Whos at fault here?
Author
Discussion

stigmundfreud

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
Thankfully my quick reactions saved this idiot from being seriously hurt both physically and then financially for the repairs to my car. But as I know the usual way things go its always the car driver at fault I am glad I own an incar video that is always recording.

Now the quality of the video is low but its better than this guys survival instincts but would like to know what the general biker population think about this one:

http://www.clicketyclicks.co.uk/biker.wmv

Here is a picture of the road layout:



looking at that picture we are approaching from Mannington Lane (White/blue car) he has pulled all the way over into the left lane which is only for turning left onto the great western way (heading north) - I am in the lane next to him which is able to filter left in the inside lane heading up the great western or directly over. He thought he should just go straight on and its only thanks to brakes and reaction he didnt get clipped.

Obviously I feel he is 100% at fault here but expect comments to the opposite for its always the car drivers fault. Also its incidents like this which make me glad I bought a roadhawk

Edited by stigmundfreud on Friday 18th December 14:48

bass gt3

10,756 posts

264 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
Obviously I feel he is 100% at fault here but expect comments to the opposite for its always the car drivers fault.
Top bit of Trolling Sir!! I applaud you. But go on then, i'll bite. Have you considered the slight possibility that the rider was unfamiliar with the road layout,and simply misjudged his lane selection?
And i'm not sure you helped matters by positioning yourself in the 3/4 blind spot position which necessitated your class A avoidance technique.
And whilst your expert application of brakes due to your cat like reflexes obviously saved the day, perhaps expert application of forward thinking and judgement might have negated any perceived issues by the application of the "what if" syndrome and giving said rider a bit of room. I will add that riders should also follow this mantra, but to err is to be human.
However i suspect that you "assumed" n which direction he was going to take, which then put you in the position you found yourself.
And i have to say it seems mildly sad that you feel you need to film every moment of your driving career but i suspect you feel the world is out to get you and are perhaps of a litigious nature, or you love to run to Matron.
So whats next? 199 tea bags in a 200 box shocker?? Can't wait....
Stones, greenhouses etc mean anything?

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
I cannot see a solid line. The left lane is, then, for left or straight on.

So, you tried to run him over, but you didn't?

stigmundfreud

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
based on where he was coming from and going to I'd say more than likely familiar and as for solid line, take a look at the video and the google satelite representation. Left lane is designed for going one way only, left.

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
I cannot see a solid line. The left lane is, then, for left or straight on.
Without knowing this roundabout, and just looking at the lanes and the markings, I'd say this was true.

If you remove the overlay, the lh lane entering the r'about carries a 'straight on arrow'.

I think that what you have is a roundabout with an unclear entry slip: neither you nor the biker were 'at fault', but I can see why he might have seemed a bit surprised at your reaction. Have another look at the junction, especially with the overlay removed. Maybe you'll see what I mean.

eta having watched your video again, you also approached very quickly behaind the biker when his attention was focussed on joining the roundabout, rather than checking his mirrors. You then entered the r'about in his blind spot. Although none of this is your fault as such, I'm not surprised about the near miss as he wouldn't have had much chance to see you.

You did ask for opinions...

Edited by N Dentressangle on Wednesday 16th December 01:57

stigmundfreud

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
I know the roundabout very well and can confirm left lane despite not being with a left only arrow is purely for left turns only.

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
I know the roundabout very well and can confirm left lane despite not being with a left only arrow is purely for left turns only.
I've got to admit, I don't think that's the way I would read it, based on what I can see. Could it be that you have your way of looking at it and he has his?

With no arrows it is unclear, and probably subjective, I'd say.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
I know the roundabout very well and can confirm left lane despite not being with a left only arrow is purely for left turns only.
Quoted. Just because.

bass gt3

10,756 posts

264 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
I know the roundabout very well and can confirm left lane despite not being with a left only arrow is purely for left turns only.
And you know this because???

stigmundfreud

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
bass gt3 said:
stigmundfreud said:
I know the roundabout very well and can confirm left lane despite not being with a left only arrow is purely for left turns only.
And you know this because???
because you bikers are closing ranks and the round about if you look at the google map and if you actually were to drive it you would know you simply do not go straight on from the left lane.

bass gt3

10,756 posts

264 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
bass gt3 said:
stigmundfreud said:
I know the roundabout very well and can confirm left lane despite not being with a left only arrow is purely for left turns only.
And you know this because???
because you bikers are closing ranks and the round about if you look at the google map and if you actually were to drive it you would know you simply do not go straight on from the left lane.
Ahhhh, another wildly inaccurate assumption. Because you perceive us "bikers" as closing ranks, you feel your position regarding the traffic regulations of the roundabout are iron clad. Seems to be a habit non, all this spurious assumtion?
And as there seems to be no solid lines dividing any of the lanes, it would appear that traffic is free to move across as necessary. Naturally observing surrounding vehicles in the process.
And whilst i ride bikes, i am not a biker per se. I also have a stable of cars, but this doesn't make me a "cager"
Might i suggest you abandon this woeful attempt at illiciting an indignant, impassioned and derogatory response and perhaps focus your efforts at something a little more original, humourous or thought provoking?
Fail.

Yoda.

2,260 posts

279 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
As you know that bit of road so well, it's good to see you anticipated that the bike may not actually intend to bear left whilst being in the 'left hand' lane...I mean you must see it all the time eh? It can hardly be a surprise wink
Your lightening reactions prevented a 50:50 fault 'accident'. The proof being on film hehe
Why are you so troubled by all this...the film ends as your vehicle is heading into the left lane...I wonder what happens next? Some sort of altercation?

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
TBH, I'm with the OP on this. The bike was in the wrong lane. Fine, we've all done it, in cars and bikes. However, training and common sense tells you to look absolutely everywhere before changing direction. The biker MUST have known he was in the wrong lane, as there was an option for him to go straight on/bear left.

In that situation, I would have been a) looking absolutely everywhere and b)nailed the throttle so that even if there were cars around me, I would have safely cleared them.

I wonder if the biker would have done the same had he been driving a car.


mitzy

13,858 posts

228 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
Do you video all your trips out in the car? Must be a great collection!


The road markings dont say left turn only, but I think his positioning could have been better , but im sure you have never been in a wrong lane, perhaps you have one of them in your collection?

heebeegeetee

30,257 posts

279 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
Chilli said:
TBH, I'm with the OP on this. The bike was in the wrong lane. Fine, we've all done it, in cars and bikes. However, training and common sense tells you to look absolutely everywhere before changing direction. The biker MUST have known he was in the wrong lane, as there was an option for him to go straight on/bear left.

In that situation, I would have been a) looking absolutely everywhere and b)nailed the throttle so that even if there were cars around me, I would have safely cleared them.

I wonder if the biker would have done the same had he been driving a car.
Agreed. Silly biker, i would say.

black-k1

12,812 posts

260 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
From the google photo shown there are no lane markings. OP says left lane is left only but there is no evidence of this!

The Highway Code is clear: Unless otherwise marked, left lane is for 1st or 2nd exit. In the description, the biker was going for the 2nd exit making the OP wrong for trying to "push" the biker out of his lane.



http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/TravelAndTransport/Hig...

heebeegeetee

30,257 posts

279 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
From the google photo shown there are no lane markings. OP says left lane is left only but there is no evidence of this!
If you study the film umpteen times i think you can just make out a left-pointing arrowhead. smile

Edited by heebeegeetee on Wednesday 16th December 07:26

black-k1

12,812 posts

260 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
heebeegeetee said:
black-k1 said:
From the google photo shown there are no lane markings. OP says left lane is left only but there is no evidence of this!
If you study the film umpteen times i think you can just make out a left-pointing arrowhead. smile

Edited by heebeegeetee on Wednesday 16th December 07:26
Check out multimap photo. Left lane is clearly marked straigt over. OP is totally in the wrong!

http://www.multimap.com/maps/?qs=manningon+lane&am... lane|Mannington Lane, Swindon, Wiltshire, England, SN5 8

heebeegeetee

30,257 posts

279 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
heebeegeetee said:
black-k1 said:
From the google photo shown there are no lane markings. OP says left lane is left only but there is no evidence of this!
If you study the film umpteen times i think you can just make out a left-pointing arrowhead. smile

Edited by heebeegeetee on Wednesday 16th December 07:26
Check out multimap photo. Left lane is clearly marked straigt over. OP is totally in the wrong!

http://www.multimap.com/maps/?qs=manningon+lane&am... lane|Mannington Lane, Swindon, Wiltshire, England, SN5 8
You could well be right. I was trying to find out which way the arrow was pointing and couldn't really discern. It does boil down to the arrow of course. if that arrow is pointing ahead the OP is going to look a tad silly. smile

Looking at your pic though it does look as though the arrows conflict with the lane markings. Yet another st roundabout from our highway engineers?

Edited by heebeegeetee on Wednesday 16th December 07:54

G Man

4,053 posts

291 months

Wednesday 16th December 2009
quotequote all
I know the roundabout, its West Swindon ....it is not a roundabout now but a set of circular traffic lights,CTL's with very confusing road markings ...

The OP is correct that the bike was in the wrong lane, but the OP showed a lack observation, anticipation and forward planning.

Car drivers in Swindon use the CTL's to overtake, block and nail someone who is in the wrong lane, it's the boy racers special game.

I would say the OP showed no defensive driving technique, a lack of observation and empathy for other road users, this could have gone wrong for the biker for what an extra 2 sec on the road.

The Bikers mistake was in navigation ... enter Chaville at your own risk