Trackdays and the suing culture
Discussion
reading in 1 of the bike mages about a minority of trackday riders who have tried to sue the orginizers if they fell off the bike during a trackday or if another rider took them off. seems amazing to me people would try this.
I have not yet done a bike track day but many with my kit car. and always understood that if I took my car on a track day and it was not insured for trackdays then if I crashed or had someone crash into me then I could do nothing.
seems fare enough. it's not fun if you get injured but was your choice to put yourself in that danger in the first palce
thoughts on this?
I have not yet done a bike track day but many with my kit car. and always understood that if I took my car on a track day and it was not insured for trackdays then if I crashed or had someone crash into me then I could do nothing.
seems fare enough. it's not fun if you get injured but was your choice to put yourself in that danger in the first palce
thoughts on this?
Totally agree. Doing track days is a risk and there will always be the odd plonker who thinks it's a race everytime they go out. If someone forces me off track or causes me to go down then I just tend to go and have a chat with them. Must admit though that since riding in the Advanced group I'm not had anyone cause me concern. People in this group tend to know what they're doing and can wait the extra couple of seconds to take you going out of the bend instead of trying to stuff you at the APEX!!
I agree that if you go on a track day then you must accept the risks that come with it but I do also think that the organisers need to do a little bit more too. Track days are very expensive and it’s only when things start to go wrong that you realise what your money is not spent on!
While the organisers are happy to give the lectures at the start of the day about it not being a race, rules for where and when to overtake and giving other track users space, they do seem to me to be quite reluctant to ‘have a word’ with those who push these limits. I have seen several occasions of people being pushed off line mid corner (me included) by inconsiderate buggers consistently ‘muscling’ through. It normally doesn’t take me long to work out who on the track should be avoided as they couldn’t care less and are very likely to either take you out or will push you into a position where the inevitable will happen. Yet, I have never seen any of these people ‘spoken to’ by the organisers with regards to their style and consideration for other track users.
Having had an ‘off’ at a track day, which resulted in a hospital visit, I was shocked as to how unhelpful the track day organisers were. While I knew full well that it was my responsibility to sort my bike, I did think that, as the track day organisers new the local area, the least they would have would be a sheet of contact numbers listing local bike dealers/ repairers, storage locations, recovery services etc. All I was told was – ‘your bike, your problem and no, you can’t leave it at the track overnight’.
While the organisers are happy to give the lectures at the start of the day about it not being a race, rules for where and when to overtake and giving other track users space, they do seem to me to be quite reluctant to ‘have a word’ with those who push these limits. I have seen several occasions of people being pushed off line mid corner (me included) by inconsiderate buggers consistently ‘muscling’ through. It normally doesn’t take me long to work out who on the track should be avoided as they couldn’t care less and are very likely to either take you out or will push you into a position where the inevitable will happen. Yet, I have never seen any of these people ‘spoken to’ by the organisers with regards to their style and consideration for other track users.
Having had an ‘off’ at a track day, which resulted in a hospital visit, I was shocked as to how unhelpful the track day organisers were. While I knew full well that it was my responsibility to sort my bike, I did think that, as the track day organisers new the local area, the least they would have would be a sheet of contact numbers listing local bike dealers/ repairers, storage locations, recovery services etc. All I was told was – ‘your bike, your problem and no, you can’t leave it at the track overnight’.
Having just read in another post that No Limits allow riders onto their track days even if they don't hold a bike license, then I can to a degree, understand the suing culture.
I think it is reasonable to expect the track day organisers to at least confirm that the other track users have a minimum level of bike control skill as defined by the UK motorcycle license. The thought of my pride and joy, or more importantly, me, being taken out (without insurance) is bad enough, but to then discover that it could be caused by someone who has not even had to pass a test to get there is, to me, terrifying!
I think it is reasonable to expect the track day organisers to at least confirm that the other track users have a minimum level of bike control skill as defined by the UK motorcycle license. The thought of my pride and joy, or more importantly, me, being taken out (without insurance) is bad enough, but to then discover that it could be caused by someone who has not even had to pass a test to get there is, to me, terrifying!
I also read this article in TWO, i couldnt really believe it thing is, its pushing track day insurance premiums up, giving less profit to the organisers, and the cost eventually comes back to you.
If anyone hears someone talking about suing over a trackday dont forget to slap them with a wet fish, thing is you cant even sue in America over trackdays because they fall into the catergorie of something to do with high risks, i.e trackdays, sports and extreme sports.
But our laws cant uphold this because of some reason or another, havnt got the magazine with me.
If anyone hears someone talking about suing over a trackday dont forget to slap them with a wet fish, thing is you cant even sue in America over trackdays because they fall into the catergorie of something to do with high risks, i.e trackdays, sports and extreme sports.
But our laws cant uphold this because of some reason or another, havnt got the magazine with me.
Before I type on, please let me be clear that I would not sue track day organisers. Instead, I don’t do track days any more. My problem is that, as far as my personal experience goes, track day organisers use the ‘well it’s your own risk’ excuse to avoid doing anything or taking any responsibility. This includes things that I would consider to be basic customer service like, for example, ensuring that all riders have at least passed a test (be that either through an ACU racing license or a through a full bike license.) They also appear to me to be very reluctant to ‘pull’ riders who are obviously riding beyond their ability or are pushing others through things like diving up the inside on corner entry.
I’ve also done a number of car track days and the culture of both the organisers and the participants appears to be very different where the one or two who do push a little too hard are taken to one side and quietly asked to desist.
Track days are expensive items and having handed over a large wad of drinking vouchers some customers expect a service. (Well, I do anyway!) In my experience, that service has often been lacking which is why I’m not quite as quick to criticise those who do end up suing. (Do remember, in order to win a law suit, the claimant will have to ‘prove’ that the track day organisers failed in their duty of care!)
I’ve also done a number of car track days and the culture of both the organisers and the participants appears to be very different where the one or two who do push a little too hard are taken to one side and quietly asked to desist.
Track days are expensive items and having handed over a large wad of drinking vouchers some customers expect a service. (Well, I do anyway!) In my experience, that service has often been lacking which is why I’m not quite as quick to criticise those who do end up suing. (Do remember, in order to win a law suit, the claimant will have to ‘prove’ that the track day organisers failed in their duty of care!)
black-k1 said:
Having just read in another post that No Limits allow riders onto their track days even if they don't hold a bike license, then I can to a degree, understand the suing culture.
As a fan of No Limits i'm going to comment on this:Yes you did read that No Limits ran a trackday without requiring a licence to be shown, that is not No Limits decision, it's the trackday owners, you'll find that all the MSV owned circuits require a licence to be valid and shown, both parts, the majority of non MSV circuits do not require a licence of any description to be shown, so you'll find that 99% of trackday organisers work the same way.
I lost a very dear friend to a trackday incident at Brands a few years ago, everyone should undrstand the risks they are taking, as it happened he was from what we can gather clipped, changing his trajectory and never regained conscousness before succumbing to his injuries.
No one thought about suing anybody, the poor guy that clipped him was a hollow individual at the hearing by the coroner and would hav to live with what was an accident.
Thats what happens at trackdays, accidents, and whether they are caused by poor decision making, over excuberance or plain bad luck, they are accidents.
Th trackday organisers provide a platform and service for thousands of people to enjoy their hobby and from my view i believe they have the balance about right (and yes, some are better than others) but lets not blame the trackday organisers for some of the idiots that book themselves on these days.
I've been on two trackdays with No Limits and they did check licence at both (that doesn't mean they always do at every track).
I agree that there shouldn't be the possibility of suing at a trackday - we've all signed up for it and know the setup - fair enough.
However - i would be seriously annoyed if someone was riding like a tosser and knocked me off causing me £££££ of damage / injury. That doesn't seem fair. I would guess you could sue that person for causing the damage/injury, but it would be really difficult to prove without witnesses and i would imagine the courts would take a dim view of you signing up for a trackday activity in the first place.
As another poster said you quickly see who is pushing other riders about and try to just let them through, but you can't see who is coming up behind you.
I did get a quote for trackday insurance - £250 for the day with a £250 excess! that seemed pretty high.
I agree that there shouldn't be the possibility of suing at a trackday - we've all signed up for it and know the setup - fair enough.
However - i would be seriously annoyed if someone was riding like a tosser and knocked me off causing me £££££ of damage / injury. That doesn't seem fair. I would guess you could sue that person for causing the damage/injury, but it would be really difficult to prove without witnesses and i would imagine the courts would take a dim view of you signing up for a trackday activity in the first place.
As another poster said you quickly see who is pushing other riders about and try to just let them through, but you can't see who is coming up behind you.
I did get a quote for trackday insurance - £250 for the day with a £250 excess! that seemed pretty high.
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


