Mot fail on brakes,anyone help?
Mot fail on brakes,anyone help?
Author
Discussion

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
Took my TLR in for an MOT.It failed on the front brakes.He was trying to hold it steady on 50 on his gauge,it would hold there then dip,hold there then dip.Took the bike home after the fail.One disc was slightly raising the pads every cycle of the wheel,you heard a click,click.Cleaned brakes with brake cleaner,problem cleared up.At the retest the needle is fluctuating about 1 and a half blocks either side on his scale of this '50' mark he's trying to hold it at.He failed it again?What reading should the brakes give,how steady should the needle be and how much is the margin of error on these gauges?Anyone help?

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
I don't know what test equipment they use but if it's failing on the front brakes then you've probably got a serious problem as (at least at my local test station) the test is really easy and any bike that doesn't pass probably isn't safe.

Ducati back brakes are famous for being crap yet mine will pass the test (if it's freshly bled) but I really wouldn't want to rely on it to stop me.

Sounds like you need a brake overhaul.

beer

D1 MAD

383 posts

263 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Tuesday 2nd September 2008
quotequote all
I overhauled the front brakes three months ago,new seals even pistons!new pads 5 months ago.The needle on his gauge didn't seem to move too much from the 50 he was trying to hold it at.I called another MOT place and they said they would pass,but with an advisory if it fluctuated three marks on the gauge either side of where you were trying to hold it on the gauge.My brakes were only fluctuating one mark either side of teh 50 figure.The brake feel great when riding it,no vibration,no snatching,fading etc,just a nice progressive feel.You can't hide bad brakes when you ride a bike,i just don't get it?I'll check that link.Thanks.

r1100rt

10 posts

221 months

Thursday 4th September 2008
quotequote all
Hmmmm,
Seems like your tester isn't a real biker. I would not fail your machine if the fluctuation was only one block. It is possible to 'feel' a brake that is juddering without worrying about how many blocks its moving on the gauge.
Either that or he is a bit of a meglamaniac, and likes the power he has over your motorcycling.
I would take your bike to another station and never darken his door again.

rumpelstiltskin

Original Poster:

2,805 posts

290 months

Thursday 4th September 2008
quotequote all
Exactly,when out on the bike the brakes come on progessively and smooth,no juddering at all!I took the discs off,cleaned behind them,scraped surface of pads clean,brake cleaner everywhere,took it back for the 'third' time,he passed it!(gauge was same as before??)He was all hush hush don't tell anyone when he passed it as if he was doing me a favour!I get the meglamaniac thing,some testers know the power they have and play on it,it pisses me off.