What bike for a short commute?
What bike for a short commute?
Author
Discussion

milkround

Original Poster:

1,371 posts

110 months

Monday 25th September 2017
quotequote all
I live about 5 miles from where I work. But am planning on getting a bike to do the commute. The trains are annoying and work out quite expensive for short journey. And there is no parking for a car. But I can park a bike for free.

I don't have a licence. So I can either get a CBT which will be cheap and then a small bike. Or I could do a DAS and get a bigger bike. I only have a few grand for everything so I think a smaller bike would be better.

I have ridden bikes in Asia without a license. And I survived. But they were automatic so much easier. After a while the 125's started to feel very slow. So I don't want to get an automatic 125 here. However the manuals will be a bit faster I think.

Any advice would be appreciated. I can wait until winter to hopefully get a cheaper DAS course and could get a small bike in the meantime. Or just use the train and save up a bit. That would push by budget to 5-7 grand. But I have no idea how much insurance costs for a bike so this could be a deal breaker.

Oh and if anyone knows a good training school near to Birmingham or Nottingham please let me know. If there is a really good one nearer Southampton that could work as well due to family there.

CTO

3,021 posts

241 months

Monday 25th September 2017
quotequote all
Near Birmingham: Streetbike are very good, I did my CBT with them on a Saturday, and then went on to do my DAS also.

I spent six months on a 125 getting some practice in,but it did my head in towards the end. Slow, less stable and less road presence all made me feel more vulnerable whilst riding.

smiles1

544 posts

253 months

Monday 25th September 2017
quotequote all
With 5 miles you could pretty much go for any 125 that is comfortable for you.

I have a Honda XL125R that I need to sell if you fancy that. It was used by my brother inlaw for exactly the purpose you mention and now he has his full license so has no need for it. Cheap, reliable and decent enough on fuel smile

tom_e

346 posts

130 months

Monday 25th September 2017
quotequote all
Push bike.

J B L

4,217 posts

246 months

Monday 25th September 2017
quotequote all
^ that or scooter

bogie

17,106 posts

303 months

Monday 25th September 2017
quotequote all
5 miles is an easy push bike ride and likely not that slower overall. You have to gear up to ride either in all weather.

Piston-slapper

74 posts

121 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
But he wasn't asking about push bikes! I'm sure if he wanted to do ten miles a day on a bicycle he would have already considered it. Get a 125 for a bit, then move up to something else if you get bored.

RemaL

25,103 posts

265 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
If you don't want a push bike any bikes good for that commute. just depends on how much you want to spend and where you will be keeping it at work

morebeanz

3,283 posts

267 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
I know it's a heinous crime to mention them, but a 5 mile commute is absolutely scooter territory. Much less faffing with gear, storage under seat and automatic like you're used to.

milkround

Original Poster:

1,371 posts

110 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
Thanks.

I have considered a push bike and a scooter. But I kind of want to learn a new skill. And as I really enjoyed a scooter throughout asia and in countries with less rules than the UK I thought I might like propper bikes. I'd also like to be legal going forward so that when I do go on holiday I can drive both legally and be covered by my insurance. Although Ive got no holidays planned.

BobSaunders

3,110 posts

186 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
I'd run the sums on a 2nd hand automatic or manual 125 for your postcode if i were you with 0 NCB. As you said make or break.

For five miles, and nothing more than simply commuting to work, via. non-fast road work, and dumping it at work during the day - then scooter.

Automatic scooters can be had for £1500 or less from a dealer with a level/period of warranty.

I wouldn't do much more than a CBT to get to work - then follow up with the DAS at a later date when you have more money and more interest.



milkround

Original Poster:

1,371 posts

110 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
Cheers - thats a good idea. Any good comparison sites for bikes?

BobSaunders

3,110 posts

186 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
milkround said:
Cheers - thats a good idea. Any good comparison sites for bikes?
MCN compare, Confused.com, moneysupermarket.

Take your pick. MCE will come out cheapest, but there is a reason for that...

milkround

Original Poster:

1,371 posts

110 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
BobSaunders said:
MCN compare, Confused.com, moneysupermarket.

Take your pick. MCE will come out cheapest, but there is a reason for that...
Cheers - just ran one for a generic bike using MCE. Hastings were cheapest for me. £360 vs MCE being £420. Seems a bit expensive compared to what I pay for my car. Car is a lot faster than a 125 and has the potential to cause a lot more carnage. But then I've been driving for over a decade and have 7 years no claims disount on that.

I'll try some other bikes after work. I can live with paying around £400 and that was for a manual mike honda CBR. I'm going to presume it would be cheaper for an auto.

JoBlack

143 posts

111 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
My advice would be go and get your CBT done first. You'll need it in any case and It'll be much easier to make a decision once you've spent a day on a geared bike. You'll spend at least a couple of hours road riding which should give you an idea if a 125 is going to be enough for what you want. If you are still undecided then ask to do a trial / taster session on a big bike after your CBT, it'll cost you 70 quid or so fir a couple of hours and you'll get to try the difference between the big bike / 125 and then will be better informed about if you want to crack on with DAS or do some time on a 125 first.

I did my CBT but was still very shaky after it and didn't feel the intensive nature if goung straight to test after 5 days riding would work for me so opted for the 125 route. After 500 miles in a month I'm at the point where I'm riding confidently in all weathers and getting on a 650 didn't phase me, but I'm actually rare I suppose that I love riding my 125 - its a lot more nimble in traffic and very light so easy to hooligan about at speeds that don't get you in trouble.

If you go the 125 route here are the caveats:

Buy a standard 125 learner bike cheap on ebay - something like a YBR or CBR - you can sell them easily. Don't be tempted by new chinese bikes - they are basically worthless the minute you buy them. Not knowing anything I made the mistake of buying something new and shiny which is harder to sell and makes upgrading a PITA.

You won't get a test ride out of a dealer so don't bother with them. I visited main franchise dealers and they literally had no interest in selling a 125.

Insurance: for a mainstream honda or yamaha then go to the meerkat for a guideline quote. If you are paying cash then insure third party only - the excess and pittance they will pay on theft makes it a waste of time on a cgeap bike because they will rape you on premiums if you ever make a claim. View your insurance as nothing more than a legal minimum and ticket to NCB. Third party only you should be paying 80-170 quid a year max depending in age/area. once you get a meerkat quote ring brokers like priveledge/carole nash and ask if they can beat it. don't take extras - get your legal cover and breakdown cover from a third party.

Buy a decent disclok. Geared 125's arent exactly a miney earner if you buy something cheap and tatty so you just need to discourage opportunist scrotes not tooled up angle grinder carriers.

invest in decent wet weather gear - it will make your commute a lot more comfortable than freezing your nuts off but with extra bhp. For short commute on a 125 textiles are fine, you'll hit something hard in an urban environment long before leathers do their work. But body armour is a must for comfortable surfing across school mums bonnets.

If you do the 125 route don't bother with the intensive DAS course, after a month you don't need days of being told how to ride - just get a few hours on a mod 1 pad, get your mod 1 then get a couple of practice sessions / mock tests to clean up your bad habits before mod 2. The easiest wat to prep your test is just do practice runs. - 45 minutes with urban, some NSL and a dual carriageway - your main aim is to build up riding stamina and concentration so you can do a solid hour without getting sloppy and make mistakes. The things you'll fail mod 2 on are easily practiced on any bike - shoulder checks, not cancelling indicators, lane discipline, road positioning, meeting traffic - if you can ride 'cleanly' on a 125 then your DAS instruction is just about big bike handling. The advantage of not doing it in an intensive course is it takes the stress and pressure to pass off - you'll have time to judge when you feel ready and capable to do it rather than being rushed into a preset timeline.

Truth be told there is no one size fits all route which is why you can't second guess what is right for you based off other people's opinions or experience. Go and do your CBT - you'll have a good idea how bike capable you are by the end of it - a trial lesson on a big bike will allow you to compare and determine what you will feel more comfortable riding and if you have sufficient confidence to crank through a intensive course without racking up expensive test fails.


so tldr:
do your CBT and a trial big bike lesson then decide what works for you.
invest in your bad weather kit before you go bike shopping, it'll stop you overspending on a shiny bike then dropping it because your fingers go numb in tescos gloves.
insure for the bare minimum and buy crap bike you can afford to drop.
don't buy chinese, you'll be stuck with it.
get hi vis kit. in bad weather if it doesn't save you it'll ensure their claim they didn't see you doesn't hold up in court.
if you get a 125 use the time to get used to riding at trst standard - watch the mod 1 and 2 videos on youtube and go out and practice
get your theory test done early - there is usually a long wait for slots it's one less thing to worry about and you cant do mod 1 until you have it. get the motorbike app and practice - the questions are easy but the hazard perception is a ballache until you learn to game the test, the app gets you used to it.

















kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
zzr1400.

Mikey2312

141 posts

110 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
I previously owned a Street Triple R and although I moved on from it I can't recommend it enough for a short commute. It was comfortable, good on fuel and had plenty of torque.

Definitely go DAS, even if you don't go for a big bike for a while at least it is done and out of the way.

As previously mentioned, invest in security, and lots of it.. bike theft is through the roof at the moment

milkround

Original Poster:

1,371 posts

110 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
Thanks again - especially JoBlack for the really detailed report.

I probably have done 10k miles on automatic 125's. I worked for a while in Indonesia and brought one. And I've driven cars for the best part of 15 years. I don't think road positioning is going to be my major problems. It's going to be getting used to a bigger bike and also gears which worry me a bit.

I'll do the cbt and see how I feel. After that I will buy something cheap and crack on. I'll probably end up doing the DAS at some point in the next 6-12 months, but using that route I won't be in a rush.

My commute doesn't go higher than 40mph. But there is a fair bit of traffic and lights which means it's 20 mins to half an hour in the car. Plus another 15 mintures of walking from where I can park it. So anything will save my time and hassle.

Tango13

10,190 posts

207 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
kurt535 said:
zzr1400.
/\ This but either take a tooth off the front or add 2 or 3 to the rear to it give that bit more 'Go' at the lights/pedestrian crossing/cold greasy roundabout.

HTH? smile

kurt535

3,560 posts

148 months

Tuesday 26th September 2017
quotequote all
Tango13 said:
kurt535 said:
zzr1400.
/\ This but either take a tooth off the front or add 2 or 3 to the rear to it give that bit more 'Go' at the lights/pedestrian crossing/cold greasy roundabout.

HTH? smile
exactly my thoughts too.