Who's at fault?
Author
Discussion

chrispwill

Original Poster:

177 posts

155 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
Hi,

My brother recently got into a crash while on his motorcycle, and just wanted to get an opinion from pistonheads as to who was at fault. The way he describes it to me is as follows.
He is filtering to the right of the line of stationary cars, this is in London (not that it legally makes a difference). There was a side road on the left up ahead. He continued overtaking the cars past this side road, when a car pulled out suddenly from between the line of cars. He braked, but not in time and hit the side of the car as it pulled out from between the line of stationary cars onto the oncoming lane so that it could turn right.

My brother admits he was going a bit too fast for the conditions, especially as it was damp, as shown by the fact he wasn’t able to stop in time. Really I just want a view of what you guys would think in terms of proportion of blame. I see it personally as 50/50, as he shouldn’t really be filtering past a junction, and if you do then he should be taking more care when doing it. On the other hand, the car should be taking the appropriate checks before pulling out, specifically for that reason.

What do people think?
Thanks

sc0tt

18,310 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
The driver pulled out into oncoming traffic so he is at fault but he should have anticipated the driver emerging from the side road. In my opinion.

But there is no point being right sat in the back of an ambulance.

kiethton

14,668 posts

211 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
Currently got the same situation dragging through the courts from a year or 2 ago as both my (and the TP's) insurance company refuse liability.

Case law is varied and often contradictory, most commonly quoted is 80/20 against the motorbike - gap that they pulled out from you should have anticipated.

gsxr renegade

126 posts

146 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
Difficult to say without knowing exact specifics, but i think it would, at best, be 50/50, at worst, blame on the motorcyclist in my opinion. He should have anticipated there may have been a car with severely restricted visibility wanting to pull out of the junction and slowed down accordingly and the driver maybe could have been a bit more cautious of filtering motorcycles/bicycles.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
It does not sound to me like he was filtering, more overtaking a line of slow moving cars. That would make it more the driver of the car needing to take more care as he is the one pulling out into an overtaking vehicle's path, and one that has been overtaking succesfully to that point.

But OK, flying past a junction is also a tad silly as it is likewise reasonable to expect a car to want to turn into it ( so imo the biker should have slowed and picked off each car one by one at the junction).

I'd say 80-20 is the best the biker can hope for. 50-50 seems likely, the not slowing at a junction does it for me.

Moulder

1,648 posts

243 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
Similar to my first (and only) accident (to date)...

Filtering along the outside of traffic, car pulls out from a car park on the left, I almost pass in front of it and he hits me side on. Damage to his car was smashed number plate where it hit my foot peg, £2600 of damage to my NSR250. Settled 70/30 in my favour.

Obviously I was the hittee as opposed to the hitter and I can appreciate things may have changed since 1993, but the above gives a real world figure.

yellowjack

18,549 posts

197 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
It would seem that this comes under the basics of "Using the Road"...

The Highway Code said:
Rule 167:
DO NOT overtake where you might come into conflict with other road users. For example...

* approaching or at a road junction on either side of the road
* where the road narrows
* when approaching a school crossing patrol
* between the kerb and a bus or tram when it is at a stop
* where traffic is queuing at junctions or road works
* when you would force another road user to swerve or slow down
...
(HC quote snipped to eliminate irrelevant examples)


Edit to add:

For balance, look at rules 170 and 172 for what the car driver may have failed to do...

Rule 170 - "Take extra care at junctions. You should watch out for cyclists, motorcyclists, powered wheelchairs/mobility scooters and pedestrians as they are not always easy to see."

Rule 172 - "The approach to a junction may have a ‘Give Way’ sign or a triangle marked on the road. You MUST give way to traffic on the main road when emerging from a junction with broken white lines across the road." This is 'The Law' too, not just advice...
"Laws: RTA 1988 sect 36 & TSRGD regs 10(1),16(1) & 25"

Although if the insurers fight each other all the way to court it's going to be more complex than simply "car broke the law, bike didn't, therefore car is 100% at fault"

Edited by yellowjack on Tuesday 24th October 16:06

chrispwill

Original Poster:

177 posts

155 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
Thanks all.
My brother admits his own lack of anticipation, and will correct in future riding styles, but I think he was concerned it would be seen as 100% his fault, whereas I was trying to tell him it's more likely to be 50/50. Most people on here seem to agree as well, so good to know.

kiethton

14,668 posts

211 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
chrispwill said:
Thanks all.
My brother admits his own lack of anticipation, and will correct in future riding styles, but I think he was concerned it would be seen as 100% his fault, whereas I was trying to tell him it's more likely to be 50/50. Most people on here seem to agree as well, so good to know.
50/50 on a good day, as I'm currently finding - good chance of it going completely against me.

CubanPete

3,820 posts

219 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
I think filtering is doing 3-4mph faster than the stationary traffic.

Overtaking passed a junction, admitting to going a bit too fast and not paying attention doesn't sound like complete innocence...

Pica-Pica

16,721 posts

115 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
CubanPete said:
I think filtering is doing 3-4mph faster than the stationary traffic.

Overtaking passed a junction, admitting to going a bit too fast and not paying attention doesn't sound like complete innocence...
This. Calling what appears to be an unwise overtake, does not make it wiser by calling it 'filtering'.

chrispwill

Original Poster:

177 posts

155 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
CubanPete said:
I think filtering is doing 3-4mph faster than the stationary traffic.

Overtaking passed a junction, admitting to going a bit too fast and not paying attention doesn't sound like complete innocence...
I said above, that my brother isn't claiming complete innocence, in fact he thought he was himself 100% at fault and I am trying to tell him that partial blame should be placed on the car driver as well, and came here for other people's opnions

curlie467

7,650 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
Our opinions mean nothing in the real world.

They may make him feel better for a bit though.

CubanPete

3,820 posts

219 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
How much 'bit too fast' was it? What was the speed limit? There is a lot of missing information. If it was a bit unlucky, could be 50/50, if he was riding like a complete one, could be completely against.

bimsb6

8,808 posts

252 months

Tuesday 24th October 2017
quotequote all
swerni said:
sc0tt said:
Sounds like the driver turned into the side road from the queuing traffic, not the other way round.
It's a bit academic what we think.

Glad he's okay
Not the way i read it .

Mr Tidy

31,893 posts

158 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Glad to hear he is OK OP. thumbup

There have been many cases like this over the years (some even going back to when I dealt with motor claims)!

Without knowing all the ins and outs of what happened, in his position I'd be happy with a 50/50.

But this case suggests that would be a good result:- http://www.kennedyslaw.com/casereview/standardofca...

It might be worth doing a quick Google on the other cases quoted.

Or possibly posting under Speed, Plod and the Law.

I hope he gets a decent settlement!



thatdude

2,660 posts

158 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
50/50 I think the insurers will look at it. The person pulling out presumably was familier with the idea that motorcycles might be filtering in trafic, so could have looked out a bit more, but at the same time your brother should have taken great caution - especially if the traffic had stopped and a gap was visible.

In any case, hope he's alright.

gavgavgav

1,569 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
In terms for insurance, whats the difference to the insured if it is 50:50, 80:20 etc. Is the important bit not "Fault" or "Non-Fault" when the renewal comes up, or does this make a difference?

JulianHJ

8,871 posts

293 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
gsxr renegade said:
Difficult to say without knowing exact specifics, but i think it would, at best, be 50/50, at worst, blame on the motorcyclist in my opinion. He should have anticipated there may have been a car with severely restricted visibility wanting to pull out of the junction and slowed down accordingly and the driver maybe could have been a bit more cautious of filtering motorcycles/bicycles.
This is my view as well. Bikers should know the dangers of filtering past nearside junctions and be prepared to stop accordingly - it was certainly drummed in to me on my DAS.

chrispwill

Original Poster:

177 posts

155 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Thanks all.. most seem to say 50/50, I do realise this is only opinions. As I said my brother was under the impression he was at 100% fault and I was trying to convince him it was not as clear cut as that.

He has notified his insurers, but I'm trying to get him to settle outside of insurance if possible, as in both parties pay for their own damage. I think he was expecting to have to pay for his own damage + damage on the other car