2008 Honda Fireblade or 2007 Ducati 1098?
2008 Honda Fireblade or 2007 Ducati 1098?
Author
Discussion

AeroPower

Original Poster:

5,739 posts

255 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
decided im not going to wait for the new RSV4 after all, i might get one when thier a year old and have depreciated a little, as much as i like my 600 i want to go back to a 1000 and really its between these 2, thier both within my price range but cant decide what to go for, ive ridden the latest Fireblade and while it may not look great it certainly is amazing to ride, ive not ridden the 1098 but i could get a test ride on one i supose, my main worry is the reliability and availability of parts on one next to the Honda, i would appreiate everyones opinions and arguements on which to get very much.

Stu R

21,703 posts

246 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
Ducati all day long for me smile

996 sps

6,165 posts

247 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
My opinion is the Fireblade will be easier to ride quick straight away but will you stand back and admire it, will it make you stand in the garage and have a cup of coffee and stare at it?

The 1098 won't be un reliable and will not be hard to get parts for, my 996 SPS is 9 years old and not difficult to get parts for, i'll have a biased opinion as i'd have the 1098, well i'd have a 996R/SPS or 998R over a 1098 to be honest.

Take the 1098 out, then go to the bike show look at the Blade on the Honda stand and 1098 on Ducati stand then make a decision.

Edited by 996 sps on Saturday 18th October 20:38

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

237 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
blade.

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
Ride the 1098. Decision will be simple after that... it's stunning.

Stu R

21,703 posts

246 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
Chilli said:
Ride the 1098. Decision will be simple after that... it's stunning.
yes

y2blade

56,325 posts

246 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
Chilli said:
Ride the 1098. Decision will be simple after that... it's stunning.
yeah he'll go for the 848 smile


AeroPower

Original Poster:

5,739 posts

255 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
do the 1098s still have the belts that need constant attention etc?, i have to admi if i was to buy on looks alone the 1098 would win, however ive ridden the new Fireblade and i loved it and have never actually owned a twin before, ive had a go on a few but i couldnt say wether i would really get on with one or not compared to an I4.

trumpet600

3,527 posts

262 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
If I had longer legs I would have the duke, its lush.

But Im a short arse

mitzy

13,858 posts

228 months

Saturday 18th October 2008
quotequote all
trumpet600 said:
If I had longer legs I would have the duke, its lush.

But Im a short arse
That was me postingbiggrin

dibblecorse

7,668 posts

223 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
look at it another way .... if you could get a Ferrari 360 into your garage for the same price as an Evo / Scooby / Monaro etc and yet only pay 10% to 15% more to service and run it, what would you buy ??

One is uber efficient and does what it says on the tin, and in many ways, ease of use, cost of ownership, sensible buy etc, makes the better purchase ....

The other has a soul, will have you bimbling around on it listening to its heartbeat bouncing off walls, will have you in it, not on it as you carve country lanes, and then as has been said before, will have you sitting in the garage with a coffee admiring the detail ...

I don't think I need to explain which way round this argument is weighted, as you either get it, or you don't.

Either way, happy shopping ....

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

237 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
i like the ducati, and i like the blade, albeit the blade a hell of a lot more, but the ducati is a nice bike none the less.


my only gripw with the dukes is their pricing.

what does a 1098r cost nowadays?? 16=19k??

lets take it at 16k, still 8k more than the blade and is it really worth that much extra?? no.

buy a 2008 blade, spend around 5k on the right bits and watch mr ducati dissapear in your mirrors, as well as you realising that you can still ride yours in the rain, cold, not service it every 10 seconds etc etc.


that said, the ducati still trumps the honda on looks anyday.

my point being thus..

if you want a posers bike, buy the ducati, if you want the best engine, the best chassis, the best aftersale support, the best dealer network, the fastest a-b bike per pound, buy the blade. job done.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
It depends how often you actually want to complete a journey without the AA assistance.


castrolcraig

18,073 posts

237 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
blade7 said:
Would you say that if you worked for Ducati ?.
yep.

996 sps

6,165 posts

247 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
castrolcraig said:
i like the ducati, and i like the blade, albeit the blade a hell of a lot more, but the ducati is a nice bike none the less.


my only gripw with the dukes is their pricing.

what does a 1098r cost nowadays?? 16=19k??

lets take it at 16k, still 8k more than the blade and is it really worth that much extra?? no.

buy a 2008 blade, spend around 5k on the right bits and watch mr ducati dissapear in your mirrors, as well as you realising that you can still ride yours in the rain, cold, not service it every 10 seconds etc etc.


that said, the ducati still trumps the honda on looks anyday.

my point being thus..

if you want a posers bike, buy the ducati, if you want the best engine, the best chassis, the best aftersale support, the best dealer network, the fastest a-b bike per pound, buy the blade. job done.
Is a 1098R worth 10/12k more than a Blade (they are about 22 K) of course they are the latest technology, traction contol full ohlins the full WSB package for the road, carbon fibre fairing, full termis the lot.

A 1098BP on the other hand brand new is around 10-11K so this is relative to the Blade. Take the 1098 all day long.

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

237 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
Would you say that if you worked for Ducati ?.
yep.
Would you say that if you were rich ?. biggrin
if i were rich, HRC would be a number in my phone book.......

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

237 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
Would you say that if you worked for Ducati ?.
yep.
Would you say that if you were rich ?. biggrin
if i were rich, HRC would be a number in my phone book.......
Explain and justify ?.
if i were rich, i wouldnt want a ducati, i would be ordering parts left right and centre from Honda Racing Corparation (HRC) and build the ultimate road going blade.

but, as im not, i have to be content with ordering for other people and for my little nc.....

and as for justification, think that HRC have overseen more 2 wheeled championships than the rest put together...


untruth

2,834 posts

220 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
Isn't a Ducati a willy waving exercise in itself? The blade is quite an ugly bugger but they're so close when it comes to performance and handling from an average consumer rider's perspective.

  • **sits happily stuck into bikes made 20 years ago****
Edited by untruth on Sunday 19th October 12:08


Edited by untruth on Sunday 19th October 12:09

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

237 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
Would you say that if you worked for Ducati ?.
yep.
Would you say that if you were rich ?. biggrin
if i were rich, HRC would be a number in my phone book.......
Explain and justify ?.
if i were rich, i wouldnt want a ducati, i would be ordering parts left right and centre from Honda Racing Corparation (HRC) and build the ultimate road going blade.

but, as im not, i have to be content with ordering for other people and for my little nc.....

and as for justification, think that HRC have overseen more 2 wheeled championships than the rest put together...
Fair enough but the ultimate road going blade sounds a bit like a willy waving exercise, I could understand it more if you wanted to build the ultimate track blade. Personally I think any of the latest thou's and some trick suspension/wheels is as much as I could use on the road, but I'd have an MV or Ducati in the garage to look at.
you nearly hit the nail on the head....and the whole point.

if i were to build said blade it would be for track use, but i would also be able to ride it to and from the circuit if i so wished...


and id consider a duke but never ever an mv.

as chris burns puts it...

the biggest pile of ste road bike ever built....and he races one!!!

y2blade

56,325 posts

246 months

Sunday 19th October 2008
quotequote all
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
castrolcraig said:
blade7 said:
Would you say that if you worked for Ducati ?.
yep.
Would you say that if you were rich ?. biggrin
if i were rich, HRC would be a number in my phone book.......
Explain and justify ?.
if i were rich, i wouldnt want a ducati, i would be ordering parts left right and centre from Honda Racing Corparation (HRC) and build the ultimate road going blade.

but, as im not, i have to be content with ordering for other people and for my little nc.....

and as for justification, think that HRC have overseen more 2 wheeled championships than the rest put together...
Fair enough but the ultimate road going blade sounds a bit like a willy waving exercise, I could understand it more if you wanted to build the ultimate track blade. Personally I think any of the latest thou's and some trick suspension/wheels is as much as I could use on the road, but I'd have an MV or Ducati in the garage to look at.
you nearly hit the nail on the head....and the whole point.

if i were to build said blade it would be for track use, but i would also be able to ride it to and from the circuit if i so wished...


and id consider a duke but never ever an mv.

as chris burns puts it...

the biggest pile of ste road bike ever built....and he races one!!!
nail on the head ^^^