Any bike mechanics out there?
Any bike mechanics out there?
Author
Discussion

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
I have a problem with my Harley, basically someone has codged up some forward controls for it, but whilst doing so the sawed off the stud for the original left footpeg. I've had the primary cover off and tried to remove said stud, to replace it with a longer one. I two-nutted it, on what is left of the thread, but no matter how tight I got the nuts I still couldn't get the bleddy stud to move.

I considered getting my huge monkey wrench on it, but there is not enough room to get in and inflict the damage.

Anybody have any guesses whether there would be a locknut inside the crankcase holding it in place, or would you think it is just torqued into a blind threaded hole in the crankcase? I think the latter, but I'm worried about destroying the crankcase.

That black ring is just a gasket around the stud.


Ruttager

2,079 posts

223 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
My first thoughts are that its simply threaded in but I'd be wary of using a lot of force to remove it. It could shear off and then you're really screwed (no pun intended).

Not a master mechanic though, just handy with a spanner now and again. I'm sure other will offer their two-cents.

I guess you've tried more specialised harley forums there has got to be tonnes around

Rutts

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
Ruttager said:
My first thoughts are that its simply threaded in but I'd be wary of using a lot of force to remove it. It could shear off and then you're really screwed (no pun intended).

Not a master mechanic though, just handy with a spanner now and again. I'm sure other will offer their two-cents.

I guess you've tried more specialised harley forums there has got to be tonnes around

Rutts
I've tried a couple of big US HD forums, but nobody has replied. I'm not so much worried about breaking the stud, but tearing out the ally boss it screws into.


nj1052

52 posts

219 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
Hi there

The stud was almost certainly installed with thread lock. To break the lock it will need to be heated up. The actual temperature depends on what was used but usually 100C will do the job. Then try the double nuts again.

Cheers


King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
nj1052 said:
Hi there

The stud was almost certainly installed with thread lock. To break the lock it will need to be heated up. The actual temperature depends on what was used but usually 100C will do the job. Then try the double nuts again.

Cheers

I'll get some heatproof blanket round it and play my blow lamp gently on the stud/ally, see what prevails. Thanks for the tip.

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
nj1052 said:
Hi there

The stud was almost certainly installed with thread lock. To break the lock it will need to be heated up. The actual temperature depends on what was used but usually 100C will do the job. Then try the double nuts again.

Cheers

I'd go along with that suggestion, plus a nice long tube on the end of your spanner to give you some decent leverage - it's surprising how little force you can actually apply with a normal length wrench or spanner, and a long tube will give you a bit more control over how much force too.

ETA Is this any use to you? It's in French (WTF?), but the language of st diagrams is universal:

http://pdftown.com/Harley-Davidson-Sportster-XLH-S...

Edited by N Dentressangle on Wednesday 13th August 16:41


Edited by N Dentressangle on Wednesday 13th August 16:47

bimsb6

8,809 posts

252 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
whereabouts do you live ? i have a set of socket type ramp and roller stud extractors which would be perfect for getting that out ,that stud doesn't appear in the buell manuals i have so i would assume it is just a stud .tapping the end gently with a hammer may help to loosen the loctite, i doubt the 2 nut method will shift it though you may need a breaker bar on it with a proper extractor .

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
bimsb6 said:
whereabouts do you live ? i have a set of socket type ramp and roller stud extractors which would be perfect for getting that out ,that stud doesn't appear in the buell manuals i have so i would assume it is just a stud .tapping the end gently with a hammer may help to loosen the loctite, i doubt the 2 nut method will shift it though you may need a breaker bar on it with a proper extractor .
I'm in Stafford, just off junction 13, M6.

I'd forgotten about them roller ramp type devices. That would get a better grip on it, as the thread is barely long enough to get two nuts on.

I go offshore next week again, so I'll probably leave it until I come back, and maybe try to get a ride on the bike before I go, if it stops bloody raining.

N Dentressangle said:
I'd go along with that suggestion, plus a nice long tube on the end of your spanner to give you some decent leverage - it's surprising how little force you can actually apply with a normal length wrench or spanner, and a long tube will give you a bit more control over how much force too.

ETA Is this any use to you? It's in French (WTF?), but the language of st diagrams is universal:

http://pdftown.com/Harley-Davidson-Sportster-XLH-S...
I'm downloading it now, see if it offers any info. I have a Clymer manual, but it shows no detail of the crank case interior, so I assume that they assume all Harley riders go to a dealer once the problems are inside the crankcases? scratchchin

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

247 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
Looks like an 883 Sportster. If so that's a screwed in stud and it's exactly as nj10... said.

I wouldn't pee about with applying gentle heat. I'd be in there with an oxy acetylene torch getting the stud hot near the stuck end pretty quick. Some of HD's thread lock can be a bloody pain.

RizzoTheRat

29,153 posts

223 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
Worth trying an impact wrench if you can get one in there. I couldn't shift the bolt that holds the damper rod assembly in my forks but got it off in seconds with a cheapo electric impact wrench.

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
Looks like an 883 Sportster. If so that's a screwed in stud and it's exactly as nj10... said.

I wouldn't pee about with applying gentle heat. I'd be in there with an oxy acetylene torch getting the stud hot near the stuck end pretty quick. Some of HD's thread lock can be a bloody pain.
Ahaa, now I know. I have oxy acetylene in the garage, so that'll do the job, with plenty of protective fire blanket around the expensive bits. Cheers.

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

247 months

Wednesday 13th August 2008
quotequote all
Actually, just another thought. It's not difficult to remove the clutch, drive sprocket and chain to gain more access.

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Saturday 20th September 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
Actually, just another thought. It's not difficult to remove the clutch, drive sprocket and chain to gain more access.
I got back from work offshore Thursday, so today I was in the garage, and after swapping the mickey mouse chopper handlebars for some normal bars, I decided to tackle the offending stud. I have bought a proper stud remover, but in a fit of laziness and enthusiasm I simply welded the nut onto the end of the stud and carefully swung on the end of a spanner, and the stud screwed out fairly easily. biggrin

Saved taking the cover off and a new gasket and mess and all.

I now have foot pegs where they belong, and handlebars where they are meant to be, and when I get a bottle of Dot 3 tomorrow I'll have brakes too. Then it'll be time for a burn on my transformed Sporty.

biggrin

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 20th September 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
I simply welded the nut onto the end of the stud and carefully swung on the end of a spanner, and the stud screwed out fairly easily. biggrin
i was gonna suggest that damnit.

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Saturday 20th September 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
King Herald said:
I simply welded the nut onto the end of the stud and carefully swung on the end of a spanner, and the stud screwed out fairly easily. biggrin
i was gonna suggest that damnit.
I didn't want to sound like a heathen either, but it seemed the easiest way to start once I was sure it was just a screw-in stud, not cast in, or with a locknut on the back of the inside crank casing.

biggrin

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

247 months

Sunday 21st September 2008
quotequote all
Dot 3? Use Dot 4 at the very least.

Got some pic's of the finished result dude?

Us ex Sporty owners might want a giggle, lol!!!!

Still one of my al time fave bikes..............



Sportster XR1000






And with a bit of luck, I'll have one one day.

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Sunday 21st September 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
Dot 3? Use Dot 4 at the very least.

Got some pic's of the finished result dude?
Well, I was planning to have a closer look at the manual before buying it but I was sure it said something about Dot 3 only. Mind you, the bike was built/manual written before Dot 4 was invented. And Dot 5 is a big no no because it is synthetic and ruins the rubber seals.

I'll post some newer pics when I get some taken, but here's a pic when I got it:




It now has lower bars, and normal footpegs. Seat might get changed, maybe paint, some ally polishing etc. The gay pride studded leather jock strap device has gone too.biggrin

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

247 months

Monday 22nd September 2008
quotequote all
4 is sound. You could go 5.1 too!

Sportsters look great stripped off the tarts handbag junk. Gotta love 'em really.

RizzoTheRat

29,153 posts

223 months

Monday 22nd September 2008
quotequote all
If you use Dot 5.1 make sure you change it regularly. It's high performance stuff, probably overkill for a road bike to be honest, but it doesn't last as well.