5w / 40 A wee bit thin ??
5w / 40 A wee bit thin ??
Author
Discussion

f@-pots

Original Poster:

204 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
OK , first off I didn't really want 5w / 40 but my mate's got a Halfrauds trade card so I asked him to purchase me some lovely 10 w/40 Mobil 1 on account of my sump wearing through and me losing all my oil on the drive!
He came back with The 5w/40 Halfords own brew saying that they didn't have any of the stuff I wanted and the home grown was probably as good. I thought I'd give it a go anyway and so filled her up. The result is not a lot of oil pressure (down to 10 on tickover only 30 at hooning revvs) a lot of clatter I didn't have before and a missfire.
All the oil pressure issues and excessive noise I can put down to the folly of using sewing machine oil instead of the proper stuff I'd like your opinions on weather its so thin that it could affect the lifters possibly producing rough running. It was running fairly sweetly(ish) before the oil change and 'no I didn't run her out of oil when the sump sprang a leak , she was still holding good pressure when I shut her down '.

Yours in anticipation of being mocked mercilessly,

Nick................. whistle

MADMAX2

2,336 posts

225 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
f@-pots said:
OK , first off I didn't really want 5w / 40 but my mate's got a Halfrauds trade card so I asked him to purchase me some lovely 10 w/40 Mobil 1 on account of my sump wearing through and me losing all my oil on the drive!
He came back with The 5w/40 Halfords own brew saying that they didn't have any of the stuff I wanted and the home grown was probably as good. I thought I'd give it a go anyway and so filled her up. The result is not a lot of oil pressure (down to 10 on tickover only 30 at hooning revvs) a lot of clatter I didn't have before and a missfire.
All the oil pressure issues and excessive noise I can put down to the folly of using sewing machine oil instead of the proper stuff I'd like your opinions on weather its so thin that it could affect the lifters possibly producing rough running. It was running fairly sweetly(ish) before the oil change and 'no I didn't run her out of oil when the sump sprang a leak , she was still holding good pressure when I shut her down '.

Yours in anticipation of being mocked mercilessly,

Nick................. whistle
im short sighted and dyxlexic did you put WD40 in your engine?


hehe

MADMAX2

2,336 posts

225 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
serious note i always use mobil 1 15/50 fully synthetic these engines are not new and halfrauds always have this in stock


also did you prime the oil pump?

Edited by MADMAX2 on Wednesday 8th April 20:26

Uncle Fester

3,114 posts

239 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
I run on 5/50 Valvolene VR1. The engine is a V8 Developments and this was their advice.

My oil pressure is steady on 60 at all temperatures and RPM. No noise that shouldn't be there, but plenty that should smile

The oil consumption is a little higher than on 20/50, but the better protection on start up and cold is worth it to me.

f@-pots

Original Poster:

204 posts

234 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
15w/50 Mobil 1 it is then , I'd still like to know if thin oil can affect the lifters tho' ?

Nick............

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 8th April 2009
quotequote all
Strange my Chim as run on fully syn 5/40 Vauxhall and Quantum(VAG group lately Vauxhall no longer sell 5/40))since i purchased it with 112K now at 122k hehe i have had no problems with clatter or oil burning(1 litre approx every 1500 miles)and change it every 3k with oil pressure stinking hot 18/20 idle and 35 off idle although i have some nice 15/50 Mobil Motorsport(bulk buy) to go in shortly when i uprate the Camshaft etc etc,just a heads up really maybe the Halfrauds stuff is crap i dunno wink in saying this i think these engines are happier with oil with a bit more body 10/50 15/50 etc and discussed on these forums so many times before.



Edited by Simon Says on Wednesday 8th April 21:27

f@-pots

Original Poster:

204 posts

234 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
It may have been discussed before about 'other peoples' cars , but mine is blue and therefore 'special' .whistle

Nick.............hehe

blueg33

47,013 posts

255 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
I was just having the same debate. Opie oils recommended a synthetic 5w40, whereas I have always used a semi synthetic 10w40. The garage that service my car advised against the 5w40 saying it would be too thin. So now I am worried, doe i drainout £50 worth of 5w40 that went in yesterday and replace it with 10w40. or do i take the risk and do a year on 5w40? Engine only has 14000 miles on it. But I will be doing le mans run in it with 2 up, luggage, and fast driving.

I would hate to kill the engine

Nick

STE VR

501 posts

237 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
My Chim has always had 0/40 Mobil 1 since new. Its on 94K and never had a cam change etc. Pulled 219bhp at the last RR session so I'm rather happy with the thin oil.

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
STE VR said:
My Chim has always had 0/40 Mobil 1 since new. Its on 94K and never had a cam change etc. Pulled 219bhp at the last RR session so I'm rather happy with the thin oil.
As usual all TVR's are different. My 450 rattles like a bag of spanners (well ok not quite that bad but ou know what I mean) if run on standard mobil 1 0w/40. Fill her up with semi-syn 10W40 and she runs fine, no clattering and good oil pressure.

I guess the answer is if you dont have any problems (no rattling, good oil pressure across the rev range) then dont worry. IMHO anyway.

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
I was just having the same debate. Opie oils recommended a synthetic 5w40, whereas I have always used a semi synthetic 10w40. The garage that service my car advised against the 5w40 saying it would be too thin. So now I am worried, doe i drainout £50 worth of 5w40 that went in yesterday and replace it with 10w40. or do i take the risk and do a year on 5w40? Engine only has 14000 miles on it. But I will be doing le mans run in it with 2 up, luggage, and fast driving.

I would hate to kill the engine

Nick
Listen if i thought 5/40 would kill my engine it would be out already that is quite simply not going to be the case wink dont worry. f@pots,sorry mate Silver ones are quicker FACT rofl Bigdods my brother uses the 10/40 semi and he seems happy enough wink everyone as differing opinions i suppose.



Edited by Simon Says on Thursday 9th April 09:50

350Matt

3,915 posts

310 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
these engines need a 50W oil

Invisible man

39,731 posts

315 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
350Matt said:
these engines need a 50W oil
yes

The guys at V8 Developments recommend it so it's good enough for me

Uncle Fester

3,114 posts

239 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
V8D weren't keen on Mobil 1.

Not so good at temperatures after a while.

Also consider Valvoline VR1 10/60.

Andy JB

1,321 posts

250 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
FWIW 5w40 will be fine - don't bother changing it. IMO RV8 does prefer a slighty thicker oil, i use 10/50 & have experimented with most viscosities. Regular changes are more important.

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Andy JB said:
FWIW 5w40 will be fine - don't bother changing it. IMO RV8 does prefer a slighty thicker oil, i use 10/50 & have experimented with most viscosities. Regular changes are more important.
Spot on that man bow

f@-pots

Original Poster:

204 posts

234 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
I hear what you guys are saying and appreciate your comments. As has been said , our engines are all different and are at different stages of wear in their lives ,they are at different stages of tune and have many varying mods carried out. Mine is a pretty stock 4.0 and of a design which is advanced in years. And so ,I'm going to use the advice of V8 Developments and the evidence of my own eyes and ears and drain off the 5w / 40 replacing it with some 10 or 15w/50 good quality oil. It may seem like an overly cautious move to some but it certainly won't hurt my engine and 'may' help it to last a little longer.
Nick.................nerd

daz the plumber

14,997 posts

262 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
ive tried all types of oils from fully synthetic 10/50 15/50 10/60 and i like this oil its american made by lucas . you can get fully synthetic 20/50 but i use the mineral 2.5 us gallons for £34 does two oil changes .
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Lucas-High-Spec-20-50-20w50-...