The great Agostini confirms Rossi the best bike racer ever!
The great Agostini confirms Rossi the best bike racer ever!
Author
Discussion

Beemer-5

Original Poster:

7,897 posts

245 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Giacomo has said that VR now fully deserves his place, at the very top of bike racing's league of legends.
The best racer ever, is how he sees it and i have also said for a while now, that the likes of Stoner are just new kids on the block, in comparison.
Against the predictions of many, Rossi has all but sewn up yet another title this season.
The guy's a genius.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Well I don't know about anyone else buy I'm probably going to masturbate to that sentiment as soon as I get home.

Edited by Rawwr on Thursday 18th September 14:47

RemaL

25,103 posts

265 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
Well I don't know about anyone else buy I'm probably going to masturbate to that sentiment as soon as I get home.

Edited by Rawwr on Thursday 18th September 14:47
nope could not wait till I got home

Beemer-5

Original Poster:

7,897 posts

245 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
Well I don't know about anyone else buy I'm probably going to masturbate to that sentiment as soon as I get home.
Can't you get a gorgeous female to do that for you?

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Can't afford it.

aeropilot

40,908 posts

258 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Beemer-5 said:
Giacomo has said that VR now fully deserves his place, at the very top of bike racing's league of legends.
The best racer ever, is how he sees it and i have also said for a while now, that the likes of Stoner are just new kids on the block, in comparison.
Against the predictions of many, Rossi has all but sewn up yet another title this season.
The guy's a genius.
Definately of the modern GP era, along with Doohan.

I think Ago is being generous as both he and Halewood and Surtess etc did the TT and other great road races, so I'm not convinced of the best ever tag.

Agree with the genius on a bike bit though.


Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Why wouldn't Rossi be now considered the best?

Does he have to risk his neck on a strip of tarmac in the Irish sea to be considered better than dare I say it.. Hailwood.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Biker's Nemesis said:
Why wouldn't Rossi be now considered the best?

Does he have to risk his neck on a strip of tarmac in the Irish sea to be considered better than dare I say it.. Hailwood.
I would really love to see Rossi on the Island thoughcloud9

Busamav

2,954 posts

239 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Biker's Nemesis said:
Why wouldn't Rossi be now considered the best?

Does he have to risk his neck on a strip of tarmac in the Irish sea to be considered better than dare I say it.. Hailwood.
so true ,

I remember Pat Hennen slating Bazza for not going to the island , so he went along to show how good he was ,

edit , he suffered severe head injuries

Edited by Busamav on Thursday 18th September 19:31

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Proof, if any were needed, that racing is more than just going fast. Sure, Rossi is quick. But he also thinks about his race rather than just hammer-down red-mist blasting until he crashes. I reckon due to this he'd also be formidable in a car, and if he were to do a season of top-level car racing he'd be able to claim the 'best racer' tag (John Surtees won world championships on both two wheels and four)...

Not so sure about 'best *ever*' though, I do tend to think that the heroes of yesteryear had it a lot harder, with machinery that was a lot harder and unpredictable to ride / drive, much more dangerous circuits (though the TT is still pretty damn dangerous), less protective clothing, and without the physical, psychological and dietary training that modern teams give their racers.

Racing was orders of magnitude more dangerous back then... you hear of contemporary bike racers saying that they don't ride on the road because it's too dangerous - well those guys wouldn't have raced back in Hailwood and Surtees' days...

That aside, Rossi is assured his place in the pantheon, but he's hardly old and it'll be interesting to see what he continues to do - he's got a lot of racing career of all sorts available to him left!!!

xspencex

1,534 posts

267 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
Well I don't know about anyone else buy I'm probably going to masturbate to that sentiment as soon as I get home.

Edited by Rawwr on Thursday 18th September 14:47
pmsl rofl

smiller

12,599 posts

235 months

Thursday 18th September 2008
quotequote all
For me, Vale has the key angles covered: he's f!!cking fast, and has the ability to make his competitors fear his ability. Thus undermining their confidence.

He's done it three times now.

He broke Biaggi at Welkom, and broke Gibernau at Jerez. He obviously broke Stoner at Laguna. It's almost as if he gets into a situation and thinks, "OK. You think you can ride? Let me show you how a 7-time world champion can ride!"

I had to laugh at Stoner's whining after the Laguna race. It's a good thing he wasn't racing in the Schwantz / Rainey / Doohan / Gardner / Mamola years! He'd have really spat his dummy out.

So. For me. Yes. Rossi is the best ever.

One example? OK.

That race in Philip Island where got penalised for overtaking on a waved yellow, and still won the race after time penalties!



Fire99

9,868 posts

260 months

Friday 19th September 2008
quotequote all
To say Rossi is the best ever is difficult since Motorcycle racing has changed so much over the years and current bikes share little more than the principal of being on two wheels compared to say 30 years ago.

However there is no denying that of the current racers that you can directly compare him with he is the greatest natural talent.
He is the complete package and astonishing to watch..

And i have to add its always great to see him before and after races as he always seems so enthusiastic and happy to be in the sport.
Stoner always seems to be whining about something where Rossi seems to just get on with it..

Anyway...Hat off to Rossi!

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

247 months

Friday 19th September 2008
quotequote all
I don't see the difficulty in comparing different era's. Sheene, Gardiner, Rainey, and a few others have raced classic machinery in classic races, and won. I'm not seeing how racing the old stuff was any harder, if at all, than racing todays bikes. In fact I'd say todays race bikes require a level of physical and mental fitness to race them that the racers of the past in comparison need not have aspired to.

Rossi is the GOAT. Such is beyond argument really.

srob

12,565 posts

269 months

Friday 19th September 2008
quotequote all
Rocket Pepper said:
I don't see the difficulty in comparing different era's. Sheene, Gardiner, Rainey, and a few others have raced classic machinery in classic races, and won. I'm not seeing how racing the old stuff was any harder, if at all, than racing todays bikes. In fact I'd say todays race bikes require a level of physical and mental fitness to race them that the racers of the past in comparison need not have aspired to.

Rossi is the GOAT. Such is beyond argument really.
Have you ever actually ridden an old bike? To say that you don't have to concentrate when riding something like a Honda 6 or a Guzzi V8 (not to mention the mad two stroke era) is complete rubbish. I think that if you look at the safety issues alone, that would be enough to sharpen most minds.

The riders you've mentioned above are all ex-professional GP racers, who ride against the likes of Tim Jackson (who works for the gas board...) at Goodwood once a year.

You simply can't compare era's. I think that Rossi is the best rider of his era. How would he compare to Hailwood, Ivy, Read, Sheene, Agostini, Woods etc... we'll never know. Appreciate him for what he is (a genius), but to say that he's better than those who preceded him is wrong and disrespectful in my opinion.

FeatherZ

2,422 posts

227 months

Friday 19th September 2008
quotequote all
Rossi is great a natural born talent, knows what hes capable of and has race craft like no one else, theres lots of fast racers around now and in the past, that were quick but crashed alot and didn't have a game plan as such, rossi seems to have it all, even when hes a second down in qualifying you know he will find that second in the race, alot of that is down to Mr jeremy burgess though, i think without him rossi maybe wouldnt be in the position he is today!

Dont ever forget about the other modern day greats like Doohan and Spencer, huge talents, i also think that Ron Haslam could of been a world champion, he was never given the honda v4 when spencer did, and the year he was on a v3 and spencer was on a v4 he was lapping quciker than spencer did on the same v3 the year that spencer won the WC the year before, its all about getting the right bike at the right time.

Rossi is a pure genious though and even when he left honda and went to yamaha people were saying thats it for him now, hes made the right moves at the right time and loves a challenge wouldnt surprise me to see him move from yamaha to say suzuki or kawazaki one day and try win one with them and if JB goes with him you wouldnt bet agaisnt it.

sprinter885

11,550 posts

258 months

Friday 19th September 2008
quotequote all
Indeed-I have to agree, although I've thought it all along. Rossi's ability to adapt to all 3 different classes AND the 3 different engine types in the "big" class, changing manufacturer and tyre supplier and still win championships says it all.

However one other thing has come to mind which I had forgotten until this weekend and that is how he has developed to improve his wet weather racing abilities. If you recall in his early days he was often quoted as not being a comfortable wet racer yet in recent years it has had no impact whatsoever on his racing-especially this year when so many races have been wet.
Yep "THE GOAT" definitely.

Rocket Pepper

1,281 posts

247 months

Friday 19th September 2008
quotequote all
srob said:
Have you ever actually ridden an old bike? To say that you don't have to concentrate when riding something like a Honda 6 or a Guzzi V8 (not to mention the mad two stroke era) is complete rubbish. I think that if you look at the safety issues alone, that would be enough to sharpen most minds.

The riders you've mentioned above are all ex-professional GP racers, who ride against the likes of Tim Jackson (who works for the gas board...) at Goodwood once a year.

You simply can't compare era's. I think that Rossi is the best rider of his era. How would he compare to Hailwood, Ivy, Read, Sheene, Agostini, Woods etc... we'll never know. Appreciate him for what he is (a genius), but to say that he's better than those who preceded him is wrong and disrespectful in my opinion.
Yes mate, at 47 years young I cut my teeth on a Bantam D7 aged 13. I grew up watching my mates ride into the sunshine whilst I built from scratch many a Brit Iron.

I think you missed my point. No Ago era, no Sheene era, no other era bike puts down 220bhp and had the technical attributes todays racers cope with. The physical strength alone required to hang on. Yes I've thrashed and MV1000F4 too, amongst others. Corner speeds I beyond the imagination of 30 and 40 years ago racing. And that old duffer of a plumber you mention is no slouch. But then Sheene and Gardiner have fought side by side on classic iron, and both won in different races. As for the Honda Six, I don't doubt it was a beast to ride with its on / off switch like action throttle, but it didn't poke out the speeds and accelerations exhibited by todays machines. In other words, Rossi, just like the racing machines of today, is too at the oinacle of development. That is man and machine. Both superior athletes over past era's. There is no going backwards.