400 HC, 430 or 450?
400 HC, 430 or 450?
Author
Discussion

domlookin

Original Poster:

1,409 posts

212 months

Tuesday 3rd March 2009
quotequote all
Hi there everyone.

I'm looking at buying a Chimaera, bit of a lifelong dream - and have read lots of the posts here in order to get info on the best choice for my needs.

I see a lot of posts about 400 vs 450 vs 500 - but am looking at the choices in the title, and figured you might be able to enlighten me regard them. Can find very little on the 400HC for example...

They all seem to have similar outputs, from what I can see - but I want to know about the other issues involved:

- reliability
- ease of obtaining replacement engine parts
- economy
- drivability

...of each.

I have a budget of somewhere in the region of 6.5k-8.5k, and have identified quite a few potential cars (although I have not contacted the owners, so unsure if they are still available)...

I have seen other posts with links to cars, so hope I'm not contrevening the posting rules (apologies if so!):

450:
http://www.tvr-webmart.co.uk/tvr_full_advert.asp?a...

430:
http://www.justchimaeracars.com/search_results_lar...

400 HCs:
http://www.classiccarsforsale.co.uk/classic-car-pa...
http://atsearch.autotrader.co.uk/www/cars_popup.js...

400:
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/846113.htm
[Included as seems to be superb, but prob sold now]


So what are your thoughts on the different engines guys - and the cars above...?

Many thanks,

Dom

Edited by domlookin on Tuesday 3rd March 23:46

steviegasgas

417 posts

216 months

Tuesday 3rd March 2009
quotequote all
Hi, very recently there has been a huge thread comparing the 400, 450 to the 500, every one has different views, all depending on previous experience, what you are seeking from the car, budget, and many other differing thoughts.
For me, 500, but then I bought a good one, and it was cheaper than a lot off 400s at the time, so depends on what is available at the time also, but whichever one you buy, enjoy it, cheers.

domlookin

Original Poster:

1,409 posts

212 months

Tuesday 3rd March 2009
quotequote all
Thanks Stevie -
I have been reading those - but feel that the performance offered by the 4.5, (stated performance of) 4.0HC and 4.3 is the level I want to be aiming for.

I was wondering if people had comparisons between these 3 - as the *stated* performance seems to be similar for all (I know they vary a lot now) - and I wondered what your guys take on these would be...

Seesm like the 4.0HC figures are optimistic - but what about comparisons between the 4.3 and the 4.5..?

cheers,

Dom

S7Paul

2,103 posts

265 months

Wednesday 4th March 2009
quotequote all
Much depends on your budget. Relatively few 430's were made, and while the 430 is supposed to be a very good engine, the car itself will be one of the older ones. If you can afford it, go for a good 450. Ignore all quoted power outputs; someone in Blackpool used to have a random number generator! All you need to know is that a 4 litre V8 in a car weighing just over a ton is quick, and a 4.5 is even quicker. It's easy to forget how fast these things are until every now and then you find yourself wondering why everyone else on the road is dawdling, and then realise that they're not.

And as EVERYONE will tell you, buy on condition, not age or mileage.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Wednesday 4th March 2009
quotequote all
Couple of points... You really don't know what you're getting with a 450?? Rob has reported some seem practically LR 4.6 engines, others are akin to 500's in state of tune... 430's only seem to vary in valve size (BV or not).

The lower priced 450's are from periods where many have questioned the quality of the chassis coating, and many advise early or late cars for good reasons. Build quality would seem to be better in the early & late periods, maybe the factory just got overloaded by demand at times who knows?

There is also a lot less to go wrong electrically with early cars, as well as being easier to fix. No custom black boxes, simple door mechanisms, no ribbon cables...

The 'drawbacks' of LT77 & GKN are real misnomers as there are plenty still being abised with much greater power than standard.. Some even prefer the LT77 to the T5.. Don't get caught in the newer is better trap wink

The real drawback with early cars is the braking, but it is relatively easy to upgrade to late style brakes or even better.

A plus point for 430's overall is that on average they have been better looked after than the other cars, as mainly more 'anal' enthusiasts have sought out those models.

S7Paul

2,103 posts

265 months

Wednesday 4th March 2009
quotequote all
spend said:
Couple of points... You really don't know what you're getting with a 450?? Rob has reported some seem practically LR 4.6 engines, others are akin to 500's in state of tune... 430's only seem to vary in valve size (BV or not).
Interesting info Dave. As a 450 owner, what differences should I be looking for (hopefully without stripping the engine down)?

AlexanderV8

1,498 posts

234 months

Wednesday 4th March 2009
quotequote all
spend said:
A plus point for 430's overall is that on average they have been better looked after than the other cars, as mainly more 'anal' enthusiasts have sought out those models.
roflrofl
Hey, you must be getting confused with that lot the other side of the fence. smile

jdl1981

299 posts

214 months

Wednesday 4th March 2009
quotequote all
if you are after a performance car, go for the best condition 500 you can afford. If performance is not that much of an issue, a decent 400 will be easier to handle and possibly a bit better on fuel. Reliability wise, it will go wrong at some stage, there's just varying degrees of wrongness!

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Wednesday 4th March 2009
quotequote all
AlexanderV8 said:
spend said:
A plus point for 430's overall is that on average they have been better looked after than the other cars, as mainly more 'anal' enthusiasts have sought out those models.
roflrofl
Hey, you must be getting confused with that lot the other side of the fence. smile
No chance! thats a completely different kind of 'anal' over there yikes

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Wednesday 4th March 2009
quotequote all
S7Paul said:
Interesting info Dave. As a 450 owner, what differences should I be looking for (hopefully without stripping the engine down)?
Size of the exhaust ports is probably the quickest way to gauge the if the heads are BV or just ported a bit. I don't know if the better 450s had the 500 trumpet bases with enlarged 'drain pipes'.. Can't say I've looked at 450's much, but a post of Robs a while ago certainly alarmed me a bit.

Back on topic, I don't think I'd bother looking at one when you know what comes with the 500 engines as standard. Just seems to me that there is even more scope for vastly differing performance in the 450's - you might be lucky - but you can't really ask a seller to pop the heads off to see exactly what your buying can you? Its hard enough as it is for new owners to distinguish between good/bad ones as it is... I'd hate to think we added to the 'underwhelmed' register hehe

Might seem a bit pedantic, but the heads are so important- just look at the difference they make on the only direct comparison we have ie 430 vs 430BV (forget Lady Grovellers tongue out Griff its a BV whatever he says hehe)

If the OP really wants a 'quick' one look out for one of the modified cars coming up for sale, none of us get the money back for mods done - so they really are bargains compared to the std 'repmobile' TVRs????