4.0hc engine upgrade?
4.0hc engine upgrade?
Author
Discussion

robbri

Original Poster:

264 posts

240 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Hi i am thinking about upgrading my chimaeras engine from a 4.0hc pre serp t5 box, should i go for a rebuild of the existing engine with a 4.6 short engine or look at other options such as 5 litre any advice would be greatly appreciated.

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Talk to the engine suppliers to get a feel for the different cost / performance upgrades available, but a stock new 4.6 with decent heads is IMO an extremely cost effective upgrade. You will most definitely notice the extra torque over the 4.0.

That Daddy

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
Talk to the engine suppliers to get a feel for the different cost / performance upgrades available, but a stock new 4.6 with decent heads is IMO an extremely cost effective upgrade. You will most definitely notice the extra torque over the 4.0.
yes Especially with a new similar spec cam to the one you already have,nice free revving motor,it does not have to be a 5.0 in fact if i was going the upgrade to a bigger motor then the 4.6 would be for me.

vrover8

33 posts

220 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
The 4.6 short motor is a very good upgrade especially if you port the heads to stage 3 spec as well. Before you get to carried away the book 'How to power tune rover v8 engines by Des Hammill' is a very good read Also talk your options though with a few specialists, v8 developments are very knowledgeable and Chris Crane from RPI Engineering loves talking, but there are many other options, a lot will depend on the current state of your engine but whilst you are spending this kind of money don't forget to consider upgrading the car, or the other option is SC Power are doing some good deals on supercharger converions at the moment.

robbri

Original Poster:

264 posts

240 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice at the moment the car has just gone in for a full body off chassis restoration at the same time i am planning to upgrade as much as possible and as the engine is allready out having this done now seems to make sense, the 4.6 seems a good option, never thought about sc before would they have to change any of the internals of the engine?

vrover8

33 posts

220 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
No it is a bolt on kit, as it only runs a low boost pressure,
so the engine internals stay the same check out the website www.sc-power.co.uk or ring them up for a chat they will be able to tell you a bit more.

robbri

Original Poster:

264 posts

240 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
The sc looks very interesting a good deal at the moment an xtra 90-100 bhp and lots more torque, how would this compare to the 4.6 upgrade in terms of power and performance and cost?

im

34,302 posts

248 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
robbri said:
The sc looks very interesting a good deal at the moment an xtra 90-100 bhp and lots more torque, how would this compare to the 4.6 upgrade in terms of power and performance and cost?
Read this thread:

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...

in particular the 6th post down from John Murray - he's got a 4.5L

If you want to chat about it feel free to PM me and I'll give you my telephone number.

fatboychim

979 posts

282 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
robbri said:
The sc looks very interesting a good deal at the moment an xtra 90-100 bhp and lots more torque, how would this compare to the 4.6 upgrade in terms of power and performance and cost?
I went the SC Power route with my 4.0L in April and it's utterley transformed my car.

On the track it goes by 4.5's and 5.0's without much trouble at all and more importantly for me it's a real pussycat around town, in fact, at low speeds you would hardly know it had a blower. It will pull 5th gear from 1000 rpm and is nicely responsive on the throttle.

I looked at several options for upgrades but most seemed to involve either lots of pennies or trading some drivability for power. Certainly supercharging gives you the biggest bang for your buck.

I installed mine myself without much trouble (or knowledge) and anything i didn't understand was sorted by a quick phonecall to SC Power, who always found time to talk to me.

For sure have a look at all your options and choose what seems right for you but as you probably can tell I'm totally smitten with the choice I made.

Andy

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
fatboychim said:
On the track it goes by 4.5's and 5.0's without much trouble at all
How much power and torque do you think it is making now?

fatboychim

979 posts

282 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
fatboychim said:
On the track it goes by 4.5's and 5.0's without much trouble at all
How much power and torque do you think it is making now?
Aw crikey that did sound a bit like a boast didn't it!

I didn't want to get into willy waving at all.

I haven't had it on the rollers yet (car not willy), so I don't want to quote figures that I don't have the experience to qualify.....and then end up looking like more of an idiot.
I plan to get it on a RR soon, when I've had it done i'll let you know

It is however considerably quicker than before and doesn't let up at all even at high speeds where before it used to ease off.
It also pulls much much better from low revs.

im

34,302 posts

248 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Dom at TVR Power's print out of mine on his RR after installation:



The top 3 graphs show both the before and after results at the rear wheels - up from 180bhp to 268bhp.

Edited by im on Thursday 24th July 16:09

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
im said:
Dom at TVR Power's print out of mine on his RR after installation:
Good to see some hard figures, but I'm struggling to match the fairly large power and torque gains with the relatively modest boost. Were other mods made at the same time?

im

34,302 posts

248 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
im said:
Dom at TVR Power's print out of mine on his RR after installation:
Good to see some hard figures, but I'm struggling to match the fairly large power and torque gains with the relatively modest boost. Were other mods made at the same time?
No - the only other job done whilst the car was in for the Supercharger modification was the 4L clutch was replaced with a 5L clutch.

funbobby

1,706 posts

289 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
i see sc power have reduced the price i wonder if that includes fitting? mmm very tempting

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
im said:
GreenV8S said:
im said:
Dom at TVR Power's print out of mine on his RR after installation:
Good to see some hard figures, but I'm struggling to match the fairly large power and torque gains with the relatively modest boost. Were other mods made at the same time?
No - the only other job done whilst the car was in for the Supercharger modification was the 4L clutch was replaced with a 5L clutch.
5.5 PSI of boost corresponds to a compression ratio of about 1.38:1 assume 100% efficiency, so I'd expect to see an absolute maximum of around 38% more torque and power - rather less in the real world since it's never 100% efficient.

The figures show torque going from 199 to 275 (38% increase) despite the fact that at peak torque the boost is only 2-3 PSI.

They also show power going from 180 to 268 (49% increase).

I'm struggling to imagine how the gains come to be so much better than you'd expect from that boost level.

Taking the figures at face value the only explanation I can think at the moment is that they're measuring boost in the plenum and assuming zero boost in the normally aspirated case, neglecting the fact that even at WOT there may be a significant manifold depression. That feels like grasping at straws to be honest, and I'm left puzzled by those numbers.

Edited by GreenV8S on Thursday 24th July 19:52

im

34,302 posts

248 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
im said:
GreenV8S said:
im said:
Dom at TVR Power's print out of mine on his RR after installation:
Good to see some hard figures, but I'm struggling to match the fairly large power and torque gains with the relatively modest boost. Were other mods made at the same time?
No - the only other job done whilst the car was in for the Supercharger modification was the 4L clutch was replaced with a 5L clutch.
5.5 PSI of boost corresponds to a compression ratio of about 1.38:1 assume 100% efficiency, so I'd expect to see an absolute maximum of around 38% more torque and power - rather less in the real world since it's never 100% efficient.

The figures show torque going from 199 to 275 (38% increase) despite the fact that at peak torque the boost is only 2-3 PSI.

They also show power going from 180 to 268 (49% increase).

I'm struggling to imagine how the gains come to be so much better than you'd expect from that boost level.

Taking the figures at face value the only explanation I can think at the moment is that they're measuring boost in the plenum and assuming zero boost in the normally aspirated case, neglecting the fact that even at WOT there may be a significant manifold depression. That feels like grasping at straws to be honest, and I'm left puzzled by those numbers.
Perhaps thats one for Dom at TVR Power or Colin Harvey at SC Power to answer - You're way beyond my level of technical competence on this issue. I can only comment on what I'm told and display the graphs I've been given.

Now if you want your VAT return checked out...

biggrin

Edited by im on Friday 25th July 08:51

robbri

Original Poster:

264 posts

240 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
quite a few options to think about the sc seems like a good upgrade but as the engine is already out the 4.6 short motor looks the best option getting the engine in top condition is the priority as an sc can always be fitted in the future, i plan on upgrading as much as possible which will include upgrading the brakes and a new clutch.

vrover8

33 posts

220 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Looks like supercharger convertions are highly rated on here. Sorry to add to the confusion again but it is best to consider everthing before you start. You could have your own engine reconditioned with a stroker kit to give you a five litre capacity at the same time! www.realsteel.co.uk

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Yeah, but I can't begin to imagine what five litres capacity would be like with standard sized valves (as the HC has) - my guess is it would be all over past 4-4.5K rpm...

So in reality it will be the stroker kit + cylinder heads upgrade + remapping +... £££