Bike design, where's it going?
Bike design, where's it going?
Author
Discussion

rhinochopig

Original Poster:

17,932 posts

229 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
People are getting taller and fatter - fact. Bikes are getting smaller and lighter - fact.

The two are not compatible, so what is going to happen?

It's in the manufacturers interest to build the smallest lightest supersports so they can win races, but if people can't fit on them, they won't sell them.

Discuss.

R5GTTGaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
Fatties should not be catered for.

(see what I did there?)

rhinochopig

Original Poster:

17,932 posts

229 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
R5GTTGaz said:
Fatties should not be catered for.

(see what I did there?)
Yeah, but when they eventually start designing bikes for Pedrosa we're all fked.

R5GTTGaz

7,897 posts

251 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
I think you have to look at the world wide audience - I think on a whole the UK and the US are a lot fatter than most other countries.

rhinochopig

Original Poster:

17,932 posts

229 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
R5GTTGaz said:
I think you have to look at the world wide audience - I think on a whole the UK and the US are a lot fatter than most other countries.
It's not the weight, more the height. I'm 6'5" and used to fit on most sports bikes, now I can't. Given my height will be far from exceptional in 10 years time, manufacturers are going to have to reconsider their current trend for miniaturisation.

Stu R

21,702 posts

246 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
R5GTTGaz said:
I think you have to look at the world wide audience - I think on a whole the UK and the US are a lot fatter than most other countries.
and also two of the biggest markets (no pun intended) for premium bikes.

Bikes tend to come and go in phases, one minute it's all the rage to have the latest, lightest, smallest fastest sports bike, the next BMW / KTM with their adventurey enduro bikes are reporting an ever increasing share of the market.

Worst comes to worst we'll all be 40 stone and riding harleys, before which time I'll hopefully be nothing more than a dent in the speed barrier hehe


Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
hell in a handcart, bikes have been getting uglier since the 70s & will continue to do so.

untruth

2,834 posts

220 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
rhinochopig said:
R5GTTGaz said:
I think you have to look at the world wide audience - I think on a whole the UK and the US are a lot fatter than most other countries.
I'm 6'5" and used to fit on most sports bikes, now I can't.
As a 6'2er who rides an NC30 daily, I put it forward that you are not trying hard enough!

untruth

2,834 posts

220 months

Saturday 11th October 2008
quotequote all
PS. I just want the designs to go back to the early 90s dual round headlights and simple 3-block-colour fairing and I'll be happy!

RizzoTheRat

29,169 posts

223 months

Sunday 12th October 2008
quotequote all
I believe the best selling bike in the UK for the last few years has been the 1200GS, might be lighter than it's predecessor but it certainly isn't smaller biggrin

PapaBear

14,233 posts

225 months

Sunday 12th October 2008
quotequote all
untruth said:
PS. I just want the designs to go back to the early 90s dual round headlights and simple 3-block-colour fairing and I'll be happy!
Sounds like my ZXR750 H1 biggrin

amare32

2,421 posts

254 months

Sunday 12th October 2008
quotequote all
If you're getting fatter then I would recommend a gym wink

Seriously, I'm no Pedbot size at 5ft 7in and 65kg, one of the reasons I went for a K7 GSXR600 is because it was a reasonable weight and I could reach the floor ok at a standstill. I'm all for more lightness and compact design but make it with more adjustability so it can be more comfier for a tall and short riders. More power aswell thanks smile

rhinochopig

Original Poster:

17,932 posts

229 months

Sunday 12th October 2008
quotequote all
untruth said:
rhinochopig said:
R5GTTGaz said:
I think you have to look at the world wide audience - I think on a whole the UK and the US are a lot fatter than most other countries.
I'm 6'5" and used to fit on most sports bikes, now I can't.
As a 6'2er who rides an NC30 daily, I put it forward that you are not trying hard enough!
Funny you should mention that bike, I fit on one of those fine. I've had many a happy hour on an NC30. People did used to describe the sight looking like a frog sat on a matchbox, but nevertheless, I did fit. Bizarrely, the most comfortable bike I've ever sat on - didn't get a chance to ride one - was a Mito. Now if only they'd stick a 450cc engine in one I'd buy it.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Sunday 12th October 2008
quotequote all
You could say the same thing about those infernal pedal cycles (no engine! whatever next) too though. People *on average* are getting bigger / taller / fatter - but the sort of people who choose to do triathlons etc. and spend more on a pushbike than your average 160 mph sportsbike are likely to be slim and fit, not the 'average' couch potato.

Equally, you tend to choose the style of bike that fits you best - are there really that many big guys complaining that there aren't 'super-size' R6s etc. ?? The big lads I know who like biking either have big GS beemers, or custom/chopper/cruiser style bikes (e.g. Harleys). Mates my size all tend to either choose sportsbikes or supermotos. The other extreme seems to be with the really small blokes, I've never seen a large Goldwing rider for example... they all seem to be 5'6" and skinny with it.

Most of the sportsbikes come from Japan, and it's well known that Japanese people are in general shorter and slimmer than those in most of the West. You'd expect global companies like Honda to produce bikes for their target markets but I'm sure that the Japs aren't complaining that the latest CBR600 is smaller and easier to push around. I'd guess that most of the reduction in weight and size is coming through improvements in materials science. Like mobile phones, once the technology has outstripped the ergonomics, and the bikes are simply too small to ride comfortably, then sales will drop off and manufacturers will make the bikes bigger (but not necessarily heavier) again.

Personally I'm all for low weight. I tried a VFR400 import once and found it far too small for comfort, and I'm only 5'11" - however all the UK market 600s I've sat on are just fine.

Hell, you can already buy 'undersized' bikes for fun - things like minimotos, those Gilera DNA scooters with 'bike' styling, the Sachs MadAss, etc. I probably wouldn't want a modern litre engine in something that small though nuts

Bike design will follow both the demands of buyers and the results of racing - if the racing is popular, and people want to buy bikes like the racers (and they fit the bikes) then they'll sell - equally if there's a new trend (e.g. how supermotos kicked off a new genre), maybe Harley type bikes with offroad tyres and 2 wheel drive hehe then manufacturers will hop on board the latest bandwagon. I do think that Charley Boorman and Ewan McGregor's adventures (and Charley on his own) have raised awareness in the general population about fun on bikes - certainly my girlfriend and her mate both did their CBTs off the back of watching the series - and perhaps that has some bearing on the sales of BMW big trailies (BMW got superb marketing out of that, however much of a prima donna McGregor is to deal with).

Also watch the scooter market. When I was riding scooters the biggest capacity engine was a 200cc Vespa but the fastest was the 180 two stroke Gilera Runner (of which I had several, and souped them up). They were the extremes - the same size twist-n-go, but with silly engines that pulled wheelies off the throttle and did stoppies, etc. But customer demand for longer distance commuting on scooters in comfort (the Runner could do the miles, at nearly 100 mph, but it was a frantic affair) has resulted in the maxi-scooter genre of bike, which are as heavy as regular motorcycles and with larger capacity engines (400, 500cc IIRC). So I'd expect some crossover to occur at some point - i.e. twist-n-go trail bikes / sports bikes (the latter may be limited to kids, as per the Gilera DNA bikes, but if a kid has ridden automatic transmission bikes all his/her life, then a faster, bigger engined auto will sell... in the future - established bikers still want gearboxes and clutches).

After all, the hypersports litre race rep bikes are the ones that grab the headlines and fill the showroom displays... but they're not what the world in general tends to ride. IIRC the UK market is weird compared to the rest of the world in that most of us ride sports bikes of 600 cc and above. Worldwide, it's a small portion of the overall bike market. I'm not surprised to hear that the GS is the biggest selling bike, but I bet more scooters are sold.

I'm waiting for the gearbox tech to enable full crossover of scooter ease-of-use with 'proper' bike performance. The maxi-scooters have shown that such machines will sell. I don't think that a Fireblade with twist-n-go transmission will be well received, but supermotos and trail bikes with auto transmissions would be fun...

Basically I reckon it's about the technology, and even though the rival manufacturers are scrapping over the last bhp and gram of performance with their sportsbikes, the real gains in sales will be when a 'new' type of bike taps a previously-nonexistent market. No road rider can get near a modern sportsbike's limits on the road whilst adhering to the law, and there's a big hole between the 'commuting machine' utilitarian bike / scooter, and the 'bought for fun' sportsbike. Weird things like BMW's C1 'scooter with a roof' show that the manufacturers are willing to take risks to tap new markets, and with petrol prices, car prices and parking spaces putting car driving under increasing pressure, getting non-enthusiasts onto two wheels and turning them into enthusiasts is a great move for bike makers. After all, only the properly wealthy can afford a selection of performance cars, whereas most average income people can afford a couple of bikes. And once you're on that road, because the cost is so much lower, you can buy a new bike much more frequently. Which is what the manufacturers want, surely?

rhinochopig

Original Poster:

17,932 posts

229 months

Monday 13th October 2008
quotequote all
cyberface said:
You could say the same thing about those infernal pedal cycles (no engine! whatever next) too though. People *on average* are getting bigger / taller / fatter - but the sort of people who choose to do triathlons etc. and spend more on a pushbike than your average 160 mph sportsbike are likely to be slim and fit, not the 'average' couch potato.

Equally, you tend to choose the style of bike that fits you best - are there really that many big guys complaining that there aren't 'super-size' R6s etc. ?? The big lads I know who like biking either have big GS beemers, or custom/chopper/cruiser style bikes (e.g. Harleys). Mates my size all tend to either choose sportsbikes or supermotos. The other extreme seems to be with the really small blokes, I've never seen a large Goldwing rider for example... they all seem to be 5'6" and skinny with it.

Most of the sportsbikes come from Japan, and it's well known that Japanese people are in general shorter and slimmer than those in most of the West. You'd expect global companies like Honda to produce bikes for their target markets but I'm sure that the Japs aren't complaining that the latest CBR600 is smaller and easier to push around. I'd guess that most of the reduction in weight and size is coming through improvements in materials science. Like mobile phones, once the technology has outstripped the ergonomics, and the bikes are simply too small to ride comfortably, then sales will drop off and manufacturers will make the bikes bigger (but not necessarily heavier) again.

Personally I'm all for low weight. I tried a VFR400 import once and found it far too small for comfort, and I'm only 5'11" - however all the UK market 600s I've sat on are just fine.

Hell, you can already buy 'undersized' bikes for fun - things like minimotos, those Gilera DNA scooters with 'bike' styling, the Sachs MadAss, etc. I probably wouldn't want a modern litre engine in something that small though nuts

Bike design will follow both the demands of buyers and the results of racing - if the racing is popular, and people want to buy bikes like the racers (and they fit the bikes) then they'll sell - equally if there's a new trend (e.g. how supermotos kicked off a new genre), maybe Harley type bikes with offroad tyres and 2 wheel drive hehe then manufacturers will hop on board the latest bandwagon. I do think that Charley Boorman and Ewan McGregor's adventures (and Charley on his own) have raised awareness in the general population about fun on bikes - certainly my girlfriend and her mate both did their CBTs off the back of watching the series - and perhaps that has some bearing on the sales of BMW big trailies (BMW got superb marketing out of that, however much of a prima donna McGregor is to deal with).

Also watch the scooter market. When I was riding scooters the biggest capacity engine was a 200cc Vespa but the fastest was the 180 two stroke Gilera Runner (of which I had several, and souped them up). They were the extremes - the same size twist-n-go, but with silly engines that pulled wheelies off the throttle and did stoppies, etc. But customer demand for longer distance commuting on scooters in comfort (the Runner could do the miles, at nearly 100 mph, but it was a frantic affair) has resulted in the maxi-scooter genre of bike, which are as heavy as regular motorcycles and with larger capacity engines (400, 500cc IIRC). So I'd expect some crossover to occur at some point - i.e. twist-n-go trail bikes / sports bikes (the latter may be limited to kids, as per the Gilera DNA bikes, but if a kid has ridden automatic transmission bikes all his/her life, then a faster, bigger engined auto will sell... in the future - established bikers still want gearboxes and clutches).

After all, the hypersports litre race rep bikes are the ones that grab the headlines and fill the showroom displays... but they're not what the world in general tends to ride. IIRC the UK market is weird compared to the rest of the world in that most of us ride sports bikes of 600 cc and above. Worldwide, it's a small portion of the overall bike market. I'm not surprised to hear that the GS is the biggest selling bike, but I bet more scooters are sold.

I'm waiting for the gearbox tech to enable full crossover of scooter ease-of-use with 'proper' bike performance. The maxi-scooters have shown that such machines will sell. I don't think that a Fireblade with twist-n-go transmission will be well received, but supermotos and trail bikes with auto transmissions would be fun...

Basically I reckon it's about the technology, and even though the rival manufacturers are scrapping over the last bhp and gram of performance with their sportsbikes, the real gains in sales will be when a 'new' type of bike taps a previously-nonexistent market. No road rider can get near a modern sportsbike's limits on the road whilst adhering to the law, and there's a big hole between the 'commuting machine' utilitarian bike / scooter, and the 'bought for fun' sportsbike. Weird things like BMW's C1 'scooter with a roof' show that the manufacturers are willing to take risks to tap new markets, and with petrol prices, car prices and parking spaces putting car driving under increasing pressure, getting non-enthusiasts onto two wheels and turning them into enthusiasts is a great move for bike makers. After all, only the properly wealthy can afford a selection of performance cars, whereas most average income people can afford a couple of bikes. And once you're on that road, because the cost is so much lower, you can buy a new bike much more frequently. Which is what the manufacturers want, surely?
Interesting post, and you clearly illustrate the ever diverging requirements in bike design. Race bikes need to be as small and as light as possible. People are getting bigger in BOTH height and weight. At some point the design of supersports bikes will exclude the majority and thus affect sales - which is the key reason why manufacturers go racing.

I personally, think the new KTM is a landmark design in this respect as at least they recognise the need for a bike to fit a diverse range of sizes by offering adjustable controls.

Muffles

516 posts

253 months

Monday 13th October 2008
quotequote all
What scale of height changes are we talking about (the weight I can already see on the street wink)?

As a 5'9" rider I'm happy with the bikes being as small as they are tongue out although that could change if they go much smaller...

rhinochopig

Original Poster:

17,932 posts

229 months

Monday 13th October 2008
quotequote all
Muffles said:
What scale of height changes are we talking about (the weight I can already see on the street wink)?

As a 5'9" rider I'm happy with the bikes being as small as they are tongue out although that could change if they go much smaller...
The 50th percentile (meaning 50% of the population are taller) is ~5'9"/5'10" for the uk. So you're bang on the average. In Holland and some of the Eastern Euro states, it is ~ 6'.

I can't find any info for secular growth increases that are relevant. However, if you assume that we stay the same or increase slightly (do kids seem taller to you then 10 years ago? I certainly notice that there are more young people closer to my height) then if super-sports bikes become much smaller, and as you say, you would struggle if they get much smaller, then the manufacturers are going to make it difficult for 50% of the population to comfortably fit on one.