2015- R1 owners - battery flattening fast
2015- R1 owners - battery flattening fast
Author
Discussion

Dog Star

Original Poster:

17,649 posts

199 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
Question for latest model R1 owners - my battery is buggered after about three days and it needs to be kept on a trickle charger. It's now not charging at all.

I reckon the battery is mullered.

Only thing fitted is a tracker, the same tracker that was fitted to my MV F4 which would manage a couple of weeks off charge.

Anyone aware of R1s having weak batteries?

R1 Dave

7,158 posts

294 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
Yes mate they're total st; designed for a 250cc scooter!!! One thing that'll kill it really quickly is turning the key past the steering lock and onto the sidelight function; despite no lights actually coming on (so it's not obvious) it'll drain the battery overnight.

Lots of people switch to Lithium batteries, they give far higher cranking amps, way less weight and don't seem to lose their charge. I've not changed mine yet but I've had it fail to start a few times, usually if I've stalled it it won't have enough juice to crank it again for long. It failed to start in the IOM and I had to bump it across a field! Think I probably left it on sidelight mode for a few hours and it drained it but I can't be sure.

R1 Dave

7,158 posts

294 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
I've read great reviews of Shorai and a friend has one on his S1000RR with no issues.

Someone in YamahaR.co.uk runs one of these and rates it:

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/282138448362

ccr32

1,984 posts

249 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
Sounds buggered. In my experience, once a lead acid motorbike battery has been deep cycled (i.e. run completely flat) it is never the same again - had similar issues with the original battery in my Fireblade in that it would charge and hold charge, but any more than a couple of starts and it wouldn't have enough juice to start the bike again, which meant it was a bit squeaky bum time when I stalled it coming off the euro tunnel once..!

Looked in to Li-ion batteries after that (and yes, Shorai kept coming up as a recommendation) but ended up just going for a Motobatt lead acid job owing to cost (and the face I'd have to get a new optimate!) and never had a problem since. Loads more cranking power, no issues leaving the ignition on for a bit without the engine running, multiple starts not a problem.

Dog Star

Original Poster:

17,649 posts

199 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, chaps.

It's very poor design, and I'm tempted to just not even bother with a warranty claim (bike is 4.5 months old) and just get the Shorai; £59 isn't bad at all. I can't see the point in replacing with an identical battery if they are that bad.

cmaguire

3,589 posts

140 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
Dog Star said:
Thanks for the replies, chaps.

It's very poor design, and I'm tempted to just not even bother with a warranty claim (bike is 4.5 months old) and just get the Shorai; £59 isn't bad at all. I can't see the point in replacing with an identical battery if they are that bad.
You aren't getting a Shorai at that money. Nearer £200.

Dog Star

Original Poster:

17,649 posts

199 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
cmaguire said:
You aren't getting a Shorai at that money. Nearer £200.
Oops. I'll see what I can do - one of my mates owns a bike shop and I get stuff at cost, very often 50%.

cmaguire

3,589 posts

140 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
Dog Star said:
cmaguire said:
You aren't getting a Shorai at that money. Nearer £200.
Oops. I'll see what I can do - one of my mates owns a bike shop and I get stuff at cost, very often 50%.
You can use a standard charger on a li-ion battery. Use it on full charge mode and disconnect it as soon as charge is finished. The drip-charging maintenance chargers popular with lead-acid batteries are a problem. Li-ion are not knackered by being part-discharged like lead acid so the whole 'maintenance' thing is less relevant anyway.
Most bikes now have low current immobilisers only (or none at all) rather than the high drain immobilisers or alarms of old, so provided the bike gets used every couple of weeks at least then you aren't likely to have issues.
I have Shorai batteries on both of my bikes.

R1 Dave

7,158 posts

294 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
That cheap JHS battery is apparently very good and it's much cheaper than a Shorai. The issue with the R1 is the space available is minuscule so only a tiny and underpowered battery will fit

cmaguire

3,589 posts

140 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
R1 Dave said:
That cheap JHS battery is apparently very good and it's much cheaper than a Shorai. The issue with the R1 is the space available is minuscule so only a tiny and underpowered battery will fit
More fool them.
The flipside is that when I popped the seat on my new bike thinking I would find a li-ion battery, as a lightweight battery was touted as one of the differences between it and the 'basic' model, I found a bloody lead acid battery (3.2 Kg). Querying this with the dealer they said the battery on the 'basic' model was a different part number, so presumably even heavier.
The li-ion Shorai was 1.2Kg.
The difference on my previous GSXR750 was greater. The standard lead acid was 3.6Kg and the Shorai was 800g

R1 Dave

7,158 posts

294 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
As a complete opposite to your experience, a friend bought his S1KRR used (for a very good price) and not only did it have an expensive tracker fitted but when he lifted the seat he found a Shorai underneath. Lucky bugger.

Dog Star

Original Poster:

17,649 posts

199 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
To be honest I don't really care if the battery weighs 10kg, I'm not going to be using the bike where that would matter; what I'm interested in is that it can cope with normal treatment e.g. start the bike after a week

R1 Dave

7,158 posts

294 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
That little bump start on the IOM was the last time I had any issue and I've done about 1500 miles since, including lots of start/stop queuing to get on the ferry home. If it starts to play up again then I'll chuck a Lithium in there but until then I'll probably leave the standard one

cmaguire

3,589 posts

140 months

Wednesday 16th August 2017
quotequote all
Dog Star said:
To be honest I don't really care if the battery weighs 10kg, I'm not going to be using the bike where that would matter; what I'm interested in is that it can cope with normal treatment e.g. start the bike after a week
In both of my cases the Shorai battery was both smaller and lighter than the original with a claimed higher output.
So if you measure the size of your battery compartment (rather than buying the Shorai replacement for your inadequate original) and buy the largest Shorai that fits then you should be well ahead (and more skint).

Dog Star

Original Poster:

17,649 posts

199 months

Monday 21st August 2017
quotequote all
I ended up getting a Motobatt.

The lithium batteries are all very well but the fact that they are toast if they get discharged beyond a certain point is a complete no-no for me.

Getting the battery changed under warranty was just too much of a pain in the arse - I talked on the phone with one chap who said it was ok just to take them the battery but when I got there it was a case of "no we need the bike to check the charging system", I can't get the bike to them - I can't start it etc etc and I also think they'd just come up with something about my tracker invalidating the warranty; easier to just buy another battery.