Bad experience of garage? What do you think?
Discussion
Right firstly the bike I'm talking about is an automatic vespa so if you want to stop reading now I understand 
Now earlier this year I had a fairly minor 'off' on some diesel in the rain. I chalked it up to experiance and got on with things. Last week I had another tumble, again in the rain where some diesel had spilt but this time I was also slowing down for a corner.
As the back brake wasn't too good, I decided to take the bike in for a check up the nearest garage. I told the bloke what had happened and he booked it in for a service.
I've just gone to collect it and they said that the rear brake cable had seized and couldn't be adjusted so would have to be replaced at another time (as they didn't have the part in), on the way out he said the break lever comes in pretty far and sent me off on my way.
However when I've given the back brake a quick test before heading onto a main road there is absolutly nothing there.
Now when they said they couldn't adjust the cable I thought I'd have at least the same breaking power as before.
I took the bike back and the bloke tells me I shouldn't even be using the back break unless it's raining, that of course they had to loosen it before they could try and tighten it and generally tried to make out there was nothing strange and I was stupid for not realising there'd be no rear brake after they'd pissed about with it.
He said all they could do was try and tighten it which would proberly snap it - which it did.
The fact they sent me out in this state has left me with no confidence that the bike is safe which is the whole reason I took it in in the first place.
I would have thought that if they are going to send someone out on a bike like that they should have made it utterly crystal clear that there would be NO REAR BRAKE.
Was I wrong to expect that something so fundemental to the safety should be spelled out to me, because from what he was saying I was expecting the break to be a little weak (as it was before) but to wave someone off knowing they have no rear brake is wrong surely?
I'm certainly taking it somewhere else to get the brake properly fixed but before I s
g off this particular place to all and sundry just want to make sure I'm not being out of order.

Now earlier this year I had a fairly minor 'off' on some diesel in the rain. I chalked it up to experiance and got on with things. Last week I had another tumble, again in the rain where some diesel had spilt but this time I was also slowing down for a corner.
As the back brake wasn't too good, I decided to take the bike in for a check up the nearest garage. I told the bloke what had happened and he booked it in for a service.
I've just gone to collect it and they said that the rear brake cable had seized and couldn't be adjusted so would have to be replaced at another time (as they didn't have the part in), on the way out he said the break lever comes in pretty far and sent me off on my way.
However when I've given the back brake a quick test before heading onto a main road there is absolutly nothing there.
Now when they said they couldn't adjust the cable I thought I'd have at least the same breaking power as before.
I took the bike back and the bloke tells me I shouldn't even be using the back break unless it's raining, that of course they had to loosen it before they could try and tighten it and generally tried to make out there was nothing strange and I was stupid for not realising there'd be no rear brake after they'd pissed about with it.
He said all they could do was try and tighten it which would proberly snap it - which it did.
The fact they sent me out in this state has left me with no confidence that the bike is safe which is the whole reason I took it in in the first place.
I would have thought that if they are going to send someone out on a bike like that they should have made it utterly crystal clear that there would be NO REAR BRAKE.
Was I wrong to expect that something so fundemental to the safety should be spelled out to me, because from what he was saying I was expecting the break to be a little weak (as it was before) but to wave someone off knowing they have no rear brake is wrong surely?
I'm certainly taking it somewhere else to get the brake properly fixed but before I s
g off this particular place to all and sundry just want to make sure I'm not being out of order.Edited by rpguk on Monday 27th October 13:20
While I agree that it was not good for the service centre to suggest that you ride the bike without an adequate rear brake, the rider is responsible for ensuring the road worthiness of the vehicle each and every time that (s)he takes the bike out on the road.
I would suggest that you simply find somewhere else to do the servicing.
I would suggest that you simply find somewhere else to do the servicing.
It sounds like garage bulls
t.
The back brake on a vespa is only a cable operated drum, right? So it can be adjusted to infinity until the cable snaps. Assuming it's just cable stretch (and not the fact that your brake shoes are down to the metal and need replacing) then when the barrel adjuster runs out of thread you just loosen the cable clamp, slide it up a bit and then tighten it up again.
t.The back brake on a vespa is only a cable operated drum, right? So it can be adjusted to infinity until the cable snaps. Assuming it's just cable stretch (and not the fact that your brake shoes are down to the metal and need replacing) then when the barrel adjuster runs out of thread you just loosen the cable clamp, slide it up a bit and then tighten it up again.
If the rear brake cable was ceased, and it sounds like it was as it did snap when you returned for adjustment (just like they said it might) then I would say the technician(s) diagnosed the fault pretty bang on. It seems that they worked on the brake, managing to free it off, but not able to adjust it up again, as they also told you, and in doing so some or all of the braking force present when you took it there in the first place, was lost. Now here's the thing you need to be a little compassionate about. When the technician gave you your scooter back the rear brake probably worked enough that it felt similar if not the same just by wheeling it across the workshop floor. Given that you make no mention of payment, and they have said they will order a cable in for you to have fitted at a later date, it seems to me like they've given you a good diagnosis of the problem whilst being unable to offer a temporary fix that actually had the brake working a little once they'd tried unceasing it. Do consider they didn't road test your scooter as there wouldn't be much point given they and you know the brake requires more work. I'm pretty sure their explanation of events had them believe you are bright enough to realise with a little bit of common sense that your rear brake was not to be relied upon. Their explanation for not using a rear brake (not just yours) is a very valid one amongst many experienced riders - though many will debate the merits for its use also. The point is, you should have taken their comments as a bit of a warning perhaps.
Anyway, it's pointless people lambasting this outfit when you are the one in the know to do so if that's what they deserve. It sounds to me like you're the one with doubts, yet they have tried to help you towards a good repair and for their efforts your inexperience has lead you to doubt them when you shouldn't. And by the way, if a modern era Vespa is anything like the older generation, I can't think of a worse job on a two wheeler than that of fitting a brake, throttle or gear change cable to a bloody Vespa. Get back to those guys and form a lasting relationship. Sounds like they know their stuff.
Anyway, it's pointless people lambasting this outfit when you are the one in the know to do so if that's what they deserve. It sounds to me like you're the one with doubts, yet they have tried to help you towards a good repair and for their efforts your inexperience has lead you to doubt them when you shouldn't. And by the way, if a modern era Vespa is anything like the older generation, I can't think of a worse job on a two wheeler than that of fitting a brake, throttle or gear change cable to a bloody Vespa. Get back to those guys and form a lasting relationship. Sounds like they know their stuff.
Gassing Station | Biker Banter | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


