MotoGP: The Michelin Rebellion
MotoGP: The Michelin Rebellion
Author
Discussion

Rawwr

Original Poster:

22,722 posts

265 months

Sunday 31st August 2008
quotequote all
Ok, so Rossi was the first proverbial rat to leave the sinking ship and now Pedrosa has ditched them mid-season to switch to Bridgestone after what appears to be some very positive testing with Shinya Nakano. So where will it all end?

Michelin utterly dominated the top class without interruption from since before Jorge Lorenzo was even born and now we have a situation where they've dropped one-and-a-half seasons down the toilet and everyone wants a bite of the Japanese rubbercake. Unfortunately, there isn't enough cake to go around. With Rossi, Pedrosa and Stoner - arguably the three strongest riders on the grid - all wearing Bridgestone and with Lorenzo obviously going to switch to Bridgestone next year and probably Repsol Honda switching to Bridgestone, are Michelin really going to put as much effort into tyre development for the few 'not so great' riders also on the field? Even if they did give their full effort into making tyres, they're going to be solely reliant on data fed from Colin Edwards, which just isn't going to be enough, surely?

Bridgestone can't support a full grid of Bridgestone runners and certainly not without detriment to the current Bridgestone runners. So are we in a situation now where the blind panic and demand for Bridgestone is going to see MotoGP forced into a single tyre manufacturer that isn't currently the best available (i.e. not Bridgestone)?

Thoughts?

RemaL

25,103 posts

265 months

Sunday 31st August 2008
quotequote all
can't blame then for wanting out.
st for 1 year but now going on 2. not good. if your racing in the best class of bikes you want the best and would have though they would have pushed the boat out this year to make up for the poor season last year

Johno

8,593 posts

313 months

Sunday 31st August 2008
quotequote all
Michelin used to operate in a totally different way, one which was unfair to other tyre suppliers, Dunlop even used to produce overnight and ship through the night for European rounds.

They are having amend their strategy post rule changes and they've got it wrong at some circuits. However, they are masters of these classes and they would come back stronger fo rthe change. They however won't if all the top teams ditch them in favour of Bridgestone although . . . borrowing form Julian Ryder yesterday, we may see the top teams switch to Bridgestones and then Michelin will have to work with the lower order teams to develop their tyres and strategy and then they will com eback.

What MotoGP dopesn't need is continuous rule changes as this doesn't serve in the best interets of the racing, it just makes it harder for everyone, there is too much knee jerk reaction stuff going on at the moment.

It will be a very sad day is it goes to single tyre manufacturer as I see no benefit from it in the long run. I see none in BSB or WSB and using safety as the argument doesn't stand up to analysis.

Slowing these bikes down can be done with 5 speed boxes and other technical solutions, so I wish they'd stop hiding behind that one.

Michelin deserve a rough ride for a while as they're not performing, however, the power of the rider or those around him is getting a little too much currently and being able to swap tyres mid season raises all sorts of debates about where this may end or what precendent it sets for the future.

2nd place today was within 3 secs, on Michelin and 5 of the top 10 were Michelins . .. Yes at some circuits they've been uncompetitive, but Bridgestone went through exactly the same thing when devloping theirs.

Michelin use differing constructions and compounds and the complexity of their opeartion has been supported by their ability to change things quickly. Bridgestone developed on the basis of having to get it right first time. Michelin will get there, but they're going to struggle now.

I hope Hayden, Tosleland, Edwards and Lorenzo occupy the first 4 places at Indy hehe