08 R1 or KTM RC8
Author
Discussion

GreigR

Original Poster:

765 posts

237 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
After a bit of advice, I've got an 08 R1 on order, should get it within the next 2-3 weeks.

Today at another dealers, right time right place (for once) I was looking at the KTM RC8's, just happened that someone had cancelled there order and I have first chance on it. If I cancel my R1 i'll only lose £100.

Part of me says go for the RC8 but as it's such a new bike, it might become a flop and be hard to sell on, not sure about finish or reliability compared to the Yamaha?

Should I forget the RC8 for a year or two, if it's a success there will be a better one out in the next 18 months, if not I won't have lost anything.

Any advice appreciated.

Thanks

bordseye

2,238 posts

223 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
Got a KTM RC8 Adventure. The finish and build quality are first class - better than the BMW I had last. No reliability problems so far. But judged purely as a sportsbike, I think I would go for the Jap. It will be a better bike assuming you are capable of using its potential.

The RC8 engine still needs some work on the fuelling at low speeds - its snatchy. And the initial test reports , whilst getting excited as the journos always do about something new, all hinted that the Jap offerings were better developed.

Unfortunately, the Japs dont really do big adventure bikes so for me its KTM or BMW.

As for the financial side - who knows? I got the 1200GS before the Charlie / Ewan thing really got going and the result was just 15% depreciation in 2 years from new. The RC8 might be like that, or it might be like other KTMs and depreciate Jap style. I favour the latter.

slim_boy_fat

735 posts

270 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
RC8 for me.

The fuling can/will be sorted either by KTM or a power commander and some dyno time.

I bet its a better road bike than the R1

I bet its worth more in 3 years than the R1, by quite a bit.

If you dont buy the RC8 your madder then mad john mcmad man from madtown.

FeatherZ

2,422 posts

227 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
I think the rc8 is a really ugly bike, i hate it with a passion, its just too different i guess, id have the r1, im just going on looks though and the rc8 gets really rave reviews, everyone loves it, but i cant get past them different looks i suppose, just doesnt look right to me!

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
R1 every day of the week for me.

Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
R1.

y2blade

56,325 posts

246 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
R1 everyday

the KTM RC8 has a ste gearbox frown
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

shame as i love the look of it

Jolley

465 posts

266 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
y2blade said:
the KTM RC8 has a ste gearbox frown
Have been reading a few reviews on the bike and all of the test riders seem to have been having a problem with it jumping out of first. The last review did say that when they raised this at the test the KTM chap said they were aware of the problem and a fix was in the pipeline...... it is a risk, but if it pays off you will be one of a very small very lucky group of owners, it depends if that is more important to you.

y2blade

56,325 posts

246 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
Jolley said:
y2blade said:
the KTM RC8 has a ste gearbox frown
Have been reading a few reviews on the bike and all of the test riders seem to have been having a problem with it jumping out of first. The last review did say that when they raised this at the test the KTM chap said they were aware of the problem and a fix was in the pipeline...... it is a risk, but if it pays off you will be one of a very small very lucky group of owners, it depends if that is more important to you.
i know what you mean but surey KTM should have sorted it before putting the amzing looking/performing bike into the showrooms and tarnishing their reputation?

not that it matters to me either way as i wont be buying one


SpydieNut

5,960 posts

254 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
R1 for me

not least because i think it looks much nicer, but yamaha have also got all the teething problems ironed out.


IforB

9,840 posts

260 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
An R1 is just that. An R1. There are thousands out there. An RC8 is an exciting new machine. I'd have that in a shot.

In a couple of years the RC8 will still be worth something, whereas the R1 will be just another 2 year old R1.

For me, it's an absolute no-brainer. KTM each and everytime.

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Even though I love R1s' and I think since 2002 they are one of teh best looking bikes Italian included I would have said RC8 in a heart beat.

I say would have only for one reason gearbox issues. I loved my GSXRs' gear box if I was getting false neutrals and notchy gears that would really annoy me more than pretty much anything else.

I would need to know that this is going to be fixed before I jumped in.

Brummmie

5,284 posts

252 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
We had 2x RC8's at Brands for a dealer tyre try out, EVERYONE commented on crap fuelling and false neutrals, and we lunched one, its the third one to get totalled already!! Looked fantastic in the flesh, the motor is great when on it.

y2blade

56,325 posts

246 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
Brummmie said:
We had 2x RC8's at Brands for a dealer tyre try out, EVERYONE commented on crap fuelling and false neutrals, and we lunched one, its the third one to get totalled already!! Looked fantastic in the flesh, the motor is great when on it.
nothing worse than a crap gearbox mad

what a shame frown

bordseye

2,238 posts

223 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
slim_boy_fat said:
The fuling can/will be sorted either by KTM or a power commander and some dyno time.
there is a lot of 990 adv owners trying to do exactly that, so far without much success. whats called the fuelling problem isnt just fuelling if you see what I mean. its an issue of too light a flywheel, a friction free very light throttle as well as the Euro 3 bit. So its not just a dyno trip to sort. Indeed a dyno alone wont make any difference since the ecm for the fuel injection is self adjusting so it just adjusts back to the standard map I believe.

incidentally the fuelling prob can be overstated - its simply a bit snatchy at 20 to 30 mph round town speeds. no prob at all on the open road.

and as for the gearbox, there are no problems on my 990, no false neutrals at all - and its exactly the same box. suppose a sports bike might be more critical somehow, but I cant see why

Edited by bordseye on Saturday 19th April 12:28

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Saturday 19th April 2008
quotequote all
bordseye said:
and as for the gearbox, there are no problems on my 990, no false neutrals at all - and its exactly the same box. suppose a sports bike might be more critical somehow, but I cant see why
I thought it wasnt the same gearbox - they've thinned the plates or something, and thats causing issues. Cant find the article with the interview in now grumpy

bordseye

2,238 posts

223 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
randlemarcus said:
bordseye said:
and as for the gearbox, there are no problems on my 990, no false neutrals at all - and its exactly the same box. suppose a sports bike might be more critical somehow, but I cant see why
I thought it wasnt the same gearbox - they've thinned the plates or something, and thats causing issues. Cant find the article with the interview in now grumpy
You might well be right and that would account for the different reports, but I remember an interview with the designer and him saying the exact opposite - that the engine was a new development but the gearbox was the same.


Busamav

2,954 posts

239 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
I dont see even a close comparison between the 2 bikes.

If you want to be different , get the KTM , but dont even start to imagine it will be anywhere near as good at the required job as the R1

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Sunday 20th April 2008
quotequote all
Busamav said:
I dont see even a close comparison between the 2 bikes.

If you want to be different , get the KTM , but dont even start to imagine it will be anywhere near as good at the required job as the R1
I think that very much depends on the required job. IMHO the KTM can give riding pleasure that the R1 can only dream about and if that were not an opinion believed to be help by a fair few people then KTM would not have a potential customer base and would not expect to sell any RC8s.

For me, it would be the KTM although I would like to see the gearbox issues sorted first.

timmyyyy

9 posts

223 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
hello guys, kinda just registered because i saw yor topic about the rc8. Im from belgium so sry for my poor english.
I have an RC8 myself and before that i had a jap. When u used 2 the gearbox of a jap well... nothing can beat that but i have the rc8 for a month now and you rly get used 2 it, all about the handling of the gearbox and it barley jumps out now. And in my opinion you are comparing 2 differnt bikes with 2 different caracters. I rly love the rc8 not only by looks but also the handling and i could not believe it myself but yo can not compare it with a standart R1 or jap rly.

Had my first circuit day with the rc8 2 weeks ago and i can say braking, steering, accelerating in turns... pownage. But its true when you say its new and didnt proof anything and the R1 sure did. I would not go or rather did not go for R1 because it still has the same looks like in 2000 hope atleast that they gonna change that for the rest, R1 supa bike. There are only 60 rc8's in belgium and i can say im very happy 2 be one of te owners lovely bike. Good luck ith your choise. And see you at the Isle of men TT