Intermittent Starting Problem
Discussion
Had a few instances recently where after turning off the alarm/immobiliser and getting in the car won't start.
First time was a few weeks ago, when the car had been left for a few hours (so was not hot), the fuel pump primes, but the starter motor doesn't fire. It's just nothing. After a couple of minutes of trying and pushing the alarm fob immobiliser it fired up.
Did exactly the same yesterday lunchtime. Just wouldn't start. After a couple of minutes of trying it went.
Last night pulling it from the drive into the garage, it didn't want to fire, then after holding the ignition for a few seconds it sprung into life.
Been in the garage tonight and it is starting fine (as it was all last weekend).
The symptoms are similar to the hot start issue, but it is not that because the car is not hot, has the hot start mod and a heat shield over the starter (which was also new about 3 years ago).
I'm hoping it is not an immobiliser problem. It is difficult to see what the problem is as when I want it to play up it doesn't and it always seems to not start on the way to or back from work.
The fuel pump primes but the starter motor does not seem to kick into life. I am wondering whether it is immobiliser related or more ignition system related.
Any ideas gratefully received.
First time was a few weeks ago, when the car had been left for a few hours (so was not hot), the fuel pump primes, but the starter motor doesn't fire. It's just nothing. After a couple of minutes of trying and pushing the alarm fob immobiliser it fired up.
Did exactly the same yesterday lunchtime. Just wouldn't start. After a couple of minutes of trying it went.
Last night pulling it from the drive into the garage, it didn't want to fire, then after holding the ignition for a few seconds it sprung into life.
Been in the garage tonight and it is starting fine (as it was all last weekend).
The symptoms are similar to the hot start issue, but it is not that because the car is not hot, has the hot start mod and a heat shield over the starter (which was also new about 3 years ago).
I'm hoping it is not an immobiliser problem. It is difficult to see what the problem is as when I want it to play up it doesn't and it always seems to not start on the way to or back from work.
The fuel pump primes but the starter motor does not seem to kick into life. I am wondering whether it is immobiliser related or more ignition system related.
Any ideas gratefully received.
Hate so say it, but I had exactly the same symptons as you, and it was the immobiliser. Apparently there are relays which are not quite up to the job in the unit and it is these that burn out/stick after time. You could try slapping the underside of the dashboard on the passenger side as this worked for me for a bit. Alternatively give Carl Baker a call as he is the expert!
Sounds like the immobiliser but could also be a sticky solenoid on the starter or a knackered battery. Do you get a click from the solenoid but no cranking ?
Try leaning under and tapping the solenoid/starter with a hammer then see if it starts (tapping may unstick it)
I know when my battery was dying the car would sometimes start, sometimes not. If it didnt turn, gave it a few minutes then it would suddenly start to work. Something to do with buckled plates in the cells and available current. Perhaps try sticking jump cables on next time it wont start.
Try leaning under and tapping the solenoid/starter with a hammer then see if it starts (tapping may unstick it)
I know when my battery was dying the car would sometimes start, sometimes not. If it didnt turn, gave it a few minutes then it would suddenly start to work. Something to do with buckled plates in the cells and available current. Perhaps try sticking jump cables on next time it wont start.
Had the same problem, ended up being a relay in the immobiliser. Just took a wire from the ignition switch to the starter solenoid through a push button (Maplin - same type as the one that turns off the dash lights but not toggle - never use it anyway - fits in the same hole) and no more problems. To test take a hot wire to the solenoid directly from the battery, if it cranks then this should sort the problem.
Thanks for the replies.
It has played up twice today, after reading the earlier post at work (wasn't able to reply though), a quick slap on the top of the dash and it starts
So it looks like the immobiliser.
Will take a look and see what can be done with it, not sure whether the relays can be easily replaced and if it is worth it, or go for a new one.
It has played up twice today, after reading the earlier post at work (wasn't able to reply though), a quick slap on the top of the dash and it starts

So it looks like the immobiliser.
Will take a look and see what can be done with it, not sure whether the relays can be easily replaced and if it is worth it, or go for a new one.
Gassing Station | Chimaera | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


