Which one? 400,450 oor 500?
Which one? 400,450 oor 500?
Author
Discussion

VX HPC

Original Poster:

77 posts

262 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Thinking about changing my Caterham 7 HPC and don't realy know which model will suit. The 7 is putting out about 190 at the wheels (225 at the crank)and while I am getting to an age were I would like something more practical than the 7, I would still like to make good "progress". Just a bit worried I might find a car in the condition I want, then find it a bit wanting in the power dept. I can't realy see how a 4lt V8 could be found wanting, perhaps you ladies and gentlmen can help. I know a Grif would be the logical step, but I do like that big boot, I could use the car as a car and not a 4 wheeled motorbike! P.s do they all have LSD's?

Uncle Fester

3,114 posts

239 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
It doesn’t matter what you buy, sooner or later you will want a bit more when you have got used to it.

There are some internal differences between 4/4.5/5 and year of manufacture.

If you are starting tuning from a standard engine then the cheapest way to big power is a supercharger kit and a newer type ECU.

If I was starting over again with a Chimp, I would go 4.5 and not do any of the natural aspiration tuning that I have done. Then go for the supercharger and ECU. ECU first if funds are tight.

sato

591 posts

242 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Sorry to jump on this topic, but purchase costs aside, would running costs be similar across the engines?

George 500

653 posts

249 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Please see link to topic below. I think that if you are coming from a seven with that much grunt then I would go for a 500 for the simple reason that everything else would appear limp (a 4 litre chim will produce less power than your current Caterham).

Essentially they weigh a tonne-ish and TVR brake pony power converts to real world brake horsepower as follows (all at crank):-

400: 200hp
450: 225hp
500: 275hp
450 S/C: 400hp

You could buy a 450 and do the work to put a supercharger on the car (although I would personally be slightly wary about the stress on the drivetrain and the cost) or personally (if you want a quick one) I would wait for a quick one to turn up.

It's much cheaper to buy one that someone else has spent the beans on. Indeed (if its location doesn't bother you) there is a highly fettled Chim for sale in County Down on here with 370hp.

For more see here

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

As for running cost difference there is virtually no difference whatsoever as all components bar the engine are the same (and more than up to coping). 500s are more highly tuned than the others but this is unlikely to make any more difference than the treatment of previous owners

VX HPC

Original Poster:

77 posts

262 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, yes I can see from the power charts that all of the standard cars would be a bit down on power to weight on the Caterham, mine weighs about half a ton I think. I don't fancy spending upwards of £5000 on a S/C on top of the car price, so it looks like a 500 would suit me better. They don't seem to be highly stresed, with the 5lt at 275BHP the engine must last forever!

CLN1

657 posts

256 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
500 and don't forget the way the V8 makes torque. You may be pleasantly surprised how well a 500 goes in comparison with what you're used to.

VX HPC

Original Poster:

77 posts

262 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Does the 500 have LSD as standard? what are the standard wheels?

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Think all Chimaeras and Griffiths have LSD as standard.
Standard wheels on the 500's are 'estorils', 7 spoke, 15" front 16" rear. 400/450 have 5 spokes [can't remember name at moment] They also have different offsets. You can fit different wheels without too much difficulty though, I have 17" all round.


Edited by macdeb on Tuesday 10th February 18:36


Edited by macdeb on Tuesday 10th February 18:39

scotty_d

6,795 posts

225 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
macdeb said:
Think all Chimaeras and Griffiths have LSD as standard.
Standard wheels on the 500's are 'estorils', 7 spoke, 15" front 16" rear. 400/450 have 5 spokes [can't remember name at moment] They also have different offsets. You can fit different wheels without too much difficulty though, I have 17" all round.


Edited by macdeb on Tuesday 10th February 18:36


Edited by macdeb on Tuesday 10th February 18:39
5 spokes Imola'ssmile

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
That's the buggers! It's my age you know. [and the beer] hehe

George 500

653 posts

249 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
See CLN's profile above (click on his name) for a picture of standard Estorils (most but not all 500s have these).

This is what Imolas look like



A number of people have switched and swopped though (not all of us are purists!)



Edited by George 500 on Tuesday 10th February 20:17

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
Estorils:

Uncle Fester

3,114 posts

239 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
Dependent upon date of manufacturing, there are some internal differences.

Thicker crank, cross bolted, valving and the like. If you're going for higher power then a strong bottom end is a must.

If you're going to stay fairly standard then all are going to be good.

There were relativity few 500 Chimps built. As such they traditionally command a price premium over smaller versions in equal condition.

By buying a 450 you're going to save that premium and be searching for the right car among a bigger pool of available cars.

If you then apply that saving to the supercharger, you will have a car capable of far outperforming a 500. All for less than it would cost to do similar with a 500.


dbv8

8,676 posts

251 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
Uncle Fester said:
There were relativity few 500 Chimps built. As such they traditionally command a price premium over smaller versions in equal condition.

By buying a 450 you're going to save that premium and be searching for the right car among a bigger pool of available cars.

If you then apply that saving to the supercharger, you will have a car capable of far outperforming a 500. All for less than it would cost to do similar with a 500.
What he said.
Save on the premium of a 500 and spend the difference on personallising your car to suit you.
Supercharging is very nice but is quite expensive.
I get my power fix (same performance as a supercharger) at a fraction of the cost using nitrous and when not in use have a very reliable and relatively economical car which is still tons of fun.

Chimtastic

139 posts

234 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
Uncle Fester said:
Dependent upon date of manufacturing, there are some internal differences.

Thicker crank, cross bolted, valving and the like. If you're going for higher power then a strong bottom end is a must.

If you're going to stay fairly standard then all are going to be good.

There were relativity few 500 Chimps built. As such they traditionally command a price premium over smaller versions in equal condition.

By buying a 450 you're going to save that premium and be searching for the right car among a bigger pool of available cars.

If you then apply that saving to the supercharger, you will have a car capable of far outperforming a 500. All for less than it would cost to do similar with a 500.
There are sone awesome 450s about at the moment and in good condition too. If you search hard enough you could probably find something for around the £12k mark with FSH. Truly fab value.

dbv8

8,676 posts

251 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
Chimtastic said:
There are sone awesome 450s about at the moment and in good condition too. If you search hard enough you could probably find something for around the £12k mark with FSH. Truly fab value.
yikes
£12k... OUCH! I reckon you can get a half decent 1 for £6k in the current climate of an excellent car for £8-10k

George 500

653 posts

249 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
I still stand by the fact that if you want a really quick one buy someone elses! I bought mine for a third of what the last owner spent on upgrading it.

Upgrades basically offer zero value uplift to value (certainly nothing like the original expenditure) and the cheapest way of having a fast car is buying one that is quick to begin with!

NB be aware that a very good Chim 450 is probably a £10k car in the current environment and a supercharger (from what I can see is a £7k upgradeyikes!)

A very good 500 is £12k....

dbv8

8,676 posts

251 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
I'd rather buy a 450 for £7k and spend £7k supercharging it than pay £12k for a highly tuned 500.
The SC car will always be quicker and more reliable IMHO

Markh

2,781 posts

306 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
dbv8 said:
I'd rather buy a 450 for £7k and spend £7k supercharging it than pay £12k for a highly tuned 500.
The SC car will always be quicker and more reliable IMHO
But what sort a shed will 7k buy you?

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Wednesday 11th February 2009
quotequote all
You can actually pick up a very nice car for £7k at the moment. A few have been had for that price in the last few months...