Always someone else's fault?
Always someone else's fault?
Author
Discussion

Gavia

Original Poster:

7,627 posts

122 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
Had my first ride on the road this year today with a couple of mates. The plan was for a gentle ride to get used to riding again after the winter lay off and scrub in some new tyres, plus it was pretty cold.

On one of their favourite roads we witnessed the first crash of the year. A lad coming the other way completely misjudged a gentle right hand bend, ran into the banking on the left side and flung himself and his bike right across the leader of our little group of three.

My mate did a great job of avoiding him. The crasher landed on the right of the road in front of me in a bit of a heap. Eventually he calmed down and decided to say it was caused by a silver car cutting him up. The only problem is that there wasn't a car on either side of the road.

He'll now go home and convince himself he crashed due to someone else and nothing to do with his own shortcomings. Disappointing that he wouldn't listen to us that there were no other cars about.

No other point to the thread other than to highlight how some riders don't do themselves any favours. Cue lots of SMIDSY / cager / horse stories to entertain us all.

Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
Cool starry bra

jjones

4,493 posts

224 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
Cue lots of SMIDSY / cager / horse stories to entertain us all.
Or maybe crap thread will sink without a trace?

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
Yeah, the last time I was out on the bike no one cut me up, no one pulled out in front of me, no one held me up and stopped me overtaking, no one even swerved at me when I was filtering..

wkers, the lot of them.

Gavia

Original Poster:

7,627 posts

122 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
jjones said:
Or maybe crap thread will sink without a trace?
Why's it a crap thread? It's a reflection of what happened today and how someone who crashed is blaming a non-existent car for his own failings. Kind of an observation on the way many riders think.

Or are you just sucking up to the other poster who said "cool story"?

Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
Or are you just sucking up to the other poster who said "cool story"?
That just sounds rude!

grumpy

Jazoli

9,707 posts

281 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
I've found that anyone who uses the word 'cager' is best avoided anyway.

It's the start of the silly season, there will be loads of crashes and quite probably a few deaths in the next week or two as the two wheeled muppet brigade take to the roads having crashes that are everybody else's fault and not their own.

SAS Tom

3,756 posts

205 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
Working in a bike shop I hear this all the time. No one has ever come in after a crash and said it was their own fault despite only them being involved. It's ridiculous and I can't imagine many people believe their bullst stories. No one ever seems to admit they were going too fast or they were impatient which seems to be the main causes. When I crashed at cadwell everybody I spoke to had an excuse as to why I came off. Most people didn't seem to want to accept it when I said it was my own fault.

Just a few of the standard shop excuses include;
Gravel on the road
Diesel
Potholes
ABS apparently caused one guy to crash

Riding down a gravelly road on an ABS equipped bike towards a diesel filled pothole would be like Armageddon!

Rubin215

4,201 posts

187 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
SAS Tom said:
Working in a bike shop I hear this all the time. No one has ever come in after a crash and said it was their own fault despite only them being involved. It's ridiculous and I can't imagine many people believe their bullst stories. No one ever seems to admit they were going too fast or they were impatient which seems to be the main causes. When I crashed at cadwell everybody I spoke to had an excuse as to why I came off. Most people didn't seem to want to accept it when I said it was my own fault.

Just a few of the standard shop excuses include;
Gravel on the road
Diesel
Potholes
ABS apparently caused one guy to crash

Riding down a gravelly road on an ABS equipped bike towards a diesel filled pothole would be like Armageddon!
I ttted my TL1000 into the scenery by arriving at a bend far too fast, panic braking and running wide on to the verge.

I blame the council for making the verge wider than it needed to be; they could have extended the road by at least another foot closer to the hedge and then I might have made it round...

hehe

Pebbles167

4,601 posts

183 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
I hear this a lot. True, often SMIDSY is the culprit, but just as often it's the biker. The amount of bike commuters I see on the way to work riding in a proper dozy way each morning , they'd likely blame a car even though their terrible roundabout lane discipline, or bad perception would be the real cause. The other day a BMW GS just strolled into my lane on a roundabout exit and nearly took his rear wheel out on my bumper then blasted off down the road. Once on the motorway, the same guy, without looking, last minute indicated and changed into the middle lane at 55mph despite the traffic running at 70mph. There was no space and so I had to brake pretty hard. The guy looked behind at me, did a condescending head shake before blasting off again. Came across him 3 more times between Bristol and Reading.

Of my own experience, In 2014 i was pottering along a country road, overtook a lorry and drove into the side of a right turning van. My fault, I owned up to everything straight away. A lot of biker mates really didn't like accepting that it was my fault, and still tried to attribute some or all of the blame to the van driver, and even the lorry driver who pulled my out from under my burning bike. I was pretty surprised, seems like a lot of bikers are geared to hate cars, much like some cyclists.

Gavia

Original Poster:

7,627 posts

122 months

Thursday 6th April 2017
quotequote all
I don't understand that last bit though. Most of us are car drivers and some of us cyclists too. I certainly drive a lot more miles than I ride on a motorbike.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
The old saying goes something like, "when reality comes into conflict with ego, memory yields"

The vast majority of people, in the face of such a daft mistake, will naturally look for the third party to blame, after all "how could they be so stupid?", So through a combination of shock and embarrassment (and wanting sympathy), they stretch the truth, perhaps not even knowingly. After they've confirmed that story it to you, they're likely to maintain such a ridiculous story through fear of being confronted for their errors, so they're unlikely to reverse themselves after having had such a bad day.

After the event, when they're calm, in their own space, and free from judgment, they may evaluate things differently.

We've all seen it happen. They shouldn't be judged too harshly unless they maintain the bullst.



Edited by Prof Prolapse on Friday 7th April 07:59

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
I thought it was the case that it was around 65% of all motorcycle accidents were rider fault?

Happy to be corrected, of course.

HughiusMaximus

737 posts

157 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
I did a speed aware course a few months back and they said that in something like 80% of fatal incidents with motorbikes it wasn't the riders fault.

Can't apply to same 80% rule to every non fatal incident obviously.


black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Nobody likes to be made to look as though they've been a prat and friends, family, just about anyone/everyone can be very good at (repeatedly) pointing out you've been a prat. To avoid this, people will often present an explanation that shows them to be less of a prat.

Everyone makes mistakes and everyone has errors of judgement, regardless how good you are or how big big your ego/dick is. Some end up having to pick up the pieces of those mistakes in front of a large audience. Is it really such a surprise they try to focus the attention somewhere else?




Rawwr said:
I thought it was the case that it was around 65% of all motorcycle accidents were rider fault?

Happy to be corrected, of course.
Around 1 third are rider only when it's hard to suggest anyone else is to blame.


Biker 1

8,615 posts

150 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Pebbles167 said:
seems like a lot of bikers are geared to hate cars, much like some cyclists.
I hate cyclists rather than cars getmecoat
And anyway, isn't it always our own fault for buying bikes in the first place??? Bloody stupid, dangerous hobby, but I love it...

moanthebairns

19,183 posts

229 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
SAS Tom said:
Working in a bike shop I hear this all the time. No one has ever come in after a crash and said it was their own fault despite only them being involved. It's ridiculous and I can't imagine many people believe their bullst stories. No one ever seems to admit they were going too fast or they were impatient which seems to be the main causes. When I crashed at cadwell everybody I spoke to had an excuse as to why I came off. Most people didn't seem to want to accept it when I said it was my own fault.

Just a few of the standard shop excuses include;
Gravel on the road
Diesel
Potholes
ABS apparently caused one guy to crash

Riding down a gravelly road on an ABS equipped bike towards a diesel filled pothole would be like Armageddon!
Every crash I've had on the track has been my fault in some way or another, apart from Croft when the bds relayed gravel on more gravel on top of more gravel at the first corner. I went into it like quick sand thinking I could ride through.....bds.....there should have been signsshootideabiggrin

bilhound

79 posts

117 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
HughiusMaximus said:
I did a speed aware course a few months back and they said that in something like 80% of fatal incidents with motorbikes it wasn't the riders fault.

Can't apply to same 80% rule to every non fatal incident obviously.
Probably because rider error usually happens on country roads where there's a bit of hedge or ditch to fall into thus ending up injury only. Accidents with motorcyclists not at fault are 9 times out of 10 going to be collisions with another vehicle, which hurts a lot more.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
bilhound said:
HughiusMaximus said:
I did a speed aware course a few months back and they said that in something like 80% of fatal incidents with motorbikes it wasn't the riders fault.

Can't apply to same 80% rule to every non fatal incident obviously.
Probably because rider error usually happens on country roads where there's a bit of hedge or ditch to fall into thus ending up injury only. Accidents with motorcyclists not at fault are 9 times out of 10 going to be collisions with another vehicle, which hurts a lot more.
As Vic Reeves used to say in the First Direct advert "100% of statistics are made up!"

http://www.motorcyclenews.com/news/2015/march/new-...

boyse7en

8,249 posts

196 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Maybe it's just me, but I nearly always take any incident as being my fault.


There is nearly always something I could have done that would have alleviated the risk. Waiting for the overtake, being a little more cautious on an unsighted bend, giving a bit more space to the driver in front... whatever it needs.