2017 Fireblade SP + GSXR1000 + S1000RR, my impressions
2017 Fireblade SP + GSXR1000 + S1000RR, my impressions
Author
Discussion

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Sunday 9th April 2017
quotequote all
So, last Saturday I test rode Fireblade SP, GSX-R1000 and S1000RR, all 2017 models, in the same day.
Right after that I wrote my impressions on another forum (not in English) so now I translate some of them into English here:

I went to test SP on my 2002 954RR.

Fireblade SP is certainly a looker.
I just did not like the plastic cover on the gas tank (a bit flimsy/thin at certain points) and the small plastic covers on the frame (imho, should have been aluminium).

The sound of the bike on cold start is very nice, growls really purposeful now.

I had it for an hour and covered two local mountain passes, I rode mostly in Mode1 (most aggressive) but tried the other two, did not notice much difference on the road, maybe the engine braking was a bit stronger in Mode3.

My impression from riding Fireblade SP, comparing to 954RR which is stock bar braded brake lines and lithium-ion battery (-2kg):

- gearbox/quickshifter - top notch, everything switches very smooth, no bangs or jerks
- the engine is very smooth, like a seal, no vibration whatsoever (954 has a more mechanic feel to the engine)
- there is no jerkiness at low rews when opening/closing throttle, unlike 954, which is not happy to hang around 3000rpm
- the electronic gas handle has a bit of "play" in it, small rotations do not really produce any go, one really has to rotate and wait to get the bike going, on 954 any small rotation produces noticeable acceleration and that behaviour fits me better
- the brake lever again had a bit of "play", at the beginning that caught me out because on 954 I can noticeably retard my movement with minute one-finger squeeze on the lever, and I like it that way, because it is more direct and more predictable
- the noise from the engine/exhaust in the helmet at normal speed kind of disappears, so one can listen to music without missing much, same on 954 actually, though SP is louder at idle
- I always had a feeling that leaning in the corner the front was sliding away from me, not confidence-inspiring. The shock is really nice, one can clearly feel how it works those waves in the pavement, it's like sitting on a rubber ball.
- I only revved to 10000, and it has the power for sure
- it is short and light, but 954RR feels even shorter, and is most likely just as light
- because of the electronics buttons on left handle the turn signal button was placed waay down, under the horn button, it's not easy to reach and really uncomfortable to press, at least for me.

In the end, after one hour, I was not enthralled by the SP. Brilliant bike, no question. It's a Honda, meaning it is like a loving dog, it just loves its rider and does everything to make him comfortable. But the bike is just too polished, and I do not mean the beautiful frame or swingarm. I've just watched MCN review and they called SP "a silent hero" and said that it did not leap to the win on the road or track right away, only after riding it hard and for longer periods of time does one understand its brilliance. Well, maybe I did not ride it hard enough, but I was on a public road, where I would not push it anyway.
I prefer my 954RR, it's more direct and more of a instant hooligan. It also feels more comfortable, because after an hour on SP I had back pain and pain in my right leg. I just wish my 954 had ABS, because those 330mm discs are mighty powerful, while rear brake is pretty st and the bike has 1395mm wheelbase.







Then I parked up the 954RR, jumped on my K6 GSXR1000 (200/55 rear tyre, RCS19 master brake cylinder with braded lines, double bubble screen, suspension reworked for my 95kg weight, Gilles rearsets, otherwise stock).

Immediately K6 feels more like a powerful superbike, it pulls harder from low revs, it sounds muscular on the roll. At idle it sounds industrial and it looks industrial and rough, typical GSXR, but it has glass-smooth throttle response in all regimes (including on/off) and it steers beautifully. The handles are very close to each other though, the closest I have ever experienced on any bike. Also, K6 feels top-heavy, just like the 2016 S1000RR felt when I rode it.

So I go to Suzuki dealer (which is also a big BMW dealer) and lo and behold, the GSXR1000 has arrived! It's a base model, with BPF suspension and no quickshifter. In Switzerland the base model with come with pre-installed quickshifter because the bikes are quite expensive, but this test bike, which is not even registered, has none. I am the third one to test ride the bike and I am waiting for it because it is on the road. The guy comes back, he is about 30, a bit shorter than I (I am 185cm), first thing he says "those japanese are very small people". Further he says he likes the engine, but he prefers Fireblade SP which he also tested already, he himself owns 2014 Fireblade. Anyway, he says, BMW S1000RR is better because it is more comfortable and has a cruise control which he needs.

I check the bike out. It looks nice and slim. I am digging matt black paint and red wheels, though Glass Sparkle Black with blue rims and fork tubes will probably look better.
That new frame is so thin! How it can carry a 200hp superbike, I don't know.
I check out the exhaust can. Yes, it is huge, it has to go, it does not do this slim bike any justice.

I sit on the bike - it feels higher than SP, which is a plus in my book. The handles do not feel as narrow as on K6.
The seat is made of some weird material, it hold you by the butt really well though.
The turn signal button is right where it is supposed to be!

I start the bike - it sounds good! Different than SP, different than K6, but good. I roll away, gearbox is perfectly smooth, the engine pulls well right from the bottom. Within three minutes, before even hitting proper curves, I feel this bike is made for me. I like how it reacts on throttle, I like how it reacts on brakes, I like the way suspension works, it's pretty stiff. The engine vibrates, but the vibration is not bad, I only feel it in my right foot and I actually like it, it gives the engine a bit of character. It sounds good on the go as well, imho it sounds better than SP, the sound is more present so to speak.

I hit the local mountain passes, I work the throttle properly, hang off the bike even though it is not registered which means if I fall I pay the full price, but I do not feel scared or uncomfortable, it accelerates beautifully, no "play" in the handle, it steers just right, it just feels like I have been riding this bike for ages, it's so easy and predictable, I laugh like a horse inside my helmet, I LOVE this bike! I spend 40 minutes on it, do two mountain passes and an acceleration test on a straight, and I do not want to give the bike away.

Instrumentation...it looks a bit industrial like the rest of the bike, you clearly see revs, speed, mode, gear, and TC setting, the rest of info is in small letters but it's not that important anyway. I did not have any problem reading the screen in stark sunlight. Instrumentation is perfectly fine as far as I am concerned, I don't mind that it is not colored, instead it follows this industrial theme.

Industrial...it is a typical Suzuki GSXR, as MCN said "a bit rough around the edges", that's how they've always been, but it rides great.













After that I decided to jump on 2017 S1000RR. Last year I rode the 2016 version on four occasions, all on the passes, and even though I liked it in the beginning, that monster engine surely impresses, by the forth ride I was indifferent, it just felt a bit generic to me (I think I've said it here before already). But since there are rumours that S1000RR was modelled on K6, I decided to see how it compares to the new Gixxer. I took the BMW on the same roads as the GSRX1000.

Well, not much changed. It is still comfortable, it is still top-heavy.

The engine is still very german, it pulls but somehow does not excite aurally, though it does these, always the same, pops on closing the throttle, it's all preprogrammed by BMW, Germans like to control everything I guess.

The turn signal is in the right place but there is not much movement in it when you click it, so you don't really know if the turn signal is on.

The bike certainly goes, but I was understeering in a couple of corners, it is obviously not the bike, it must be my lack of skill or familiarity with S1000RR, but I did not have the same problem either on SP or on GSXR, also, last year, when I was comparing the naked bikes, I had the same problem with the S1000R but not with Monster 1200R, The Beemers just feel like slow steering bikes.

Quickshifter/blipper works, but there are sometimes some kind of weird bangs and jerks from the gearbox, also when I was shifting gears manually.

Another thing I noticed, my right foot (wrapped in Supertech R boot) was getting pretty warm, it was not uncomfortable but I did feel it. Maybe the engine heat blowing off the engine, maybe heat coming from the open exhaust collector, but I did not have the same feeling on the other 4 bikes I rode that day. The exhaust collector on 2017 S1000RR, it looks now like the pre-2015 model, it looks ugly, open and now more pipes going out of it, with pretty ugly welds, the exterior certainly took a step back with the Euro4 introduction.





Conclusion: after all these rides I liked the GSXR the most, despite the fact that it's the cheapest and the roughest looking and moreover has an ugly muffler. I just felt the most comfortable (no pains) on it and went the fastest on it right of the bat. BUT, that GSXR REALLY needs a quickshifter/blipper!

So, there you go, my 2c on these three 2017 superbikes. smile

Edited by Ho Lee Kau on Sunday 9th April 15:29

Loyly

18,295 posts

190 months

Sunday 9th April 2017
quotequote all
That sounds like a good day out. The GSXR certainly sounds impressive. But then, there has never been a bad GSXR 1000.

trickywoo

14,283 posts

261 months

Sunday 9th April 2017
quotequote all
Nice write up and pics - thanks.

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Sunday 9th April 2017
quotequote all
trickywoo said:
Nice write up and pics - thanks.
My pleasure!

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Sunday 9th April 2017
quotequote all
Loyly said:
That sounds like a good day out. The GSXR certainly sounds impressive. But then, there has never been a bad GSXR 1000.
It was. I only planned to be out for an hour, just to test SP at my favorite Honda place. I started 9am, came home 5pm. wobble
Next in line for the test are GSX-R1000 R version and the Triumph Street Triple RS. bounce

Fire99

9,868 posts

260 months

Sunday 9th April 2017
quotequote all
I saw the new GSXR 1000 at a show and the silencer is an abomination but the rest of the bike impressed me.
Purely on gut instinctive opinion, my current faves in the litre class are the ZX10r (because I'm a Kawasaki man at heart), the GSXR 1000 and the RSV4 for its slightly different take on the 'superbike'..

podman

9,086 posts

271 months

Sunday 9th April 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for taking the time to post, interesting read, not in a position to purchase any of them but on looks alone, I wouldnt buy the GSXR , certainly in the paints scheme anyway, just goes to prove you have to put the effort in and go and ride them.

dc2rr07

1,238 posts

262 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Fire99 said:
I saw the new GSXR 1000 at a show and the silencer is an abomination
Yes we have the Eurocrats to thank for them, but yes the one on the GSXR is terrible.

Edit. Good effort from the OP on all the tests in one day as well.

Edited by dc2rr07 on Monday 10th April 13:16

Shadow R1

3,845 posts

207 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Great write up.

Renn Sport

2,761 posts

240 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Good insight... kind of glad to see that the GSXR1000 doing well for being up against much stiffer competition.

I have to say I am surprised that the Honda Blade SP getting so many plaudits from MCN. 20k bike...!

I'd like to hear your thoughts on the R1.


I am going to try a Street Triple RS myself through the Mountain passes of Clapham and Stockwell in London.

Nearest we get in the city.

Gunk

3,302 posts

190 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Funny how your 14 year old 954 Fireblade is the best looking of the lot, they got that one right first time! Tadao Baba's favourite Fireblade.

MOBB

4,595 posts

158 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Gunk said:
Funny how your 14 year old 954 Fireblade is the best looking of the lot, they got that one right first time! Tadao Baba's favourite Fireblade.
Just what I was thinking smile

spareparts

6,796 posts

258 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
The 954 was a great bike (I had one), but it isn't a patch on the latest Blade, and it is a mistake to use it as a benchmark in any way shape or form. The K6 was also a brilliant bike (I also had one of these), and to suggest the S1000RR is not a significant step on is laughable. It was clear from the previous SP thread that HLK will rate the new GSXR whilst dismissing the SP as it was not deemed to be a new bike; and unfortunately this 'review' has no credibility. As bad as MCN may be, I'd happily take MCN's opinion over this one.

Edited by spareparts on Monday 10th April 18:36

cmaguire

3,589 posts

140 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
spareparts said:
The 954 was a great bike (I had one), but it isn't a patch on the latest Blade, and it is a mistake to use it as a benchmark in any way shape or form. The K6 was also a brilliant bike (I also had one of these), and to suggest the S1000RR is not a significant step on is laughable. It was clear from the previous SP thread that HLK will rate the new GSXR whilst dismissing the SP as it was not deemed to be a new bike; and unfortunately this 'review' has no credibility. As bad as MCN may be, I'd happily take MCN's opinion over this one.

Edited by spareparts on Monday 10th April 18:36
Adam Child does however need to accept that he is going bald, and stop moving his hair trying to hide it like some kind of floppy comb-over.

Other than that distraction, the video did paint a slightly better picture for the GSXR than the newspaper review. The video was slightly biased towards what Neeves and Child thought directly, whereas the article appears to be broader than that and as they said in the video, the Fireblade came out on top because everybody on the trip found it easier to get along with.

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
spareparts said:
The 954 was a great bike (I had one), but it isn't a patch on the latest Blade, and it is a mistake to use it as a benchmark in any way shape or form. The K6 was also a brilliant bike (I also had one of these), and to suggest the S1000RR is not a significant step on is laughable. It was clear from the previous SP thread that HLK will rate the new GSXR whilst dismissing the SP as it was not deemed to be a new bike; and unfortunately this 'review' has no credibility. As bad as MCN may be, I'd happily take MCN's opinion over this one.

Edited by spareparts on Monday 10th April 18:36
Hey, I do not purport to be a rider on the level of Michael Neeves, or the other guys for that matter.
As I said, I did my test rides and decided to share my personal opinions about these machines.
That's why I mentioned the guy riding the Gixxer before me, from his words this bike is for small Asian people, but I, being taller than he, experienced the opposite, for me that bike was very comfortable.

So, absolutely, do not take my word for it. In fact, do not take anyone's word for it, including MCN's, go test ride for yourself and see what fits you.

As far as 954RR and K6 are concerned, if I had the opportunity I'd put 954RR on the wall, that's how much I like the looks of that bike.
And I had two of them at the same time, that's how much I like how it rides.
It's not perfect, but not even the latest ultra-modern bikes are perfect.

But, and this is another personal opinion of mine, the sportsbikes of the last 15 years are so good that the differences come down to power level, suspension components and electronics. On track all of these matter and 954RR would not compete with the later Fireblades, but on the road, imho, mostly electronics make a tangible difference these days.

That is why I would consider swapping my K6 for the new GSXR, for example. I'd like to have ABS for sure and probably TC as well (this Saturday I had a scare moment when the rear of my 600cc CBR started sliding when I opened throttle in second gear leaned over on a narrow public road), though I think that these electronic aids will make people more bold without making them more knowledgeable, TC saves your butt but it does not teach you how to manage the bike and sometimes learning by doing involves a bit of disappointment, failure and even pain.

As far as I am concerned, I feel 100% confident on 954RR going into corners, it's just stable, predictable and friendly. I did not feel that way on the ultra-modern Fireblade SP during the hour I rode it, but I did feel confident on the new GSXR during the 40 minutes I rode it.

MCN said that one negative of GSXR is that it is too much like the old one. Maybe that is why I felt as if I rode this bike for a year already. For me it is not a bad thing that this completely new bike full of electronics feels like an old shoe, less hassle and time wasted relearning the behavior. If I really wanted something totally different and "characterful" and "exciting" I'd just buy the Panigale 1299S, but I don't because I value other traits more.

BTW, I did not say that S1000RR is not a significant step on from K6, of course it is. I prefer K6 over S1000RR because the old girl excites me more, whether it sounds logical to you or not, and I do not understeer on it.

I am not here to tell you "the truth" or what you should like or buy. I did my same-day rides and I've built an opinion for myself that I shared here. Someone will have a diametrically opposite opinion and I will be interested in hearing it.
That's what forums are for!

Credibility whatever... you take it all too seriously.

Edited by Ho Lee Kau on Monday 10th April 20:48

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
podman said:
Thanks for taking the time to post, interesting read, not in a position to purchase any of them but on looks alone, I wouldnt buy the GSXR , certainly in the paints scheme anyway, just goes to prove you have to put the effort in and go and ride them.
Thank you for reading it.

I am not looking to purchase anything either, I have enough iron sitting still in the garage, but I was curious, and, believe it or not, I was not going into these tests with a pre-set mind, in fact, I own 3(!) CBRs and my favorite bike is RSV4 (which I did not buy even though I had a great opportunity 2 years ago, instead preferring to keep my 2014 Daytona 675), but I felt the most excited on the new basic GSXR1000.

To each his/her own, as the saying goes...

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Shadow R1 said:
Great write up.
Merci beacoup!

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Honda is really beautiful in SP livery, no question about it. I am also a sucker for golden wheels. smile

I have no idea about the Yoshi cans. I know that Arrow and Yoshi have already developed mufflers for the new Gixxer, there are videos of them on Youtube. It is probably easier to put one of them aftermarket cans on a bike in UK than in Switzerland where I am. Here everything is so regulated. For example, I cannot put anything on my 954RR besides and ugly and even more silent than stock Scorpion can. I guess I can consider myself lucky because I actually like and want to keep the original 954RR can. :-)

I like the front end of GSXR, it looks extremely simple but I like the cyclopes look (I also like MV Agusta). Gixxers generally always looked simple, I don't mind, I like my black K6.

BMW S1000RR - you need to try one of these, they surely are impressive in many ways. Big kudos for the heated grips straight from the factory, cannot believe it the Japanese manufacturers do not offer this useful piece of kit even as option!

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Gunk said:
Funny how your 14 year old 954 Fireblade is the best looking of the lot, they got that one right first time! Tadao Baba's favourite Fireblade.
Mmm, I would say they got it right the 3rd time. I only like the 2002-2003 954 version of the FireBlade, the previous two versions are not my cup of tea.

Ho Lee Kau

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

156 months

Monday 10th April 2017
quotequote all
Renn Sport said:
Good insight... kind of glad to see that the GSXR1000 doing well for being up against much stiffer competition.

I have to say I am surprised that the Honda Blade SP getting so many plaudits from MCN. 20k bike...!

I'd like to hear your thoughts on the R1.


I am going to try a Street Triple RS myself through the Mountain passes of Clapham and Stockwell in London.

Nearest we get in the city.
It's not so much insight, rather my personal feelings. At least we now have several reviews to compare. :-)

As far as I know the GSXR in the MCN test aced all the acceleration tests (0-60, 0-100, 0-max, acceleration in 6th gear, fastest speed, fastest 1/4), that with the second smallest amount of power, so this bike has at least that going for it. They also said it is comfortable and immediately recognizable "behind the wheel", that's been my experience as well, and, in fact, I read some other private reviews of GSXR and there the ease of riding it and feeling like you've ridden this totally new bike for ages has also been mentioned. From that one can make certain conclusions already, imho.

As far as Fireblade SP is concerned, I can totally see what you pay this kind of money for. And remember, GSXR1000R is a couple of thousand cheaper but it does not have Ohlins electronic suspension, it does not have slide control, and the exhaust can has to be replaced right away, so in that light it is maybe implicitly more expensive than SP!

I've ridden R1 only once, last year, and it was in curves but on flat surface, I do not have Yamaha dealer close to the familiar mountains and they do not bring their bikes for test days on the hills like BMW and Ducati do.
From the short ride on R1 that I had I made the following personal observations:
- it is really small, really feels like a 600cc bike
- it has really high and committed sitting position, it IS a bike for track racing first, street second, like Yamaha said
- it sounds good, somewhat Ducati-like
- it incites you to go faster and faster in the corners, such is its agility
- the throttle response in mode A is absolutely awful
- I am not big fan of its looks, I particularly dislike the ugly open exhaust collector

For me in particular the jerky throttle is a big turn-off, so R1 is not on my list of the bikes I would want to buy first, though the speedbump yellow anniversary edition with golden wheels looks mighty tasteful (but again, that ugly collector yuck )

Edited by Ho Lee Kau on Monday 10th April 21:23