Weak spark
Weak spark
Author
Discussion

Teetertank

Original Poster:

358 posts

218 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Car is a P reg 5.0 Chim

Has recently been treated to new:

- Spark plugs
- Spark plug extenders (Magnecor)
- HT Leads (Magnecor)
- Rotor Arm (Lucas)
- Dizzy Cap (Lucas)
- Coil (Bosch)


Yet the spark at the plugs weak and orange coloured, rather than strong and blue as hoped.

Anyone have any ideas what to check?

Could it be fault with ignition module/amplifier, duff coil, poor earth?


f@-pots

204 posts

234 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Just changed all of the above plus ign amp , no more shunting and much smoother.

Did them aqll one by one , most noticeable difference was rotor arm (new aftermarket out new lucas in) and ignition amp.

Nick.................


Teetertank

Original Poster:

358 posts

218 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Then, that makes me suspect it could be the ignition amp, but have been told they either work or don't, and there is a spark, allbeit a weak one.

...but have read on the net that both ignition amps and ignition coils can "go weak".

Anyone know of a method to test an ignition amplifier?

blitzracing

6,422 posts

251 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
They are quite difficult to test statically as the sensor "rotor" needs to be moving at a reasonable speed to trigger, plus it only switches the coil for a moment so you dont get a 12 volt - 0 volt -12 volt switch like you do with points. Something like a basic Crypton tuner can give you an osciloscope display that would show the 0 - 12 volt switch reliably with the engine running. A basic test is to remove the king lead from the distributor cap, and jam a plug in the end of the lead. Then remove the distributor cap to expose the magnetic rotor and sensor. Rotate the engine slowly until a magnetic rotor arm is aligned with the sensor. There is a small air gap only. Now get a flat blade screwdriver and tape a good magnet to the shaft, so the tip becomes magnetic. With the ignition on, tap the screw driver tip across the air gap to complete a "magnetic" circuit. The plug in the king lead should fire each time you bridge the gap.

Mark

philmccann

430 posts

231 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Ignition system is obviously delicate. I changed mine out for lovely blue Magnecors, new extenders, new cap and rotor (admittedly aftermarket. First off, couldn't even get the cap on with the new rotor arm. Replaced with original (Lucas) rotor arm. Fitted this time. Tried to start.....nothing, not a whisper. Fitted the original cap and away she went.So now back to original black cap except for leads and extenders.(they are working ok)
I even tried some spare bits I had in the garage from previous RV8 stuff. No joy there either. So looks like only one combination, and one only, will work.

Can someone give me the codes and where to get good cap and rotor, so I don't waste my hard-earned again.

Cheers

Phil

Teetertank

Original Poster:

358 posts

218 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
philmccann said:
Can someone give me the codes and where to get good cap and rotor, so I don't waste my hard-earned again.
Cap is a Lucas 44870, ask for arm to suit.

See here for part codes etc: http://www.chimaerapages.com/resources_partslist.p...



Teetertank

Original Poster:

358 posts

218 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
I tested the coil last night and all resistances check out ok.

blitzracing said:
They are quite difficult to test statically as the sensor "rotor" needs to be moving at a reasonable speed to trigger, plus it only switches the coil for a moment so you dont get a 12 volt - 0 volt -12 volt switch like you do with points. Something like a basic Crypton tuner can give you an osciloscope display that would show the 0 - 12 volt switch reliably with the engine running. A basic test is to remove the king lead from the distributor cap, and jam a plug in the end of the lead. Then remove the distributor cap to expose the magnetic rotor and sensor. Rotate the engine slowly until a magnetic rotor arm is aligned with the sensor. There is a small air gap only. Now get a flat blade screwdriver and tape a good magnet to the shaft, so the tip becomes magnetic. With the ignition on, tap the screw driver tip across the air gap to complete a "magnetic" circuit. The plug in the king lead should fire each time you bridge the gap.

Mark
Mark,

Thanks for your reply. Will this magnet & screwdriver test actually indicate a weak ignition amplifier or just check it functions? The reason I ask is that, there are sparks being produced, but they are just not strong sparks, and believe their weakness is causing the misfires at low revs high load.

That Daddy

19,466 posts

252 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
I cant comment on the Lucas module fited to your car,but i have known Hitachi,OKI & Bosch modules to fail yet still create a very weak spark,its just a heads up don't dismiss the module being faulty just because you still have spark wink can you borrow one? maybe from another member smile where in London are you based approx?

Edited by That Daddy on Tuesday 7th April 14:23

Teetertank

Original Poster:

358 posts

218 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
That Daddy said:
I cant comment on the Lucas module fited to your car,but i have known Hitachi,OKI & Bosch modules to fail yet still create a very weak spark,its just a heads up don't dismiss the module being faulty just because you still have spark wink can you borrow one? maybe from another member smile where in London are you based approx?

Edited by That Daddy on Tuesday 7th April 14:23
Hadn't ruled the amp out, but wasn't sure if the test Mark described would distinguish between a good and weak module/amplifier.

I don't personally have any vehicles I could swap modules with, but have e-mailed a couple of people on e-bay breaking cars with appropriate module (e.g. Orions, Fiestas, Escorts, Maestros etc.)

Otherwise there are replacement modules (presumably generic) new for about £10 which seems good, but not sure they will be as good as an Lucas type? Anyone confirm?? Maybe I shouldn't be worried about trying them, but scared of the scaremongering about non Lucas caps & arms etc...

I'm based in East Dulwich (SE22) and wouldn't mind travelling a little to eliminate the component. Planning on being around Cambridge area over the bank holiday (and saw a couple of Tivs last time I was up - one in Fowlmere and another Nr Bassingbourn!!)

blitzracing

6,422 posts

251 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
The test is just for basic function, although if the spark on the end of the king lead is good, then you know the faults further down the HT routing. You will need an osciloscope to look at the voltage levels and speed of switching to really know if the amp is failing as Semiconductors do go "leaky" so they dont switch cleanly some times, but a side effect of this would be a hot ignition amp. You can (could ??) get a simple HT testers from Gunson. Its nothing more than a variable air gap to determin how the high HT really is, without the guesswork. You may find the voltages are higher than you think.

That Daddy

19,466 posts

252 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
This guy as Genuine Lucas ones http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/CLASSIC-MINI-IGNITION-MODULE... (i asked)just tell him the type you need(yes its the same part as a late Metro)it would be worth having a spare anyway it will also confirm if its something else wrong once,i have one in my tool kit for the Chim.

Edited by That Daddy on Tuesday 7th April 22:43

f@-pots

204 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
Truth is, they're cheap enough to just buy one and see,

Nick..................

That Daddy

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
f@-pots said:
Truth is, they're cheap enough to just buy one and see,

Nick..................
Exactly my point wink i would want a spare anyway,if that thing goes down on the road you aint going no place frown

BRITISHBEEF

75 posts

217 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
I had a few issues, and my weak spark was the amp. May not be the answer but sounds like you changed everything I did and the amp cured me!

Teetertank

Original Poster:

358 posts

218 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
That Daddy said:
This guy as Genuine Lucas ones http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/CLASSIC-MINI-IGNITION-MODULE... (i asked)just tell him the type you need(yes its the same part as a late Metro)it would be worth having a spare anyway it will also confirm if its something else wrong once,i have one in my tool kit for the Chim.

Edited by That Daddy on Tuesday 7th April 22:43
Many thanks for the link. Have seen cheaper but prefer the peace of mind that it is an original part.

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
Teetertank said:
That Daddy said:
This guy as Genuine Lucas ones http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/CLASSIC-MINI-IGNITION-MODULE... (i asked)just tell him the type you need(yes its the same part as a late Metro)it would be worth having a spare anyway it will also confirm if its something else wrong once,i have one in my tool kit for the Chim.

Edited by That Daddy on Tuesday 7th April 22:43
Many thanks for the link. Have seen cheaper but prefer the peace of mind that it is an original part.
Yes me too thumbup

philmccann

430 posts

231 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
Why are these amps so troublesome?

Don't ever recall anyone telling me that a Metro, or Orion etc had problems with an ignition amp.

Is it because it's driven so hard with eight cylinders?

I have heard heat being diagnosed as a problem, would mounting it elsewhere be beneficial?

Any suggestions??

Cheers

Phil

rigga

8,808 posts

232 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
Under bonnet heat kills componants,metro's and orions being metal shelled cars can radiate the heat away from these parts.... tvr's being what they are hold the heat in......

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
philmccann said:
Why are these amps so troublesome?

Don't ever recall anyone telling me that a Metro, or Orion etc had problems with an ignition amp.

Is it because it's driven so hard with eight cylinders?

I have heard heat being diagnosed as a problem, would mounting it elsewhere be beneficial?

Any suggestions??

Cheers

Phil
Not many Benny eek they gave plenty trouble on both those cars,i lost track of the amount of CVH escorts to have Module failures in the late eighties early nineties with Lucas kit wink to be fair Lucas ignition systems have never been great frown

Edited by Simon Says on Wednesday 8th April 20:45

philmccann

430 posts

231 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Oh well,

If that's the case, you would have thought someone would have come to the rescue with a re-designed reliable unit.
Is it purely reliability or is the heat an issue??

Cheers

Phil