Stiff Gear Change
Stiff Gear Change
Author
Discussion

MajorClanger

Original Poster:

749 posts

301 months

Wednesday 7th January 2009
quotequote all
The gear change in my Chimaera has become VERY stiff all of a sudden. Yesterday, started up and could not get the car into gear with engine running (so engine off, select gear, start engine - luckily didn't need to do a three point turn!). Eventually got underway but was still stiff when changing gears (I don't mean the usual stiffness, this was "if I use any more force I'm going to do some damage"). Seemed to loosen up as the car warmed up after 20 minutes.

Today, problem was even worse. Couldn't select first gear at all and remaining gear changes very difficult.

Could this be a problem with gearbox, clutch, clutch hydraulics or just a characteristic in this extremely cold weather? Car is 10 years old, 42k miles, original clutch.

Cheers for any help.

MC

PS Clutch is also 'biting' at minimal clutch pedal lift (only noticed on way home today)

Edited by MajorClanger on Wednesday 7th January 20:15

Inny

456 posts

228 months

Wednesday 7th January 2009
quotequote all
(I no very little about cars but seeing as I'm in the same boat, thought I should share what very little I know...)

Had the same thing: reluctant change initially, then obstructive, now can't change gear at all. Fluid on the clutch pedal so *think* it's the master cylinder leaking.

Will top up the fluid this weekend, pump the pedal and *try* to drive to my mechanic.

HTH

MajorClanger

Original Poster:

749 posts

301 months

Thursday 8th January 2009
quotequote all
Was hoping it wasn't the master cylinder as this was replaced 2 years ago... but would be par for the course! Will check fluid levels though.

MC

Inny

456 posts

228 months

Thursday 8th January 2009
quotequote all
Let us know how you get on...

over_the_hill

3,340 posts

277 months

Thursday 8th January 2009
quotequote all
Could just be the cold weather. Gear changes do get easier as the car and gear box oil warms up. The oil is likely to be thicker than usual at the minute from cold. Also, do you know when it was last changed if ever ? It probably should be done at certain service intervals but that doesn't mean it was.

MajorClanger

Original Poster:

749 posts

301 months

Thursday 8th January 2009
quotequote all
Warming up certainly helped, but last night was relatively warm compared to previous nights and the car would have had 40 minutes to warm up but still had problems. I initially thought it was the cold when this all started a couple of days ago after the really cold night weather started.

G/B oil I thought was replaced in last two years (and I'd trust the guy to do it). The clutch pedal biting after lifting so little seems to point the finger at the clutch hydraulics (or possibly clutch plates) which may also have been affected by the extreme cold.

MC

chrispitman

742 posts

285 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
On the top of the box there is a tube/guide which is part of the linkage, it could be this. To get you need to remove the center console and under neather there is an access hatch held in by screws bemove this and you have access to the top of the box. Worth giving everything a check and re oil.

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
You can test whether it's the linkage by changing gear with the engine stopped. If that's OK then almost certainly the problem is that the clutch isn't releasing. If you continue to drive like this you will cause a lot of wear on the synchros and this can lead to a very expensive bill to remove and rebuild the gearbox. Hopefully it's just a hydraulic problem. A clutch slave failure will always result in fluid loss. A failure at the master may result in fluid loss, but it may not. So checking the fluid level is the first step.

WOO5IE

967 posts

228 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Have you checked the fluid level .

I had this a few weeks ago and the level was very low although no signs of a leak. Refilled and bled and it is now perfect.

Trev

MajorClanger

Original Poster:

749 posts

301 months

Saturday 10th January 2009
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
You can test whether it's the linkage by changing gear with the engine stopped. If that's OK then almost certainly the problem is that the clutch isn't releasing. If you continue to drive like this you will cause a lot of wear on the synchros and this can lead to a very expensive bill to remove and rebuild the gearbox. Hopefully it's just a hydraulic problem. A clutch slave failure will always result in fluid loss. A failure at the master may result in fluid loss, but it may not. So checking the fluid level is the first step.
Many thanks. Yes, gear deselection/selection is perfectly OK with engine off, so I have eliminated problems with the linkage.

Checked the fluid level. It's at the bottom of the tube (I can see both ports that come into the filler neck about 8 cm from the top of the tube).

Will take it down to Heathfield and let the pros take a look.

Thanks for everyone's help. Will let you know what their diagnosis is.

MC

OK, initial thought confirms that it's something with the hydraulics but will require investigation (as you'd suspect) - level should be close to top of 'filler' tube. They did say that they have had the odd case where draining and repeated flushing has cleared the problem in similar cases. Slave cylinder is main suspect (as main cylinder 'recently' replaced - but not totally eliminated). Time will tell!

Edited by MajorClanger on Monday 12th January 08:13

MajorClanger

Original Poster:

749 posts

301 months

Tuesday 20th January 2009
quotequote all
It was the Master Clutch Cylinder!

V8 Animal

6,015 posts

241 months

Tuesday 20th January 2009
quotequote all
MajorClanger said:
It was the Master Clutch Cylinder!
And that was replaced 2 years agofrown
Begins to sound like a serviceable item surly you must have been unlucky.