Is it time for Ferrari to buy Ducati?
Is it time for Ferrari to buy Ducati?
Author
Discussion

Motorsport3

Original Poster:

568 posts

223 months

Sunday 9th July 2017
quotequote all
Ducati is up for sale and Ferrari is doing great so to me it would make sense to return to italian management. Am i alone thinking that this would be a very cool merger?

lucido grigio

44,044 posts

194 months

Sunday 9th July 2017
quotequote all
It might cause a conflict of interest seeing as Fiat sponsor Yamahas in Moto GP.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
lucido grigio said:
It might cause a conflict of interest seeing as Fiat sponsor Yamahas in Moto GP.
Things like that are easily dealt with, when Audi bought Ducati they were sponsored by AMG. The logos just quietly disappeared.

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
It would make no business sense for Ferrari. Just because they are Italian is not a good business reason.

Ferrari aim at a very select, very exclusive, very small market and having Ducati as a Ferrari brand would bring nothing to Ferrari. Likewise, Ferrari can't really help Ducati with their market which is the higher end of mass production and with their requirement for volume purchasing clout.

Now, Fiat buying Ducati would be a slightly different ball game! (And having Ducati in the "Fix It Again Tony" stable would somehow seem appropriate! biggrin )

huckster6

245 posts

248 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
Marriage between Ducati and Fiat looks and sounds like a good idea. Both companies are geographically and culturally closer. The German conglomerate lacks the tradition of the Italian conglomerate.
The tradition of beauty and performance dates back to the top European armourers of the medieval age and beyond to the genius of the Roman Empire.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
huckster6 said:
Marriage between Ducati and Fiat looks and sounds like a good idea. Both companies are geographically and culturally closer. The German conglomerate lacks the tradition of the Italian conglomerate.
The tradition of beauty and performance dates back to the top European armourers of the medieval age and beyond to the genius of the Roman Empire.
Yes, I often waxed lyrical about comparisons of medieval Italian armourers, versus their Bavarian equivalents when I was driving around in a Fiat Punto...

Genuine question, has Ducati ever produced higher sales than it has under "Zee Germans"?

Another genuine question, has Ducati ever produced higher performing bikes, or more reliable bikes, than it has with it's Audi stakeholders?

Looks wise as well, I would say the new stuff is very stylish. I personally think it's the best looking stuff they've ever produced... But looks are of course subjective.

Stereotypes of "Italian flair", or "Cold German precision", are very outdated.

998420

929 posts

182 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
If you visit the lovely North of Italy, you will quickly see that they are not your typical Italians, they are more Swiss/German/Austrian in personality and vibe, serious workers, engineering etc. I know one from the part of Austria that Hitler gave Mussolini, wierd, seems totally Austrian, is Italian.

Renn Sport

2,761 posts

240 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
VW-Audi have been very good for Ducati as they have for Lamborghini. It would be Ducati's loss if they lost their current owners.

slightly off topic... if Ducati were sold perhaps MV-Augusta would be a good purchase for VW-Audi. They could transform the fortunes of that company and perhaps make MV-Augusta a real rival for Ducati in the marketplace.

fergus

6,430 posts

306 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
Stereotypes of "Italian flair", or "Cold German precision", are very outdated.
What makes you say that?

Farlig

633 posts

183 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
But looks are of course subjective.
You got that bit right at least tongue out

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

221 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
fergus said:
What makes you say that?
I think logically, the onus falls on the person making the claim to back it up to be honest... But, I think it's a tired stereotype. Italy may remain the ancestral home of motoring exotica, but to suggest culture and heritage is anything but a tool of marketers in this day and age requires backing up I feel.

These companies are International by most sensible definitions. Regardless of where the factory is, the board, the design engineers, the vast majority of the components, and the tools they use, will be from all the corners of the globe. Regardless of where there HQ is, they won't be recruiting exclusively from Northern Italy to incorporate local culture into the design.

It's pure romanticising, and "Italian Flair", is nothing more than increased budget allocated to designer styling the finished product, and some appropriately shiny bolts-ons.

Audi know this as well as they do good business acumen, and have consequentially pulled Lamborghini and Ducati out from the gutter, and to suggest the race of an international based company ownership plays a significant role in the product is fantasy. JLR and TATA are similar examples of this.

That said, I don't want to cross wires here, I do agree there is an expectation of Italian exotica to have "flair", Japanese products to be efficient and high performing, etc. But this is part of the design brief to sell products. It's fk all to do with the nationality of the owners in this day and age.











super7

2,275 posts

239 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
Didn't FIAT use to own Ducati before Audi became involved?

I'm sure Ducati and Ferrari both developed the F4 enigne that's in the MV aswell. That was designed for the "Ferrari" Motorbike that never happened. MV then used it when they tried to get an engine of Ducati...

MV would not be bought by Audi either.... It's part owned by AMG already (Hence AMG stickers all over the WSB's) and Lewis Hamiltons Dragster LH44.

Could be wrong though?

nyxster

1,452 posts

202 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
From an R&D perspective marriages between bike makers make more sense than car makers because there is no shared parts bin otherwise. Being owned by a volume bike maker like BMW allowed Husqvarna to build the awesome Nuda, a bike they'd have struggled to engineer without a BMW platform as a template. The other aspect for someone like Ducati is getting better volume discounts by shared supplier purchasing, access to a larger dealer support network and the ability to share the higher R&D costs of electronics and software.

I don't think nationality of ownership is as important as a deal that improves the business and end product.

sjtscott

4,215 posts

262 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
lucido grigio said:
It might cause a conflict of interest seeing as Fiat sponsor Yamahas in Moto GP.
I don't see this really is an issue LOL Not sure where you've been the past few years smile
http://www.crash.net/motogp/news/165704/1/fiat-yam...

Swampy1982

3,694 posts

142 months

Monday 10th July 2017
quotequote all
nyxster said:
From an R&D perspective marriages between bike makers make more sense than car makers because there is no shared parts bin otherwise. Being owned by a volume bike maker like BMW allowed Husqvarna to build the awesome Nuda, a bike they'd have struggled to engineer without a BMW platform as a template. The other aspect for someone like Ducati is getting better volume discounts by shared supplier purchasing, access to a larger dealer support network and the ability to share the higher R&D costs of electronics and software.

I don't think nationality of ownership is as important as a deal that improves the business and end product.
This is the true reason a merger either makes sense or doesn't. Rather than some romantic notion of bringing a company back to their spiritual home, its more about squeezing the life out the margins through economies of scale. Shared parts bins, dealer networks etc go a long way in achieving this and would be the most likely reason for purchase.

Unless of course Ferrari decide to spend the stupid margin's they will get from their planned SUV to bring Ducati back to Italy...

Motorsport3

Original Poster:

568 posts

223 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all
Swampy1982 said:
nyxster said:
From an R&D perspective marriages between bike makers make more sense than car makers because there is no shared parts bin otherwise. Being owned by a volume bike maker like BMW allowed Husqvarna to build the awesome Nuda, a bike they'd have struggled to engineer without a BMW platform as a template. The other aspect for someone like Ducati is getting better volume discounts by shared supplier purchasing, access to a larger dealer support network and the ability to share the higher R&D costs of electronics and software.

I don't think nationality of ownership is as important as a deal that improves the business and end product.
This is the true reason a merger either makes sense or doesn't. Rather than some romantic notion of bringing a company back to their spiritual home, its more about squeezing the life out the margins through economies of scale. Shared parts bins, dealer networks etc go a long way in achieving this and would be the most likely reason for purchase.

Unless of course Ferrari decide to spend the stupid margin's they will get from their planned SUV to bring Ducati back to Italy...
While I agree that this is the main reason for merger of same type of companies, there are lifestyle type of portfolio composition, e.g. matching leather goods company with champagne producer and/or fine watchmaker.

Similarly, Ferrari historically wanted to be considered a racing team that is also selling cars has at least one more thing in common with Ducati other than the shade or their Red and the domicile.

TimmyWimmyWoo

4,364 posts

212 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all
I think it's a bad idea, they'll just put the indicator switch in the wrong place and charge a fortune for fancy stitching.

dibblecorse

7,666 posts

223 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all
Prof Prolapse said:
Another genuine question, has Ducati ever produced higher performing bikes, or more reliable bikes, than it has with it's Audi stakeholders?
Not higher performing but as reliable I think, I know many of the newer machines have some real inherent issues, visit any forum and ask about Multistrada 1200's .....

Swampy1982

3,694 posts

142 months

Tuesday 11th July 2017
quotequote all
Motorsport3 said:
Swampy1982 said:
nyxster said:
From an R&D perspective marriages between bike makers make more sense than car makers because there is no shared parts bin otherwise. Being owned by a volume bike maker like BMW allowed Husqvarna to build the awesome Nuda, a bike they'd have struggled to engineer without a BMW platform as a template. The other aspect for someone like Ducati is getting better volume discounts by shared supplier purchasing, access to a larger dealer support network and the ability to share the higher R&D costs of electronics and software.

I don't think nationality of ownership is as important as a deal that improves the business and end product.
This is the true reason a merger either makes sense or doesn't. Rather than some romantic notion of bringing a company back to their spiritual home, its more about squeezing the life out the margins through economies of scale. Shared parts bins, dealer networks etc go a long way in achieving this and would be the most likely reason for purchase.

Unless of course Ferrari decide to spend the stupid margin's they will get from their planned SUV to bring Ducati back to Italy...
While I agree that this is the main reason for merger of same type of companies, there are lifestyle type of portfolio composition, e.g. matching leather goods company with champagne producer and/or fine watchmaker.

Similarly, Ferrari historically wanted to be considered a racing team that is also selling cars has at least one more thing in common with Ducati other than the shade or their Red and the domicile.
I guess the key word here is "historically"

Surely the imminent production of a Rosso Red margin rich SUV leads one to assume that most of Enzo's wishes are spinning with him in his grave... much to the delight of all modern stakeholders