Any Real World BMW R1200RS Experiences?
Any Real World BMW R1200RS Experiences?
Author
Discussion

K12beano

Original Poster:

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
I'm very, very busy having my umpteenth midlife crisis. The least of my worries should be "do I just sell up, or do I need, I mean NEED, another bike now before I die"......


But life isn't clear cut in the Beano household, so.....

Is there anyone out there in PH-land with some real-life experience of living with the R1200RS latest incarnation, because it looks to be ticking so many boxes from here....


Although I might just slink off and get an Ole Duffer Sports Car to die in.......

sjwb

561 posts

239 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
I've owned one, from new for two years.
What would you like to know, other than what is below?
Two things that are not to my liking.
The throttle return spring is weak and makes steady state progress on rough roads a bit awkward. I reckon the later models have been modified.
The second issue is common across the BMW range it seems; Shift Assist is great going up the box if the throttle is WOT, but harsh changes can be the case at small openings. Downshifts are in the main, fine.

K12beano

Original Poster:

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for your response. I've been seven years with my current K-series and have owned four K-series back to about 1988. I like Beemers, although not naturally a Boxer-lover, and - since I tend to own for at least five years - am just casting out there for any pluses and minuses when you get to own a bike.

Reading and watching reviews is encouraging, just might want to get into bed with one.......(!).....

lazybike

1,011 posts

122 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
I'm looking at one of these as well, I've not ridden anything with shift assist so sorry if this is a stupid question, but can you not just shift normally using the clutch?

K12beano

Original Poster:

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
lazybike said:
I'm looking at one of these as well, I've not ridden anything with shift assist so sorry if this is a stupid question, but can you not just shift normally using the clutch?
That's definitely a good question.

When the salesmen start to talk about this it makes me glaze over. I am still thinking "why couldn't they just make a good gearbox in the first place!?"

But - and this was one of the reasons behind my original Q - maybe I'm missing the point. On the other hand, I think that the old K12 is very weak on the gearbox front, and possibly the BMW worst I've endured spanning back to 1988, and I'm just being closed to the possibility of a big step forward.....

lazybike

1,011 posts

122 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
I vaguely remember reading something about BMW using the firm who make the Bugatti veyron gearbox. I'm hoping to get a test ride on the 1200rs so I'll try the shift assist.

K12beano

Original Poster:

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
Good stuff, Lazy..., I'm due to try out on Friday... will report back!

Unbusy

934 posts

128 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
Hi Lazybike, yes you can use the clutch as normal.
I only use the quick shifter when I'm wringing the bikes neck. Otherwise the gear change is not so good.
OP, I prefer the boxer to the K. Keeps me out of jail!
I have oilheads and the RS isn't different enough for me to make the change, but if you are selling the K it might be spot on. Test ridden it yet?
Edit. Doh, Friday. Enjoy!

sjwb

561 posts

239 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
Having owned a K1300GT I think that I might anticipate your reaction to a twin. However, what you may interpret as lack of refinement, will be more to do with increased connectivity with the bike.

I loved the power, comfort and sheer capability of the K, but in the end could not live with the detachment. Not to mention of course, being quite a heavy brute.
If, or should I say when you try an RS, give it a couple of hours. In traffic they are acceptable, but on the open road they are in their element. For fun, exit your favourite corners, hard on the throttle an just shift up through the box. You will be surprised how much difference not having to close the throttle or pull the clutch makes. Oh, it becomes addictive!
The RS is a very capable and well thought out machine with a big fun element built in.

Sadly, the shift assist cannot be disengaged - which is poor in my view. It is possible to change gear using the clutch, but it is not intuitive.

lazybike

1,011 posts

122 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
@unbusy cheers for that, good to know.

Have a good ride Friday, look forward to hearing what you think of it.

ianrb

1,644 posts

171 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
Got one. Best bike I've had for years.

Flat twins have a very distinctive engine noise, which some people dislike, and if you fall into that group then a doubt it's for you. Having said that some claim the official Akra exhaust does wonders, but that's over budget for me so I couldn't say more.

The current liquid cooled bikes have a completly different engine/clutch/gearbox architecture to all flat twins which have gone before, so they don't suffer from the same slow clunky gearchange. It may not quite match the very best Japonese gearchanges, but it's still very good.

The torque curve is quite flat, which some people mistake for lethargy, but then you realise how fast it's going. Sticking it in Dynamic mode solves that.

I ended up buying the SE version as I got a deal on it, but I'm not sure the ESA and keyless go stuff are worth it. So either the basic RS or the RS Sport may be better VFM.

It's the second most comfortable bike I'v ever owned, first being a 1300 Pan European. It handles very well, not something which previous boxers could alway claim, and as most of the weight is low down it's a piece of cake to trickle along at walking speed in traffic.

It may not set your pants on fire, but it's good at covering ground while still being fun.

K12beano

Original Poster:

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
sjwb said:
<Interesting stuff>
Oo - thank you for that. I think I got that right away from your background.... and exactly the sort of feedback that I want too appreciate....

Pretty sure I'm going on the test ride on Friday so I'm looking forward now......

K12beano

Original Poster:

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
ianrb said:
Got one. Best bike I've had for years.
Really interesting perspective - and thanks for replying. In fact I'm quite encouraged by your comment in comparison to a Pan.... It's many years since I tried a pan and yet i can immediately relate to how a Pan would behave. Absolutely nothing against that Pan, but it is surely the most capable all rounder, even above any Beemer, that we can use as a gauge?

K12beano

Original Poster:

20,854 posts

306 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
Unbusy said:
Hi Lazybike, yes you can use the clutch as normal.
I only use the quick shifter when I'm wringing the bikes neck. Otherwise the gear change is not so good.
OP, I prefer the boxer to the K. Keeps me out of jail!
I have oilheads and the RS isn't different enough for me to make the change, but if you are selling the K it might be spot on. Test ridden it yet?
Edit. Doh, Friday. Enjoy!
You got it, time up on Friday. Interesting to hear the "not so good" comment. To be honest I'm baffled that modern BMW, from 1995 onwards can't make a "good' gearbox for the user, and as mentioned, my experience is that each evolution seems to get worse! Can you elaborate on your gearbox experience?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
lazybike said:
I vaguely remember reading something about BMW using the firm who make the Bugatti veyron gearbox. I'm hoping to get a test ride on the 1200rs so I'll try the shift assist.
That was Ricardo, they were responsible for the update of K1200S to K1300S.

GM182

1,490 posts

256 months

Wednesday 5th April 2017
quotequote all
I tried the R1200RS a couple of weeks ago. It's a really fun bike. In the end I went for a GS partly because on the RS with the lower suspension I kept bashing my shin against the cylinder head.

The Gearshift Assist Pro is good on down shifts but indeed can be jerky on less than full on upshifts. I use clutch on the way up if I am just riding normally and it's fine.

Mad Jock

1,272 posts

293 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
Gearshift Assist Pro is available across a lot of the BMW range, and personally I've yet to be fully convinced by it. I was loaned a GS Rallye with it fitted, to try it (and the Rallye seat) out, and came back still preferring my fully "manual" box, although only did about 20 miles.

A couple of days ago, while my own bike was being serviced, I was given an R1200RT to play with. Part of the dealer's new rental fleet, I was asked to add some miles to it to get it run in before the rental season gets going, so I took it away down the A701 to Moffat, then back to the dealer via Innerleithen, just over 100 miles.

While the ratios may well be different for the R1200RS may be slightly different, the way the gear box works should not be.

My own views are: Use the clutch for 1st to 2nd gears, and possibly 2nd to 3rd, but after that, it's fine. Full throttle upshifts are pretty damn good, and useful for overtakes and the like. Unlike others, I had pretty smooth upshifts at part throttle, but it does seem to be dependent on the throttle position.

Downshifts, with the "auto-blipper" are again pretty good, especially when hard on the brakes, but as you have to have the throttle completely closed, it takes a bit of getting used to if you are used to blipping the throttle yourself on downshifts.

Where it doesn't work well is for a downshift before an overtake, and it's best to use the clutch, as you are wanting to raise the revs to accelerate anyway, so closing the throttle fully before you want to go for it is both counter intuitive and slows you down anyway.

The plus point is that you can ride the bike as if it were a conventional box, and revert to the Gear Assist Pro should you feel a little lazy, or use the assist most of the time, and revert to manual when the need arises. It may feel strange initially, and I would probably take the view that rather than it adding complexity where it's not needed, it actually enhances the ride, simply by using it where and when needed. A kind of having your cake and eating it.

I should also add that the R1200RT is a much, much better bike than I had imagined, and it can fk with your head. As it was a wee bit cold early in the morning, I had the (electronic) screen almost fully up, barn door like, and was very well protected from a cold wind. Once it was warm enough, I dropped the screen down to its lowest setting, and suddenly I feel like I'm on a sports bike. Just a difference in the screen height transforms how the bike looks and feels from the saddle, and while it's only a visual thing, it changes the way you ride the bike. It suddenly feels more chuckable (it's not really), and you can hustle that big barge far more easily than I would have imagined. It's all in the head, it really is not a sports bike, but as a bike that I had always dismissed out of hand, I would be happy enough to own one now for touring on good roads. For our own ratty B and C roads, I still think that a GS is better, as the suspension can cope with the bumps and potholes much better.

Edited by Mad Jock on Thursday 6th April 16:43

Chipchap

2,639 posts

228 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
I have now done c4000 miles on mine. Did 6 days 1800 miles on it in Dec in Spain. 400 mile days are no problem. Gear Shift Assist is great up and down the box with no clutch.

Very comfortable and very economical. 200 miles on a tank is achievable. Easy to ride fast too. Off turns or roundabouts you keep it in the 400-6000 range and it is a relative missile.

Bear in mind that I also own a 200 BHP MV Agusta.

I love the bike and it would take a lot to get me off it.

sjwb

561 posts

239 months

Saturday 15th April 2017
quotequote all
What happened, did I miss something?

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Saturday 15th April 2017
quotequote all
I think there are some calculations being done at this very moment! biggrin