Should DAS be scrapped?
Should DAS be scrapped?
Author
Discussion

Esceptico

Original Poster:

8,897 posts

140 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
If you are younger than 24 then it seems that you can't get a full licence without having to spend time on lower powered bikes. However, those over 24 with a car licence can still go straight to any bike they want by doing the CBT and passing the bike test. From memory when I did that back in 97 that involved one morning for the CBT and five or six lessons prior to the test. I was then able to ride out of the showroom with a new ZX6R (but had I been prepared to pay more and could have persuaded someone to insure me, it could have been a ZX9R or Fireblade). At the time I thought a 600 was going to be fine. To compensate jumping to a full on sportsbike I also did advanced training and passed the RoSPA exam. However, in hindsight I am not sure it was a good idea going for such a quick bike as my first bike. Yes my experience of driving a car did give me better road sense than a complete newbie but I didn't have any biking experience. I don't think there is any substitute for miles. It is possible that the advanced training, despite giving me extra skills, may have made me more dangerous by lulling me into thinking I was better and safer than I actually was.

If it is a good idea to make your riders progress through lower powered machines, then shouldn't it apply to all new riders, irrespective of whether they have a car licence or not?

As an aside, when I started biking there was lots of talk of "born again riders" (either those returning to biking or older people taking it up), who made up a disproportionate percentage of fatalities (the classic crash being on left hand bends where newbie thinks they can't make the bend, brake, sit up, go straight on and are taken out by oncoming traffic). Does that still apply today i.e. do such riders still make up a large percentage of fatal accidents? Or was the hype never backed up sufficiently with statistics?

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Any argument for this should be based on the government's own accident statistics.

I seem to recall (but am happy to be corrected), based department for transport accident data, there was no statistically significant correlation between capacity and accidents in younger riders in the UK at the time the system was implemented. It only happened "because EU said so", whether other EU countries statistics differ I do not know, presumably they did.

I'd let it run until there's sufficient data generated to demonstrate it does fk all, then you can justify getting rid of it.

But in all honesty I don't think you can scrap it until we've left the EU, which will take an age at this rate, so the whole argument is moot..


2wheelsjimmy

624 posts

128 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
When I was 19 I didn't have the maturity to ride a motorbike, without killing myself. I know you can still kill yourself on a lower powered bike, but fact is I would have gone out and bought the fastest bike I could, to piss my parents off, and then properly overestimated my skill and come off on the first fast corner I rode, showing off.

Good thing for my life that I wasn't allowed one until I was 24, when I'd matured a lot.

It is a nanny state thing, but I can understand the logic behind it.
I'd think it should be scrapped, but at teh same time, riders have to put in a lot more hours of proper tuition and training, not just the small amount needed to pass the test.

Edited by 2wheelsjimmy on Monday 12th June 09:50

HustleRussell

26,711 posts

191 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Is a 125 safer? I didn't like the rear drum brake or the hard, skinny tyres. I reckon that unless you're going to ride like a nutter, the bigger bike with its superior tyres and brakes, stability and handling, could well be safer.

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
It's an odd system, with the CBT so easy (and many just repeating it every 2 years) but DAS being so complex & costly.

The NZ system (think AU is very similar) requires a theory test and basic handling skills test like a CBT in order to get a learners licence. Then you can ride an "approved" bike (essentially anything <250cc, or a list of slower bikes over 250cc, similar to our A2) on L plates, no pillions, and not at night (10pm to 5am)

You can either give it 6 months and do a practical test, or do a fast-track DAS-style training and assessment. You end up with a restricted licence - same bikes, same "no night riding" restriction but no L plates. You then have to wait at least 12 months to be able to progress on to a full licence.

So in theory a keen youngster can have a full licence at 17 1/2, with a year of 250cc riding under their belt. Someone wanting a bike for transport can just stay on a restricted licence as long as the night riding thing isn't a problem. Someone middle aged can't just do 4 days at a bike school then buy a R1.

There's no substitute for miles, but how do you enforce that? Even under the NZ system you could simply take the first stage then wait it out until you can progress to the next one.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
I'm currently doing my DAS. I'm 51. I should perhaps have taken my bike test when I was 17 and it involved riding a 250cc round town with the examiner stood on street corners. However, I took my car test and obviously it's a lot easier to take your mates about in a car and pull girls, so I didn't bother.

Fast forward to now and because I can, I want to do the test now. It's probably a mid life crisis thing, and I may well not buy a bike immediately, and certainly won't be riding it in the wet - sunny days only!! With hindsight, I would have been a lot more dangerous on a 250 at 17 (because obviously at that age you're immortal) than now on a 650 at 51.

So no, for what it's worth I think the extra training I'm getting is a potential life saver.

londonbabe

2,161 posts

223 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Although I could have I chose not to take DAS for two main reasons. I felt more comfortable and confident on my own bike (a Honda CBR125R) and thought (correctly I think) that if I was riding that I would perform much better on the test, have fewer nerves etc. The second was that I had two mates who both did DAS, immediately bought powerful motorbikes (one a Ducati) and wrote them off within about 2 weeks. I know that's too small a sample size but I did think I would have been a 3rd to do so.

Sure it was a bit frustrating staying on 33bhp for two years (especially the last 6 months) but I'm glad I did it the slow way.

Tanguero

4,535 posts

232 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Esceptico said:
As an aside, when I started biking there was lots of talk of "born again riders" (either those returning to biking or older people taking it up), who made up a disproportionate percentage of fatalities (the classic crash being on left hand bends where newbie thinks they can't make the bend, brake, sit up, go straight on and are taken out by oncoming traffic). Does that still apply today i.e. do such riders still make up a large percentage of fatal accidents? Or was the hype never backed up sufficiently with statistics?
Ooops!! As the victim of exactly such an accident (and still in hospital) while I can't speak as to percentages, I can testify that they certainly do happen. I think the only relevant danger factor really was my own inexperience. I was well trained and preparing for my IAM test, and according to the Serious Accident Investigation Unit, was riding at an appropriate speed for the road and conditions, so the engine size of the bike had nothing to do with it. Unfortunately risk free experience is impossible to achieve.

mygoldfishbowl

4,304 posts

174 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
No, is my answer.

What I would like to see scrapped is people saying, " taken out" as it sounds ridiculous.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
Any argument for this should be based on the government's own accident statistics.

I seem to recall (but am happy to be corrected), based department for transport accident data, there was no statistically significant correlation between capacity and accidents in younger riders in the UK at the time the system was implemented. It only happened "because EU said so", whether other EU countries statistics differ I do not know, presumably they did.

I'd let it run until there's sufficient data generated to demonstrate it does fk all, then you can justify getting rid of it.

But in all honesty I don't think you can scrap it until we've left the EU, which will take an age at this rate, so the whole argument is moot..
I seem to remember that, not only was there no accident statistic correlation between CC and age, but that there was also no correlation between cc and time full license held. Experience significantly reduces the likelihood of an accident (unsurprisingly) but at a very similar rate across all capacity groups.

The reality is that statistics show that the only way to significantly reduce accidents is to ban everyone from riding until they have a good 2 years plus experience on a bike!!!! paperbaggetmecoat


Harji

2,224 posts

192 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
i think the whole DAS thing is great, I understand it's odd to do the same thing again at 24 (and something can be done to change this), but would you prefer lots of 18 year olds in high powered cars or 18 year olds on high powered motorcycles? Given that you have alot more 'maneuverability' to use the power of a motorcycle more than a car , and if most 18-24 year olds are like I used to be , totally oblivious to dangers and jumping in head first, then yes it's a good thing.

If anything, I think there should be a similar restriction on cars.

moanthebairns

19,183 posts

229 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
I'm in the camp of, I'm older now, I've got my licence, I don't give a fk.

HustleRussell

26,711 posts

191 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
27 y/o. Doing my DAS this month. Not going to buy a bike any time soon but having ridden extensively in other countries where licences are less obligatory and having already done some riding in this country on a CBT I thought 'why not'.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
I seem to remember that, not only was there no accident statistic correlation between CC and age, but that there was also no correlation between cc and time full license held. Experience significantly reduces the likelihood of an accident (unsurprisingly) but at a very similar rate across all capacity groups.

The reality is that statistics show that the only way to significantly reduce accidents is to ban everyone from riding until they have a good 2 years plus experience on a bike!!!! paperbaggetmecoat
I would say that just reinforces any argument that test standards (and by extension training) are either (a) too low, or (b) do not place emphasis the correct areas personally. Restricting vehicle choice is largely an irrelevance if the goal is to promote rider safety.

People whinge about statistics, but when adequately powered and interpreted sensibly, they will fit real life observations, by definition they have to. The problem is we go through all the effort of generating the data, which is then just cherry picked to try and support an existing idea. i.e. rather than try and do things scientifically, that is to attempt to disprove our hypothesis (in this case that "larger CC bikes in less experiences riders increase the risk of injury"), we ignore data that contradicts preconceptions. As we agree happened with the DAS system.

The sad truth as well is, if we hadn't refused to drop our preconceptions that, "faster bikes are more dangerous", we actually could have tried to drill down into the real issues, perhaps even just made small revisions to test content, and this may have increased rider safety beyond what is likely the case as it stands.

It is quite frustrating, but as MTB says, thankfully it is no longer my problem.

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Im an ex-school owner which, at its peak had a fleet of 20 CBT/DAS motorcycles.

The adoption of of the EU legislation of Mod 1 and Mod 2, including age changes decimated mine and many other riding schools with one foul swoop. Our business turnover halved within the space of 1 year putting 50% of my trainers out of a job (4).

The major disappointment for me when it all happened was the indifference of the then head of the DSA, Rose Thew. The arrogance both she and her senior staff showed to assembled school owners at various pre-implementation information conventions was staggering.

I believe, at the time, the UK could have declined from aligning itself with the new rules and paid a paltry annual fine. Instead, spending £80m+ on the creation of off-road sites was deemed a goer!

So you have to ask yourself why they went along with it. Well, I strongly, strongly suspect (having held off record discussions with visiting CBT inspectors) it was a way to reduce overall motorcycle casualty figures i.e. less riders passing the test, less people to kill/hurt themselves. Cynical? Yup. But this can be backed up the the number of people fully passing DAS collapsing to less than 50% before the rule changes. What they didn't count on though was the increase of CBT riders involved in PWT RTC's stuck in the endless cycle of a poorly delivered CBT every two years (many repeat CBT's completed within an hour - totally illegal)

It also killed the A2 training market; as a school it wasn't worth gearing with new bikes for this discerning set of rules. CBT's inevitably suffered as well due to so many people under the age of 24 deciding to not bother as they couldn't ride anything worthwhile for so many years.

For those who passed the assessments, was the end product a safer rider? Well, on a normal 4-day DAS (CBT separate), no. Less time was spent on the road developing road craft, riding knowledge and situational awareness. Instead, valuable time was spent off-road practicing such delights as cone swerving and slow-riding alongside a walking instructor.

So, should DAS be scrapped in its current format? Big yes.
Should we revert to the previous format? Yes

BUT:

Caveat: DVSA (previously DSA) desperately needs to become far more accountable rooting out the cowboy schools which wholly and utterly infect the motorcycle training industry. Their failure to protect learner riders from unscrupulous firms has seen the training school race to the bottom accelerate in recent years as schools cut the cost of their courses in a bid to keep turnover going. One irony I will never forget is the CBT Section disallowing me to report another school instructor for taking 4 x riders out on CG125's for their CBT 2 hour road ride. Their reason? I was a competition; never mind the fact the other school had broken statute law.

I could go on and on and on but won't. It is a great shame how rider training has arrived at its current destination. Knowing the DVSA, nothing will change,even if we do leave the EU....





Edited by kurt535 on Monday 12th June 14:07

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Looks like my speculation matches your, rather sad, observations Kurt.

Bad news is as well that it is enshrined into the UK now, we can deviate later on of course, but with money being what it is I can't see any future government being willing to invest in test/training standard revisions that will deviate from the EUs for quite some time. Especially if what you say is true and having just spent (wasted?) "£80 million", at a time when we need to choose our battles with regards to a lack of conformity with our European cousins.

It's more cost effective to crucify motorists for misdemeanors than train them too. We're all just food for worms after all.

caelite

4,282 posts

143 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
I think it's a joke, particularly the A1 as it actively encourages younger riders to hang around on just a CBT until they turn 19.

I see the legislation as a whole simply a way of discouraging people taking up motorcycling when they are younger, most likely as an effort to reduce overall road traffic fatality statistics.

I see the best means of fixing the downfalls is to simply bring back automatic timed progression, so if you get a a1 at 17 it automatically progresses to an A at 19, same applies for an a2 at 19 progressing to an A by 21. This means that test centres don't need to revamp there bikes, but it also encourages younger riders to do there test.

Although I should remind you they are changing the requirements for DAS bikes AGAIN in 2018.

trickywoo

14,283 posts

261 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Harji said:
i think the whole DAS thing is great, I understand it's odd to do the same thing again at 24 (and something can be done to change this), but would you prefer lots of 18 year olds in high powered cars or 18 year olds on high powered motorcycles? Given that you have alot more 'maneuverability' to use the power of a motorcycle more than a car , and if most 18-24 year olds are like I used to be , totally oblivious to dangers and jumping in head first, then yes it's a good thing.

If anything, I think there should be a similar restriction on cars.
Insurance costs 'self police' a lot of that anyway.

Even if you are old anything sporty is expensive to insure as a newish rider with little or no NCD.

rockford22

362 posts

163 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
Funnily enough I was thinking of this topic only last weekend and am currently in the middle of my DAS. I must admit I am not truly enjoying the process and don't feel it is great preparation.

My CBT was fun, covered the basics and really got me hooked. I duly paid for a full DAS course but having only completed the MOD 1 and 600cc conversion days I've decided to put it on hold until the end of summer. A trusty Honda CBF125 is being delivered to me on Thursday and I'll get some miles under my belt. Personally, as much as I could have probably had my full A licence by the end of next week (that was the plan), I'm doing this as a hobby as much as for transport...no rush and I would feel better and more relaxed doing it the slow way. The MT07 was quite good fun to ride though so come back to me in 3 months and I doubt the 125 will be around wink

wuckfitracing

991 posts

174 months

Monday 12th June 2017
quotequote all
trickywoo said:
Insurance costs 'self police' a lot of that anyway.

Even if you are old anything sporty is expensive to insure as a newish rider with little or no NCD.
I passed my test 2 years ago. I will be 50 this year. My insurance is £150 a year fully comp. Now I know its not a Sports bike in modern terms but A BMW K1100RS is a quite a bit quicker than my TVR. So there are ways round the insurance even if you are older.