Third party only insurance
Third party only insurance
Author
Discussion

mattzmith

Original Poster:

39 posts

201 months

Sunday 18th June 2017
quotequote all
Hypothetical insurance question for those in the know.

I have my eyes on a ratty commuter scooter that will hopefully not catch any theiving scumbags eyes, but I work in London so who knows. The price differential between TPFT and TP is more than the value of the bike so I'm inclined to go TP only.

But what would happen if the bike was nicked? Would I have to advise the insurers or not? Obviously I wouldn't be covered, but If I'm not claiming I'd rather not have the black mark against my name.

Insight/advice required...

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Sunday 18th June 2017
quotequote all
I'm the same, also commute into London but it's a £1.2k CBR600F

My TPO quote was near £800, 2.5x that for FC and 2x for TPTF

My intention should the worst happen to report it to the police and get a new bike myself.

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Sunday 18th June 2017
quotequote all
No need to report it as it's not a loss that's covered by your policy. Theoretically, you should declare it when getting a new policy though, as they usually ask "any losses or claims whether insured or not".

I wouldn't declare it though, but that's just me.

podman

9,087 posts

271 months

Sunday 18th June 2017
quotequote all
If you dont report it to the police and the insurance company and the vehicle then ends up in an accident whilst still in your name, you are personally liable for any loss/damage and I believe injury...tread carefully on this one.

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Sunday 18th June 2017
quotequote all
podman said:
If you dont report it to the police and the insurance company and the vehicle then ends up in an accident whilst still in your name, you are personally liable for any loss/damage and I believe injury...tread carefully on this one.
Report it to the police and cancel the policy, but don't tell them it's been nicked.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
Report it to the police and cancel the policy, but don't tell them it's been nicked.
I think they'll be able to find out ... pretty easily!

Not declaring a theft that's very easy to trace through the police report opens you up to all sorts of potential problems with your insurance company. It's unlikely that such problems would happen while you're handing over your money for the new policy, but they are likely to happen when you're making a claim and thus need things to "just work".

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
I think they'll be able to find out ... pretty easily!

Not declaring a theft that's very easy to trace through the police report opens you up to all sorts of potential problems with your insurance company. It's unlikely that such problems would happen while you're handing over your money for the new policy, but they are likely to happen when you're making a claim and thus need things to "just work".
You've not told them that it was stolen, why would they go looking for it in a police report? You can't claim for theft on a TPO policy as it doesn't cover it.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
black-k1 said:
I think they'll be able to find out ... pretty easily!

Not declaring a theft that's very easy to trace through the police report opens you up to all sorts of potential problems with your insurance company. It's unlikely that such problems would happen while you're handing over your money for the new policy, but they are likely to happen when you're making a claim and thus need things to "just work".
You've not told them that it was stolen, why would they go looking for it in a police report? You can't claim for theft on a TPO policy as it doesn't cover it.
If they are going to have to make a big payout then it is worth them "doing some digging" to find ways of either reducing that payout or of reclaiming some/all of it from else where.

If you want to not declare, then don't. I wouldn't advise such an approach but that's your choice and your risk. The chances are it will not cause any issues. However, do that understanding that if there are going to be problems they will very likely be at exactly the time you least want them and could potentially be very big.

cbmotorsport

3,065 posts

149 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
Report to police, cancel policy immediately.

It's really none of their business if it gets stolen, you're not paying them to offer cover, and their not offering that service.

Cadaver

32 posts

114 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
You sold it for no fee, you just weren't aware the deal was happening until the morning after laugh

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
If they are going to have to make a big payout then it is worth them "doing some digging" to find ways of either reducing that payout or of reclaiming some/all of it from else where.

If you want to not declare, then don't. I wouldn't advise such an approach but that's your choice and your risk. The chances are it will not cause any issues. However, do that understanding that if there are going to be problems they will very likely be at exactly the time you least want them and could potentially be very big.
Why are they going to make a big payout? As soon as you cancel the policy then they're not going to be paying for anything that happens afterwards. If it happened before cancel i.e. after the theft, but before you're aware, then there's nothing you could've done anyway.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
black-k1 said:
If they are going to have to make a big payout then it is worth them "doing some digging" to find ways of either reducing that payout or of reclaiming some/all of it from else where.

If you want to not declare, then don't. I wouldn't advise such an approach but that's your choice and your risk. The chances are it will not cause any issues. However, do that understanding that if there are going to be problems they will very likely be at exactly the time you least want them and could potentially be very big.
Why are they going to make a big payout? As soon as you cancel the policy then they're not going to be paying for anything that happens afterwards. If it happened before cancel i.e. after the theft, but before you're aware, then there's nothing you could've done anyway.
The bike you buy and insure the next day gets stolen and hits a bus queue of kids, disabling a large number of them.

Your insurance will pay out, because it has to, but it's worth the insurance companies time and effort looking into your history and coming after you for every penny they can because you didn't declare something that potentially would have had an impact on the costing of the policy. Likely to happen? No! Possibly could happen? Yes!

As said, it's your choice but don't be under any illusion that it's a totally risk free strategy.

Dr Doofenshmirtz

16,952 posts

231 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
In my experience TP only cover is way more expensive than TPF&T or Comprehensive.

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
The bike you buy and insure the next day gets stolen and hits a bus queue of kids, disabling a large number of them.

Your insurance will pay out, because it has to, but it's worth the insurance companies time and effort looking into your history and coming after you for every penny they can because you didn't declare something that potentially would have had an impact on the costing of the policy. Likely to happen? No! Possibly could happen? Yes!

As said, it's your choice but don't be under any illusion that it's a totally risk free strategy.
What am I supposed to declare? Is this me insuring a second bike after the first was stolen, it I didn't tell my original insurers or these? If so, then how will they ever find out?

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
black-k1 said:
The bike you buy and insure the next day gets stolen and hits a bus queue of kids, disabling a large number of them.

Your insurance will pay out, because it has to, but it's worth the insurance companies time and effort looking into your history and coming after you for every penny they can because you didn't declare something that potentially would have had an impact on the costing of the policy. Likely to happen? No! Possibly could happen? Yes!

As said, it's your choice but don't be under any illusion that it's a totally risk free strategy.
What am I supposed to declare? Is this me insuring a second bike after the first was stolen, it I didn't tell my original insurers or these? If so, then how will they ever find out?
Insurance proposal form said:
mandatory
Have you had any accidents, claims, thefts or losses on any motor vehicle policy in the last 5 years (either fault or non-fault - whether claimed for or not)?
There are all sorts of ways they could find out, especially if you report the theft to the police. If they're going to have to pay out many millions of pounds then it's definitely worth them putting some effort into doing their homework. As said, your choice, your risk.

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
Gavia said:
black-k1 said:
The bike you buy and insure the next day gets stolen and hits a bus queue of kids, disabling a large number of them.

Your insurance will pay out, because it has to, but it's worth the insurance companies time and effort looking into your history and coming after you for every penny they can because you didn't declare something that potentially would have had an impact on the costing of the policy. Likely to happen? No! Possibly could happen? Yes!

As said, it's your choice but don't be under any illusion that it's a totally risk free strategy.
What am I supposed to declare? Is this me insuring a second bike after the first was stolen, it I didn't tell my original insurers or these? If so, then how will they ever find out?
Insurance proposal form said:
mandatory
Have you had any accidents, claims, thefts or losseson any motor vehicle policy in the last 5 years (either fault or non-fault - whether claimed for or not)?
There are all sorts of ways they could find out, especially if you report the theft to the police. If they're going to have to pay out many millions of pounds then it's definitely worth them putting some effort into doing their homework. As said, your choice, your risk.
Hang on a minute I said almost exactly the bits you've put in bold in my first post, but also that I wouldn't tell them. Ironically your bits in bold make it clear that I dont need to tell them, see the bit that I've done in big text to separate it from your highlighted bits. I haven't suffered a loss on "any motor vehicle policy", as theft isn't covered and I've cancelled it before the thief did anything that caused a claim.

T6 vanman

3,570 posts

130 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
Gavia said:
black-k1 said:
Gavia said:
black-k1 said:
The bike you buy and insure the next day gets stolen and hits a bus queue of kids, disabling a large number of them.

Your insurance will pay out, because it has to, but it's worth the insurance companies time and effort looking into your history and coming after you for every penny they can because you didn't declare something that potentially would have had an impact on the costing of the policy. Likely to happen? No! Possibly could happen? Yes!

As said, it's your choice but don't be under any illusion that it's a totally risk free strategy.
What am I supposed to declare? Is this me insuring a second bike after the first was stolen, it I didn't tell my original insurers or these? If so, then how will they ever find out?
Insurance proposal form said:
mandatory
Have you had any accidents, claims, thefts or losseson any motor vehicle policy in the last 5 years (either fault or non-fault - whether claimed for or not)?
There are all sorts of ways they could find out, especially if you report the theft to the police. If they're going to have to pay out many millions of pounds then it's definitely worth them putting some effort into doing their homework. As said, your choice, your risk.
Hang on a minute I said almost exactly the bits you've put in bold in my first post, but also that I wouldn't tell them. Ironically your bits in bold make it clear that I dont need to tell them, see the bit that I've done in big text to separate it from your highlighted bits. I haven't suffered a loss on "any motor vehicle policy", as theft isn't covered and I've cancelled it before the thief did anything that caused a claim.
I think you misunderstand .... You take out a TPO policy and your bike is stolen (theft), You commute by tube for three years.
You have a young family and invest in a trendy SUV for your family ... You insure this fully bells and whistles comprehensive.... However you do not declare the theft from 3 years ago ... in contravention of the highlighted text above, You are safely proceeding down the motorway and suffer a tyre blow out and cross the carriageway into a school bus full of children, your offspring suffer catastrophic injuries and require 24hr care for the rest of their life ... The school bus instantaneously combust with no survivors ..... The insurance company do minimal homework and identify you made a police report of your bike theft and you did not report this. Insurance nun & void cancelled

sc0tt

18,312 posts

232 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
T6 vanman said:
I think you misunderstand .... You take out a TPO policy and your bike is stolen (theft), You commute by tube for three years.
You have a young family and invest in a trendy SUV for your family ... You insure this fully bells and whistles comprehensive.... However you do not declare the theft from 3 years ago ... in contravention of the highlighted text above, You are safely proceeding down the motorway and suffer a tyre blow out and cross the carriageway into a school bus full of children, your offspring suffer catastrophic injuries and require 24hr care for the rest of their life ... The school bus instantaneously combust with no survivors ..... The insurance company do minimal homework and identify you made a police report of your bike theft and you did not report this. Insurance nun & void cancelled
So wrong it hurts. What do I know though.

T6 vanman

3,570 posts

130 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
sc0tt said:
So wrong it hurts. What do I know though.
No your right .... It wouldn't happen like that and (whisper it quietly) insurance companies do sometimes take a pragmatic view to undeclared omissions to insurance requests ... but they could decide you've deliberately held back information that would alter their proposal to you due to risk and ultimately they could declare the policy void.

The scenario I used would likely be paid out .... but if you were still in the same address and it was a theft claim ??scratchchin??

Gavia

7,627 posts

122 months

Monday 19th June 2017
quotequote all
T6 vanman said:
I think you misunderstand .... You take out a TPO policy and your bike is stolen (theft), You commute by tube for three years.
You have a young family and invest in a trendy SUV for your family ... You insure this fully bells and whistles comprehensive.... However you do not declare the theft from 3 years ago ... in contravention of the highlighted text above, You are safely proceeding down the motorway and suffer a tyre blow out and cross the carriageway into a school bus full of children, your offspring suffer catastrophic injuries and require 24hr care for the rest of their life ... The school bus instantaneously combust with no survivors ..... The insurance company do minimal homework and identify you made a police report of your bike theft and you did not report this. Insurance nun & void cancelled
They are clearly asking if you've suffered any losses on any motor policy. I haven't. A TPO policy doesn't cover theft, so there was no policy in place for that event. I am quite correct not to declare it.

Your example is irrelevant.