twin airflow meters...can it be done...?
twin airflow meters...can it be done...?
Author
Discussion

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
i was wondering if anyone knew what the chances of putting a second AFM on the chim would be?
I am going for a twin plenum and dont want to run it through the one AFM as that would defeat the point a bit...

Can anyone see any problems???

Eventually i will be going megasquirt but that is a way off yet so i need a temporary measure for now

AntonyJ

5,254 posts

312 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
The ECU probably wont be capable of accepting to analogue inputs and coming up with a happy medium bewteen the two.
Probably just easier to junk the Lucas and go aftermarket.

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
thats what i was thinking...i was just wondering if there was some kind of way round it...i might just hang fire until i get the megasquirt...

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
I've been scratching my head on this - and theoretically it sounds possible.
My thoughts were to engineer two airflow meters into the air inlet - but to only connect one of them but with a bit of simple electronics bump up the output voltage so that it reflects the airflow through both meters.
Theoretically both meters should have the same airflow so I wouldn't over complicate it trying to connect both of them.
I'm sure in reality there are lots of issues that mean this won't work.

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
Barkychoc said:
I've been scratching my head on this - and theoretically it sounds possible.
My thoughts were to engineer two airflow meters into the air inlet - but to only connect one of them but with a bit of simple electronics bump up the output voltage so that it reflects the airflow through both meters.
Theoretically both meters should have the same airflow so I wouldn't over complicate it trying to connect both of them.
I'm sure in reality there are lots of issues that mean this won't work.
What's the second one for then - restricting the air flow to the same extent as the functioning one on the other side?

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
900T-R said:
What's the second one for then - restricting the air flow to the same extent as the functioning one on the other side?
eventually they will both go...i am making a new plenum...was thinking of doing the siamese one but am now thinking of going for two separate boxes, one to feed each bank...for now i was thinking of using two AFM's until i get the megasquirt...IIRC the car stops running if you just disconnect the existing AFM, and i dont want to run the two through one AFM

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
900T-R said:
Barkychoc said:
I've been scratching my head on this - and theoretically it sounds possible.
My thoughts were to engineer two airflow meters into the air inlet - but to only connect one of them but with a bit of simple electronics bump up the output voltage so that it reflects the airflow through both meters.
Theoretically both meters should have the same airflow so I wouldn't over complicate it trying to connect both of them.
I'm sure in reality there are lots of issues that mean this won't work.
What's the second one for then - restricting the air flow to the same extent as the functioning one on the other side?
Yes - I figured you need the same venturi to get away with only one meter being connected - the easiest way I thought is just to use another meter - it doesn't even need to work.

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
Barkychoc said:
Yes - I figured you need the same venturi to get away with only one meter being connected - the easiest way I thought is just to use another meter - it doesn't even need to work.
good point...one bank will be drawing roughly the same as the other...hmmmmmm...getting more confusing now hehe

Cider Andy

1,889 posts

256 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
There was a guy a year or two back, either on here or the TVRCC forum, I can't remember which. He had two plenum chamber tops that he had cut vertically lengthways and then joined together the two halves to make a chamber with two air inlets. He'd knocked up some electronics to combine the two AFM signals giving the 14CUX the proper voltage corresponding to the actual airflow. I don't know if he finished the job, or how he connected the two throttles together.

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
OK - Thinking about this in its basic form - what we need is some data for the standard setup.
In its most basic form it would be the AFM output with the standard single plenum at various rpm on the engine - maybe if you're feeling really ambitious and have an accompice you could even get some data with the car on the move - some simple logging of voltages at various levels of rpm.

That Daddy

19,466 posts

252 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
Andy it would be great in theory but a bloody nightmare to get those AFM,s to meter output properly to the ECU,me personally hold out for the Megasquirt or whatever you choose to use(like the sound of that plenum idea though)oh yeh,hows it going mate thumbup and when you gonna update your profile pics whistle

Chimjunkie

2,879 posts

242 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
If the airflow meter signal is linear with airflow and there is no offset, i.e zero flow is zero voltage, then a simple signal adding chip could be used. Otherwise it's prob a major electronics hack about. Like the idea of using the two meters and just connecting the one.


spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
Cider Andy said:
There was a guy a year or two back, either on here or the TVRCC forum, I can't remember which. He had two plenum chamber tops that he had cut vertically lengthways and then joined together the two halves to make a chamber with two air inlets. He'd knocked up some electronics to combine the two AFM signals giving the 14CUX the proper voltage corresponding to the actual airflow. I don't know if he finished the job, or how he connected the two throttles together.
You're not thinking of Phil Ringwood are you?

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
Chimjunkie said:
Like the idea of using the two meters and just connecting the one.
I have been thinking about that...if i half the plenum then there will only be half the air flow so it would be reading weak...?
Surely the AFM would be expecting a draw for 8 cylinders instead of 4...if it was just drawing air for 4 then it would only upply the fuel for 4...unless i have had too many beers and am not thinking straight...

That Daddy said:
Andy it would be great in theory but a bloody nightmare to get those AFM,s to meter output properly to the ECU,me personally hold out for the Megasquirt or whatever you choose to use(like the sound of that plenum idea though)oh yeh,hows it going mate thumbup and when you gonna update your profile pics whistle
Well i can do most of the mods and just use the one AFM but it will not be ideal as running throughh the one AFM would kind of defeat the object...as for updating the profile pics i shall try and do it now...

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
profile is updated but not with the most reccent pics....it has now got corrado mirrors on and a silver grill... wink

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
The suggestion was just to connect one AFM - but it will need some simple electronics (theoretically) to increase the voltage to the level it would be at with all the air going through one AFM - does that make sense?
The problem is that we have no reference data what these values need to be.

Thinking again it might be easier to connect both AFM's to a simple electronic circuit that adds both voltages together (this is easy to do) then divides it by 2, again easy to do. This should again theoretically give the normal idle value.

The question would be at idle with half the normal level of air going through the AFM is it still within the operating range of the AFM or maybe it won't register at this new lower level of airflow.

If someone has done it before it would be worth finding out what they did and if it worked - no point reinventing the wheel IMHO.

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
sounds good in theory...
think i might see if i can log some data of outputs from the AFM at different revs and then see what it puts out with the twin plenum and then i might have a base to work from...it shouldnt be too hard to get right.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
You're just asking for a lot of grief Andy, IMHO. If you stick another ecu on it and map of pressure it will have been a complete waste of time and effort.

Just do it when you install your MS (you're intention I believe). If you plan to have banked plenums you will need a balance pipe, just take map (pressure) sensor off that... No need for AFM('s) at all in that case. Much less grief wink

ETA: self policing grammar variety hehe

Edited by spend on Monday 29th December 23:14

andy-w

Original Poster:

1,987 posts

257 months

Monday 29th December 2008
quotequote all
spend said:
If you plan to have banked plenums you will need a balance pipe, just take map (pressure) sensor of that... No need for AFM('s) at all in that case. Much less grief wink
now that sounds good...use the MAP sensor on the MS and have a pipe running from each plenum to a to 'T' peice running to the MS...think what i am going to do is build the parts first, fit the MS and then put the twin plenums on...

Just need to put a shopping list together now...!

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Tuesday 30th December 2008
quotequote all
andy-w said:
spend said:
If you plan to have banked plenums you will need a balance pipe, just take map (pressure) sensor of that... No need for AFM('s) at all in that case. Much less grief wink
now that sounds good...use the MAP sensor on the MS and have a pipe running from each plenum to a to 'T' piece running to the MS...think what i am going to do is build the parts first, fit the MS and then put the twin plenums on...

Just need to put a shopping list together now...!
Vacuum tubing is not good enough to balance the plenums between 2 banks IMO, a large fixed balance pipe (say 25mmish) or 2 will avoid problems of the banks running unevenly (and balance things like servo / purge... automagically).

I still would not really advocate that however, 2 side by side throttles on a single plenum is much easier, getting rid of the horrible RV8 letterbox and S shape behind the throttle would be a massive improvement IMHO. Beyond that if you start playing with the inlet manifold the world is your oyster I reckon wink If you want some alternate ideas contact me offline, I've done quite a lot of research into different methods and even created some DXF of manifold flanges, they look really funky prototyped in plastic.