for the Kettle I want to go and snag in a week or two
Just got off the phone with the insurance company. They have dropped their price on the salvage, and the way it all works out, I will have to put my hand in my pocket for the princely sum of £1975 to retain the bike
I then own the bike, no PCP or anything. I think a 2012 RT for under £2k is a leeetle bit of a bargain. I could break it for parts for more than that.Sums are all worked out based on the agreed value, the PCP balance, their lower % on the salvage but £1975 is the bottom line. Back to the world of comfort, adjustability, toys - oh, and audio

And there's still plenty of cash in the bank for the Kettle I want to go and snag in a week or two

CAPP0 said:
Ask and you shall receive....
Just got off the phone with the insurance company. They have dropped their price on the salvage, and the way it all works out, I will have to put my hand in my pocket for the princely sum of £1975 to retain the bike
I then own the bike, no PCP or anything. I think a 2012 RT for under £2k is a leeetle bit of a bargain. I could break it for parts for more than that.
Sums are all worked out based on the agreed value, the PCP balance, their lower % on the salvage but £1975 is the bottom line. Back to the world of comfort, adjustability, toys - oh, and audio
And there's still plenty of cash in the bank for the Kettle I want to go and snag in a week or two
That is a huge result!! Luckeee luckeee bJust got off the phone with the insurance company. They have dropped their price on the salvage, and the way it all works out, I will have to put my hand in my pocket for the princely sum of £1975 to retain the bike
I then own the bike, no PCP or anything. I think a 2012 RT for under £2k is a leeetle bit of a bargain. I could break it for parts for more than that.Sums are all worked out based on the agreed value, the PCP balance, their lower % on the salvage but £1975 is the bottom line. Back to the world of comfort, adjustability, toys - oh, and audio

And there's still plenty of cash in the bank for the Kettle I want to go and snag in a week or two

d. Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


