Solid vs Hydraulic lifters
Solid vs Hydraulic lifters
Author
Discussion

Chimjunkie

Original Poster:

2,879 posts

242 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
What are the benefits of fitting solid lifters over Hydraulic? Going to try and sort out my tapping top end once and for all. Pros and Cons on solids?

Jon.

Zumbruk

7,848 posts

291 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
I've just had my top end rebuilt, with hydraulic lifters and it doesn't tap at all. The rockers and cam were utterly shagged on my old engine, so it was a tad clattery... smile

Chimjunkie

Original Poster:

2,879 posts

242 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
Zumbruk said:
I've just had my top end rebuilt, with hydraulic lifters and it doesn't tap at all. The rockers and cam were utterly shagged on my old engine, so it was a tad clattery... smile
Hi Zumbruk, I had my engine apart not too long ago and the cam looked good, as did the rest of the rocker gear. It is possible, as Spend said, that an adjustable pushrod is just catching the head or one of the rockers is catching something. Since i plan to re-investigate i may be in the mood to replace the followers with solid ones. My question is whether there is a real benefit to this in performance etc. I really dont care about the engine being tappety if it is supposed to be. its just the annoying noises that should not be there hehe


spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
More positive actuation of the valve wink

Only downside is adjusting the clearances occasionally. Thats makes roller rockers with lash adjusters very desirable compared to 'fiddling' with bloomin adjustable pushrods.

You do set the clearances so that there can be slight tappety sound whilst cold, but as soon as all is warm & oiled you at least know any noises are significant screams for attention. Generally if they start clattering its a good sign that you need to check the clearances PDQ!. Suitable parts assembled correctly should have a lot less to go wrong as well hehe

Call Rob, I think he might make your mind up for you if you ask the right questions...

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
Hydraulic lifters limit the rev range you can use, so if you plan to increase this significantly above standard you would need solid lifters. Hydraulic lifters flex more than solid ones so when changing between the two you need a different cam profile to get the equivalent effect. Solid lifters don't adjust to compensate for thermal expansion and wear, so you can expect the solid lifters to be noisier than hydraulic most of the time - and get worse over time needing adjustment a couple of times a year. Unless you actually *need* the extra rev range my feeling is solid lifters are a backwards step.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
I take strong issue with that Peter, yes you can rev them higher if you want to, but both Joo & Pascos car on solids use FA more revs than when they were hydraulic cars. I believe what you are seeing is that at the higher RPMS the cam still lifts positively so they are getting all the partial through full opening that the cams are designed for.

Certainly with the stroked cars you can use wilder cams (softened by the capacity) but as far as revs go you are more limited by the increased piston speeds I would guess? The stronger solid cams are just using as much lift as is available AFIK, there are of course racier cams either solid or fluffy's that can be designed for different rev ranges. I don't know the exact figures but I would hazard a guess that the hydraulic lifters could start being +/- 0.1" valve lift at 4500rpm (just an illustration of the idea) and become progressively worse as revs rise.

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
Ah, although non rover the ls7 uses hydraulics, a roller cam and some hairy lift and it revs past 7k. I'm not a fan of solids although I do find some easier to adjust the others. I would consider them if I was after max bhp but most of the time I'd settle with hydraulics. Solids probably to sharpen up response time though.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
...and do our friends over the pond in Nascar... use rumpypumpy followers??? evilhehe

Sorry but much of our inspiration does come from them frown

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
^ Ah but could a tvr run in Nascar? That's foxed you smile

Chimjunkie

Original Poster:

2,879 posts

242 months

Sunday 22nd March 2009
quotequote all
scratchchin

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
^^It's Monday now, have you put the kinky boots away for workdays?

Found lots of horrible grockles for you to entertain next Saturdaytongue out Oh they are fat & ugly yuckrofl

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
^ They're bound to be fat and ugly in your neighbourhood. I only went there once and that was enough. Catch you later.

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
Perhaps you should check you cam bearing .. it could be the cause of your problem.

I have solid lifters and because of the added maintenance I would say they are not for everyone.. only really needed for wild cams and the adjustment is a pain in the ar8e..

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
Yeah, if I wanted a high maintenance mistress I'd have bought an AJP or S6-engined car... hehe That's £350 on top of your 6,000 mile services for setting valve clearances, Sir...

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
It takes about an hour to check and adjust the clearances on an RV8..

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
AJP use shims, RV8 screwed adjusters.. very different maintenance procedure.

If someone charged you £350 for adjustment on an RV8 you would be farting very quietly for a while evilhehe Its about an hours work when you are prepared and know what you are doing (just add some time for tricky to get at adj pushrods if necessary).

For someone like the OP who put his own engine in, etc. Its just a Sunday morning wash/polish session twice per year swap wink

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
Ah, I am only familiar with the shim method... (had my fair share of SOHC Saab 8-valve turbos) biggrin

Chimjunkie

Original Poster:

2,879 posts

242 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
spend said:
If someone charged you £350 for adjustment on an RV8 you would be farting very quietly for a while evilhehe
rofl

Have no problem with adjusting on occasion. But need a bit more convincing it is worth changing.

Are the hydraulic followers partly responsible for the power dropping off from 5500rpm? I know the cam profile will play a major part in this...


Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
"Are the hydraulic followers partly responsible for the power dropping off from 5500rpm? I know the cam profile will play a major part in this..."


This may be the case as in some ways they act as a rev limiter on a standard rover.


Chimjunkie

Original Poster:

2,879 posts

242 months

Monday 23rd March 2009
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
This may be the case as in some ways they act as a rev limiter on a standard rover.
Mark Adams has worked his magic on my car so the rev limiter has been set at 6000rpm. Would it be unwise to take this up to 6250?