To commute or not to commute...and what bike??
To commute or not to commute...and what bike??
Author
Discussion

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Following some pretty silly insurance quotes I had resigned myself to not getting a bike this year however, following my disgust at the lack of refund on my travel season ticket, even though my journey has been halved, I'm considering cashing it in altogether and getting a bike to commute.

My main worries in doing this are: -

1: The comlpete lack of other options i.e. "here's my bike and this is how I'm now going to get to work for at least the next year, come rain or shine" (All comments along the lines of "suck it up you pussy, I've been doing it for years" are welcome and shall be used as reassurance / motivation).

2: Although I will now have some extra cash for the bike and insurance, I don't really want to be paying rediculous money for insurance and I'm worried that anything over a 600 will be rediculous. That's fine as a 600 would be more than enough bike generally but would it get a bit tiresome on dual carriageway journeys (A12, M25, M11). (Also on that point, I realise that I could probably get away with a bigger engine in a 'non-sports' bike but the thing is, like my instructor said "get a bike that you WANT to ride".....and I want a sports bike).

All advise will be gratefully received on both the positive and negative aspects of daily commuting as well as bike suggestions. As a guide, my preferance is sports bikes but I could possibly be swayed by, for examle a VFR with a single seat and the rear pegs taken off!?

Many thanks


xspencex

1,534 posts

267 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
get some good all weather gear and riding all year round isn't so bad...
On bikes, and dependant on the cash you have available...possibly;

VFR 800
CBR 600F
VTR
BMW F800 S/ST

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
1: The comlpete lack of other options i.e. "here's my bike and this is how I'm now going to get to work for at least the next year, come rain or shine" (All comments along the lines of "suck it up you pussy, I've been doing it for years" are welcome and shall be used as reassurance / motivation).
Will you really have no other possible options whatsoever? Personally I will always ride if possible but certain things will definitely stop me. These are mainly things like mechanical breakdown, feeling like st due to a cold (I'm really unhappy riding through rush hour traffic when my balance and attention span is compromised past a certain point but suspect other people are harder wink) and snow. On those days I take the car (or stay in bed).

Given the exception I ride pretty much all year round but I must admit I didn't simply start doing that. Essentially I started off with days where the weather man swore over his mother's grave that it would not rain and slowly progressed to pretty much riding all the time because I wanted to and because I'd got kit to deal with the weather. I'm not sure I'd want to have jumped right in either as the confidence I have now was built up over time and is now based on experience.

Good luck though.

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
roboxm3 said:
1: The comlpete lack of other options i.e. "here's my bike and this is how I'm now going to get to work for at least the next year, come rain or shine" (All comments along the lines of "suck it up you pussy, I've been doing it for years" are welcome and shall be used as reassurance / motivation).
Will you really have no other possible options whatsoever? Personally I will always ride if possible but certain things will definitely stop me. These are mainly things like mechanical breakdown, feeling like st due to a cold (I'm really unhappy riding through rush hour traffic when my balance and attention span is compromised past a certain point but suspect other people are harder wink) and snow. On those days I take the car (or stay in bed).

Given the exception I ride pretty much all year round but I must admit I didn't simply start doing that. Essentially I started off with days where the weather man swore over his mother's grave that it would not rain and slowly progressed to pretty much riding all the time because I wanted to and because I'd got kit to deal with the weather. I'm not sure I'd want to have jumped right in either as the confidence I have now was built up over time and is now based on experience.

Good luck though.
I should proabbly add that should the worst happen i.e. it snows or I fancy a few beers after work etc I can still get the train or (I haven't looked in to car parking yet) possibly take the car.

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
I should proabbly add that should the worst happen i.e. it snows or I fancy a few beers after work etc I can still get the train or (I haven't looked in to car parking yet) possibly take the car.
You're laughing then. Just get some decent kit that will keep you warm and dry and away you go.

On the bike front you can commute on anything, build a list of stuff you like and get some quotes. My blade costs me less than 200 a year incl unlimited miles and commuting although admitedly I'm getting to that age where my life is, apparently, due to begin - which I'm looking forward to immensely. It also has to be said that I'm looking to get something that's a fk of sight more comfy for the commute too after 7 years wink

lawrence567

7,507 posts

221 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
I dont have a car license, i ride all year round (have done for the 4 years i've had bikes). I ride in wind, rain & i have ridden in ice/snow.
If you get some good textiles the rains absolutely nothing, the cold doesnt bother me as i just get some thick gloves & a neck warmer!
Plus it wakes you up!
Try said bikes above, VFR,CBR, try a thundercat or maybe even a BMW?

untruth

2,834 posts

220 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
I commute on an NC30 - dual carriageway then central London and love it :-). I reckon you are able to enjoy any bike as long as you accept it's pitfalls and don't wish you were on another comfier one :-)

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
As been said before....Get the right gear, and it's a piece of cake... an enjoyable way to commute. I rode the R6 and then the 750 through all sorts of crap and they never let me down once. I was lucky that I had a space to park should I have late night business meeting in some lap, strip, wine bar.

Andy OH

1,961 posts

281 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
Following some pretty silly insurance quotes I had resigned myself to not getting a bike this year however, following my disgust at the lack of refund on my travel season ticket, even though my journey has been halved, I'm considering cashing it in altogether and getting a bike to commute.

My main worries in doing this are: -

1: The comlpete lack of other options i.e. "here's my bike and this is how I'm now going to get to work for at least the next year, come rain or shine" (All comments along the lines of "suck it up you pussy, I've been doing it for years" are welcome and shall be used as reassurance / motivation).

2: Although I will now have some extra cash for the bike and insurance, I don't really want to be paying rediculous money for insurance and I'm worried that anything over a 600 will be rediculous. That's fine as a 600 would be more than enough bike generally but would it get a bit tiresome on dual carriageway journeys (A12, M25, M11). (Also on that point, I realise that I could probably get away with a bigger engine in a 'non-sports' bike but the thing is, like my instructor said "get a bike that you WANT to ride".....and I want a sports bike).

All advise will be gratefully received on both the positive and negative aspects of daily commuting as well as bike suggestions. As a guide, my preferance is sports bikes but I could possibly be swayed by, for examle a VFR with a single seat and the rear pegs taken off!?

Many thanks
I commute into the city of london daily and cover roughly 1,400 miles a month on a 2005 Yamaha R1. I fitted Yamaha heated grips to it for the winter which are brilliant and allows you to use thinner gloves as opposed to the thicker ones which I do not like as you loose the feel of the bars. The bike has now covered 50,000 miles with no problems at all.

The gear I wear is Dainese, leather trousers (I don't like the cordura (sp?) trousers) and a Dainese Goretex jacket, summer waterproof gloves from Racer (and Austrian company) and Daytona Evo Sports Goretex boots. I also carry thin waterproof over trousers and an Alpinestars RJ3 rain jacket (it's like an over jacket which is waterproof) should it be hosing down.

The bike you choose is down to you, many people will say you're mad to commute on a sports bike...but I can get through gaps most traillies and upright bikes cannot...obviously this is my choice but a sports bike for commuting works for me...

Good luck.

Andy.

GuyMarks

350 posts

264 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
2: Although I will now have some extra cash for the bike and insurance, I don't really want to be paying rediculous money for insurance and I'm worried that anything over a 600 will be rediculous. That's fine as a 600 would be more than enough bike generally but would it get a bit tiresome on dual carriageway journeys (A12, M25, M11).
It's not a 'real' sports bike, but the BMW F800s is a good sports tourer (I'm completely biased as I have one). One of the reasons I bought it was the BMW insurance, £250 fully comp for the year, (first bike, parked on the street etc). It's a very good deal. Also just got my renewal - think it's gone up by only tenner, so they haven't whacked up the premium.

A few other bits like the belt drive (no maintenance) and ABS make it a good year round bike whatever the weather.

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Not sure if you were thinking of buying new, but I think Suzuki are still doing excellent deals on insureance with a new GSXR. I paid £130 IIRC.

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Chilli said:
Not sure if you were thinking of buying new, but I think Suzuki are still doing excellent deals on insureance with a new GSXR. I paid £130 IIRC.
I wasn't going to go new for the first bike, I can't imagine how I'd feel having paid £7k for a new bike only to watch it cartwheel into a field or something! weeping

Seriously though, I think the Suzuki insurance deals rely on the rider being over 24yo, which I am but also 4 years NCB and a clean license, of which I'm sad to say, I have neither.

I'll save the spanking Gixxer 750 for my second bike!

Twit

2,908 posts

295 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
First... "suck it up you pussy, I've been doing it for years" hee hee!!!

More constructively... I would say to commute comfortably the gear is probably more important than the bike - you can be on your dream bike but if its pissing with rain, freezing, your soaked, its dark and you have 50 miles to go its miserable! But, it doesnt have to be like that, buy decent gear and you can be comfortable in all weathers. I wear BMW stuff in the winter with thermals and I'm fine, but my bike does have furness hot heated grips and a heated seat... Wuss, me!! wink In the summer its less of an issue, in fact the issue is getting too hot but you don't need to worry about that for a few months now! I do a round trip of about 200 miles a day and do that at least 4 times a weeks and its fine you just need to get the right head on.

Bikewise, you can commute on anything and whilst its good to have power on the m-ways etc, remember that in rush hour most of them are jammed so you need a bike you are comfortable at riding. I do it on a 1200 RT and love it -its huge, keeps the worst of the weather off, really comfy and I'm no slower than other riders. I used to do it on a Yam XT660 and that was great too, a bit asthmatic when the roads really opened but in the city it couldnt be beaten. Personally I'm not into sports bikes and the times I have commuted on a sports bike I hated it, but thats me.

Finally, I am assuming you havent yet passed your test or got a bike? If so, your instructor is right - you do need a bike you want to ride. But, if you have never ridden a bike you won't know what suits you best! I thought I would love sports bikes before I passed, after a few years now I hate them - uncomfy crotch rockets with zero character and you end looking like a knob dressed as a power ranger... The point is go and test ride as wider range of bikes as you can and then make a choice. If you get on with trail bikes for example, a nearly new XT can be had for about 3 grandish and it will cost next to nothing to insure, I think mine was about 80 quid, even my RT is only a hundred and something. Commuting is different to riding just for fun, if you accept that and accept that different bikes do different things then it can be done quite cheaply! The only problem is you end up getting different bikes for different types of riding... I have 5 now and I'm still looking to expand...!

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
yes

Yamaha XT660 Supermotard!

You want to avoid Knoblies in the wet, they don't grip and wear out quite quick

Cheap to buy
Quick enough to get you into trouble
Cheap to ensure
Quite good on fuel
Cheap to maintain
Reasonable crashproof
Fun to throw around
Good in trafic


roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
Twit said:
First... "suck it up you pussy, I've been doing it for years" hee hee!!!

More constructively... I would say to commute comfortably the gear is probably more important than the bike - you can be on your dream bike but if its pissing with rain, freezing, your soaked, its dark and you have 50 miles to go its miserable! But, it doesnt have to be like that, buy decent gear and you can be comfortable in all weathers. I wear BMW stuff in the winter with thermals and I'm fine, but my bike does have furness hot heated grips and a heated seat... Wuss, me!! wink In the summer its less of an issue, in fact the issue is getting too hot but you don't need to worry about that for a few months now! I do a round trip of about 200 miles a day and do that at least 4 times a weeks and its fine you just need to get the right head on.

Bikewise, you can commute on anything and whilst its good to have power on the m-ways etc, remember that in rush hour most of them are jammed so you need a bike you are comfortable at riding. I do it on a 1200 RT and love it -its huge, keeps the worst of the weather off, really comfy and I'm no slower than other riders. I used to do it on a Yam XT660 and that was great too, a bit asthmatic when the roads really opened but in the city it couldnt be beaten. Personally I'm not into sports bikes and the times I have commuted on a sports bike I hated it, but thats me.

Finally, I am assuming you havent yet passed your test or got a bike? If so, your instructor is right - you do need a bike you want to ride. But, if you have never ridden a bike you won't know what suits you best! I thought I would love sports bikes before I passed, after a few years now I hate them - uncomfy crotch rockets with zero character and you end looking like a knob dressed as a power ranger... The point is go and test ride as wider range of bikes as you can and then make a choice. If you get on with trail bikes for example, a nearly new XT can be had for about 3 grandish and it will cost next to nothing to insure, I think mine was about 80 quid, even my RT is only a hundred and something. Commuting is different to riding just for fun, if you accept that and accept that different bikes do different things then it can be done quite cheaply! The only problem is you end up getting different bikes for different types of riding... I have 5 now and I'm still looking to expand...!
That's some good advice, thanks, perhaps not as much of a Twit as your username would suggest!! wink

You're right, I haven't yet got or ever had a road bike. I passed my test 3/4 weeks ago now but I do ride motocross most weekends and your suggestion of a trail type bike above has got me thinking along those lines, at least I know I'd be comfortable / confident on it, although, I'm not so sure a big thumper would be very nice for a journey largely consisting of dual carriageways and m-ways.

Having had both sports bikes and the big beemer, would you say that the insurance on something like a R1100S would be anything less than or comparable to a 600 / 750 sports? I could quite see myself on a Boxer Cup replica.....not sure I'd be able to touch the ground though!?

RizzoTheRat

29,148 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
As you say insurance could be a killer with no experience and no no claims. The point about "get a bike you'll want to ride" is all well and good but when you've just passed your test you'll want to ride everywhere on whatever you can get your hands on.

There's a lot of options though, starting with boring but cheap to insure like a Diversion, Dauville, or faired bandit for a year to build up some no claims. There's also the slightly sportier options like the Fazer and CBF which will be cheaper to insure and comfier to ride than the sports bikes, and not noticably slower for a new rider. Then there's the taller options like the V-Strom, Transalp, TDM etc which give better visability than lower bikes, and gicve you the option of handguards to keep the weather off your gloves without looking silly. Or just go the sports bike route, either buying something a few years old which will be cheaper to insure, or brand new on one of these "1 year free insurance" deals.

Whatever bike you choose take note of the advice above about kit. Good quality waterproof kit makes the difference between a miserable ride in crappy weather, and a fun commute in a bit of rain.

sybaseian

1,826 posts

306 months

Wednesday 3rd September 2008
quotequote all
roboxm3 said:
Twit said:
First... "suck it up you pussy, I've been doing it for years" hee hee!!!

More constructively... I would say to commute comfortably the gear is probably more important than the bike - you can be on your dream bike but if its pissing with rain, freezing, your soaked, its dark and you have 50 miles to go its miserable! But, it doesnt have to be like that, buy decent gear and you can be comfortable in all weathers. I wear BMW stuff in the winter with thermals and I'm fine, but my bike does have furness hot heated grips and a heated seat... Wuss, me!! wink In the summer its less of an issue, in fact the issue is getting too hot but you don't need to worry about that for a few months now! I do a round trip of about 200 miles a day and do that at least 4 times a weeks and its fine you just need to get the right head on.

Bikewise, you can commute on anything and whilst its good to have power on the m-ways etc, remember that in rush hour most of them are jammed so you need a bike you are comfortable at riding. I do it on a 1200 RT and love it -its huge, keeps the worst of the weather off, really comfy and I'm no slower than other riders. I used to do it on a Yam XT660 and that was great too, a bit asthmatic when the roads really opened but in the city it couldnt be beaten. Personally I'm not into sports bikes and the times I have commuted on a sports bike I hated it, but thats me.

Finally, I am assuming you havent yet passed your test or got a bike? If so, your instructor is right - you do need a bike you want to ride. But, if you have never ridden a bike you won't know what suits you best! I thought I would love sports bikes before I passed, after a few years now I hate them - uncomfy crotch rockets with zero character and you end looking like a knob dressed as a power ranger... The point is go and test ride as wider range of bikes as you can and then make a choice. If you get on with trail bikes for example, a nearly new XT can be had for about 3 grandish and it will cost next to nothing to insure, I think mine was about 80 quid, even my RT is only a hundred and something. Commuting is different to riding just for fun, if you accept that and accept that different bikes do different things then it can be done quite cheaply! The only problem is you end up getting different bikes for different types of riding... I have 5 now and I'm still looking to expand...!
That's some good advice, thanks, perhaps not as much of a Twit as your username would suggest!! wink

You're right, I haven't yet got or ever had a road bike. I passed my test 3/4 weeks ago now but I do ride motocross most weekends and your suggestion of a trail type bike above has got me thinking along those lines, at least I know I'd be comfortable / confident on it, although, I'm not so sure a big thumper would be very nice for a journey largely consisting of dual carriageways and m-ways.

Having had both sports bikes and the big beemer, would you say that the insurance on something like a R1100S would be anything less than or comparable to a 600 / 750 sports? I could quite see myself on a Boxer Cup replica.....not sure I'd be able to touch the ground though!?
At this time of the year, you'd be better of buying something that you won't mind riding over winter, that'll need little maintenance and is comfortable. Save the nice sports bike for next spring.

As has been said, the BMW insurance scheme is cheap and there are loads of older BMW's for sale. If you're not short in the leg, an early GS1150 would be a good start as they are fun and can be chucked about a lot.

I commute daily, up and down the M11 and A12 which can be boring at times - however, there are great alternatives if the weather is nice......


toxgobbler

2,903 posts

222 months

Thursday 4th September 2008
quotequote all
Before you decide, an easy, cheap and reliable commuter is the Honda CBF600 (With half faring) it won't set the pulse racing, but it will just do what it says on the tin in all weather and won't try and kill you. Plus the fact it's narrow and will filter very nice;y into Central London

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Thursday 4th September 2008
quotequote all
toxgobbler said:
Before you decide, an easy, cheap and reliable commuter is the Honda CBF600 (With half faring) it won't set the pulse racing, but it will just do what it says on the tin in all weather and won't try and kill you. Plus the fact it's narrow and will filter very nice;y into Central London
I was loaned one of these a couple of months ago and would completely agree... they are very very easy to ride if a little on the dull side.

roboxm3

Original Poster:

2,486 posts

226 months

Thursday 4th September 2008
quotequote all
dern said:
toxgobbler said:
Before you decide, an easy, cheap and reliable commuter is the Honda CBF600 (With half faring) it won't set the pulse racing, but it will just do what it says on the tin in all weather and won't try and kill you. Plus the fact it's narrow and will filter very nice;y into Central London
I was loaned one of these a couple of months ago and would completely agree... they are very very easy to ride if a little on the dull side.
In that case nono I want something that's going to offer at least some element of fun and excitement. As I said in my OP, I want something that I'm going to want to ride, firstly as I'm going to have to ride it everyday and secondly becasue it will be my only road bike and would be using it at weekends for fun as well.