Discussion
Hi there,
The old shunting/snatching problem is beginning to pee me off again, probably because I've been driving my wife's Audi for a while and gotten used to being able to drive with my foot off the accelerator without having to shove it into neutral to avoid getting whiplash !
Started searching the internet for Mark Adams upgrade services, thinking it's about time I get this sorted and the new fuel map chip was the most likely way to do it and ended up talking to Austec who seem to offer this service with a RR session as well now.
Anyone used them and know what the differences are to what Mark used to do ?
How many people are offering this service now ?
Cheers,
Matt
The old shunting/snatching problem is beginning to pee me off again, probably because I've been driving my wife's Audi for a while and gotten used to being able to drive with my foot off the accelerator without having to shove it into neutral to avoid getting whiplash !
Started searching the internet for Mark Adams upgrade services, thinking it's about time I get this sorted and the new fuel map chip was the most likely way to do it and ended up talking to Austec who seem to offer this service with a RR session as well now.
Anyone used them and know what the differences are to what Mark used to do ?
How many people are offering this service now ?
Cheers,
Matt
steve-V8s said:
It really is worth considering a proper ECU first and then getting someone to map it.
Thanks steve,By proper ECUs do you mean a programmable one then? I have heard of Tornado, blank standard chips and Mark Adams but not sure what the differences are. Have been looking for threads comparing the different options but not come up with anything yet.
Cheers,
Matt
taylormj4 said:
Hi there,
The old shunting/snatching problem is beginning to pee me off again, probably because I've been driving my wife's Audi for a while and gotten used to being able to drive with my foot off the accelerator without having to shove it into neutral to avoid getting whiplash !
Um, what would remapping do to solve the driveline snatch that occurs on the overrun with throttle closed at low (sub-1,500 in my case) RPM? AFAIK the Lucas CU(X)14 system shuts the inj's on the overrun until just above idling speed, like any modernish fuel management system...The old shunting/snatching problem is beginning to pee me off again, probably because I've been driving my wife's Audi for a while and gotten used to being able to drive with my foot off the accelerator without having to shove it into neutral to avoid getting whiplash !
Edited by 900T-R on Thursday 12th March 10:29
900T-R said:
Um, what would remapping do to solve the driveline snatch that occurs on the overrun with throttle closed at low (sub-1,500 in my case) RPM? AFAIK the Lucas CU(X)14 system shuts the inj's on the overrun until just above idling speed, like any modernish fuel management system...
I'm no expert but I understand that the fueling at small throttle openings is often incorrect, often causing the engine to run lean. This causes intermittent misfires and variations in the amount of engine braking applied, which is seen as the lurching or snatching. In my car, if I make the ECU go open loop by taking the revs above 2800rpm and then stay on over run with no throttle as the revs decrease, the snatching disappears. This continues right down the rev range until either the throttle is opened or the ECU opens the throttle as the revs get down to around 1500rpm, which puts the ECU back into closed loop mode and allows it to start fiddling with the mixture again.Edited by 900T-R on Thursday 12th March 10:29
The new ECU is mapped to your engine and the fueling can be made more exact at each point in the rev range for all the various throttle opening positions.
Matt
Ah, well mine is spot on as long as I have any sort of throttle opening - the only shunting I get is with my foot completely off the throttle at below 1,500; the more the lower the gear/road speed. As long as I shift down to keep the revs at 1.5K or higher on the overrun or dump the clutch, everything's hunky dory. 
Running a TVR Power Eprom upgrade, BTW.

Running a TVR Power Eprom upgrade, BTW.
Edited by 900T-R on Thursday 12th March 11:43
Mapping the part throttle stuff accurately does make quite a difference Eric, compared to the fairly coarse on/off Lucas. I think Mark does compress/concentrate some of the sites where you need them TBH. Don't know about Austec, but they used to be one of the places where Mark held his surgeries?
Can't see how you can get rid of all the effect if the cam gives shed loads of low down torque coming in with that big bang TBH. Nice progressive torque curve to 3-3500rpm helps IMHO.
Having said that sloppy driveline clanking makes the annoyance far more intolerable
OP if you want to search alternate ECU's try the likely suspects MS / Megasquirt, Emerald, VEMS, KMS..
Can't see how you can get rid of all the effect if the cam gives shed loads of low down torque coming in with that big bang TBH. Nice progressive torque curve to 3-3500rpm helps IMHO.
Having said that sloppy driveline clanking makes the annoyance far more intolerable

OP if you want to search alternate ECU's try the likely suspects MS / Megasquirt, Emerald, VEMS, KMS..
spend said:
Mapping the part throttle stuff accurately does make quite a difference Eric, compared to the fairly coarse on/off Lucas.
But I don't have any problems on part-throttle, only off the throttle where it would cut off the injectors, anyway? The only problem I see is that it should return to idle mixture on the overrun @ just over idle (say 1,100-1,200 rpm), not 1,500 rpm where even with lightened internals it still takes a couple of seconds in second or third before I normally would depress the clutch... 900T-R said:
spend said:
Mapping the part throttle stuff accurately does make quite a difference Eric, compared to the fairly coarse on/off Lucas.
But I don't have any problems on part-throttle, only off the throttle where it would cut off the injectors, anyway? The only problem I see is that it should return to idle mixture on the overrun @ just over idle (say 1,100-1,200 rpm), not 1,500 rpm where even with lightened internals it still takes a couple of seconds in second or third before I normally would depress the clutch... taylormj4 said:
I get this too. Car will idle when warm at around 950rpm but when you overrun it starts pulling like a train and basically drives itself like an older car would with the choke on high idle setting.
but with the difference that the mixture seems to be inconsistent so that the drivetrain snatch occurs. As said, at part throttle it feels spot on all the time with excellent driveability - this is a hugely flexible engine (built by a bloke who specialises in Jaguar V12s). 
When the clutch is depressed, revs will typically stick at 1,500 for a second or two before dropping to their regular idle level. Before, it would sometimes stick @ 1,750 - 2,000 for a bit or for as long as you were sitting stationary in traffic, but the installation of SC Power's restrictor kit in the hose from TB to stepper motor took care of that.
Matt,
Your simptoms sound like a lazy stepper motor to me.
My Chim did the same, as you said it drives it's self as if you had a very high idle speed.
Try getting the engine up to temp with a nice smooth idle and then disconnect the plug to the stepper motor. Go for a drive and see if the problem is still there. I bet it will have gone. You could then just leave the car as it is or clean/replace the stepper motor. The only disadvantage of leaving the stepper motor disconnected is the motor will not idle when cold for the first couple of minutes.
Hope this helps.
Cheers.
Paul.
Your simptoms sound like a lazy stepper motor to me.
My Chim did the same, as you said it drives it's self as if you had a very high idle speed.
Try getting the engine up to temp with a nice smooth idle and then disconnect the plug to the stepper motor. Go for a drive and see if the problem is still there. I bet it will have gone. You could then just leave the car as it is or clean/replace the stepper motor. The only disadvantage of leaving the stepper motor disconnected is the motor will not idle when cold for the first couple of minutes.
Hope this helps.
Cheers.
Paul.
If it cut off the injectors when you lifted then the pistons would get very hot - the ecu just reduces the fueling. Like everything else 'how much' varies with the particular engine / induction. Generally if it is reduced too much you will get the characteristic pops 'n 'bangs, if there is none at all you wouldn't have any nice cool petrol reducing the heat on the piston crowns, which TBH always worries me a little 
If your car is still pulling at low revs, check the ECU is getting road speed input (early cars from the gearbox drive, later split from the diff driveshaft to ecu + speedo with a 'blackbox'). RPM info to the lucas is from the dizzy ~ without it the ecu won't even run the fuel pump.

If your car is still pulling at low revs, check the ECU is getting road speed input (early cars from the gearbox drive, later split from the diff driveshaft to ecu + speedo with a 'blackbox'). RPM info to the lucas is from the dizzy ~ without it the ecu won't even run the fuel pump.
This is cause and effect, the ECUS tend to shunt because they dont like the poor airflow at low RPM with the types of cam TVR use- its never a problem on stock Range Rover cams. The low / pulsed airflow makes the ECU think there is less air going in than there is, so it limits the fueling. This makes the engine run lean, and the ECU then tries to compensate for this, but it hits the limit of its fuel enrichment, but keeps trying. This gives a pulsed effect to the fueling, so the car shunts. Problem is, once this has started it snatches the drive train, so slack develops, and the problem becomes worse. Obviously no amount of ECU work will compensate for wear and tear. Apart from this, there can be many reasons that make it worse fuel wise, as you are trying to ignite a very lean mixture, so anything that makes the burn any worse wont help- thats why you will get a whole raft of reasons why "xxx" fixed it. It tends to be worse when the inlet air temp is lower, as the air density is greater, so more oxygen for the given amount of fuel, so it runs even leaner. I did wonder if reconnecting the preheat on the plenum might help, but Ive not had a chance to try this on a faulty car yet- any takers?
If you take it to Mark Adams, he will check everything else before a possible remap and thats seriously expensive. Im sure if it had been just a case of getting the mapping right in the first place, he'd of been the first one to sell a chip that would cure the problem. The www.torquev8.co.uk conversion is rumored to be a good fix, as it improves the airflow and the ECU is remapped as well. They have been pretty clever on this one, as the ECU has a map that basically suits the new AFM they produce, and final tweeking is done by adjusting the AFM output to bring the fueling spot on. This option is very very good value compared to bespoke mapping or aftermarket ECU's (which by the way not many have done 100% sucessfully without huge expense and time inspite of the hype some would have you believe)
Mark T.
If you take it to Mark Adams, he will check everything else before a possible remap and thats seriously expensive. Im sure if it had been just a case of getting the mapping right in the first place, he'd of been the first one to sell a chip that would cure the problem. The www.torquev8.co.uk conversion is rumored to be a good fix, as it improves the airflow and the ECU is remapped as well. They have been pretty clever on this one, as the ECU has a map that basically suits the new AFM they produce, and final tweeking is done by adjusting the AFM output to bring the fueling spot on. This option is very very good value compared to bespoke mapping or aftermarket ECU's (which by the way not many have done 100% sucessfully without huge expense and time inspite of the hype some would have you believe)
Mark T.
paulathome said:
Matt,
Your simptoms sound like a lazy stepper motor to me.
My Chim did the same, as you said it drives it's self as if you had a very high idle speed.
Hmmm, my experience would indicate the reverse - before I cleaned the stepper motor it would be a bit slow to take up idle when depressing the clutch on the overrun, sometimes enough so to have the engine die. Now it seems to regulate idle speed in two stages on the overrun with the clutch depressed - first 1,500 rpm for 1-2 seconds before returning to its normal 950 or so.Your simptoms sound like a lazy stepper motor to me.
My Chim did the same, as you said it drives it's self as if you had a very high idle speed.
Edited by 900T-R on Thursday 12th March 13:11
spend said:
If it cut off the injectors when you lifted then the pistons would get very hot - the ecu just reduces the fueling.
Err, but that's how it normally works with any modern OE engine management system - no throttle and engine speed > idle -> ECU shuts fuel delivery completely. Your on-board information display will show '0.0' as your fuel consumption of that moment, regardless of road speed and rpm. blitzracing said:
This is cause and effect, the ECUS tend to shunt because they dont like the poor airflow at low RPM with the types of cam TVR use- its never a problem on stock Range Rover cams.
Every RR/Disco Efi I have owned has done it periodically, traffic driving without using the clutch makes wonder about flicking transfer box! Its just a lower speed to sports carsblitzracing said:
aftermarket ECU's (which by the way not many have done 100% sucessfully without huge expense and time inspite of the hype some would have you believe)
However there are plenty well into 300bhp territory at a far lower cost than if they had persisted with the Lucas and clockwork spark! There are still yet plenty trying to solve the shunting problems, even yourself?blitzracing said:
This is cause and effect, the ECUS tend to shunt because they dont like the poor airflow at low RPM with the types of cam TVR use- its never a problem on stock Range Rover cams. The low / pulsed airflow makes the ECU think there is less air going in than there is, so it limits the fueling. This makes the engine run lean, and the ECU then tries to compensate for this, but it hits the limit of its fuel enrichment, but keeps trying. This gives a pulsed effect to the fueling, so the car shunts. Problem is, once this has started it snatches the drive train, so slack develops, and the problem becomes worse. Obviously no amount of ECU work will compensate for wear and tear.
That still doesn't explain why a car displays the low-rpm snatching on the overrun when it's absolutely fine otherwise at any load/rpm - except if the only point on the map that's too far 'off' for the lambda control loop to be able to compensate fully would be zero load and 1,500 rpm. spend said:
However there are plenty well into 300bhp territory at a far lower cost than if they had persisted with the Lucas and clockwork spark! There are still yet plenty trying to solve the shunting problems, even yourself?
Um, I've never seen more than 15-20 bhp difference documented back-to-back with the Lucas ECU and ignition distributor on the same car, and that's on 300+ bhp applications; to me that seems a poor ROI for £2K+ (but then I'd say the same about multi throttle induction set ups and fancy exhaust manifold set ups which are in the same ballpark).900T-R said:
blitzracing said:
This is cause and effect, the ECUS tend to shunt because they dont like the poor airflow at low RPM with the types of cam TVR use- its never a problem on stock Range Rover cams. The low / pulsed airflow makes the ECU think there is less air going in than there is, so it limits the fueling. This makes the engine run lean, and the ECU then tries to compensate for this, but it hits the limit of its fuel enrichment, but keeps trying. This gives a pulsed effect to the fueling, so the car shunts. Problem is, once this has started it snatches the drive train, so slack develops, and the problem becomes worse. Obviously no amount of ECU work will compensate for wear and tear.
That still doesn't explain why a car displays the low-rpm snatching on the overrun when it's absolutely fine otherwise at any load/rpm - except if the only point on the map that's too far 'off' for the lambda control loop to be able to compensate fully would be zero load and 1,500 rpm. 900T-R said:
Hmmm, my experience would indicate the reverse - before I cleaned the stepper motor it would be a bit slow to take up idle when depressing the clutch on the overrun, sometimes enough so to have the engine die. Now it seems to regulate idle speed in two stages on the overrun with the clutch depressed - first 1,500 rpm for 1-2 seconds before returning to its normal 950 or so.
That sounds about right. I read somewhere that the ECU should do the rev reduction in stages with time delay of approx 3 seconds. Why it needs to be so slow I don't know. Flippin annoying in traffic. You have the choice of burning your clutch or looking like an idiot boy racer revving your engine.Edited by 900T-R on Thursday 12th March 13:11
Matt
Gassing Station | Chimaera | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


