Buying advice needed - BMW, Triumph or Honda?
Buying advice needed - BMW, Triumph or Honda?
Author
Discussion

NobleLord

Original Poster:

1,065 posts

279 months

Saturday 27th September 2008
quotequote all
I've decided it's time to get a bike for a 200 mile round trip commute once a week and a bit of fun at the weekend. I thought I was pretty much sold on the BMW R1200GS, but having done some research, the Triumph Tiger and the Honda XL1000V ABS seem like reasonable alternatives. I have limited time to test ride so have only managed to get on the BMW so far.

Does anyone here have experience of two or all three of these bikes? Just interested to hear positives and negatives of each and owner experiences. Also, have I missed any obvious alternatives that should be on the shortlist?

Cheers,
NL

Rob_F

4,155 posts

295 months

Saturday 27th September 2008
quotequote all
You know they're all in this months Bike magazine's second hand bike test right?

Cheers,
Rob.

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Saturday 27th September 2008
quotequote all
Have a go on a trophy and a sprint... you might like those. I picked up my trophy today and love it. It's no scratching machine but handles much better than you would imagine.

NobleLord

Original Poster:

1,065 posts

279 months

Saturday 27th September 2008
quotequote all
Rob_F said:
You know they're all in this months Bike magazine's second hand bike test right?

Cheers,
Rob.
I didn't thanks Rob smile

NL

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

237 months

Saturday 27th September 2008
quotequote all
THE XL700, PEACH OF A BIKE.

barry sheene

1,524 posts

314 months

Saturday 27th September 2008
quotequote all
I have a Tiger, it's my 4th. Best all round bike and waaaaay cheaper than the BMW. Also you don't get that 'Ewan and Charlie wannabe' thing like you d with the beemer biggrin

If you want some more info on it, pop over to The Tiger List (PS I'm the moderator)

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Saturday 27th September 2008
quotequote all
Not tried them all but I have tried each of their ‘sister’ bikes (Firestorm, Sprint, R1200ST etc.) and they are all very different. You need to try them and find out what works for you and what doesn’t.

Edited by black-k1 on Saturday 27th September 23:27

Twit

2,908 posts

295 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
BMW no question, much (much) better built than the Triumph and more fun than the Honda. Its the most expensive but it will hold its cash better and BM dealers / warrenties are the best around. When I looked at the Tiger it just looked and felt so fragile, I'd be worried about using it in the winter in case it feel apart! Having said you havent mentioned the best Honda which is the Africa Twin, if you can find a good one they are bomb proof, ride well, look great and are cheaper than both the BM and the Triumph.

steveo29

1,885 posts

220 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
speed triple or a honda fireblade tongue out

Rob_F

4,155 posts

295 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
NobleLord said:
Rob_F said:
You know they're all in this months Bike magazine's second hand bike test right?

Cheers,
Rob.
I didn't thanks Rob smile

NL
NobleLord said:
Rob_F said:
You know they're all in this months Bike magazine's second hand bike test right?

Cheers,
Rob.
I didn't thanks Rob smile

NL
Sorry, it's actually the slightely older models (R1100GS, XL1000v + Tiger 955i) in a "£4000 Tall Rounders" article in this months Bike. It may still prove interesting i suppose.. The outcome was quite predictable really!

As a complete newbie i'd have the Triumph - better style, image and engine note!

Rob

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Sunday 28th September 2008
quotequote all
steveo29 said:
speed triple or a honda fireblade tongue out
eh? He's not looking for that kind of bike. He's after a big trailie.