Discussion
Hi folks, if I raise the revs of my bike to a fast idle (1500-2000rpm) when it's warm or hot, it makes an intermittent single knock, accompanied by a drop in the revs of perhaps 3-400rpm for perhaps 1/2 a second. As it doesn't do it below or above this rev range and it's got no worse in the few hundred miles since I noticed it, I think I can safely assume it's not a mechanical snag. I chacked the ignition timing today, just in case it occasionally made an erroneous spark hugely advanced, but the timing seems to be fine. It's one of those noises that could be nothing or could be cause for concern, so I want to get to the bottom of it, hopefully just to put my mind at rest. Could it just be spitting back through the carbs?
Edited by Matthew-TMM on Thursday 25th September 17:01
It's a GS500. It's not a regular noise, on investigation, it might happen twice in 10 seconds, or it might be a minute or more between. As it only happens at those revs, I doubt it's mechanical wear or any sort of snagging anywhere (say from a lump of debris in the sump getting into things).
I don't know what spitting back through carbs sounds like on an engine with an airbox, so perhaps someone could give me a description?
I don't know what spitting back through carbs sounds like on an engine with an airbox, so perhaps someone could give me a description?
Edited by Matthew-TMM on Thursday 25th September 21:00
Matthew-TMM said:
I chacked the ignition timing today, just in case it occasionally made an erroneous spark hugely advanced
Can you elaborate on this 'erroneous spart' you mention? I'm not sure if you're saying it IS making odd sparks, or isn't?If it's firing when it shouldn't, the knocking will be caused by detonation during the wrong part of the cycle. This can quickly destroy engines if left unchecked.
Edited by Hyperion on Friday 26th September 09:17
I would expect that it is ‘pinking’ that is the problem, the question is why? It could be caused by this ‘erroneous spark’ you mention but that should not be happening so would need further investigation. It also could be that the mixture on your bike is very lean (to make it as economical as possible) and that at that throttle opening/engine speed it’s just a little too lean and causing a bit of pre-detonation. (Will be worse when it’s hot) This is not a big problem providing the plugs show that the mixture is OK on general use, under load and with more throttle. It would be worth checking for inlet leaks just in case and if you have a ‘freer flowing end can’ (read louder) or high flow air filter fitted then these could also be part of the problem.
The bit about ignition timing was just postulating. I checked it and it seems to be in order, so it's not that. FYI this is happening under no load. It is backfiring through the carbs though. Both spark plugs weren't done up very tight at all and both insulator noses were white/brown which seems OK, except that both have some speckled deposits, which is not OK. Air filter and exhaust are both standard. Time to look for air leaks I think.
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


