Which flip lid?
Author
Discussion

RizzoTheRat

Original Poster:

29,164 posts

223 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
Thinking of replacing my lid this winter as it's getting on a bit. I quite fancy a flip front, want something fairly quiet, and must be able to wear glasses and fit my Autocom in it. Any recomendations beyond my initial thoughts of:

Shoei Multitec - Been very happy with my Raid, tried a Multitec the other day and it was instantly comfortable. Some deals on the web including a free dark visor for about £260

Schuberth C2/C3 - A mate keeps raving about how great his C2 is. I really like the idea of the internal visor and they're supposed to be very quiet. C3 is better looking and pushing £400 but C2 is not much more than Multitec and might start to see better deals now the C3 is out. Sure I remember some comments about them not being great with glasses though.

Other suggestions?

kiwi_uk

279 posts

241 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
I wouldn't touch them with a barge poll. Article has photos which you shouldn't view if squemish!!

http://motorbiker.org/blogs.nsf/dx/the-danger-of-f...

http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?s=eb...



Edited by kiwi_uk on Friday 3rd October 15:11

lawrence567

7,507 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
bought a flip lid, wore it once & sold it, didnt like it at all!

GuyMarks

350 posts

264 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
RizzoTheRat said:
Shoei Multitec - Been very happy with my Raid, tried a Multitec the other day and it was instantly comfortable. Some deals on the web including a free dark visor for about £260.
I'd recommend the Multitec - really comfortable lid and much much quieter than my Shoei XR1000 (which I never use as a result - anyone want it on the cheap?!). Multitec was about £250, I got it from Infinity and it came with free tinted visor, pin lock, whisper strip and chin guard. I reckon all this free kit makes it a bit of bargain.

Edited by GuyMarks on Friday 3rd October 15:31

kiwi_uk

279 posts

241 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
or this from AD Rider, warning, photos of bashed up face

http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?s=eb...

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
I’ve had the Shoei Synchrotec 2 before I got my current C2. I was/am happy with both helmets and I’m sure the Multitec/C3 are good helmets too. My Synchrotec was quite quiet (for a flip front – they are generally noisier than full face helmets) but was very light (again for a flip front). It took a little while to bed in and never lost any of it’s shape so didn’t start to feel lose like me previous Laser. The C2 was a little heavier than the Synchrotec but was noticeably quieter. The C2 flip front claims to be a one handed operation (which it was in the Synchrotec) but I find I need to brace the rear of the helmet to close it. It does have two nice little indicators to show the both sides of the front have locked down which are great. The C2 took a long time to bed in but now is very snug and extremely comfortable.

The flip down sun visor is VERY useful! Mine can be up and down like a prostitutes drawers on a single trip as I move in and out of the sun. It takes a little getting used to on the C2 though as it only comes down about half way but that works as it keeps the low Autumn/Spring sun out of your eyes without making it difficult to see the instruments as they are viewed below the level of the sun visor.

I ruled out the Multitec as a replacement for the Synchrotec as it didn’t have a quick release buckle which the C2 does.

I don’t use an intercom or glasses so can say definitively but both helmets had glasses cut outs in the lining and had ample space around the ears for speakers.

For me, the C2 was worth the extra money over the Synchrotec, but only just and, had I been able to get a replacement Synchrotec, or had the Multitec been fitted with a quick release buckle, I would never have bought the C2 and would still have been very happy.

As for other suggestions, BMWs have always been about the best flip fronts but they are very pricey. (They’re also made by Schuberth). I bought a Lazer and it was crap! Cheap, yes, but still crap. There is also the Nolan but I don’t have a Nolan shaped head. Roof do one but I think that’s an open face helmet with a front on rather than a full face helmet that opens. I think Arai do one also but again, I have a Shoei head rather than an Arai. My wife has a Caberg (sp?) and that is fine but not as light, quiet or ‘quality feeling’ as the Shoei or Schuberth. I’m sure there are more but, at the moment, I can’t think of them.

RizzoTheRat

Original Poster:

29,164 posts

223 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
Kiwi, your first link doesn't seem to work for me. I must admit I don't fancy a flip up from a cheaper make, but I'd have expected that bloke Schuberth to have held out.

My current Raid has a quick release buckle and I must admit the buckle and the internal visor are both good points in favour of the schuberth over the Shoei

Busamav

2,954 posts

239 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
kiwi_uk said:
or this from AD Rider, warning, photos of bashed up face

http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?s=eb...
I wouldnt touch one after seeing the state of a guys face when i came across a low speed bikers accident . The front just flipped up and allowed his face to take the impact .

No Siree............

kiwi_uk

279 posts

241 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
GuyMarks said:
RizzoTheRat said:
Shoei Multitec - Been very happy with my Raid, tried a Multitec the other day and it was instantly comfortable. Some deals on the web including a free dark visor for about £260.
I'd recommend the Multitec - really comfortable lid and much much quieter than my Shoei XR1000 (which I never use as a result - anyone want it on the cheap?!). Multitec was about £250, I got it from Infinity and it came with free tinted visor, pin lock, whisper strip and chin guard. I reckon all this free kit makes it a bit of bargain.

Edited by GuyMarks on Friday 3rd October 15:31
Sorry you can't read it mate. I've posted the text here minus the photos;

Flip-up helmets are very popular amongst motorcycle riders. They offer the ease that a jet helmet offers, and the protection of an integral motorcycle helmet. Or do they?

If you think about it, a flip-up helmet is a jet helmet with a chin protector that is bolted to your helmet, not a single molded piece like with an integral helmet. There are two bolts inserted in the main helmet unit, and on these two bolts is located the chin protector.

If you fall off your motorcycle, on your chin, while riding at low speed, or even parked (yes, it does happen), the chin protector should be able to withstand the impact.

But what happens when you fly off your motorcycle at a reasonable speed, and hit an unmovable object (in this case the tarmac) with your chin first.

Here's the case of UK based Dazco, who had properly locked his flip-up helmet, and thought he was safe. Below are two photos of the final result of what happened when the bolts snapped off the helmet at the first impact.

WARNING: The photos below the "Continue Reading the Article" are NOT FOR THE SQUEAMISH !!

DO NOT LOOK IF YOU CAN NOT STAND THE SIGHT OF BLOOD !!!


From the photo, it would seem that the chin piece pushed into Dazco's face. So on impact, the bolts snapped, and the chin and visor slammed into his face.

The result is not nice, and will have hurt like hell:



Dazco wrote:
howdo everyone, and thanks for the concern.
Everyone did an excellent job on Saturday.(my hat off to you all). i was more pissed off that i spoild a good days ride for everyone else.
The Ambulance ride was rougher than the pillion ride on the R80Gs with Mick(top man)
Sunday had a plastic surgeon put 40 stiches in the lip,a 3 and a half inch cut ,then Spent most of yesterday in the Dental hospital in Sheffield being prodded and poked(ooo errrrrr missus) and having that broken tooth yanked out by a cak handed student dentist. OUCH
The missus has been good about it all so far. shes probably just waiting till i feel better before she sticks the boot in.
One thing i have learned though is that ill not be using a flip front helmet in the future.The rest of the body took a battering but stood up pretty well(that extra padding i have worked wonders).
Any way hope to be back out on the road by the end of the week on 1100, if i get that drive bearing done.
See ya all soon
and Thanks
Dazco




In many countries, flip-up helmets are rated as jet helmets. In many cases you're better off with a jet, since you know that there's no chin protection.

This article was not written to dissuade you from using or buying flip-up helmets, but to make sure you understand that you do not have 100% protection as you would have with an integral helmet. I mostly have flip-up helmets, and plan to continue to use them. But... I'm going to make extra sure that it's properly latched, and just be that extra careful out there.

Dazco, hope you get better soon, and back on your motorcycle.

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
kiwi_uk said:
or this from AD Rider, warning, photos of bashed up face

http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?s=eb...
kiwi_uk said:
I wouldn't touch them with a barge poll. Article has photos which you shouldn't view if squemish!!

http://motorbiker.org/blogs.nsf/dx/the-danger-of-f...

http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?s=eb...
It is easy to pick specific incidents and show the results but they are not scientific tests and have no reference. (What would have happened to a full face in exactly the same circumstances?) I’ve broken the shell on two full face helmets in my time so they are not beyond being shown in a similar light.

I would be surprised if a flip front offered exactly the same protection as an equivalent full face but the other side of that is the number of bikers who are now paralysed as a result of their full face being taken off incorrectly after an accident where a flip front could simply be ‘flipped’.

When SHARP test them we can see how many stars they get, but I would suggest the protection they offer can’t be too bad as just about every police force in Europe uses them for their bike cops and I’m sure, in the days of health & safety and liability litigation, there would be concern if the protection levels were not viewed as at least reasonable.

G Man

4,053 posts

291 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
Add in the BMW System V helmet, made by Schuberth, it is being replaced in spring with a System VI

RizzoTheRat

Original Poster:

29,164 posts

223 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
I would suggest the protection they offer can’t be too bad as just about every police force in Europe uses them for their bike cops and I’m sure, in the days of health & safety and liability litigation, there would be concern if the protection levels were not viewed as at least reasonable.
That's my thinking too. Pity sharp haven't tested any flips yet.

Just had a rummage through Ride magazine's tests and it seems they've never tested them either.

Edited by RizzoTheRat on Friday 3rd October 16:09

YZF600R

4,121 posts

239 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
I've tried countless and I can't find one that is really comfortable.

A Shoei XR1000 in 'M' is a perfect fit for my head. Any flip helmets in 'M' seem massive (including the Multitech) but 'S' seem very cramped and would cause a headache.


RizzoTheRat

Original Poster:

29,164 posts

223 months

Friday 3rd October 2008
quotequote all
That's bizzare that two from the same manufacturer should be that different. My Shoei Raid is a good fit and when I tried on the multitec it felt like I was wearing my own helmet.

steveo29

1,885 posts

220 months

Saturday 4th October 2008
quotequote all
ooh err :/

thinking of the removale of the helmet can cause bad damage.

anyone know of a helmet friendly place that i can get a "DO NOT REMOVE" sticker for it???

(my lid is a bit tight to take off but once on like a glove.)

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Saturday 4th October 2008
quotequote all
steveo29 said:
ooh err :/

thinking of the removale of the helmet can cause bad damage.

anyone know of a helmet friendly place that i can get a "DO NOT REMOVE" sticker for it???

(my lid is a bit tight to take off but once on like a glove.)
The issue then is, how does the first on the scene give you mouth to mouth if you are not breathing? Lack of breathing kills quicker than just about anything else!