Got the car back - No different!
Discussion
sigh....... Just been to pick up the car. Felt lovely on the A-Roads going back towards the M4 - smooth, responsive with perfect exhaust tone. Was driving for about 30 mins at around 40 - 60 mph then hit the motorway. 30 mins at 80 and came off onto M32 - feels lumpy and rough with flat spot in exhaust note!!!!!!!
Does anyone else's do this - is this normal??!?
Tearing my hair out!!!!! What's left of it :-) It's something to do with having the car at over 2800 rpm for a sustained period. Won't happen when the car is cold. Drives lovely.
I just REALLY want to get to bottom of this roughness. I can't live with it!!!!
And I couldn't sell it either - Any potential buyer would notice it and besides it's dishonest to pass the car off as fine when it isn't.
Been round a fair few of the South West's TVR indies now and they can't seem to find anything wrong... AARGHGGGHHH (throws cup at wall)
Hi all,
Chim Junkie - No, haven't. Where is it located? I'll have a look.
AL 450 - That's the screw in sensor in the bottom of the swirl pot right? Haven't changed it but did cut and re-terminate connections.
Zippy 500 - Brief history:
Bough car -> cam noise -> change cam + followers -> noise still there -> took to Indie in Wales -> Engine strip-> Slipped Liner -> New Liner, Piston, Mains, Rockers + Shaft -> car back, very nice -> soon after (2000 miles) slight engine vibration at 2100 ish revs -> gets worse over time -> change plugs, rotor, cap, leads, fuel pressure reg -> still no better and getting worse -> where we are now.
Roughness accompanied by tappety ticking and occasional knocking/clattering. One earlier post suggests this could be another liner gone. Just looked at by Neil Garner. Plugs good colours, Warm compression test 6 around 150's, a 145 and a 155. Tighten Exhaust Manifold Bolts. Adjust throttle Pot.
Personally, I think it's mechanical. Like a failing tappet, or maybe one that hasn't taken to the cam. or another liner gone. I'm all for stripping the bugger down myself. Get the block top hatted and rebuild to the letter. Thing is I don't have any workshop space!!
What's everyone's views on failing tappets. Can/Do they? Could one (or more) have 'not taken' to the new cam?
I'm basically fed up of changing parts and getting garages to look at it just to find it doesn't make any difference. Something is DEFINITELY wrong. If I could sum it up in a sentence:
It feels horrible to drive and it sounds like a bag of spanners after it's warmed up. :-(
As it's OK before it's fully warm - I think you can rule out the tappet and liner problems.
It does sound very much like the very cheap coolant sensor.
There are 2 - 1 in the swirl pot (for the rad fans) and the other in the front of the inlet manifold which controls the temp the ecu seems and reads information from.
I'd replace that first ..
after that I'd look t see if the lambda sensors were working correctly .. you you have had a broken liner and therefore the coolant loss .. the anti freeze always kills the sensors .. so if it has not beem replaced the a new one probably is needed..
It does sound very much like the very cheap coolant sensor.
There are 2 - 1 in the swirl pot (for the rad fans) and the other in the front of the inlet manifold which controls the temp the ecu seems and reads information from.
I'd replace that first ..
after that I'd look t see if the lambda sensors were working correctly .. you you have had a broken liner and therefore the coolant loss .. the anti freeze always kills the sensors .. so if it has not beem replaced the a new one probably is needed..
Edited by rev-erend on Wednesday 18th February 11:36
debaron said:
Hi all,
Chim Junkie - No, haven't. Where is it located? I'll have a look.
AL 450 - That's the screw in sensor in the bottom of the swirl pot right?
Nope, that is the otter switch and will not make any difference to you - it mererly switches current to the fan relay at a given temperature (somewhere between 78 and 87 degrees depending on which one you have fitted)Chim Junkie - No, haven't. Where is it located? I'll have a look.
AL 450 - That's the screw in sensor in the bottom of the swirl pot right?
IMO without getting your car hooked up to some electricery and potentially a rolling road you are unlikely to diagnose this one - If you can't monitor the engine whilst it is displaying the characteristics then you will end up spending more money parts swapping and not necessarily getting any benefit.
Without meaning to scaremmonger (as your secanio sounds slightly different) the last time I drove a car that gave a vibration at 1 specific RPM, this soon got much much worse (20 miles) and then the engine turned into a sack of spanners as the bottom end got very unhappy. A crank bearing or two had failed, on stripping it down it was well beyond economical repair - one scrap engine.
Cheers,
Matt.
Edited by M@H on Wednesday 18th February 10:34
Ok, will try Manifold Coolant Sensor this weekend.
Have been doing some more diagnostics this afternoon:
I now do not think the ticking and the rough running are related. It seems to tick all the time yet will run really nice now and again (while still ticking)
-> I also have a smell of exhaust gas from right bank (drivers side) - right down low by plug 6's manifold - smells quite petroley & rich...... PLEASE don't suggest EMG - has just been checked by Neil Garner and all tight as the proverbial gnat's chuff. Maybe the 4-into-1 crack problem? Any good way to test for this without burning my face off?!?!
When the car IS running nicely, the exhaust sounds deeper and boomier - any chance this could be a pre cat/cat problem? If so - would I expect to see glowing hot at either of the aforementioned?
What are the symptoms of troublesome Pre Cats & Cats - Could a blocked Pre Cat be holding burnt exhaust gas back from exiting cylinder?
Thanks
Ryan
debaron said:
-> I also have a smell of exhaust gas from right bank (drivers side) - right down low by plug 6's manifold - smells quite petroley & rich...... PLEASE don't suggest EMG - has just been checked by Neil Garner and all tight as the proverbial gnat's chuff. Maybe the 4-into-1 crack problem? Any good way to test for this without burning my face off?!?!
I found the leaks in mine by: (obviously when engine and exhaust is cold)1. Bunging up the exhaust as at the back of the car with a tennis ball cut in half and some duct tape doens't need to be a perfect seal.
2. putting a hole in one of the half tennis balls and feeding a foot pump nozzle into the exhaust.
3. Sprayed all the exhaust with a washing up liquid/water mix
4. Got my friend to pump the foot pump whilst I checked for bubbles in the engine bay.
5. Even though my exhaust manifolds were VERY tight - the gaskets were leaking like sieve
My whole exhaust system was leaking so badly especially at the 4-into-1 I could even hear the air escaping.
No need to pump up the pressure too far / probably not wise to go crazy on the footpump
Edited by mb450 on Thursday 19th February 14:43
Edited by mb450 on Thursday 19th February 14:44
debaron said:
sigh....... Just been to pick up the car. Felt lovely on the A-Roads going back towards the M4 - smooth, responsive with perfect exhaust tone. Was driving for about 30 mins at around 40 - 60 mph then hit the motorway. 30 mins at 80 and came off onto M32 - feels lumpy and rough with flat spot in exhaust note!!!!!!!
Does anyone else's do this - is this normal??!?
Tearing my hair out!!!!! What's left of it :-) It's something to do with having the car at over 2800 rpm for a sustained period. Won't happen when the car is cold. Drives lovely.
I just REALLY want to get to bottom of this roughness. I can't live with it!!!!
And I couldn't sell it either - Any potential buyer would notice it and besides it's dishonest to pass the car off as fine when it isn't.
Been round a fair few of the South West's TVR indies now and they can't seem to find anything wrong... AARGHGGGHHH (throws cup at wall)
Have you found a cure for this problem? I've got exactly the same symptoms but on a '92 4.6 pre-cat Griffith (so no cats)! When upto working temperature the engine presents a vibration/misfire/harshness at 2800-3000 rpm (80mph in 4th, 60 in 3rd etc.).Does anyone else's do this - is this normal??!?
Tearing my hair out!!!!! What's left of it :-) It's something to do with having the car at over 2800 rpm for a sustained period. Won't happen when the car is cold. Drives lovely.
I just REALLY want to get to bottom of this roughness. I can't live with it!!!!
And I couldn't sell it either - Any potential buyer would notice it and besides it's dishonest to pass the car off as fine when it isn't.
Been round a fair few of the South West's TVR indies now and they can't seem to find anything wrong... AARGHGGGHHH (throws cup at wall)
Been to Neil Garners (exactly the same result as you - compression OK, plugs OK, etc), have systematically changed ignition components, induction, etc., no joy.
Thinking of having the injectors cleaned or the AFM checked next.
What exactly happens in the ECU/fueling loop at 3000 rpm when the engine gets upto working temperature?
Just replaced a 'new' pattern part rotor arm with a spanky new Lucas one and mine ran better. 'don't ask me how cos the old (new) one looked fine. The only thing I can think of is that the pattern ones run elliptically or something like that?
Does your engine run hot? Mine indicates in the high eighties and I've noticed a bit of a tail off in performance when it's hot, I've got it running sweet as a nut now after all sorts of problems but it's not quite as sweet at the high temps.
Nick..................
Does your engine run hot? Mine indicates in the high eighties and I've noticed a bit of a tail off in performance when it's hot, I've got it running sweet as a nut now after all sorts of problems but it's not quite as sweet at the high temps.
Nick..................
I have a very similar if not identical problem - once engine goes above 3000 rpm and she is up to running temp then she is missing somewhere and running like a bag of nails.
Booked into Austec this weekend for rolling road session - I suspect something very simple like ecu temp sensor or mass flow etc.Will report back findings - hopefully on monday.
Booked into Austec this weekend for rolling road session - I suspect something very simple like ecu temp sensor or mass flow etc.Will report back findings - hopefully on monday.
Gassing Station | Chimaera | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


