Farmer Kills Green Lane Biker

Farmer Kills Green Lane Biker

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

Himself

483 posts

149 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
When I get caught riding my mountain bike on 'illegal' trails I always play the 'I'm lost' card. I'm middle aged and always polite so I very rarely get killed.

Mr E

21,799 posts

261 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
and what would you suggest? She was walking in our crop while my colleague was spraying, he rightly gave her a bking for being in in the crop and being no where near the foot path. her husnad then drivers through the standing crop, then follows my colleague back to the yard and both him and his son threaten the sprayer driver. So then, how would you deal with people like this? Have a nice cordial word with them.

A nice cordial word followed by a court case to recover all the damages/costs due to their tresspass would appear to be appropriate.

If they're causing that much of an issue.

VinceFox

20,566 posts

174 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Himself said:
When I get caught riding my mountain bike on 'illegal' trails I always play the 'I'm lost' card. I'm middle aged and always polite so I very rarely get killed.
Surely you must have been once or twice?

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

241 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Trespassing in the UK is rife. I used to live by a river which clearly stated 'No Fishing' along that stretch. Yet regularly people would ignore these signs and when approached get aggressive or simply ignore the fact that someone was advising them that they weren't allowed to be there doing what they were doing. Why do people do this? I really can't understand why people ignore clearly stated information on what can/can't be done in a certain location, particularly on private land. Prvate land means it's not your's and you have no say about what to do on it. What's so difficult to understand about that?

As far as I'm concerned, as soon as you break the law/ignore warnings the consequences are down to you.

Himself

483 posts

149 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
VinceFox said:
Surely you must have been once or twice?
Never been killed to death.

J B L

4,201 posts

217 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
As far as I'm concerned, as soon as you break the law/ignore warnings the consequences are down to you.
Death? Really?

I mean, yes, if someone is coming to your house to rob you and might harm your family, by all means defend yourselves.

But a few ruts in the ground or a fish...

Himself

483 posts

149 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
J B L said:
Death? Really?
Yes, I wonder how he'd feel if he was shot for doing 75mph on the motorway?

The punishment must fit the crime and that's not for use to decide.

STHi

26,988 posts

179 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
This a typical thread for the persecuted biker community.

If the article read "Farmer mows down who was trespassing on his land. The farmer has been the victim of several burglaries and his crops have been ruined by ramblers and other trespassers over the years". Then 99% of posters would be with the farmer.

There's also the small aspect of how the pitchfork brigade have managed to turn "the car toppled over.." into "mad with rage farmer with smoke coming out of his ears and eyes popping out of his forehead deliberately raced across the field to kill all the bikers, in the process he also killed Bambi's mother"

This thread is pathetic.

Apriliaer

848 posts

160 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Farmers are dicks, proven fact. The tresspass law is weak, farmers never seem to apply common sense when acosting 'tresspassers'. Had it myself, on foot mind, when doing nothing wrong and have been more than happy to tell them to jog on.

I don't think anyone has made reference to the fact the charges should be harsh because they were bikers, it's been mentioned because the incident involved bikes and this is a bike forum. So as for the 'persecuted biker' theory....... Douche.

The sound of the engines probably disturbed his subsidy counting.

May he rot in jail.

Himself

483 posts

149 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Apriliaer said:
Farmers are dicks, proven fact.
Really? Proven? Go on then, this should be good. For every internet fact you find, I'll find a fact that points to bikers being dicks even ones on an Aprilia.

Farmers get a tough deal these days as do us bikers, remember ALL Volvo drivers are out to kill us.

heebeegeetee

28,924 posts

250 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
Trespassing in the UK is rife. I used to live by a river which clearly stated 'No Fishing' along that stretch. Yet regularly people would ignore these signs and when approached get aggressive or simply ignore the fact that someone was advising them that they weren't allowed to be there doing what they were doing. Why do people do this? I really can't understand why people ignore clearly stated information on what can/can't be done in a certain location, particularly on private land. Prvate land means it's not your's and you have no say about what to do on it. What's so difficult to understand about that?

As far as I'm concerned, as soon as you break the law/ignore warnings the consequences are down to you.
Luckily, we've moved a long way from this nonsense.

http://www.peakdistrict-nationalpark.com/kinder-tr...

http://www.marionshoard.co.uk/Documents/Articles/E...

>>The Kinder Scout Mass Trespass of April 24, 1932 resulted in the arrest and subsequent imprisonment of four young Manchester ramblers, whose only ‘crime’ was walking on the moors.

Eighty years ago, the highest and wildest moorlands of the Peak District were frustratingly out-of-bounds to the growing army of walkers from the surrounding cities, and were jealously guarded by stick-wielding gamekeepers for their grouse-shooting masters.

On that sunny Sunday morning, about 400 ramblers set off from Hayfield on the western side of Kinder to deliberately trespass on what was then the Peak’s ‘forbidden mountain.’

When they stepped off the path, they were met by a line of gamekeepers and a few scuffles followed. A victory meeting was held near Ashop Head and then the trespassers marched back to Hayfield, where police arrested five people who were charged, significantly not with trespass, but with with public order offences such as riotous assembly.

At their subsequent trial at Derby Assizes, four of the five young defendants received swingeing prison sentences of between two and six months. Ironically, it was the severity of the sentences which served to unite the ramblers’ cause.<<

Apriliaer

848 posts

160 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Himself said:
Really? Proven? Go on then, this should be good. For every internet fact you find, I'll find a fact that points to bikers being dicks even ones on an Aprilia.

Farmers get a tough deal these days as do us bikers, remember ALL Volvo drivers are out to kill us.
I've seen it written down so it is a fact. Of course aprilia riders are dicks, just like Max.

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

241 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
heebeegeetee said:
Luckily, we've moved a long way from this nonsense.

http://www.peakdistrict-nationalpark.com/kinder-tr...

http://www.marionshoard.co.uk/Documents/Articles/E...

>>The Kinder Scout Mass Trespass of April 24, 1932 resulted in the arrest and subsequent imprisonment of four young Manchester ramblers, whose only ‘crime’ was walking on the moors.

Eighty years ago, the highest and wildest moorlands of the Peak District were frustratingly out-of-bounds to the growing army of walkers from the surrounding cities, and were jealously guarded by stick-wielding gamekeepers for their grouse-shooting masters.

On that sunny Sunday morning, about 400 ramblers set off from Hayfield on the western side of Kinder to deliberately trespass on what was then the Peak’s ‘forbidden mountain.’

When they stepped off the path, they were met by a line of gamekeepers and a few scuffles followed. A victory meeting was held near Ashop Head and then the trespassers marched back to Hayfield, where police arrested five people who were charged, significantly not with trespass, but with with public order offences such as riotous assembly.

At their subsequent trial at Derby Assizes, four of the five young defendants received swingeing prison sentences of between two and six months. Ironically, it was the severity of the sentences which served to unite the ramblers’ cause.<<
so you're happy for anyone to walk through your garden (assuming you have one)? Whilst they are there, you're happy for them to set up for the day and then leave all of their rubbish (cans/sandwich boxes/crisp packets/bottles) all over your land (garden)?

XG332

3,927 posts

190 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Apriliaer said:
Farmers are dicks, proven fact
I live in the countryside and know a lot of the farmers in and around are village. There nice hard working people. Yes they don't always abide to the law. But once you see how expensive the gear they need is and how little they earn from some produce you soon realise why they can be stressed.

But calling them all dicks? Your just come across as a very immature and naive person.

obscene

5,174 posts

187 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Pretty sure my dad knew the guy/people related to him as I heard the story quite a while back. While the guy shouldn't have been riding on the land he shouldn't have been killed for it. Both parties in the wrong.

STHi

26,988 posts

179 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
obscene said:
Pretty sure my dad knew the guy/people related to him as I heard the story quite a while back. While the guy shouldn't have been riding on the land he shouldn't have been killed for it. Both parties in the wrong.
ha you mean is.

While the guy shouldn't have been riding on the land he didn't deserve to be killed in an accident, albeit an avoidable one.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

169 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
J B L said:
But a few ruts in the ground or a fish...
"We" spend quite a bit of money, time and effort to reduce "a few ruts in the ground"

Machinery guided by satellite to reduce over lap to just about zero, hugely expensive tyres, optimum ballast to keep wheel slip in the optimum range, machinery on tracks and not working the land when it won't stand traffic.

This may astonish you, but the ground is where the crops grow and they don't grow too well in "a few ruts". They like loose but firm soil so they can push their roots down to moisture and nutrients, hence why people spend tens of thousands of pounds and more trying to avoid "a few ruts".

You won't see many animals out in the fields over winter because the put "a few ruts in the ground" and it stops the grass growing, which feeds them, which in turn pays the bills.

People seem to have very little respect for other peoples property, be it a nice car, nice house, phone or in this case somebodies land.

VinceFox

20,566 posts

174 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Himself said:
Apriliaer said:
Farmers are dicks, proven fact.
Really? Proven? Go on then, this should be good. For every internet fact you find, I'll find a fact that points to bikers being dicks even ones on an Aprilia.

Farmers get a tough deal these days as do us bikers, remember ALL Volvo drivers are out to kill us.
United against a common enemy, all hostilities cease.

I like you, you should stay.

poo at Paul's

14,225 posts

177 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Cock Nilly said:
PaulMoor said:
Willy Nilly said:
Only in the UK can people trespass and the land owner end up in court.
Because killing someone doing no harm to you is ok... one of the people in my block of flats keeps leaving their bicycle in my parking space (which I own). Should I be aloud to run him over too?
I hate to break it to you, but the land these people were riding on is rather key to the land owners business. Would they ride across the pitch at Wembley? How about around your garden?
You're assuming that he killed the guy on his land, the article says they had left his field when the farmer pursued them and killed him.
Not only did he drive so dangerously as to collide with one vehicle in front, he drove so dangerously he overturned his own fking vehicle. "Willy", we'll just call you "Cock" from now on.

This idiot is a coward. He'd never have dared to drive like this and crash into a group of 4x4 owners, who'd have got out looked at another battle scar and beaten the st out of him.
He pursued the bikers, in his landrover, knowing that in a collision, he' be safe and he'd cause an accident and a serious injury to the other party. He's lucky he's only up for manslaughter, if it turned out he'd be waiting for them behind the hedge for a while, planning it, it'd be murder.

If you think that this sort of action is appropriate, I hope your employer reads this and realises what a potential liability you are as an employee, and gets rid of you.

Edited by poo at Paul's on Sunday 26th February 14:15

bimsb6

8,065 posts

223 months

Sunday 26th February 2012
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
J B L said:
But a few ruts in the ground or a fish...
"We" spend quite a bit of money, time and effort to reduce "a few ruts in the ground"

Machinery guided by satellite to reduce over lap to just about zero, hugely expensive tyres, optimum ballast to keep wheel slip in the optimum range, machinery on tracks and not working the land when it won't stand traffic.

This may astonish you, but the ground is where the crops grow and they don't grow too well in "a few ruts". They like loose but firm soil so they can push their roots down to moisture and nutrients, hence why people spend tens of thousands of pounds and more trying to avoid "a few ruts".

You won't see many animals out in the fields over winter because the put "a few ruts in the ground" and it stops the grass growing, which feeds them, which in turn pays the bills.

People seem to have very little respect for other peoples property, be it a nice car, nice house, phone or in this case somebodies land.
or somebodies life ,you forgot to add that one .

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED