VFR1200 Lunched Engine
VFR1200 Lunched Engine
Author
Discussion

Plew

Original Poster:

6 posts

113 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
I've had the misfortune of buying a lovely 2012 VFR1200, which has managed to do something terrible to at least one of its big ends in the five weeks that I've owned it.

The dealers I bought it from have been very helpful so far (it came with a six month warranty), collecting the bike they day after it happened. They have said that it will be cheaper to source another engine rather than repair the current one.

My only concern is that the bike had a full service history before, so I'm a bit worried that the bike will lose value due to this engine swap and all the associated uncertainties that this brings.

If anybody has any advice/experience of this sort of thing it would be much appreciated!

trickywoo

14,283 posts

261 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
I'd try and get the dealer to give your money back and let them keep the bike and decide what they want to do with it.

That being said unless they are a Honda dealer I think you have to give them the opportunity to repair it. I doubt any compensation will be coming your way besides them fixing it but it doesn't hurt to ask. Maybe some gear or a couple of free services?

Doesn't say much for Honda if a FSH 2012 bike has lunched its engine. What mileage has it done?

TwoStrokeNut

1,713 posts

272 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Make sure you get some evidence that the replacement unit is low mileage and also a receipt of the work involved.

You'll need to forward to the DVLA. for an engine number change.

Plew

Original Poster:

6 posts

113 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
trickywoo said:
I'd try and get the dealer to give your money back and let them keep the bike and decide what they want to do with it.

That being said unless they are a Honda dealer I think you have to give them the opportunity to repair it. I doubt any compensation will be coming your way besides them fixing it but it doesn't hurt to ask. Maybe some gear or a couple of free services?

Doesn't say much for Honda if a FSH 2012 bike has lunched its engine. What mileage has it done?
I'll see what they come back with about the replacement engine with regards to quality. The bike had just ticked onto 25,075 miles when it failed.

The 2010/11 engines had a recall for this precise problem I think, but mine wasn't under the recall notice. Can't say I'll be in the market for another one after this!

graham22

3,328 posts

236 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
I'll probably get flamed for this but assuming full & correct Honda service history and buying from a reputable dealer would Honda be able to help, especially if some had been recalled for remedial work.

Plew

Original Poster:

6 posts

113 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
graham22 said:
I'll probably get flamed for this but assuming full & correct Honda service history and buying from a reputable dealer would Honda be able to help, especially if some had been recalled for remedial work.
It's not a Honda dealer that I bought it from if that makes a difference?

As I say, the dealer isn't quibbling at all - they are replacing with an alternative engine but my concern is that this will harm the value of bike - I assume it's much harder to prove the replacement engine's mileage and history.

I only bought it five weeks ago and as well as losing confidence in the bike I've also (hypothetically) lost money! No more Honda for me I don't think.

HustleRussell

26,710 posts

191 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
If you are happy in principle for the dealer to change the engine for a used replacement, I wouldn't worry about future saleability. Who checks engine numbers these days? Call me naughty but I wouldn't even bother sending the V5C off- it'll only draw attention to it.

podman

9,086 posts

271 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
Plew said:
graham22 said:
I'll probably get flamed for this but assuming full & correct Honda service history and buying from a reputable dealer would Honda be able to help, especially if some had been recalled for remedial work.
It's not a Honda dealer that I bought it from if that makes a difference?

As I say, the dealer isn't quibbling at all - they are replacing with an alternative engine but my concern is that this will harm the value of bike - I assume it's much harder to prove the replacement engine's mileage and history.

I only bought it five weeks ago and as well as losing confidence in the bike I've also (hypothetically) lost money! No more Honda for me I don't think.
I can understand how you feel at the moment but, to be fair, all manufacturers have had their fair share of engine problems over the years, you have as you said, been unlucky, easy for me to say but I wouldnt be happy about it especially mid Summer but sounds like the dealer is doing the right thing.

Now, if it was a classic motorcycle, an engine replacement most likely would affect its value but a 5 year old Honda is far from that, if it was mine, I would change the numbers in the logbook but I wouldn't declare the engine swap come sale time unless asked.

I also agree that approaching Honda is worth doing, you have nothing to lose but be clear what you want from them before you contacting them, again, you can be sure a new engine isnt going to be forthcoming.

Its fair to ask the dealer for some compensation for 5 weeks(or however long) worth of insurance or perhaps a loan bike to at least enjoy some of the Summer on.


anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 28th June 2017
quotequote all
podman said:
I can understand how you feel at the moment but, to be fair, all manufacturers have had their fair share of engine problems over the years, you have as you said, been unlucky, easy for me to say but I wouldnt be happy about it especially mid Summer but sounds like the dealer is doing the right thing.

Now, if it was a classic motorcycle, an engine replacement most likely would affect its value but a 5 year old Honda is far from that, if it was mine, I would change the numbers in the logbook but I wouldn't declare the engine swap come sale time unless asked.

I also agree that approaching Honda is worth doing, you have nothing to lose but be clear what you want from them before you contacting them, again, you can be sure a new engine isnt going to be forthcoming.

Its fair to ask the dealer for some compensation for 5 weeks(or however long) worth of insurance or perhaps a loan bike to at least enjoy some of the Summer on.
What he said. Failures do happen.

I guess asking the source of the 'new' engine isn't too difficult a question to pose, and also whether you get any sort of guarantee against the future failure of said motor. I should imagine a good dealership isn't going to want it to come back and bite them on the bum in the future..

NITO

1,359 posts

237 months

Thursday 29th June 2017
quotequote all
I'd be asking very politely for my money back. They can take the bike in, repair it and sell it on.

2wheelsjimmy

624 posts

128 months

Friday 30th June 2017
quotequote all
I'd ask for a refund, nicely.

Call citizens advice bureau and check your rights. 03454 04 05 06

You might well be within the timeframe for legal ground for your money back.

A993LAD

2,154 posts

252 months

Friday 30th June 2017
quotequote all
I'd definitely want money back from dealer and move on.

Think you have been very unlucky though.

I've just bought a 2nd vfr1200 after doing 30k on my first with 100% reliability and there are a few on the forums with 50k plus miles.

It's a great bike and they are good value usually so I'd recommend one although i appreciate you will be a bit prejudiced against them after your experience .